Bonum Certa Men Certa

When EPO Does Not Control and Coerce the Judges — Part II — ILOAT Judgment No. 4550

Series parts:

  1. When EPO Does Not Control and Coerce the Judges — Part I — ILOAT 134th Session: Two More Bittersweet Victories for EPO Staff
  2. YOU ARE HERE ☞ ILOAT Judgment No. 4550


Campaign of managerial bullying and 'moral harassment' from Benoît Battistelli his 'Human Resources' enforcer Elodie Bergot
Back in the day, EPO staff protested vigorously against the campaign of managerial bullying and "moral harassment" which Benoît Battistelli (l.) and his "Human Resources" enforcer Elodie Bergot (r.) conducted against CSC appointees Michael Lund and Aurélien Pétiaud.



Summary: Case 4550 [PDF] was lost by EPO management last week [1, 2] at the Administrative Tribunal of the International Labour Organisation (ILOAT); today we look closely into it

In the case of Judgment No. 4550, the complainant was Michael Lund from Denmark (now retired) and it’s worthwhile recalling the full background to this particular matter.



Back in 2014, Michael and his French colleague Aurélien Pétiaud [PDF] were members of the EPO’s Internal Appeals Committee (IAC). [PDF]

The IAC deals with appeals filed by EPO staff against management decisions and it is a "joint body" comprising members appointed in equal numbers by EPO management and by the Central Staff Committee (CSC).

Michael and Aurélien were not elected staff representatives but rather they were staff members with a recognised level of legal expertise who enjoyed the confidence of the CSC and had been nominated by it as members of the IAC.

At some point in 2014, their heavy workload did not allow them to deal with all of their tasks as IAC members, which include “completing opinions or dissenting opinions following the hearings and sessions within the deadlines provided.”

Michael and Aurélien had to make a difficult choice: either stop writing dissenting opinions on cases of previous sessions, or refuse to work on new cases. They made a decision not to attend an upcoming session of the IAC.

"Michael and Aurélien were not elected staff representatives but rather they were staff members with a recognised level of legal expertise who enjoyed the confidence of the CSC and had been nominated by it as members of the IAC."Battistelli was furious and threw one of his famous "tantrums". He accused them of insubordination and instructed his HR "dompteuse" Elodie Bergot to have them subjected to a politically-motivated disciplinary proceedings which led to their downgrading.

Michael was accused of obstructing the work of the IAC by refusing to attend a session of the committee. He was further accused of having committed, in the framework of the disciplinary proceedings, an additional actionable offence by disclosing confidential and personal appeal-related information to unauthorised third parties.

The majority opinion of the disciplinary committee recommended that the charges against Michael be dismissed. However, a minority found a breach of duty and recommended downgrading by a single step.

True to form, Battistelli ignored the majority opinion and decided that Michael should be downgraded in accordance with the minority opinion. However, Battistelli decided that the relegation in grade should be three steps - that is to say, two more than recommended by the minority opinion.

Both Michael and Aurélien appealed against their downgrading but they lost their cases before the ILOAT: Judgment no. 3971 of the 125th session (Aurélien) and no. 4050 of the 126th session (Michael).

"True to form, Battistelli ignored the majority opinion and decided that Michael should be downgraded in accordance with the minority opinion. However, Battistelli decided that the relegation in grade should be three steps - that is to say, two more than recommended by the minority opinion."ILOAT Judgment No. 4050 [PDF] - delivered on 26 June 2018 following the 126th session of the Tribunal under the presidency of Italian judge Giuseppe Barbagallo - dismissed Michael’s complaint. The judgment focused on a single aspect of the case – Michael’s non-attendance at the IAC session - while ignoring the pertinent factual circumstances and dismissing what seem to be his valid reasons for not being able to participate in that session. Aurélien Pétiaud’s complaint had already suffered a similar fate during the preceding ILOAT session.

Amongst EPO staff [PDF], the disciplinary measures against Michael and Aurélien were widely perceived as being politically motivated. These managerial actions were seen as part of a vicious campaign of bullying and "moral harassment" conducted by Battistelli and his minions, in particular Elodie Bergot, against staff representatives and their nominees on the EPO’s joint bodies.

Nevertheless, in its judgments relating to these disciplinary cases, the Tribunal showed no understanding of the difficult situation in which Michael and Aurélien found themselves and it somehow managed to find the sanctions imposed on them to be “within the range of acceptability” or “not to be disproportionate”.

Battistelli for his part was not content with the imposition of disciplinary sanctions on the CSC-appointed members of the IAC. He wanted to punish them further for their perceived "insubordination" and so he decided to prematurely terminate their terms of office on the IAC.

"Amongst EPO staff, the disciplinary measures against Michael and Aurélien were widely perceived as being politically motivated."This was accomplished by means of the notorious "reform" bearing the title of "Social Democracy" - CA/D 2/14 [PDF], which was adopted by the Administrative Council of the EPO on 28 March 2014 on the basis of a proposal submitted to it by Battistelli.

Amongst other things [PDF], Battistelli’s Orwellian "Social Democracy" substantially restricted the CSC’s power to appoint its nominees to the EPO’s various joint bodies. It required the CSC to henceforth choose amongst its own elected members, whereas previously it could choose freely among all staff in active employment.

This meant that when CA/D 2/14 entered into effect on 1 April 2014, Michael and Aurélien and all other non-elected CSC nominees were no longer permitted to serve on the joint bodies to which they had been appointed.

The premature termination of Michael’s IAC appointment on the basis of CA/D 2/14 forms the subject of ILOAT Judgment no. 4550.

In this case, the Tribunal found in Michael’s favour, noting that "CA/D 2/14, by restricting the Staff Committee’s choice of persons it could appoint as members of the Appeals Committee, had a significant negative impact ... on the quality of staff representation within the Appeals Committee and, consequently, on the composition of that joint body, which is no longer balanced."

According to the Tribunal:

"…the obligation imposed on the Staff Committee to choose the members to be appointed on the Appeals Committee exclusively from among its own members substantially undermined, in various respects, the quality of the effective representation of staff on that body."


The Tribunal dismissed the EPO’s unsubstantiated and manifestly bogus claims to the effect that the impugned measures had been aimed at "improving the conditions of staff representation within the Organisation", noting that the CSC was clearly opposed to these measures and that there was no evidence that the Organisation was responding to a wish expressed by staff members.

According to the Tribunal:

"The EPO’s argument cannot therefore lawfully warrant the violation of the employees’ right to freely associate by restricting the Staff Committee’s powers and undermining the quality of staff representation on the Appeals Committee."


However, despite the fact that the Tribunal found in favour of the complainant, it dismissed his claim for "exemplary damages" against the EPO and merely awarded the paltry amount of € 100 as "moral damages" along with a further € 500 in costs.

"Battistelli for his part was not content with the imposition of disciplinary sanctions on the CSC-appointed members of the IAC."In the next part we will look at Judgment no. 4551, the second case from the 134th session which confirms breaches of the fundamental rights of EPO staff due to the arbitrary and unlawful censorship of mass e-mails by the Office management.

Recent Techrights' Posts

(Live-)Stream of Richard Stallman's Latest Talk in Europe (No Longer Live)
The latest public talk and Live-Streamed schedule were announced early on for the public to know about
Richard Stallman is Already in India, Giving Talks About Microsoft Chaffbots and More
he's already giving some talks in India
Drunk on Chatbots, LinuxSecurity.com Spews Out More LLM Slop About "Wine"
They just keep googlebombing "Linux" and "Security" using slop
Gemini Links 24/01/2025: The "Hey Hi" Hype Continues Fading, Tesla/X/Twitter/SpaceX Associate With Nazism
Links for the day
Robbery at the European Patent Office (EPO), Office Staff as 'Prisoners'
publication from the Central Staff Committee, dated yesterday
Techrights in 0.036 Seconds
Combining Gemini and HTTP/S, yesterday we served an impressive number of requests
BetaNews Run by Plagiarism Bots That Googlebomb (for SEO) "Linux"
Google rewards and thus encourages plagiarism
IBM Titles Considered Worthless and Many IBM 'Fellows' Are Vanishing (Also: IBM Staff Inside Linux Attacks the Rights of Computer Users for Recognition or Rewards Like "Distinguished Engineer")
James Bottomley is still "a Distinguished Engineer at IBM"
 
Rumour of IBM 'Bloodbath' in Clown Computing
Performance Improvement Plans mean one step ahead or before layoffs
Dr. Andy Farnell: "Richard Stallman Chose to Stand For the Rights of People to Use Technology as They Wish. He Chose Freedom Instead of Riches."
Keeping busy in public transport
Gemini Links 24/01/2025: Drehgriffel, Computer Science and Capitalism
Links for the day
Microsoft Lost a Ton of Market Share in Web Servers Last Month (the Last Month of 2024) and Massive Losses Continue in 2025, Shows New Report
Microsoft down sharply
Microsoft (Nick Vidal) and Co-opting "Open Future" With Microsoft-led "Open Source AI Definition" (Openwashing LLM Slop and GPL Violations)
Microsoft is tainting all sorts of groups via the OSI
Microsoft, IBM, and Front Groups That Advance Racism for Profit
IBM has profited a lot from racism and it still does
FOSDEM and 'No Nazis'
the issue isn't wealth but principles
Gemini Links 24/01/2025: "Social" Control Media is Unsatisfying; An Old Call for a Gemini Without TLS
Links for the day
[Meme] Levels of Outrage
Apparently it's hip for criminals to leverage "the law" to silence their exposers
Links 24/01/2025: Earthquake, Landslide, and Official Implicated in Airplane With Landing Gear Issues (Boeing Plane) "Found Dead"
Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Thursday, January 23, 2025
IRC logs for Thursday, January 23, 2025
CDN Giant: Microsoft Bing and Skype Collapsed Since the LLM Hype, Same as Other Metrics Show
No wonder Microsoft managers suffer anxiety and there are several waves of layoffs even on the same month
Gemini Links 23/01/2025: Experience With Outer Wilds and Gifting a Site
Links for the day
Slopwatch: Fake 'Articles' About Linux by Brian Fagioli and by Brittany Day in BetaNews and linuxsecurity.com (LLM Slop Sites That Are Online Leeches or SEO Operations Working Against Free Software Journalism)
Two new examples for today
Links 23/01/2025: More Overt Constitutional Violations and "TikTok Executive Order" (White Flag to CCP)
Links for the day
Status of New Year's Resolutions
3 weeks later
"The AI Bubble is Popping", Now It's Bailout Time
The hype will quietly fizzle, just like "blockchains"
[Meme] When the Government of the Netherlands Participates in Your Crimes It Lacks an Incentive to Hold You Accountable for Crimes
the EPO's corrupt management boasted (on television) that it would ignore rulings against it even if issued by the highest Dutch court
Links 23/01/2025: US Constitution Already Besieged (Impeachable Offences Pile Up), Arrest Warrant for Assad
Links for the day
Microsoft's Head of Business Development Quits (Days After Two Large Waves of Mass Layoffs)
We recently learned that people close to the management are very stressed this month
[Meme] Reliable Sources
Sooner or later LLMs swallow up their own lies (that they generated), which means that over time those things will only deteriorate further, exacerbating an already-large misinformation pandemic
BetaNews Plagiarising Work in the Linux Space
The originals won't even be listed
Gemini Links 23/01/2025: US Politics and DevOps Career
Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Wednesday, January 22, 2025
IRC logs for Wednesday, January 22, 2025
Links 22/01/2025: Jeju Air Blame-Shifting (Talk to the Wall), Copyright Maximalism Rebounds
Links for the day
[Meme] The 'Garbage in, Garbage Out' Patent Office
"law of the buzzword"
Clueless and Nontechnical EPO Management Uses the 'Great Scam' (Hey Hi Hype) to Justify Automation Where It's Both Detrimental and Illegal
The EPC has been practically set aflame; thus, the EPO has no legitimacy or reason to exist anymore
Links 22/01/2025: Democratising Tech Initiative and "Bye Bye Meta"
Links for the day
The Japanese translation of the term "free software"
by Akira Urushibata
Links 22/01/2025: "The AI Bubble Is Bursting" and Microsoft's Scam Altman is Already Looking for De Facto Bailout From the Insurrectionist
Links for the day
Dr. Andy Farnell's Latest Article About Software Freedom and Richard Stallman
why Dr. Stallman is being picked on
Geminispace (Gemini Protocol) Offers an Escape From Social Control Networks Owned by Oligarchs and Governments
Gemini capsules that promote fascism and retreat to feudalism are rare and scarce
The Free Software Foundation (FSF) Has Formally Added an Outreach and Communications Coordinator
Maybe the addition happened last year (we mentioned it in passing), but now it's in the "rota"
Electronic Frontier Foundation: Fighting 'for the Poor and Powerless' While Taking Home $336,000 in Annual Salary
nowadays works for or serves not the interests of the masses
Of Note: The Misguided, Infiltrated, Weakened Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) Now Operating at a Loss of Over a Million Dollars
Worst since the COVID-19 lockdowns
Free Software Foundation's Miriam Bastian: We Surpassed Our Year-end Goal of $400,000 USD Thanks to You!
Miriam Bastian: We surpassed our year-end goal of $400,000 USD!
[Meme] Omit Microsoft When It's a Scandal or a Breach, Whereupon It Becomes Just an 'IT Company'
Microsoft is like a cult. Members of this cult promote the opposite of security, expecting to be financially rewarded for it.
Calling Out Windows (TCO) is Apparently Impermissible in Some News Sites
The online news sites are failing us (and corporate sponsors play a role)
Richard Stallman's Remarks on His Pain
Published two days ago
Focusing on the Issues
we'll do our best to find the news and not talk about "Mr. T"
Only About 3.6% of Web Users in Pakistan Use Vista 11, According to statCounter
It's not hard to see why so far in 2025 Microsoft has already had several waves of mass layoffs - more than any other company
Rumour: In IBM, Impending "25% Reduction in Finance Roles"
25% to be laid off?
[Meme] Fake Articles From linuxsecurity.com (Just Googlebombing "Linux" With LLM Slop)
Google should really just entirely delist that site
RedHat.com Written by Microsoft Staff, Promoting Microsoft' Proprietary Software That Does Not Even Run on Linux!
This is RedHat.com this week...
Links 22/01/2025: Mass Layoffs at Stripe, Microsoft's Illegal Accounting Practices Under Scrutiny
Links for the day
Fake 'Article' by Brittany Day (Guardian Digital, Inc) About Linux Mint 22.1 'Xia'
Apparently they've convinced themselves that this is OK
Red Hat Dumps "Inclusive Language", Puts "Master" In Official Communications and Headlines
Red Hat: you CANNOT say "master" (because it is racist). Also Red Hat: we put in it our headlines.
Red Hat Offers DRM, TPM, and Backed Doored 'Confidential' Containers (CoCo) for Microsoft (Proprietary Spyware)
No kidding!
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Tuesday, January 21, 2025
IRC logs for Tuesday, January 21, 2025