Bonum Certa Men Certa

“The Decision of the President [Battistelli] to Overstep the Recommendation of the Disciplinary Committee is Arbitrary and Shows Bad Faith.”

It also highlights the fact that EPO management lied to all staff about its union-busting activities

Els Hardon



Summary: A letter sent from Elizabeth Hardon to Benoît Battistelli shortly after her unjust dismissal, which is part of a wider-spread campaign across EPO branches to crush the unions and replace them with pseudo (management-leaning) unions

THIS morning we mentioned that the EPO 'generously' gave back to a staff representative her pension for which she worked and she's totally entitled/eligible for (as per the rules). She did not get her job back (she ought to), but here is what happened behind the scenes in order to make Battistelli relent a little and then attempt to recover. There's no generosity at all from Battistelli, just an effort (however minuscule) to salvage a morsel of credibility after making a mockery of justice itself. What do scientists and lawyers (people who work for the EPO) think of this business school graduate and his epic (mis)handling of science and law?



Here is the letter sent to Battistelli:

TO Benoît Battistelli, President of the EPO FROM Elizabeth Hardon, Staff Representative (SUEPO, MSC) RE Dismissal with 20% reduction of pension DATE 28 January 2016

1. With a letter dated 15.01.2016 I was informed of the decision to dismiss me with immediate effect and to reduce my pension by 20% (ANNEX 1).

2. The above letter indicated that the legal means of redress against the decision is a request for review in accordance with Article 109 ServRegs.

3. Therefore I herewith file a request for a review of the above decision pursuant to Art. 109 ServRegs. The request is filed within 3 months of the decision and hence is receivable.

4. I file this request under protest for the following reasons.

5. According to Article 10(1) ServRegs “A request for review shall be compulsory prior to lodging an internal appeal ...” Decisions following a disciplinary procedure are not subject to review by an internal appeal (Art. 110(2)(a) ServRegs) and should therefore logically not be subject to the review procedure.

6. Moreover, the review procedure is a pre-litigation dispute resolution mechanism whose claimed purpose is to come to an early, informal resolution of conflicts. This may be possible before a disciplinary procedure, but is highly unlikely after a disciplinary procedure.

7. I note in the passing that even at the best of times, the review procedure seems ineffective. The external auditors of the EPO reported that only about 4% of the requests reviewed by them were successful (CA/21/15)

8. The investigations against me were initiated by Ms Bergot, PD HR and right hand of the President. The decision after the disciplinary procedure has been taken by the President himself. Under the circumstances it seems highly unlikely that anything that I can submit will make any difference.

9. The requirement to go through a review procedure is thus procedurally incorrect and merely serves to delay my access to the Tribunal.

10. Given that there seems no chance of an impartial and objective review of the disputed issues, I will not expand on the many other formal errors made in my procedure. I merely refer to the letter of my lawyer dated 02.12.2015 (ANNEX 2).




11. The accusations against me were set out in a document sent to me on 17.11.2015, signed (on every page) by Ms Bergot, and are as follows:

(a) Acting as an accomplice in a campaign to disseminate information and opinions detrimental to the EPO, its proper functioning and its reputation as well as the reputation of its employees (based on investigation C-61b),

(b) threatening colleagues at a meeting on 10.12.2104, and at a subsequent meeting, asserting in threatening terns that those volunteering for the posts of members of the Internal Appeals Committee (IAC) would suffer serious harm (based on investigation C- 071/2015), and

(c) disregarding (i) the express instruction of my employer and (ii) my concurrent obligation under Art. 4 of Circulars No. 341 and No. 342 to keep the investigation C-011/2015 confidential.

12. Concerning the first allegation (acting as accomplice to the suspended DG3 member) it is surprising that the alleged conspiracy was only “discovered” almost a year after the investigations that led to the suspension of the DG3 member had been closed and at a moment when the initial accusations in my case (a purported harassment campaign against a staff representation colleague in The Hague) were not being confirmed by the external investigators of Control Risks.

13. The allegations in the investigation C-61b were sent to me on 09.11.2015 (at 17.44h). The summary of the findings relating to the investigation was sent to me for comment on 16.11.2015. The deadline for comments was 23.11.2015. A disciplinary procedure based on those findings was initiated on 17.11.2015, i.e. the day after I received the “preliminary” findings and well before the deadline set for my comments. Ms Bergot apparently received the “summary of findings” even earlier because the copy in my disciplinary file is dated 13.11.2015. In other words: Ms Bergot was informed of the findings barely four (!) days after I was informed of the accusations and well before I was able to comment.

14. The timing of events gives the strong impression that the additional accusations were patched together with haste in order to make up for the failure of Control Risks to confirm the earlier accusations.

15. Concerning the accusations themselves, the Enlarged Board of Appeal found in the reasoning for its decision of 17.09.2015 the allegations against the DG3 member unsubstantiated to the extent that neither the accused nor the Board could understand what exactly he was accused of (points 7.10-7.12 of the reasoning; ANNEX 3). If the “evidence” provided in the case of the DG3 member was identical or similar to mine, I understand the position of the Enlarged Board of Appeal.

16. I furthermore strongly deny “having acted as an accomplice in a campaign to disseminate information and opinions detrimental to the EPO, its proper functioning and its reputation as well as the reputation of its employees".

17. Concerning the second allegation (threatening colleagues at a meeting on 10.12.2104) I first note that the complaint was not lodged by any of the persons allegedly affected but by Ms Bergot (PD HR), in a wider investigation targeting the staff representation and




accusing its members of harassment. The investigations were started at a time when the administration, represented by Ms Bergot, and the staff representation found themselves increasingly in conflict. This in itself raises questions about the credibility and good faith of the accusations pursued by Ms Bergot.

18. The meeting of 10.12.2014 was a meeting of the Munich Staff Committee. Policy discussions within the Committee are confidential. The investigation launched by Ms Bergot obliged the members of the Staff Committee to breach that confidentiality. This is inappropriate and in my opinion constitutes misconduct.

19. ILO-AT judgment 3106 states that the principle of freedom of association “ ... precludes interference by an organisation in the affairs of its staff union or the organs of its staff union (see Judgment 2100, under 15). A staff union must be free to conduct its own affairs, to regulate its own activities and, also, to regulate the conduct of its members in relation to those affairs and activities." The same principle obviously applies to other staff associations, like the Staff Committee.

20. In other words: the investigation into the activities of the Staff Committee and my subsequent punishment on the basis of my alleged behaviour in a meeting of the Staff Committee are in breach of fundamental principles of freedom of association.

21. The relevant discussion within the Staff Committee was triggered by a letter of the President inviting individual members to “volunteer” as a staff representative in the Internal Appeals Committee (IAC). At the relevant time two of the previous members had been suspended and/or were facing disciplinary proceedings. With that invitation the President was trying reconstitute the IAC while avoiding any discussion with the Staff Committee concerning the problems in the functioning of the IAC. The invitation was in breach of the Service Regulations that do not foresee “volunteers” selected by the President but only nominations by the Staff Committee (Art. 36(2)(a) ServRegs).

22. The invitation of the President was controversially discussed within the Munich Staff Committee. However, the tone and contents of the discussions never went beyond what could fairly be expected from a lively policy discussion in an international environment. I emphatically deny having threatened or intimidated anybody.

23. The external investigators held that the exact wording of my allegedly threatening statement could not be determined. The wording relied on by the disciplinary committee is based on the assertions of only one (!) of the seven witnesses. The selective presentation of “facts” and the many procedural short-cuts taken by the disciplinary committee raise serious doubts about its impartiality and objectivity.

24. In that context I note that in an earlier video-conference discussing Patent Administration matter, a Principal Director who was subsequently a member of my disciplinary committee in the present case shouted at me “SUEPO is a cancer, a CANCER!" thereby making it impossible for me to speak. I left the room in distress.

25. Art. 5 ServRegs, interpreted by the administration as requiring from employees of the EPO “the highest standard ... of integrity” throughout their employment in the Office, should apply a fortiori for members of the disciplinary committee who are called to judge upon their colleagues. The above mentioned aggression was not considered to disqualify the Principal Director concerned from participating in my disciplinary




committee and acting as rapporteur. In contrast, my alleged “threat”, that did not have any visible impact on the person(s) concerned, is considered to merit a severe disciplinary measure. The lack of consistency and double standard being applied here is obvious.

26. Concerning the third allegation (breach of confidentiality) I maintain that in a well-run public service organisation transparency would be the norm, and confidentiality only requested in circumstances that justify such a request. The desire of the administration c.q. Ms Bergot to cover up its wrongdoing in the form of unjustified and spurious investigations and disciplinary actions against the elected staff representation is not a valid reason for demanding confidentiality. Moreover, staff has a legitimate interest in being informed about such attacks, in particular when the administration simultaneously makes public claims to the effect that it is seeking a social dialogue.

27. The Disciplinary Committee found me guilty of the majority of the charges. It recommended the penalty of dismissal. The Disciplinary Committee explicitly stated that in view of my many years of positive contribution to the EPO there would, however, be no justification for a reduction of my pensionable rights and that the standard conditions of dismissal should be applied. The President nevertheless decided on a 20% reduction of my pension. The decision of the President to overstep the recommendation of the Disciplinary Committee is arbitrary and shows bad faith.

28. The recent investigations and the disciplinary procedure against me are not my first. I have already been investigated and downgraded for alleged harassment despite a unanimous recommendation of the disciplinary committee in my favour. At the time the alleged offense was a single sentence expressing a common opinion (belief) within the Munich staff representation that was contained in a confidential e-mail sent to a small group of people (17 persons, including myself) via a suepo.org address.

29. The repeated investigations against me (now 3 in total), the fabricated accusations and the total disproportionality of the sanctions are indicative of a process of institutional harassment against me. The permanent, unexplained and seemingly unjustified, house-ban1 further illustrates the apparent desire of the administration to inflict maximum damage upon me and to isolate me from staff.

REQUESTS

30. I request the above indicated decision as well as the earlier decision to down-grade me to be quashed. I also request full reimbursement of my legal costs as well as moral and/or exemplary damages for the prejudice suffered.

______________ 1 €«I remind you that you remain excluded from entering the Office premises at any time €», Yann Chabod, letter dated 25.01.16


The part about "a process of institutional harassment against me" is reminiscent of older letters.

How can justice be expected to happen in secret when the EPO management shamelessly lies to the staff about the process? ⬆

Comments

Recent Techrights' Posts

An American and South Korean Cartel Artificially Inflating the Prices You Pay for Computers (or Any Service That Relies on Computers, I.e. Almost Everything)
As long as the principal tenant of the White House is a white-collar criminal we can expect only cover-up and participation, not a crackdown
The EPO Still on Strike. 141 Tickets Opened Regarding Lack of Toilet Paper (or Similar).
Yesterday staff representatives at the EPO in The Hague (LSCTH] spoke of a meeting which took place a month ago
 
Links 17/11/2026: Jensen Huang's Price-Fixing Story, "Russian Attacks Aimed At 'Breaking The Spirit' Of Ukrainians"
Links for the day
NVIDIA Continues Diving and Press Reports Speak of Business Crimes of Jensen Huang (Not China or Sex)
The deeper they go...
Gemini Links 17/11/2026: Super Power, Knowember, Writing in Shorthand, Cooking over a Woodstove, Decoupling Code and Content
Links for the day
Links 17/11/2026: California Sues Slop Peddlers and Nvidia Was Already in Trouble Before the Jensen Huang Mess
Links for the day
NVIDIA Corp Was Grossly Overvalued, Lost 36.06% of Alleged "Market Value" in 5-6 Weeks
NVIDIA has many of "obligations" (to pay), not money
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Monday, November 16, 2026
IRC logs for Monday, November 16, 2026
Intercontinental Brigading - Part XXXXXIII - An Attack on the Dignity of Reporters and Their Family Members (by Proxy/Attack Dogs)
The Microsofters seem to be super-upset that I uncovered Microsoft fraud
IBM and OSI Said opensource.net Would Replace opensource.com, But It Has Been Dead for 1.5 Years and the Person Who Had Made Promises Left OSI
Over a year ago he left
Red Hat and IBM Meet Targets (of Pushing People Out)
now there are claims of security breach inside IBM, but no press reports related to that
Gemini Links 17/11/2026: Reading Clocks and StreetComplete
Links for the day
Buy Influence "Over Dinner With The Register."
The Register MS is the facilitator or 'pimp'
While the Slop Industry Wobbles The Register MS Bags Tens of Thousands of Pounds to Publish Propaganda With "AI" 23 Times in It
The Register MS is selling its reputation away
The Real News About the White House (Not the 'Exclusive' Rupert Murdoch Published for It at Midnight Monday) is Complicity in NVIDIA Fraud
They need a distraction from commercial malpractice
Links 16/11/2026: Microsoft Increases Indian Clown Computing Prices by 15%, Meta Fined $887 Million in Italy
Links for the day
Gemini Links 16/11/2026: Container Gardening, Laughing at an LLM, "EU 72-Hour Guidelines Through a Lawyer's Eyes"
Links for the day
I Tried Linux Again After 10 Years - Here's What Blew My Mind
It's like leaving your hometown as a teenager and coming back to find the weird kid from high school is now the mayor
Links 16/11/2026: Data Centers (White Elephants) as Tax Evasion Scam/Ploy, Social Control Media Harms Boomers, "Microsoft Outage Hindered Ticket Issuance in Greece"
Links for the day
The Register MS Seems to Have Moved to 'The Cloud' (WeWork) After Shutting Down the Office
The Register MS will have a hard time explaining why it so passionately participated in the "hey hi" pyramid scheme
Holiday Plans (We Need More IBM Whistleblowers)
in particular with possession of material in relation to PIPs, NDAs, and silent RAs
After Microsoft Outage GNU/Linux Usage Leaps to 9% in the UK (Where Public Services Were Notoriously Overdependent on Microsoft Disservices)
in the UK we are extremely dependent on Microsoft stuff in the NHS, courts, law firms, police etc.
Richard Stallman Was Right About the Corruption of the Term "Artificial intelligence"
This will do severe damage to the administration which participated in the scam
The Dictatorship Already Working to Distract From NVIDIA Corruption and Slop Bubble Reaching Its Limits
Circular financing is simply a form of financial fraud
IBM Selling Itself, Piecewise, to Raise Money (to Pay Salaries)
IBM is a zombie waiting to inhale one last time (last breath)
"Allies" of Disgraced NVIDIA CEO Aren't About Morality, They're Just Covering Up Their Own Backs (and Loans)
The next stage is examining the false accounting (fraud basically)
No Outage Since 2023
I did host from home between 2020 and 2023
Intercontinental Brigading - Part XXXXXII - Back Doors and Kill Switches From Microsoft Are Objectively Undesirable
"I dual-boot Omarchy and Windows. Be careful updating your BIOS. Mine made Omarchy unbootable."
Gemini Links 16/11/2026: Enjoyable Coding, Social Control Media Considered Harmful, and Recursive Rectangular Subdivision
Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Sunday, November 15, 2026
IRC logs for Sunday, November 15, 2026
Cusp of Collapse
NVIDIA Corp (NASDAQ: NVDA) is set to open in the red tomorrow
Getting Fed Up Not Only With Microsoft But Also Windows
This morning we wrote about North America
Layoffs and Silent Layoffs (e.g. PIPs) as a "Break" From IBM
If the press doesn't report it, then it never happened, right?
Microsoft XBox at 25 and All-Time Low
XBox will be "officially" dead (not the brand) when sales fall below some threshold and then production is halted, sort of like Apple's Vision Pro
Links 15/11/2026: Microsoft Already Emitting Chaff to Distract From Its Catastrophe, Jensen Huang Deemed Just 'Fall Guy' Amid Collapse of the Pyramid Scheme
Links for the day
Gemini Links 15/11/2026: CD Players Live on and Self-Hosting from Home Fallacy
Links for the day
When Short is Way Too Short (Superficiality, Lowering of Entropy)
Demonstrating how truly worthless social control media was all along
Techrights Hates Slop Bots
They benefit nobody
The Economy is Fine! (If Only for China!)
The future is slop! If not, then it's China's fault! It's "sabotaging" the "Western hey hi" in this "hey hi arms race!"
"IT" as "Musical Chairs" (on the Deck of The Titanic)
Each generation will get worse for "IT"
Salesforce in Trouble, Debt Nearly Quadrupled in 9 Months
Salesforce is perishing in a deep pool of debt
"Microsoft is Next IBM"
The words of a Microsoft insider and responses to that
IRC is Decentralised
Bye, Microsoft Teams/Skype
Links 15/11/2026: Murdoch's "WSJ Buries Stephen Miller's Racism" and "America Has Entered a New Age of Propaganda"
Links for the day
In the UK, GNU/Linux Usage Soared During Microsoft Downtime
since the massive outage GNU/Linux usage soared to over 10%
Google Slop About Richard Stallman Shows Stallman Was Right, LLMs are BS Generators
Google slop is the "new Google"
Spouse of Garrett Needs to Get "Several Firearms" to Feel Safe Amid Divorce (Garrett Has a "Girlfriend" Now)
Seems like Isis and my wife have a lot in common when it comes to Garrett
Vista 11 is Small
Can Microsoft survive the fall of Windows?
Six Richard Stallman and FSF Talks This Month (FSF Staff at Ohio State University)
Dr. Stallman's talks in Ecuador are well timed because of the collapse of the LLMs (slop) pyramid scheme
NVIDIA's Crisis Has Only Just began
NVIDIA Corp (NASDAQ: NVDA) is set to open in the red tomorrow
IBM Has Destroyed Red Hat and Hashicorp, Insiders Say It's the Usual From IBM:
Bluewashing is a death wave
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Saturday, November 14, 2026
IRC logs for Saturday, November 14, 2026
Techrights Was Right About Slop Destroying Development Communities and Projects
Slop does not improve your project. It kills the community. Without community, what is left? A 'botfarm'?
Intercontinental Brigading - Part XXXXXI - Harassment Law and "Things Are Unfairly Asymmetric" (Exploring the Boundaries of Death Threats and Various Threats From America)
the sort of "technofascism" that our country must learn to confront rather than facilitate
Gemini Links 15/11/2026: "The Bastards Can Never Win" and "The Last Low-Tech Generation"
Links for the day