Bonum Certa Men Certa

The Patent Litigation 'Industry' Controls the European Patent Office (Vendor Capture) and Everyone Suffers, Even the European Union

posted by Roy Schestowitz on Dec 14, 2024

Objective setting 2025

Teasers can say stuff in a nutshell or in a few seconds. But what's the source or the substance? Well, the António Campinos "Mafia" (same Mafia that was started by Benoît Battistelli along with Campinos at EUIPO) seems incapable or respecting the law. Patent offices exist not to maximise the number of monopolies they hand out, but who cares, right? The EPO openly admits that its sole goal is money and it began calling applicants "customers", "clients" etc. No wonder they grant European software patents - i.e. patents which are both illegal and undesirable - and even patents on chewing gum. If the EPO doesn't sort itself out, it'll need to be altogether abolished (which is unlikely to happen when the political discourse is captured by large corporations).

Today we relay an EPO publications dated just 4 days ago (this past Tuesday).

Objective setting 2025

What you can do at the time of objective / target setting

The 2025 draft budget[1] announced a planned production of 413 000 SEO (Search Examination Opposition) products for 4 025 planned examiner posts. This is a 7% increase from the 2024 plan. It does not come as much of a surprise seeing the now 10-year-old trend of target increases, which coincides with the lifetime of the new career system.

2025 draft budget

Still, during a recent meeting of the LSCTH with VP1, the question was raised as to why such a steep increase was requested from DG1 staff when the financial study[2] foresees an increase in productivity of 2.1% per annum. His reply was that the financial study is the touchstone of the yearly planning, that the 2,1% increase will not necessarily be implemented linearly, and that the increased targets recover from the dip[3] in productivity of recent years – see also orange line on the graph above.

Why is this a problem?

Apart from the period of 2020-2022, DG1 staff seems to have been meeting the challenge of these increased targets – see graph above – and is catching up with the maximum production per examiner of 2019.

However, SP2028[4] has one goal: sustainability. The financial sustainability of the EPO seems to be on the right track: the “gap” announced by the 2019 financial study has already been filled, the independent actuaries estimate that the pension liabilities are adequately covered, and the EPO – a public service organisation not supposed to make benefits - has regularly been producing surpluses of nearly €400m[5].
But we doubt very much that the productivity increases of the order of 30% in 10 years are sustainable.
We also fear for our colleagues’ health[6] and the quality of the final products[7], and invite higher management to put in practise the statements of SP2028: “putting the wellbeing of our people first” (p.17) and “The EPO aims for a complete and accurate search covering all aspects of the invention and a thorough written opinion.”, (p.42).

Some of you have informed us that your teams will be receiving double digit increases in targets for 2025. Others, that individual time capacity is completely disregarded, and all colleagues will receive the same targets irrespective of how much time they will have available to reach them. Or that the files allocated to team members on long term (sick) leave will be redistributed to the rest of the team.
This is once again at odds with the SP2028: “It is about providing a framework for a flexible and healthy work-life balance, putting the wellbeing of our people first and nurturing a community that, through diversity and inclusion, brings fresh perspectives and innovative thinking to the table” (p.17).

We have informed VP1 of such practices, who seemed to say they should not occur. We reiterate the message here.

What you can do about it

On unreasonable target increases:
The intranet announcement “Performance cycle 2025”[8] states: “Staff and managers are invited to engage in collaborative discussions as the basis for well-written goals that serve as a reliable guide for the coming year”. We therefore encourage you to re-negotiate your targets and if that is not possible at least to communicate your doubts on the objectives setting with your line management, possibly collectively (i.e. as a whole team or even directorate), and possibly using the template in Annex below as a guide.

It is important that you be conservative and realistic and avoid committing to unattainable objectives for which you alone will be deemed to be responsible and will have to bear the consequences, in 2025 and beyond.

On health:
Work should not make you sick: if your work is having negative effects on your health (exhaustion, stress, sleeping problems, headaches, trouble disconnecting…), we advise to take sick leave, consult your doctor and report it to your line manager and to OHS.

On quality:
We advise to ask for written instructions of how to perform your tasks such as to reach the targets – see also template below. This is to avoid that the responsibility for the quality of your work and the consequences thereof be placed on your shoulders.

Discussing objectives is reasonable, but committing to a target imposed on you is not. We therefore recommend informing your direct line manager in writing – possibly using the template below. Your email should then be appended to your 2025 performance appraisal in the successfactors tool. We would appreciate if you could then forward your email to redacted@suepo.org or redacted@epo.org.

Don’t hesitate to contact us or your local staff committee The Hague.

Related publications:

 
Kind regards,
Your SUEPO TH committee – M18B10 and De Bruyn Kopsstraat, 15, Rijswijk

[...]

 


[1] See CA/50/24, p.6 and p.100

[2] Financial Study 2023

[3] The productivity dip of 2020-2022 seems to be due to covid, wave of retirements, "low-hanging fruits” already picked, DG1 staff used as testers for the Minimum Viable Product tools, IT system disruptions, etc.

[4] Strategic Plan 2028

[5] See slide 7 of the January 2024 LSCTH GA presentation on objective setting and SUEPO’s comment on the President’s announcement.

[6] During the COHSEC of 22.02.2024, OHS physicians voiced that also highly productive staff – mainly examiners and including some team managers -  work overtime, come to their limits and start to suffer from work related stress causing them to contact OHS with health issues. They mentioned that the 12% increase in stress related symptoms between 2022 and 2023 might be only the tip of the iceberg. See also agenda points by members nominated by the CSC, p.3-4, and Key facts 2023, table 4.

[7] See also Industry Patent Quality Charter (IPQC), which is publicly critical about the substantive quality of EPO patents.

[8] See „Performance cycle 2025“, EPO Intranet, 20 November 2024.
 



 
ANNEX: template email to manager, please use only the parts which apply to you, delete and / or adapt the rest.    
 


 
Dear xxxx,
 
On [FILL IN DATE] my objectives were set at [FILL IN]. As in the past, I commit to working to the best of my abilities in 2025. However, the following points prevent me from presently committing to the objectives set for 2025:

 
Best regards
 

They quote the Office regarding “putting the wellbeing of our people first”; well, words are cheap. In practice, not only does the EPO destroy the minds of EPO workers; it equips aggressive corporate giants (typically based outside Europe but hiring European law firms) and patent trolls with lousy (but expensive to invalidate) patents they in turn use to destroy the wallbeing of Europeans.

Jolly Person

The EPO is a disgrace. If the EU cares about its reputation and long-term viability, then it must intervene ASAP. Its fate is tied to EPO's, not only through high-level corruption but also fake 'courts' which represent a rapid death to EU justice.

Guess who's laughing the last last here (profiting from this chaos).

Other Recent Techrights' Posts

"Journalism in Twitter" is a Paradox
"I am writing an article" is not the same as "I am writing a set of tweets" (usually random thoughts and unverified assertions, citing other unverified assertions)
The Future of the World Wide Web is Just 'Webapps' in Chrome, Not Web Pages in One's Browser of Choice
The monoculture gets worse, not better
EPO Corruption is a Real Threat to the European Union (EU). The EPO Helps Russia. If It Does Not Reform or Reboot, It Can Contribute to the Collapse of the EU and UPC (Which Was Never Legal or Even Constitutional, It's a Captured Kangaroo Court Controlled by the Patent Litigation Industry).
second-largest institution in Europe
Linux is Becoming Non-free Software and the So-called 'Linux' Foundation Likes It That Way (It's Fronting for Companies That Violate the GPL, the Licence of Linux)
What's happening here is, they rip off people using their "stolen" (GPL-violating) product
Red Hat: Thank You, Microsoft. Here's Your Paid-for Puff Pieces From Our Media Partner!
Sort of like "money laundering" (or funnelling of bribes) for bribed "journalists"
 
Today's Slopwatch
MaKenna Hensley's latest
Playing Social Control Media 'Games' Instead of Writing Articles
someone will need to run two sites. One is "In Support of Richard Stallman", which is run by oneself, and other is "Stallman Support".
The Patent Litigation 'Industry' Controls the European Patent Office (Vendor Capture) and Everyone Suffers, Even the European Union
Today we relay an EPO publications dated just 4 days ago (this past Tuesday)
No, Mr. "Journalist", You Might be Corrupt (But Denying It to Yourself and to Others to Pacify Your Consciousness)
"Journalists" like the label because it makes the job sound like an honourable profession and they're presumed objective
Stop Glorifying Murderers, They Aren't Helping Anybody
Murder isn't the solution. Murder is a problem.
Europe's "Manhattan Project" Should be Abandoning Microsoft, Moving Everything to Free (Libre) Software
At the moment, Microsoft draws much of its budget from taxpayers
Gemini Links 14/12/2024: Minor Thing About git and jujutsu
Links for the day
Links 14/12/2024: Adobe's Shares Collapse, Apple Publishes Fake News With LLMs
Links for the day
Links 14/12/2024: ChatGPT Down, Microsofter Bracing for Layoffs
Links for the day
Gemini Links 13/12/2024: Firing at Work, jujutsu, and Gemini Mode
Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Friday, December 13, 2024
IRC logs for Friday, December 13, 2024
Links 13/12/2024: British Journalism Awards and Censorship by Copyright Misuse
Links for the day
Gemini Links 13/12/2024: "Virtue Signaling", Gopher, HTML and the 90s Web Aesthetic
Links for the day
Links 13/12/2024: Military Buildup Around Taiwan, More Health Problems Associated With Social Control Media Illuminated
Links for the day
Maybe - and Hopefully - More News Sites Will Go "Static" (More New Material Published But Established Pages Served Directly From the File System)
Keeping things simple and light is important for the sake of scaling
[Meme] Vendor Capture for 'Civility's Sake'
"I CoCed him already"
[Teaser] The EPO is Still Calling Monopolies "Products"
Coming soon
Anonymity for Sources
At the moment we can learn about stories in person or in encrypted voice chat
What Topics We Prioritise
On fishing for topics to cover
Why We Cover the Topics That We've Long Focused on (by Choice)
We'll continue to cover suppressed issues because such issues are usually obstructed
[Meme] The Reasonable Man
"The reasonable man adapts himself to the world"
Oligarch-Owned Media Twists the Narrative and Demands More Surveillance
Corruption is the real issue here
Windows Falls to Single-Digit "Market Share" in Benin
Windows has fallen even further
[Meme] Doing Online Activism in Social Control Media
Dictators have always loved lists
Gemini Links 13/12/2024: Creative Moods, Berkeley DB, and More
Links for the day
Microsoft Windows Falls to New All-Time Low in Guatemala (Less Than a Quarter)
When it comes to operating systems, we don't think we've mentioned it before
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Thursday, December 12, 2024
IRC logs for Thursday, December 12, 2024
[Meme] Leave My /home Alone
A new version of Systemd
There's a New Version of Lagrange (Gemini Reader) and Its Developer is Making an IDE/Editor
I share or reciprocate almost anything I can through Gemini Protocol
International Troll Alert by Helen Plews
Helen Plews from Cybershow has this new article
Nick's Job at OSI: Promote Microsoft, Promote Proprietary Software
This is what Microsoft pays him to do
[Meme] Award-Winning Back-stabbing Opportunists
part of the rebel alliance
The FSF (Free Software Foundation, Inc.) Can Reach Its Funding Goal of $400,000. This Bothers the Imposters and Foes of the FSF.
Software Freedom is something we must perpetually fight for
Azerbaijan Rejects Microsoft
Azerbaijan seems to have very little interest in Microsoft
Linux Foundation Pays for LLM Slop (Puff Pieces Made by Bots) About the Linux Foundation
The so-called Linux Foundation is responsible for the production of spam and slop
[Meme] You Just Grab Him by the CoC
Sponsors of Python Software Foundation... "You don't like Python's corporate sponsor?"
Explaining What Deb Nicholson Does to the Python Software Foundation
Of course the OSI, which Nicholson also occupied, still helps Microsoft attack copyleft
IBM Said to Be Firing People Days Before Christmas
IBM is entering taboo territories
Microsoft Falls to Just 11% in Ivory Coast
Microsoft tried hard to catch up in mobile
General Consultative Committee (GCC) Meeting at the European Patent Office (EPO) Shows Existing Problems
the "real problems" and why "digitalisation" doesn't solve them
Links 12/12/2024: Shell Settles With Greenpeace, DOJ Whistleblower Pilot Program
Links for the day
Gemini Links 12/12/2024: AuraGem TV and Advent of Code 2024
Links for the day
Fake "Linux" News, Produced by Microsoft Chatbots in 'Brittany Day' or "LinuxSecurity" Clothing
She's back at it
Microsoft OSI Promoting GitHub, Which is Proprietary and a Massive GPL Violator
OSI works for Microsoft, speaks for Microsoft, promotes proprietary software
Links 12/12/2024: Another 'Self-driving' Cars Dead End, Infowars Sale Blocked by Court
Links for the day
Links 12/12/2024: "Hey Hi" Hype Debunked, ActivityPub and Gemini Software on Same Server
Links for the day
Google Has Only Solidified Its Search Monopoly in Africa Since Microsoft's Chatbot/LLM Hype Started
Africa is basically a "Failed Market" to Microsoft
[Teaser] EPO is Running Out of Brains
EPO has been in the business of offering fake patents
South Korea Has Its Own Alternative to IBM's Proprietary RHEL
Owing to the Open Enterprise Linux Association (OpenELA)
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Wednesday, December 11, 2024
IRC logs for Wednesday, December 11, 2024