Bonum Certa Men Certa

The Patent Litigation 'Industry' Controls the European Patent Office (Vendor Capture) and Everyone Suffers, Even the European Union

posted by Roy Schestowitz on Dec 14, 2024

Objective setting 2025

Teasers can say stuff in a nutshell or in a few seconds. But what's the source or the substance? Well, the António Campinos "Mafia" (same Mafia that was started by Benoît Battistelli along with Campinos at EUIPO) seems incapable or respecting the law. Patent offices exist not to maximise the number of monopolies they hand out, but who cares, right? The EPO openly admits that its sole goal is money and it began calling applicants "customers", "clients" etc. No wonder they grant European software patents - i.e. patents which are both illegal and undesirable - and even patents on chewing gum. If the EPO doesn't sort itself out, it'll need to be altogether abolished (which is unlikely to happen when the political discourse is captured by large corporations).

Today we relay an EPO publications dated just 4 days ago (this past Tuesday).

Objective setting 2025

What you can do at the time of objective / target setting

The 2025 draft budget[1] announced a planned production of 413 000 SEO (Search Examination Opposition) products for 4 025 planned examiner posts. This is a 7% increase from the 2024 plan. It does not come as much of a surprise seeing the now 10-year-old trend of target increases, which coincides with the lifetime of the new career system.

2025 draft budget

Still, during a recent meeting of the LSCTH with VP1, the question was raised as to why such a steep increase was requested from DG1 staff when the financial study[2] foresees an increase in productivity of 2.1% per annum. His reply was that the financial study is the touchstone of the yearly planning, that the 2,1% increase will not necessarily be implemented linearly, and that the increased targets recover from the dip[3] in productivity of recent years – see also orange line on the graph above.

Why is this a problem?

Apart from the period of 2020-2022, DG1 staff seems to have been meeting the challenge of these increased targets – see graph above – and is catching up with the maximum production per examiner of 2019.

However, SP2028[4] has one goal: sustainability. The financial sustainability of the EPO seems to be on the right track: the “gap” announced by the 2019 financial study has already been filled, the independent actuaries estimate that the pension liabilities are adequately covered, and the EPO – a public service organisation not supposed to make benefits - has regularly been producing surpluses of nearly €400m[5].
But we doubt very much that the productivity increases of the order of 30% in 10 years are sustainable.
We also fear for our colleagues’ health[6] and the quality of the final products[7], and invite higher management to put in practise the statements of SP2028: “putting the wellbeing of our people first” (p.17) and “The EPO aims for a complete and accurate search covering all aspects of the invention and a thorough written opinion.”, (p.42).

Some of you have informed us that your teams will be receiving double digit increases in targets for 2025. Others, that individual time capacity is completely disregarded, and all colleagues will receive the same targets irrespective of how much time they will have available to reach them. Or that the files allocated to team members on long term (sick) leave will be redistributed to the rest of the team.
This is once again at odds with the SP2028: “It is about providing a framework for a flexible and healthy work-life balance, putting the wellbeing of our people first and nurturing a community that, through diversity and inclusion, brings fresh perspectives and innovative thinking to the table” (p.17).

We have informed VP1 of such practices, who seemed to say they should not occur. We reiterate the message here.

What you can do about it

On unreasonable target increases:
The intranet announcement “Performance cycle 2025”[8] states: “Staff and managers are invited to engage in collaborative discussions as the basis for well-written goals that serve as a reliable guide for the coming year”. We therefore encourage you to re-negotiate your targets and if that is not possible at least to communicate your doubts on the objectives setting with your line management, possibly collectively (i.e. as a whole team or even directorate), and possibly using the template in Annex below as a guide.

It is important that you be conservative and realistic and avoid committing to unattainable objectives for which you alone will be deemed to be responsible and will have to bear the consequences, in 2025 and beyond.

On health:
Work should not make you sick: if your work is having negative effects on your health (exhaustion, stress, sleeping problems, headaches, trouble disconnecting…), we advise to take sick leave, consult your doctor and report it to your line manager and to OHS.

On quality:
We advise to ask for written instructions of how to perform your tasks such as to reach the targets – see also template below. This is to avoid that the responsibility for the quality of your work and the consequences thereof be placed on your shoulders.

Discussing objectives is reasonable, but committing to a target imposed on you is not. We therefore recommend informing your direct line manager in writing – possibly using the template below. Your email should then be appended to your 2025 performance appraisal in the successfactors tool. We would appreciate if you could then forward your email to redacted@suepo.org or redacted@epo.org.

Don’t hesitate to contact us or your local staff committee The Hague.

Related publications:

 
Kind regards,
Your SUEPO TH committee – M18B10 and De Bruyn Kopsstraat, 15, Rijswijk

[...]

 


[1] See CA/50/24, p.6 and p.100

[2] Financial Study 2023

[3] The productivity dip of 2020-2022 seems to be due to covid, wave of retirements, "low-hanging fruits” already picked, DG1 staff used as testers for the Minimum Viable Product tools, IT system disruptions, etc.

[4] Strategic Plan 2028

[5] See slide 7 of the January 2024 LSCTH GA presentation on objective setting and SUEPO’s comment on the President’s announcement.

[6] During the COHSEC of 22.02.2024, OHS physicians voiced that also highly productive staff – mainly examiners and including some team managers -  work overtime, come to their limits and start to suffer from work related stress causing them to contact OHS with health issues. They mentioned that the 12% increase in stress related symptoms between 2022 and 2023 might be only the tip of the iceberg. See also agenda points by members nominated by the CSC, p.3-4, and Key facts 2023, table 4.

[7] See also Industry Patent Quality Charter (IPQC), which is publicly critical about the substantive quality of EPO patents.

[8] See „Performance cycle 2025“, EPO Intranet, 20 November 2024.
 



 
ANNEX: template email to manager, please use only the parts which apply to you, delete and / or adapt the rest.    
 


 
Dear xxxx,
 
On [FILL IN DATE] my objectives were set at [FILL IN]. As in the past, I commit to working to the best of my abilities in 2025. However, the following points prevent me from presently committing to the objectives set for 2025:

 
Best regards
 

They quote the Office regarding “putting the wellbeing of our people first”; well, words are cheap. In practice, not only does the EPO destroy the minds of EPO workers; it equips aggressive corporate giants (typically based outside Europe but hiring European law firms) and patent trolls with lousy (but expensive to invalidate) patents they in turn use to destroy the wallbeing of Europeans.

Jolly Person

The EPO is a disgrace. If the EU cares about its reputation and long-term viability, then it must intervene ASAP. Its fate is tied to EPO's, not only through high-level corruption but also fake 'courts' which represent a rapid death to EU justice.

Guess who's laughing the last last here (profiting from this chaos).

Other Recent Techrights' Posts

The Word About the Upcoming Talk by Richard Stallman - Scheduled for Friday This Week - Has Spread ("The Cost of Freedom," Lausanne, Switzerland)
So the word is spreading
Microsoft Front Group Starts the Year by Championing Underage (or Child) Labour
the fake 'FSF'
Chatbots Are Not Data-Driven, They're Human-Censored and Rely on Wage Slaves (and Sometimes Unpaid Volunteers)
This is the Microsoft wage slavery
 
Links 13/01/2025: Conflicts, Prisoner Exchange, and Homes on Fire
Links for the day
Angola: Microsoft Windows Falls Below 10%
Microsoft has a really bad 2024 in Africa
[Meme] Twitter ("X") Has Been Grooming Radicals Since 2022
Musk's very own "grooming gang"
[Meme] What Free Speech Ought to Mean
It does not sound like RMS suggests anything other than quitting social control media
Gemini Links 13/01/2025: RestFest, Yule, and Deedum
Links for the day
Modern Web Browsers as Web Censorship Software
We continue to recommend Geminispace
Two Weeks From Now Dr. Richard Stallman Speaks at The Summit of Future 2025 (India)
he will be giving a "Keynote Address" in India
Microsoft is Tight With Money: It's About the Salaries ('Cost' of the Workers)
a question of cost, not skill
Google Got People Sort of Addicted to Android So It Can Cash in (Services, App Store, Advertising) Decades Later
This is not software freedom
The Free Software Foundation Reaches 370k Dollars in Funding, Due Date is January 17th When Richard Stallman is Guest of Honour in Lausanne (Switzerland)
Even fellow board members seem unaware of it
Record Lows for Windows (Microsoft) in Botswana
The market share of Vista 11 is seen as going down
Preserving Deleted Articles About Bill Gates Talking Like a Drug Dealer About Computer Users
Now it's 2025. Different challenge.
Links 13/01/2025: Disinformation, Social Control Media Actively Promoting Nazism, and Catchup With Ukraine
Links for the day
TPM Boosters Inside Debian (TPM Isn't About Security, It is About Control Over Users and Their Machines)
We're not rushing to any conclusions
Aaron Swartz Died 12 Years Ago After a Vicious Government Campaign to Stop Him
The Aaron Swartz story is a reminder of the importance of having verifiable/verified information out there for the general public to see
Links 13/01/2025: GitLab Enshittification and Minimalism and Efficiency with Gemini Protocol
Links for the day
Links 13/01/2025: Hardware, Health, and Conflicts
Links for the day
Microsoft Appears to Have Fallen to Only 15% in Maldives
This is a problem for Microsoft
Rumours of IBM Canada Layoffs
We'll keep a vigilant eye on this
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Sunday, January 12, 2025
IRC logs for Sunday, January 12, 2025
Bots Covering Debian Releases
It would be quite safe to guess that chatbots were at least partly leveraged for that text
Gemini Links 12/01/2025: No Country For Old Men, Burned Homes, and "Planet P is Clean"
Links for the day
Slopwatch: Brittany Day and Brian Fagioli Are Still at It, Googlebombing "Linux" With LLM Slop (Taking Away Traffic From the Articles They're Plagiarising)
Some more sites that used to cover GNU/Linux have turned into slopfarms
Links 12/01/2025: Microsoft Admits It's Laying Off Staff Only Where Staff is "Expensive" (Race to the Bottom)
Links for the day
[Meme] Being High on Drugs Isn't Happiness (Likewise, Being a "Star" in Social Control Media is Temporary)
Many entities - or people - will regret telling everybody "follow me on Twitter"
[Meme] They Say That RMS Says the "F" Word (Freedom) Too Much...
About 32.7k US dollars are now left for the FSF to raise (in 6 days)
Links 12/01/2025: More Sanctions Against Russia, SCOTUS Signals Fentanylware (TikTok) Ban Will Stay
Links for the day
[Meme] A Jihad Against Servers the User Controls
We need to strive for and work towards greater control by users over "their" servers
Microsoft Azure-Only Bugs in "Linux" Can "Compromise the System."
From ubuntu.com and linux.org a few days ago
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Saturday, January 11, 2025
IRC logs for Saturday, January 11, 2025
Gemini Links 12/01/2025: DHL Express Does Not Deliver, Oddmuse Update
Links for the day
Links 11/01/2025: Social Control Media Facing Sanctions, Carter Respected at Funeral
Links for the day
If TikTok (China) Has the Rights of American Persons, Then ByteDance Can be Sentenced to Death
TikTok - like Julian Assange - does not enjoy any protections of the First Amendment and since it's not a person it would lack these protections as an American company, too
After a Year of Layoffs in Microsoft Nigeria (and Microsoft in Africa at Large) Windows Falls to New Lows and Bing Falls to 0.46% "Market Share"
Of course Microsoft gave bribes in Nigeria to suppress GNU/Linux adoption
An Important Lesson About Patents and Patent Maximalism (They Drive People and Companies Away)
This previously happened in Texas, where companies perceived their presence (in any form) to be a liability as patent trolls could drag them to friendly courts and win "damages"
When It Comes to Fentanylware (TikTok), a Digital Weapon of a Hostile Entity, Common Dreams is Jumping the Shark Again (Years After It Ran Out of Steam or Money)
Or maybe it likes the agenda promoted (curated) by Fentanylware (TikTok) and its parent company, Bytedance or Chinese Community Party (CPP)
BetaNews is Now Officially a Spamfarm With Phantom Authors and Fake Text (SPAM and Linkspam Made With LLM Slop)
That's it, the site is virtually dead now (maybe that was the plan all along)
Hazem Abbas of medevel is Ruining His Site With LLM Slop
Some of his articles are original, but now everything is suspect
[Meme] Real and Fake (or "several influential "open source" organizations [which] have come to be dominated by large companies")
The Free Software Foundation has not sold out
Free Software Foundation: Anchoring the FSF in its values
Original by Free Software Foundation
GNU/Linux Surges to All-Time Highs in Greenland, Windows Sinks to All-Time Lows
a lot of GNU/Linux gets detected there lately
Microsoft's "Donald Trump First" Doctrine
national deficits growing
Microsoft in Trouble as Azure Breaks and Only Days After Promising Investment in "Datacentres" Construction of Actual Datacentres Paused (Expect More Azure Layoffs Very Soon)
No wonder many people who got trapped inside Azure quit Azure, which keeps bleeding (losses and layoffs)
Gemini Links 11/01/2025: Wildfire, Militia and the Mole, IRC vs Social Control Media
Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Friday, January 10, 2025
IRC logs for Friday, January 10, 2025