Bonum Certa Men Certa

USPTO As Broken as Always, Proof Herein

Repeating the same mistakes of the drug industry

Whenever you find comfort in the belief that you have seen enough, here comes another disturbance. This one is from RIM.

What do you get if you mesh a dual-orientation handset together with a slide-out keyboard and a tracker ball? Potentially, the next BlackBerry from Research in Motion (RIM), if its latest patent application is anything to go by.


USPTOWhat RIM patents here has plenty of prior art and we recently saw an incident where RIM actually sued unnecessarily, attacking a weaker company like Motorola using weak patents applicable to wireless communication standards. The Nokia N810 and the Mylo from Sony seem rather similar to the design in this patent application, but this does not seem to bother or deter RIM. Remember what these people think: More Patents = More Innovation. But not so fast!

It seems like a patents blog has just shown up (or been born) in C|Net and it now speaks about the "first-to-file" rule, which renders the whole system utterly pointless and prone to error.

Generally, the first person to file the lawsuit gets to choose where the suit is brought. This is called the "first-to-file" rule. It works much like the lines you stand in at the grocery store, airport security, or countless other places; it's simply first come, first served.

However, in the context of patent litigation, being first in line is a big deal. Different courts have different procedural rules that can affect the way a case is litigated and the speed at which the case goes to trial. Moreover, there is a perception that courts in certain areas are more plaintiff-friendly than others.


The term "first-to-file" is used in numerous other circumstances which equally well demonstrate the weakness of the whole approach. The pharmaceutical industry is already learning its lessons, so why can't others?

Below we're appending some relevant and recent stories about conclusions arrived by drug companies and biologists. They are sorted reverse-chronologically (roughly).




1. Open Lab

The open source wave could soon power drug discovery initiatives in the country. A decentralised, web-based initiative is emerging that would enable scientists from laboratories, universities, institutes, and drug Companies to work together in discovering new drugs for diseases like tuberculosis (TB), malaria, various types of cancer, AIDS, Chikungunya, Kala-azar, dengue fever, etc.


2. Open-source model for drug discovery?

Significant public funding along with the ability for private enterprise to benefit from the open source approach will result in a strong public-private partnership and ensure success of the open source approach.


3. Open source drug discovery

The idea, taking off from successful open source models such as the human genome sequencing initiative, is very simple. All the relevant data and accumulated intelligence on a particular disease, tuberculosis to begin with, would be hosted online.


4. 'Open source' urged for TB drug design effort

One of India's top genetics researchers has called for a global, collaborative effort to design a new tuberculosis (TB) drug using an 'open source' approach.


5. Open Source Pharmaceuticals - New Business Model

Software is not the only field affected by open source; many fields of study and social and political views have been affected by the growth of the concept of open source. Advocates in one field will often support the expansion of open source in other fields, including Linus Torvalds who is quoted as saying, "the future is open source everything."


6. Open source synthetic biology

Not everyone within synthetic biology takes the open-source approach, Andrew Hessel, an iGEM consultant who recruits teams from Canadian universities, told me, but the driving force behind it is iGEM and MIT (Rettberg works with renowned hacker-turned-synthetic biologist Tom Knight). Hessel likened the atmosphere to the time when computers were first becoming cheap enough to be affordable by anyone who wanted one, and young, bright kids began to play around with code.


7. Biology Goes Open Source

Some of the world's biggest drug companies are finding that their genetic research is worth more to them if they give it away.


8. Pharmac publishes directly with open source

The team used Python, libxml/libxslt and TeX, running on Debian GNU/Linux, and the open document standards TeX, XML, MathML, XHTML, and Xlink, says Geering.


9. Open Source Research -- the Power of Us

Open source methods have delivered tangible benefits in the computer science community. We describe here efforts to extend these principles to science generally, and in particular biomedical research. Open source research holds great promise for solving complex problems in areas where profit-driven research is seen to have failed. We illustrate this with a specific problem in organic chemistry that we think will be solved substantially faster with an open source approach.


10. Our Biotech Future [is Open Source]

Open Source biology could be a powerful tool, giving us access to cheap and abundant solar energy.


11. Open-Source Drug Safety?

More than a million Americans take Avandia every year; the risk Glaxo had found would mean thousands of extra heart attacks. But the company argued that the risk only occurred in patients who already had serious heart problems, and that it didn't show up in long-term clinical trials. The FDA made no decision, and no public statement.

[...]

It's an open source approach to drug safety.


12. Open Source Pharmaceuticals - New Business Model

"Open source" as applied to culture defines a culture in which intellectual property is made generally available. Participants in such a culture are able to improve and modify those products and redistribute them back into the community.


13. Thailand fed up with high drug prices - minister

"We have thought about this for more than five years. It's long enough," said Mongkol na Songkhla, who is leading one of the biggest challenges to Big Pharma's patent rights in years.


In relation to this:

"Collaboration reduces development costs and subsequent high prices, and therefore precludes the need for patents. Took them long enough to figure that out, didn't it?"

--Slated, March 4th 2008



Time for change. Software patents do more harm than good.

Comments

Recent Techrights' Posts

Certificate Authorities (CAs) Are Serving the Authorities, Not You
The centralised CAs "model" is not working
Rage in the Propaganda Machine
There has never been a better time to quit social control media
The Free Software Movement Must Not Assume That Truth and Science Always Win
Sometimes the bad people and the liars get ahead
Peter Eckersley and 'Afterlife'
It's better to look after one's health at present than to pursue all sorts of perceived 'insurance' policies
Terms of Service (TOS) Under Scrutiny - Part XV - "Zoom's terms of service change sparks worries over AI uses" (and More)
Then they wonder why users get all grumpy?
IBM is Cutting - Almost in Half - Its Office Space in Austin, So Expect Many Layoffs (RAs)
IBM reduces office space by 187,00 square feet or 37%
IRC Proceedings: Saturday, September 07, 2024
IRC logs for Saturday, September 07, 2024
They Used to Say Avoid Nginx (or NGINX) Because It's Russian. Now You Can Say Avoid It Because It's Microsoft.
Thankfully we quit using NGINX when we shut down our HTTP proxy for Gemini
Instead of Telegram People Should Use Free Software (Telegram Was Always Unsafe for Use)
"Modern" so-called 'smart' 'phones' are compromised at the OS level or baseband side
Techrights is a Demonstrably Popular Site, Reporting Suppressed Facts. Those Vouching for Its 'Unpopularity' Express a Desire Rather Than a Condition or a Fact.
Our 100% source protection record will hold up
 
[Meme] EPO 'Hush Money' to Companies That Point Out EPO Breaks the Rules
A bribed doorman: "We have patent examiners, but if you say the right words, we'll bypass them for you"
New EPO Letter Expressing Concerns About EPO Violating Its Charter, Clearly Violating Rules (Possibly Bribing Siemens With Monopolies) and Granting Loads of Fake Patents to Make More Money
Why does the EU tolerate the EPO's crimes and how much longer will this go on for?
Gemini Links 08/09/2024: WebDAV, OpenBSD, Pocket Reform, and More
Links for the day
Links 08/09/2024: Super Typhoon and Lots of Climate Journalism
Links for the day
Terms of Service (TOS) Under Scrutiny - Part XVI - When Radio is No Longer "Read-Only" (Listening Mode) Because Someone Listens and Sells Your Data
Who would want to put up with this?
redhat.com is Promoting Revisionism and Lies Regarding the Origin of the Term "Open Source"
debunked many times before
Software Patents Against GNU/Linux Again
Patent extortion against OpenShift and Red Hat Enterprise Linux
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
Gemini Links 07/09/2024: Self Hosting (Not "CLOUD") and Site Reliability Engineering
Links for the day
The Arrest of Pavel Durov is Changing Telegram
Remember that Telegram's founder, who is also French, cannot leave France until he satisfies those who detained him
The Growth of GNU/Linux is Now a Mainstream Topic With Widespread Awareness
We can do less counting (of baskets and eggs) and more advocacy
John Pilger's Site Relaunches, Wikileaks' Site Has Not Been Updated in Years
We have long hoped that, more so after the release of Assange, Wikileaks will have some kind of "relaunch" or recovery
A Terms of Service (TOS) Notion of "Consent"
We're well past the true notion of real consent
Terms of Service (TOS) Under Scrutiny - Part XIV - Zoom the Beast
breakdown of the Zoom TOS and corresponding privacy statement
Links 07/09/2024: Qualcomm May Buy Parts of Intel, YouTube Deletes Channels for the US Government
Links for the day
No, Mastodon is Not Growing, Social Control Media is Generally Waning
Our sister site pulled the plug on the whole thing over a year ago, seeing it was mostly a source of online abuse
A Loss for Fake Security, a Win for Net Autonomy
Crucifixion of domains has been ramping up this past week; it's a cautionary signal
Links 07/09/2024: UK Police Raid Journalist's Home, Epoch Times Setbacks, and Karma
Links for the day
FSFE: Donate to Us to Co-Fund With Microsoft the Unpaid Underage Labour, YH4F
Latest from FSFE
Links 07/09/2024: China's Financial "Bond" to Africa and Attempts to Postpone Trump Criminal Cases
Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Friday, September 06, 2024
IRC logs for Friday, September 06, 2024
linuxsecurity.com is Still Spamming the Web
This is not harmless to Linux and it definitely merits a shun
Gemini Links 07/09/2024: Freedom in Bareness, Reactions in Addictive Social Control Media
Links for the day
Why We Are Suing Matthew J. Garrett for Harassment and Why It's Important to Everybody in the Community
There's a limit to how much abuse to me and to my family I can tolerate for the act of merely reporting on corporate corruption
[Meme] Confused Michael
Teaser...
Links 06/09/2024: Censorship of Sites by US, Hype Around LLMs Noted
Links for the day
[Meme] Hijacking the Brands
"Linux? Ah, you mean Microsoft!"
Google: We Help Combat What We Are Guilty of
The search itself is a conflict of interest
Linux Foundation Technical Advisory Board Has Election, But Google is Already Guaranteed Over 33.3% of the Seats ('Reserved' for It)
It has too much power/influence and it looks like a stacked panel
[Video] Theodore Ts'o Says How He Brought Linux to the United States (MIT) and What Makes Linux Leadership Effective
Microsofters keep attacking him
Layoffs Are Healthy and Not Happening
Good news for a change?
[Meme] Trickle-Down Ponzi Scheme
Where does money actually come from?
Considering Microsoft's Totally Fake Finances It Too is at Risk of Being Delisted From the Dow Jones Industrial Average and Other Indexes (NASDAQ, S and P) in the Near Future
Microsoft and Apple both had many layoffs this year
Asking Ourselves What Topics to Strategically Focus on
A lot of the tech media - if not "mainstream" media too - is already covering the growth of GNU/Linux
Media Needs to Stop Asking If "AI" is Just Hype (It Is, It's Not a Question)
The media should stop asking if the "AI" thing is bubble about to pop
Lots of GNU/Linux Detected in Palau and Windows Falls to New All-Time Low (14%)
Windows is falling further
Gemini Links 06/09/2024: Degoogling, LLMs, and ROOPHLOCH
Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Thursday, September 05, 2024
IRC logs for Thursday, September 05, 2024