Richard Stallman Saw Microsoft's Plans Against GNU/Linux Back in 2004

Dr. Roy Schestowitz

2008-08-11 15:26:32 UTC
Modified: 2008-08-11 15:26:32 UTC

The following interview from Digital Tipping Point is a quite fascinating. Towards its end and a couple of minutes after the beginning, Stallman mentions that the Linux kernel, which makes up about 0.25% of the GNU/Linux system according to him, was found to have been covered by 286 different US patents. It is not necessarily news that there was such a study, but watch this video.

Non-Ogg versions are here.

According to Richard Stallman (back in 2004), Microsoft wanted to be using software patents and it was filing for (or granted) several patents per week with the aim of destroying competition like GNU/Linux. As he points out, documents showed that they intend to use software patents against GNU/Linux. That was in 2004.

Not too shabby for a company that violates not only patents but copyrights too.

Microsoft Austria has collected the top prize in the Community category of the Austrian Big Brother Awards. The prize, a tacky looking robot thing which can be viewed here, was given for the company's activities in spamming Austrian Linux users with questionnaires. Microsoft Austria recruited G3 GMBH to handle the mailing. This outfit seems to have helped itself to the email addresses of Austrian users registered with the Linux Counter and then sent them the questionnaire, which asked about their views on the software industry, about Linux, and about their employment. This was in breach of the Linux Counter's copyright and terms of use, which specifically bar use of the data for mass mailings.

The more things change, the more they stay the same. Microsoft is filing for software patents more than ever before. That may be the plan. ⬆

Comments

twitter

2008-08-11 22:35:39

Richard Stallman probably understood the issue of software patents back in the 1980's, just as soon as the US recognized them. It is clear that M$ has been using them from at least 1999 when Bill Gates penned his infamous ACPI memo:

One thing I find myself wondering about is whether we shouldn't try and make the "ACPI" extensions somehow Windows specific. .... Maybe we could define [things] so that they work well with NT and not the others even if they are open. Or maybe we could patent something related to this.

Clearly, he wanted to use any method possible to keep free software from working well with commodity hardware. His disdain for the work of others comes out when he calls reverse engineering efforts, "nothing" and seeks to make everything else unusable by denying key parts of hardware.
Roy Schestowitz

2008-08-11 22:57:38

There's a copy of that E-mail from Gates here. The links above does not work.

Linux Kernel 7.0 Release Candidate Comes Out, Stallman Turns 73 in Three Weeks: It predates Microsoft and Apple
In Greenland, Firefox's Gecko and KHTML (KDE, But Bastardised by Apple) Bigger Than Chrome: Are those Danes recognising the risk of monoculture?
IBM Layoffs Definitely Still Happening: Contrary to what some apologists try to say
Don't Use the Future Tense to Discuss the Slop Bubble: Wall Street does not react to reality; it reacts to panic, which is related to expectations
The Broken Window Industry and Its Ongoing Desires to Make Technology Less Dependable: Reliable computing is becoming harder to find
New XBox CEO Typecast in Social Control Media: Microsoft apologists will fall back on (or shuffle between) the "racist" and "sexist" angle
Sites Without JavaScript Deserve Your Visits: We're not arguing that the Web should be as simple or barebones like Gemini Protocol/GemText
EPO Strikes Are Already Working: Campinos is already going "into hiding"
Based on Insider Leaks, Asha Sharma's Job is to Kill XBox While Talking About "AI": They cite SneakerSO
Germans Recognise the Contagion is Digital, Not Racial: How to dismantle or neutralise those weapons? Turn them off
Free Software (or Software Freedom) Ain't No Religion: It's hardly surprising that some of the loudest opponents of Software Freedom and its luminaries also disregard or bend facts
Dr. Andy Farnell Explains Why the Slop Industry is Like Trespassers and Thieves: interesting new article about robots.txt files
The Demise of the Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA) and Profession Based Around Bullying With SLAPPs and Empty Threats: For press to survive and thrive in the UK we need the hired gun to be submerged
Gemini Links 23/02/2026: Imperfect Journal, Evil, and "Progress Goes Boing!": Links for the day
“Power is a Thing of Perception. They Don't Need to be Able to Kill You. They Just Need You to Think They are Able to Kill You” ― Julian Assange: When leadership becomes corrupt enough to lose a sense of authority its days are numbered; it'll be replaced
IBM Has Already Admitted 2026 Mass Layoffs (in 4Q Earnings Call): We showed this earlier this month, but some people bring that up again
Reasons to Go on Strike in the European Patent Office (EPO): If you live in Europe and don't work for the EPO, you can still help
First speech of Chanellor Hitler, Andreas Tille & Debian denounce Branden Robinson: Reprinted with permission from Daniel Pocock
Over at Tux Machines...: GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Sunday, February 22, 2026: IRC logs for Sunday, February 22, 2026
More and More Projects Quit Microsoft GitHub This Year, XBox Will See the Same: Microsoft GitHub's embrace of slop as "strategic" gives us a clue of what'll happen to XBox very soon
Google "Intelligence": Despite Slam-Dunk or "Smoking Gun" Proof, Drug Abuse in EPO Leadership is "Unverified Allegations": Google's slop (so-called 'AI') lacks intelligence
8,000 Pages/Articles Per Year: We're eager to maintain a good production/publication pace and illuminate the sinister attempts to interfere with Freedom of the Press in the UK
Gemini Links 22/02/2026: Okonomiyaki and Midcrunch Crisis: Links for the day
Freedom Means Accepting He or She Who is Different: In the Debian community we're sadly seeing some authoritarian overreach this month
Microsoft Windows Falls to Another New All-Time Low in Guatemala, It is a Bottomless Pit: Maybe users come to realise that Windows means back doors and those doors are open to a regime that ought not be trusted
"XBox" Will Become Slop After Mass Layoffs: When all else fails, "AI it"
Links 22/02/2026: Hardware Price Hikes Across the Board, "Microsoft Issues Statement on Potential Layoffs": Links for the day
Microsoft "Layoffs Incoming": This transition isn't about promoting games; it's about canning the console
Links 22/02/2026: "Bloat of Modern Fitness Apps" and Wikipedia Deprecates Archive.today: Links for the day
Our IRC 5-Year Anniversary (for Self-Hosted) is Fast Approaching: A week from now it's March already
Gemini Links 22/02/2026: Dream Job Gone and Slop in Taskwarrior: Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...: GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Saturday, February 21, 2026: IRC logs for Saturday, February 21, 2026
GNU/Linux Grew a Lot in Nicaragua: We've not noticed until today
Techrights Has Over 1,000 Good Articles 'in the Tank': Drafts, notes, and lengthy documents
New Article Challenges Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA) for Choosing the Wrong SLAPP Cases to Investigate: The one point we can agree on is that SRA does not know how to correctly select the worst culprits/offenders
The Brand 'Watsonx' is a Terrible Name for IBM 'Hey Hi' (Chatbots) Because Watson Agreed With Adolf Hitler: Almost a century has passed and IBM still believes that selling "intelligence", chatbots in particular, should be done under the name "Watson"
Why IBM is Still Scary and Dangerous: Keep a distance from "Big Blue" Bully
Measuring the Growth of Our Mission and Community: Something between experiment and prototype
Richard Stallman in the United States - Part III - Georgia Tech Did a Fine Job Upholding Free Speech Principles: The real problem was social control media (toxic)
Debian's Master is Deleting Criticism of SystemD and Other Things (On-Topic and Published by Debian Developers), Resorts to the Excuse Messages Are "Too Long": Censorship serves nobody except the masters that control this censorship
Digg's Latest Incarnation Already Failed, It's Infested With LLM Slop: Many submissions go to slopfarms and some get summarised by slop
Gemini Links 21/02/2026: Veganism and DeskPi RackMate T0: Links for the day
On The Web, XBox Already a Dying Breed: Down to about 0.05% on large machines, based on statCounter [...] Microsoft will never publicly admit or say how many billions it lost on the XBox
2026 a Year of 'Top-Down' Microsoft Layoffs (Management First): Stay tuned for what comes next
Your "Likes" Aren't Yours and They're Mostly "Worthless Clicks": Social hermits are not popular, irrespective of how many "Facebook friends" or "likes" they get
Waggener Edstrom/Frank Shaw Lied, There Are Definitely Microsoft Layoffs: Microsoft never issued a formal statement, it made allusions by proxy
Microsoft-Controlled Media With Embargo and Press Operatives: This won't be the last example of media manipulation for narrative control or face-saving "damage control"
Slop Hype Makes Our Core Technology Less Reliable and Far Less Resilient (We Pay for the Catastrophe That Follows): Only slop-free projects can be trusted
Going for 1,000 (Days of Uptime): universal records are vastly better
Firefox is No-Go in China, Not Even 1% "Market Share" Anymore: Given Mozilla's utterly rubbish marketing these days (politics over technical aspects), set aside the cheerleading for slop, there's hardly a chance of Mozilla Firefox reaching or exceeding 10% again
EPO "Cocaine Communication Manager" - Part III - It's in His Eyes: Workers are free to draw their own conclusions
Links 21/02/2026: Tensions Over Iran and Illegal Cheeto Tariffs, Presidential Approval Sags: Links for the day
Links 21/02/2026: "Moving Away From Cloudflare", Many Layoffs or Shutdowns in Games (Including XBox/Microsoft): Links for the day
GNU Linux-libre is a Grown-Up Today: "before that, every distro that wanted to respect its users' freedom had to remove itself all of the binary blobs that were distributed as part of the kernel Linux's so-called sources"
Over at Tux Machines...: GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Friday, February 20, 2026: IRC logs for Friday, February 20, 2026
Gemini Links 21/02/2026: "The Evil of Action" and Slop Bots Causing Great Harm Online (Not Just the Web): Links for the day

Richard Stallman Saw Microsoft's Plans Against GNU/Linux Back in 2004

Comments

Recent Techrights' Posts