Red Hat Was Wrong About UEFI, Failed to Ask the Users

Dr. Roy Schestowitz

2012-06-13 14:51:04 UTC
Modified: 2012-06-16 16:09:12 UTC

UEFI? Et tu?

Summary: Red Hat was not open about its decision to collaborate with Microsoft and consequently it upset many FOSS proponents, choosing to ignore their rationale

Red Hat's and Fedora's UEFI decision was a bad one because it does not improve security. A Fedora member seems to suggest that it's a matter of convenience versus freedom and principles, which makes a poor excuse. To quote:

A big flame does not end suddenly, it continues with echoes and as echoes go further away, the more ridiculous they get. You can learn, for example, why do Fedora needs signed binaries for UEFI with Secure Boot: because is too hard for users to enter BIOS and change a setting there.

What about other distributions of GNU/Linux? Red Hat's action legitimises Microsoft's anti-competitive tactics and leaves all but Red Hat uncovered. Fedora members who are Red Hat employees complain about this piece for merely daring not to drink Red hat's Kool-Aid (link to Google spyware, aka "Plus", omitted). To quote Noyes:

Microsoft Loves Linux - as Long as It's Not Red Hat

[...]

However, there's one major Linux player that's sort of getting left out of the lovefest. It's enterprise Linux leader Red Hat (NYSE: RHT) and its Red Hat Enterprise Linux (RHEL), which has to sit by while other distributions, including RHEL community clone CentOS and market competitors SUSE and Ubuntu, get first-class treatment in Microsoft's Azure cloud.

This wouldn't be the first time we've seen Microsoft look to the "other" Linux distributions as leverage against Red Hat. Though some may be critical of Microsoft for its apparent selective Linux approach, the bottom line is that Redmond is among the broadest supporters of Linux in the industry today. HP (NYSE: HPQ) has historically been among the most aggressive, backing unpaid Linux distributions such as CentOS, Debian and Ubuntu -- which is also a paid Linux option with support from Canonical.

Noyes was not alone in her criticism. If Red Hat would like to just shut its ear and shout, people will lose respect for it. Perhaps it's not too late for Red Hat to admit it made a mistake; it's probably too late to retract. Why didn't Red Hat approach the public? There was no poll or survey, no referendum on the subject. This is Open Source? For a company that claims to champion the open source way (they have a site, opensource.com) it is proving to be as open on decisions as SUSE/Novell was. It's not even meritocracy (like Canonical's). Nobody was asked. ⬆

Comments

twitter

2012-06-13 17:30:26

The problem is not Red Hat's work around, it's their defeatism and endorsement that chaffs. Red Hat should be telling people to avoid Windows 8 hardware because it's a pain in the neck and their little escape hatch probably won't work long in the real world. Ideally, Red Hat will stand with the FSF and endorse Coreboot instead. When reports of malicious hardware come flooding in, Red Hat will be forced back to this anyway and then they will recognize the mistake of trusting Microsoft for anything. None of us should assume that Microsoft's restricted boot will be successful. There may be a little spurt of production but it is likely to sink with Windows 8.

Red Hat's good faith effort to work with Microsoft will be useful in the next big anti-trust case against Microsoft. It might be very difficult or impossible to turn off Microsoft's restricted boot. I've read reports of oddball "forthlike commands" being required, different for each board and therefore difficult to find on the web. That too will make rich evidence of coercive intent.
Dr. Roy Schestowitz

2012-06-13 17:35:48

Red Hat's good faith effort to work with Microsoft will be useful in the next big anti-trust case against Microsoft.

Same with Canonical.

'Cancel Culture' Doesn't Work (in the Long Run): Despite all the attacks, I'm enjoying life, I'm keeping productive, and our audience continues to grow
GNU/Linux Still up (statCounter Says to 6%) in Bosnia And Herzegovina: Let's see where it is at year's end
Making Layout Changes: Feedback can be sent to us
Behind an Economy of Fake 'Worths' and Fictional 'Valuations' or 'Market Caps': They normalise white-collar crime and say "everyone is doing it!"
Links 18/01/2026: "South Africa is Running Out of Software Developers", Companies Spooked to Find Slop is a Major Liability: Links for the day
Place Your Bets: Who Will Die First? Microsoft or IBM?: Not even joking; make a guess
Restoring Professional Pride in the Tech Sector: Rejecting slop isn't being a Luddite
Slop Bubble "Is Worse Than The Dot Com Bubble": Edward Zitron Says It like it is
IRC Proceedings: Saturday, January 17, 2026: IRC logs for Saturday, January 17, 2026
Links 18/01/2026: The "Deepfake Porn Site Formerly Known as Twitter" and Turkey to Block Kids' Access to Social Control Media: Links for the day
Gemini Links 18/01/2026: Against English as Language of the Net, "Symposium of Destruction": Links for the day
You Would Expect This Kind of Misleading Narrative Shortly Before Microsoft (or GAFAM) Mass Layoffs: misleading PR
FOSDEM 2026: democracy panel, GNOME & Sonny Piers modern slavery experiment: Reprinted with permission from Daniel Pocock
Pump-and-Dump With IBM Shares, Courtesy of People Who Stand to Gain From the 'Pump': "3 Reasons to Buy IBM Stock Right Now"
IBM: Spying on Staff Like Never Before and Implementing Silent Layoffs This Month, Say Insiders: what we heard from whistleblowers seems to corroborate
IBM is Not a Free Software Company (It Never Was): Red Hat's main product, RHEL, is full of secret sauce and has 'secret recipes' (it is basically proprietary)
IBM Turning Up the 'RTO' (Stress) and 'PIP' (Fear) Heat on Workers, Rebellion May be Brewing: Sometimes it feels like today's executives at IBM view IBM workers as a liability
Links 18/01/2026: Indonesia Against Comedy, Media-Hostile (Censors Comedians) Convicted Felon in White House Defecting to Opponents of NATO: Links for the day
Eventually the Joke (and Financial Fraud) is on Microsoft, Stigmatised for Slop: Is Microsoft trying to commit suicide?
GNU/Linux Leaps to All-time Highs in Virgin Islands: it seems to have started around the "end of 10"
Making and Keeping the Sites Accessible: Sometimes less does mean "more" (or "MOAR")
The "Alicante Mafia" - Part IV - How Europe's Largest Patent Office Recruited Drug Addicts, Antisemites, and People Who Absolutely Cannot Do the Job (But Know the 'Right' People): To better overlap industrial actions we might delay/postpone/pause this series for a bit
Benefiting by Adding Presence in Geminispace: As the Web gets worse, not limited to bloat as a factor, people seek alternatives
Google News Recently Started Syndicating Another Slopfarm, Linuxiac: Even if Google is aware that there is slop there, it's hard to believe that Google will mind
Software Patents and USMCA (or NAFTA): We recently pondered going back to issuing 2-3 articles per day about patents and common issues with them
IBM Sued Over PIPs: PIPs are "performance improvement plans"
Sites With "Linux" in Their Name That Are in Effect Slopfarms and Issue Fake Articles: We try to name some of the prolific culprits
Gemini Links 18/01/2026: Raising Notifications From Terminal and Environmental Sanity: Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...: GNU/Linux news for the past day
Links 17/01/2026: Internet Blackout Normalised, Russian Attacks Civilians by Causing Massive Blackouts: Links for the day
Microsoft Lunduke Keeps Distracting From the Real Problems With Rust: Microsoft Lunduke is stigmatising critics
Linuxiac Has Become a Slopfarm, Calling Them Out Isn't Fixing That: What a shame. A once-decent site about "Linux" bites the dust.
Luzern Lion Monument, Albanian Female Whistleblowers: Swiss jurists were cowards: Reprinted with permission from Daniel Pocock
The Splinternet is Already Here, Owing to the Militarisation of Technology (Slop, Social Control Media, Back Doors, and More): you know what's gonna happen next...
Stack Ranking Against IBM/Red Hat Staff and a Signal of Mass Layoffs (RAs) Justified by Red Hat and IBM as Poor Performance/Misconduct/Other: Working in an atmosphere like this sounds like a nightmare
Gemini Links 17/01/2026: Slow computing and Environment Leak: Links for the day
Links 17/01/2026: US Censorship and Violence Crisis, Growing Anger Levels Against Slop Sold as "Intelligence": Links for the day
Microsoft's "valuation depends on infrastructure that does not exist.": Indeed
The Typical Trajectory: Datamation Began Experimenting With LLM Slop for Fake Articles. Then Datamation Died. (Last Month): It's always ending up this way
Accounts or Devices (e.g. Phones) That Get 'Burnt' Have Many Pitfalls: Embassies and consulates habitually fail at this
Avoiding the Spooks (Nobody Watches the Watchers, They're Practically Unaccountable): If more people adopt encryption, it'll be easier for us to deal with whistleblowers
Protecting Whistleblowers Requires Technical Knowledge/Skills: even the highest media judges aren't aware of how to protect sources
At Least 5 Women Quit Brett Wilson LLP in Recent Months. It's the Firm That Attacked My Wife and I on Behalf of Americans (One of Them Strangled Women).: It seems like good news that the women escape this workplace
Slop About Slop and Slop About "Linux": In short, avoid slopfarms
Report/Benchmark Says 'Vibe Coding' Results in Security Holes: There are risks they don't like talking about
EPO Abuses Covered in Spanish: Knowing what we know (and heard/saw), the sinister silence of the media is perceived by some to be complicity of the lower order.
Richard Stallman Encourages "ICE Out For Good" Protests, His Opponents Do Not (Passive and Uncaring About Human Rights): He has done a lot philosophically, politically, and so on
Record Traffic in Geminispace or Over Gemini Protocol: it's never too late to join
The "Alicante Mafia" - Part III - Europe's Second-Largest Organisation on Strike, Protests, Other Industrial Actions to Come Impacting Over 95% of the Workforce: The EPO's management is highly evasive, weak, and vulnerable
Claim That IBM Marked 15% of its Workforce for Potential Layoffs: No wonder we keep hearing from Red Hat people who say they hate IBM
Over at Tux Machines...: GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Friday, January 16, 2026: IRC logs for Friday, January 16, 2026
Great Reset at IBM, the Company That Pulps Red Hat: In 2026 many workers are RTO'ed, PIP'ed, and at Red Hat many have effectively 'left the company' and now start afresh as "IBM" staff
The "Alicante Mafia" - Part II - Breakout of Discontent This Winter in Europe's Second-Largest Organisation: So far we've caused a lot of panic and stress inside Team Campinos
The "Alicante Mafia" - Part I - An Introduction to the Mafia Governing the EPO: Are some people 'evacuating' themselves to save face?
J.H.M. Ray Dassen & Debian, Red Hat, GNOME unexplained deaths: Reprinted with permission from Daniel Pocock
At Microsoft, "Firing People is a "Cheat Code" to Pump the Stock Short-term But They Are Literally Destroying the Company's Soul Long-term.": They frame layoffs as a "success story"
Gemini Links 16/01/2026: "Porting My Main Website Over to Gemini" and Seeed Studio DevBoard: Links for the day
IBM Stacked and Ranked Badly, Maladministration Dooms the Company: Now they stack people up for PIPs and layoffs ("RAs")
Google News Poisons Its Own Index With More Slopfarms (Including "filmogaz"): Naming and shaming lazy slobs who rip off other people using LLMs can work, eventually
Links 16/01/2026: UK Royal Family's "Legal Team Accused of Dishonesty, Fraud and Misconduct", OSI Still Controlled by Microsoft (the OSI's Spokesperson is on Microsoft's Payroll, Not Interim Executive Director, Deborah Bryant): Links for the day
Writing About Corruption: Fraud is everywhere
The B in IBM is Brown-nosing and Buzzwords (or Both): International Buzzwords Machines
Naming Culprits in Switzerland: Switzerland is highly secretive about white-collar crime
IBM's 'Scientific-Sounding' Tech-Porn Won't Help IBM Survive (or Be Bailed Out): Who's next in the pipeline?
IBM Was Never the Good Guy: its original products were used for large-scale surveillance, not scientific endeavours
The Bluewashing is Making Red Hat Extinct (They All Become "IBM", Little by Little): IBM does not care what's legal
Slopfarms Push Fake News About Microsoft Shutdown, 30,000+ Microsoft Layoffs Last Year Spun as Only "15,000": The Web is seriously ill
Countries Take Action Against Social Control Media and 'Smart' 'Phones', Not Slop (Plagiarised Information Synthesis Systems or P.I.S.S.): None of this is unprecedented except the scale and speed of sharing
Sanitised Plagiarism as "AI" (How Oligarchy Plots to Use Slop to Hide or Distract From Its Abuses, or Cause People Not to Trust Anything They See/Read Online): This isn't innovation but repression
Sites That Expose Corruption Under Attack, Journalism Not Tolerated Anymore (the Super-Rich Abuse Their Wealth and Political Power): Sometimes, albeit not always, the harder people try to hide something, the more effective and important it is for the general public
Recent Layoffs at Red Hat (2026 the Year of Ultimate Bluewashing): I found it amusing that Red Hat's CEO has just chosen to wear all blue, as if to make a point
Links 16/01/2026: Social Control Media Curbs in Australia Underway, MElon Still Profiting by Sexualising Kids 'as a Service': Links for the day
More People Nowadays Say "GNU/Linux": We still see many distros and even journalists that say "GNU/Linux"
LLM Slop on the Web is Waning, But Linuxiac Has Become a Slopfarm: I gave Linuxiac a chance to deny this or explain this; Linuxiac did not
More Signs of Financial Troubles at Microsoft, Europe Puts Microsoft Under Investigation: The end of the library is part of the cuts
Team Campinos Talks About SAP Days Before EPO Industrial Actions and a Day Before the "Alicante Mafia" Series (About Team Campinos Doing Cocaine): EPO staff that isn't morally feeble will insist on objecting to illegal instructions
Pedophilia-Enabling Microsoft Co-founder Cuts Staff: Compensating by sleeping with young girls does not make one younger
Microsoft Shuts Down Campus Library, Resorts to Storytelling About "AI" to Spin the Seriousness of It: Microsoft is in pain
Free Software Foundation (FSF) Back to Advertising the Talks of Richard Stallman: A pleasant surprise
Stack(ed) Rankings and Ongoing Layoffs at Red Hat and IBM (Failure to Keep Staff Acquired by IBM): IBM is mismanaged and its sole aim is to game the stock market (by faking a lot of things)
Over at Tux Machines...: GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Thursday, January 15, 2026: IRC logs for Thursday, January 15, 2026
Gemini Links 16/01/2026: House Flood and Pragmatic Retrocomputing Dogfooding: Links for the day

Red Hat Was Wrong About UEFI, Failed to Ask the Users

Microsoft Loves Linux - as Long as It's Not Red Hat

Comments

Recent Techrights' Posts