Bonum Certa Men Certa

My Year as a Digital Vegan — Part VII — Staying the Course and Fake It Till You Make It?

By Dr. Andy Farnell

Series parts:

  1. My Year as a Digital Vegan — Part I — 2021 in Review
  2. My Year as a Digital Vegan — Part II — Impact of a 'COVID Year'
  3. My Year as a Digital Vegan — Part III — Lost and Found; Losing the Mobile Phone (Cellphone)
  4. My Year as a Digital Vegan — Part IV — Science or Scientism?
  5. My Year as a Digital Vegan — Part V — Change in Societal Norms and Attitudes
  6. My Year as a Digital Vegan — Part VI — The Right Words
  7. YOU ARE HERE ☞ Staying the Course and Fake It Till You Make It?


Fake Tech VeganSummary: Dr. Andy Farnell continues sharing his 'Tech Vegan' experiences from this past year; this series will carry on well into the new year (2022)

Staying the course



Another theme I have dealt with this year is "tenacity versus resignation". People have different coping mechanisms to technological stressors, some get mad, some get even, some get the hell out of there. I began the year helping a student edit an inspiring story of how he graduated without non-free software. I was very impressed with this individual's ability to unerringly act with firm politeness and perseverance against the kind of institutional steamroller that crushes other students.



"I began the year helping a student edit an inspiring story of how he graduated without non-free software. I was very impressed with this individual's ability to unerringly act with firm politeness and perseverance against the kind of institutional steamroller that crushes other students."Elsewhere I have encountered learned helplessness (see Seligman et al. Hiroto75). Defeatism is one of the greatest enemies we face in seeking digital rights, as people seldom feel able to confront what they do not understand. A disappointing number of people (wrongly) said to me "What's the point boycotting your supermarket Andy? They're all just doing the same". Despite there being absolutely no evidence that other British supermarkets were violating privacy rights there's a pervading sense around tech that a possibility once is a necessity forever, which feeds into a nihilistic refusal to resist even the most tepid incursions by technological abusers.



What I've learned is that small, polite but resolute gestures make big changes. Standing up for principles as a single voice does make a difference. Sometimes you need to start as an army of one and remember that all progress "depends upon the unreasonable man". Despite every armchair theorist's wisdom on the intractability of 'network effects' we successfully flipped our whole family communication circle from Whatsapp to Signal in a few weeks.



But this raises a troubling question. By what right am I an evangelist? What prophet made me an influencer and missionary charged with saving the souls of technological sinners? None whatsoever. And wouldn't it be grandiose and egotistical to take on such a role?



How the world has changed since the '90s when I had a T-shirt that said, "No. I will not fix your computer", because like every other geek I was inundated with requests for help. "Help me install a new hard drive". "Help me connect to the Internet". "Help me build this web page"… I have yet to hear an honest request - "Please, help me get off social media".



"Like many of the most insidious harms, technological harms are invisible, delayed, accumulative and tolerance building. All you can do is stand back and hope others see the harm and abuse they are bringing upon themselves."I wrote several chapters in Digital Vegan, about addiction, cults, entrenched behaviour and the impossibility of proselytising others to a crazy cause. I advise against it - and indeed the book title is an ironic take on that problem. Anyone who has dealt with alcohol or drug problems knows the pain of seeing those you love harm themselves and knowing that, generally, any interventions only make things worse. Like many of the most insidious harms, technological harms are invisible, delayed, accumulative and tolerance building. All you can do is stand back and hope others see the harm and abuse they are bringing upon themselves.



Fake it till you make it?



Being a Vegan "impostor" myself I've developed a sharp nose for "Fake Digital Vegans" - those who say "Oh yes, how ghastly it all is", while messaging on Facebook. They care deeply about everything, so long as changing would not inconvenience them. I've also noticed a slew of click-bait stories in the popular press that tease us with "I quit my smartphone for a month and you'll never guess what happened to me next!". Actually, I can guess… you got paid a big bag of money for lying about it. Celebrities making grand public theatre of their few weeks without Alexa (the horror) actually subtract from responsible, moderate use.



"All platforms encourage token dissenters, because that legitimises them as "democratic"."Only this week another latecomer joined the party. Comedian David Baddiel made his own apologies on the BBC for correctly naming everything wrong with social media, including his own daughter's distress, before admitting his hopeless addiction and crawling back to it. The point is that Baddiel is a courageous intellectual, but ultimately seemed defeated in his bid to extricate. What does that bode for us lesser beings?



All platforms encourage token dissenters, because that legitimises them as "democratic". One cannot wholly burn-down ones own platform in protest. How did this public spectacle of failure help? And if he had been successful, who would have ever heard of David Baddiel again? So, here lies the paradox of celebrities attempting to set an example regarding social media.



I've come to think that fetishism of "tech-fasting" only cements addict-like behaviour. It's flip-side is Cyber Monday bingeing on IoT junk to "reward yourself". Do or do not, there is no try. Like Baddiel's, these accounts are generally pessimistic in their conclusion that it's "impossible" to stand up against Big-Tech. They are coded messages from the establishment saying, "Don't be so silly, nobody can really live without a smartphone and social media". Of course that's not true. But you won't ever hear that on social media.



"When I made video lectures criticising Google, it felt awful that the most likely outlet would be YouTube."Thus I am ambivalent towards those conflicted pragmatists "changing the system from the inside". I decline joining their "Overthrow The Empire" Facebook groups. Yet I have respect for their courage. It takes something to fully embrace hypocrisy, or dualism. When I made video lectures criticising Google, it felt awful that the most likely outlet would be YouTube.



Successful projects I have encountered seem advocate modest and gradual change and are not too Puritan to use the platforms they denounce to spread their message. However, many projects that attempt to address subjects like social media dependency disorder and have been active since around 2015 have not found traction. They've achieved only modest success despite the growing prevalence and visibility of the problem. Why is this?



"If token dissent is no longer being tolerated and disaffection swept under the rug, it means the big platforms are scared."Amidst mounting scientific evidence and whistleblower reports, widespread sentiment on the need for society to back away from collective smartphone and social media delirium is booming. However, critical discussion now encounters suppression across all corporate mass communications systems like Twitter, Facebook, TikTok, etc.



Active censorship of social technology critique is a good thing (and quite inevitable). It marks a vital advance in the sequence "first they ignore you, then they ridicule you, then they fight you, then you win." If token dissent is no longer being tolerated and disaffection swept under the rug, it means the big platforms are scared.





_______


Bibliography

  • [Hiroto75] "Hiroto & Seligman, Generality of learned helplessness in man, "Journal of Personality and Social Psychology", 31, 311-327 (1975).



Recent Techrights' Posts

Why Government Data on "Job Openings" is Typically a Lie (Perpetrated in Part by Corporations)
Millions (yes, millions!) of fake "openings" exist in the US alone, based on a survey done last year
All the Latest 'Articles' in This Fake 'News' Site Are SPAM, LLM Slop, or Both (to Googlebomb CES)
These people destroy the Web
LLMs Destroy the Web Not Just by Filling It With Cruft and Chaff (Slop)
It'll destroy many sites or increase the cost of running them
Who Says Microsoft Is Actually Succeeding as a Business? (It's Faking a Lot)
Microsoft has been cooking the books for a long time
The Free Software Foundation (FSF) Turns 40 This Year, Now It Shows Possible Logos for the Special Event That Celebrates Sharing
FSF's options in a nutshell
President Biden Has Less Than a Fortnight Left to Pardon Julian Assange (Donald Trump's Regime Plotted to Assassinate Assange)
Don't try to lecture/explain/preach to people that exposing corruption, resisting corruption, and merely covering corruption is "bad" because crime "is everywhere"
 
IBMers Question IBM's Decision to Send Money to "Chinese Military Companies" in Spite of US Sanctions
Some people bring this up now
[Meme] Real Money and Fake (Speculative, Fictional) Money
"Looking for the next $400,000,000,000 in 'investment'"
Microsoft LinkedIn Going 'the Way of the Epstein'
LinkedIn is going downhill
Will 2025 Bring Recovery of News Sites or Just More LLM Slop? Probably the Latter.
The Web is deteriorating. Geminispace does not have LLM trash (yet).
Engagement in Microsoft GitHub Falls, Expect More Layoffs and Office Closures
Maybe it'll become an "open secret" if some rebellious whistleblower contacts us
[Meme] Microsoft's January 6th
Most Microsoft employees want to leave the company
Microsoft Starts 2025 Like 2024: Mass Layoffs Every Month!
It's a company in tailspin
Links 08/01/2025: Arrest of Yoon Suk Yeol Still Due, Prime Minister of Canada Stepped Down
Links for the day
Gemini Links 08/01/2025: Why Mastodon Sucks and Fake Code Generated by Scanning Real Code
Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Tuesday, January 07, 2025
IRC logs for Tuesday, January 07, 2025
Microsoft Has a Google Problem (and GNU/Linux Problem) in Sweden
Sweden likes Chromebooks, Web access data suggests
Less Than a Tenth of a Second
Look ma, static pages!
[Meme] The LLM Salesperson
LLMs are net liability (loss)
Links 06/01/2025: 10 Years Since Terrorism Against Satire in France
Links for the day
Gemini Links 07/01/2025: Praise of E-mail and App Store 'Invention'
Links for the day
[Meme] Removing Correct Information
publish what's true
From 92% to Less Than 25%: How Microsoft Lost Norway (and Still Loses What's Left)
just like in most countries
Matt Birchler: "This is why it’s important for people to own their presence on the web, especially when it comes to government agencies that need to communicate with people."
hours ago
Microsoft Continues to Attack Users' Choice
We're being herded into uniformity
Diversity of Views, Diversity of Sources
We want diversity, not monopoly
With 10 Days Left the Free Software Foundation (FSF) Looks to Raise Just Over $50,000 More
More than 10 days in Boston (eastern coast)
In Europe, Russia's Yandex About to Become Bigger Than Microsoft's Bing, Google Search Estimated to Have Grown Since the LLM Hype Began
Remember that Bing had many layoffs in the past 2 years, the corporate media barely reported on those
The Google Exodus That Wasn't
Search engines exist to serve their masters, not their users
Google (Blogger) is Already Disintegrating and It's a Reminder of the Great Dangers of Outsourcing Blogs to Companies (Including Automattic or WordPress.com)
Plus, Phoronix admits that using PHP - and not static pages - causes the Web site to be DDOSed, sort of
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Monday, January 06, 2025
IRC logs for Monday, January 06, 2025
Links 06/01/2025: Presidential Arrest and Kursk as Bargaining Card
Links for the day
BetaNews Has Basically Become a Spamfarm, All the Latest 'Articles' Are SPAM and LLM Slop
No kidding...
On BetaNews Latest Technology News: "We are moderately confident this text was [LLM Chatbot] generated"
The future of newsrooms or another site circling down the drain with spam, slop, or both?
Links 06/01/2025: Cyber Security in 2025 Still a Joke (Undermined by Authorities Themselves), US Layoffs 2025 Commence Today
Links for the day
Links 06/01/2025: Security Theatre and BBS Archives
Links for the day
[Meme] Don't Worry, They Say There's 7 Trillion Dollars Waiting at the Top
At whose expense? With whose consent?
Fedora Seems to be Dying of Neglect by IBM
IBM is doing to Fedora what it did to CentOS. It's still there, but only/mostly by name.
TRILLIONS! And TRILLIONS and TRILLIONS and TRILLIONS! Invest today!
If the mainstream media and national broadcasters know (and can see) it's a pyramid scheme, why aren't they calling it?
[Meme] A Corporate Wolf in Sheep Clothing
Will Apple "fans" pay attention? Will they even care?
British Police: Register a New Account With Unscrupulous American Companies (Microsoft and MElon X) to "Follow" Us
When authorities outsource to foreign social control media
Links 06/01/2025: Leftover General News and Dangers of US Debt Default
Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Sunday, January 05, 2025
IRC logs for Sunday, January 05, 2025
Gemini Links 06/01/2025: End of Christmas, New Leaves and Fresh Starts
Links for the day