Patent Alert: Is GNOME Growing a .NET Dependency?

Dr. Roy Schestowitz

2007-07-23 05:00:05 UTC
Modified: 2007-07-23 05:01:39 UTC

Please allow me to start off by stating that love GNOME. I use KDE most of the time (at work and at home), but I used to be using GNOME more regularly and I love it very much. The choice it offers berings benefit to everybody.

I am only posting this only because certain information needs to reach people's attention, no matter how inconvenient it may be. Many times in the past we repeated the alarming argument that Novell is turning its Linux desktop into a .NET-rich platform. It appears to be a matter of strategy, based on some recent interviews with Novell executives. Is it a good strategy? Probably not. The main issue is not the fact that Microsoft controls and extends .NET. The main issue is software patents, which bring monetisation (or "taxation") into the equation. Say No to Mono

Amid a discussion (and purely by serendipity), something strange was realised. information that I received from someone who wishes to remain anonymous began with the sarcastic statement that "apparently there is considerable effort under way by the Gnome team, to poison Gnome by completely rewriting it in C#!!! Thank you Miguel de Icaza."

To paraphrase the person, "this turned out to be a tongue-in-cheek remark, but it isn't far from the truth". This person is a maintainer of a major Linux distribution. He has sufficient knowledge and credibility to be worth trusting, but please post a correction if we are wrong. I requested some references, which he kindly provided:

Here's some historical references:

http://www.theregister.co.uk/2002/02/01/gnome_to_be_based/ http://linuxplanet.com/linuxplanet/reviews/6232/1/

As a test, install Fedora 7 using the defaults, then (post-install) try to remove the gtk-sharp and mono-core packages. Chaos ensues. It rips out half the system.

And this on a distro where the original maintainers *swore* they would never let mono enter the tree. Now it is poisoned beyond repair.

It's only a matter of time before the Gnome core libs will be mono dependant, I'd stake my life of that fact. I'm ready to ditch Gnome permanently.

I decided to make the person aware of Novell's big plans for .NET (Mono). To this, the reply was:

God help them.

I think one can safely assume that Novell are now working almost exclusively to Microsoft's agenda. If it comes from Novell, it is irreparably tainted.

I wish to believe that GNOME developers will not be persuaded or lured into more Mono dependencies. Other distributions use GNOME. KDE received some Mono bindings a couple of weeks ago, but there has never been any of this at the core, let alone in the build.

Surely, the patent system in the United States has gone completely out of hand. While centralization of .NET control remains an important factor, let the insane court battles teach you a lesson. At the end of last week we saw two important rulings. The first one was a dismissal of an appeal. It is a very serious case that involves a ban.

A U.S. appeals court on Friday dismissed Qualcomm's appeal of an order by a federal trade agency banning some cellular telephones containing Qualcomm chips.

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit said it lacked jurisdiction over an order by the U.S. International Trade Commission because Qualcomm has a request pending before the Bush administration asking it to invalidate the decision.

"An ITC determination does not become final for purposes of judicial review until the president has either approved of the determination or failed to disapprove within 60 days," the court said.

The second case speaks about a defeat where obviousness could not be refuted.

In its third opinion of the day designated precedential, the Board of Patent Appeals and Interferences once again affirmed an examiner's obviousness rejections. Specifically, the Board found that Appellant's apparatus incorporating bioauthentication and a consumer electronics device was an obvious solution to a known problem, as all elements of the claims other than the bioauthentication device were found in one prior art reference, a second reference disclosed the bioauthentication devices in a related context, and a third disclosed that they could be substituted for each other. The BPAI appears to have fully embraced its new "flexibility" in determining obviousness in light of the Supreme Court's recent decision in KSR.

At times when patent madness thrives in the United States, one must keep an eye open. GPLv3 is needed here, or at least eradication of absurdly-patented ideas. Please refrain from contaminating GNOME with Microsoft-patented technology.

Comments

Roy Shitzforwitz

2007-07-23 05:37:34

Who's paying you to FUD Novell?
Roy Schestowitz

2007-07-23 06:10:58

Nobody pays me. Standing up for users' right needn't any monetary encouragement. Are you going to carry on trolling the site?
GNU/Linux user

2007-07-23 07:19:51

"As a test, install Fedora 7 using the defaults, then (post-install) try to remove the gtk-sharp and mono-core packages. Chaos ensues. It rips out half the system."

I can't agree. I've just tested it few minutes ago and the only problem was that mono-core has Tomboy dependency (but afaik Tomboy is written in Mono). So maybe other distributions are affected (afair openSUSE is) but Fedora 7 isn't. Mono can be safely removed and it won't delete half of your system. I'm 100% Mono free (at least I don't have any Mono and Mono related packages installed). Fedora rocks ;)
Roy Schestowitz

2007-07-23 07:37:27

Thanks for the information. One thing that leaves room for doubt (to me at least) is an article that talks about Mono in Fedora. It is quite surprising. I was under the impression that Red Hat would never approach Mono.

New Mono-Based Applications for GNOME in Fedora Core 5--Part 1

The hardest concern to address is that of patents. This worry is muddied by the fact that C# was handed by Microsoft to the ECMA (European Association for Standardizing Information and Communication Systems), standards organization as a language standard. As a standard, C# is technically out of Microsoft's hands to control. However, that doesn't mean that the rest of .NET doesn't contain patent issues. In 2002, Microsoft applied for just such a patent, causing a ripple of concern throughout the technology community. Many decried the patent as too broad, and potentially even a violation of the ECMA's rules for the standards it controls.

Speculation continues to run rampant on whether the patent will be granted, and what this patent will ultimately mean for anyone using .NET technology if Microsoft chooses to enforce the patent in a way that will have it invalidated for ECMA handling. In the meantime, the Mono and DotGNU projects continue on and various groups are throwing their hats into this collective pot.

We've accumulated a lot more material and pointers. The worry here is that complacency might lead to risk (through gradual embrace). Recall what happened with MP3 format after many years of "ignorance is bliss".

I am aware that Red Hat does not distribute Mono 'out of the box' (the same applies to DVD playback, some fonts technology, among many other things). One issue to be aware of, however, is behind-the-scenes, Microsoft violation claims s. Microsoft 'collects' money from Linux users (without even being specific, mind you). That's where the distributor is irrelevant. These threats are made secretly. It's a shame that few people are aware of this, so they can't protest and call "RICO ACT".

http://www.ricoact.com/ricoact/nutshell.asp
Slated

2007-07-23 08:48:18

"I am aware that Red Hat does not distribute Mono 'out of the box'"

I'm afraid it does Roy.

Here are four packages on the Fedora 7 DVD:

mono-core-1.2.3-3.fc7.i386.rpm gmime-sharp-2.2.3-5.fc7.i386.rpm gnome-sharp-2.16.0-1.fc6.i386.rpm gtk-sharp2-2.10.0-4.fc7.i386.rpm

In addition to Tomboy: tomboy-0.6.1-1.fc7.i386.rpm http://www.gnome.org/projects/tomboy/

There's also Beagle: libbeagle-0.2.16.2-5.fc7.i386 http://beagle-project.org/Installing_prerequisites

Also, I recommend you read this: http://duncan.mac-vicar.com/blog/archives/145

"Then I found dbus-1-mono and I raised an eyebrow. I thought “Mono is coming too.”. Not big deal, only that not only mono-core was there but mono-data and mono-web. Why a framework would depend in mono-web?. I am completely sure an IDE would depend on it, but a network applet?"

I'm also concerned that a number of Mono-built Gnome Applets might be poisoning the tree, however proving this is a matter of an audit - no simple task.

I'm currently in the process of examining the spec files of every package on the Fedora 7 DVD, to try to ascertain the full and precise extent of Mono infiltration into Fedora. Stay tuned.
Roy Schestowitz

2007-07-23 08:59:59

I am doing some further reading on Mono at the moment. Last year, I believe the following was brought to Groklaw's attention with the intent of showing what Miguel really strives to achieve.

http://port25.technet.com/archive/2006/08/11/Let_2700_s-talk-Mono_3A00_--Sam-interviews-Miguel-de-Icaza.aspx

This is from Microsoft. It is worrying to see that Microsoft (through Miguel) is apparently now deciding what belongs inside the the core of Linux. Why aren't people more aware of this?

http://www.gnome.org/~seth/blog/mono

http://www.newsforge.com/article.pl?sid=02/02/19/1651244

The patent trap: If Gnome gets Mono

Thursday February 21, 2002 (09:24 AM GMT)

A lot has happened in 5+ years.
Stephen

2007-07-23 09:19:42

The folks (except the troll) have given some great detail. I would like to add that the hackers producing these Mono applications are very pro-opensource people - just look through the list of authors.

Personally, I would like to see Mono being an Add-on CD type of deal for those that want it (choice etc). I can understand the rationale for Mono though, it represents much less of a barrier to entry in developing for a core platform such as Gnome and that makes sense.

My hope with Mono is that it, and its supporters, can wrestle control of the specification from Microsoft by a more open standards process. This will eventually happing with OOXML. I know, I know - it's Microsoft and nothing can be taken for granted!
Stephen

2007-07-23 09:20:40

It's clear I need a Gtk-grammar module ;-)
Roy Schestowitz

2007-07-23 09:27:50

> Mono applications are very pro-opensource people

Definitely! Awareness seems to be the missing piece though. Speaking for myself, I am very well aware of their preference are and I respect that. I talked to/confronted people who came from Windows development to GNU/Linux and wanted to maintain (even thrive) in their previously-acquired skills.

That said, have a look at this short article which was published last night. It should serve as a lesson to Xandros and Linspire.

http://blog.wired.com/monkeybites/2007/07/ubuntu-must-pla.html

Ubuntu Must 'Play To Its Strengths" to Beat Microsoft Add as My Number One

"You can't out-Windows Windows, he says. Defining and playing to Ubuntu's strengths are what will make free software succeed on the desktop."

Remember another thing: Mark Shuttleworth said that he would not put wine on those Dell PCs because Linux has its own strengths.

While we're at it, maybe you can help push this into the front page. ;-) 24 Diggs in the past 5 hours...

http://digg.com/linux_unix/Ubuntu_Must_Play_To_Its_Strengths_to_Beat_Microsoft
akf

2007-07-23 09:31:27

I also use GNOME and I have no Mono(pol) software installed.

GNOME programs that would need Mono are: Tomboy, Beagle, F-Spot

Maybe we should maintain a blacklist...
Roy Schestowitz

2007-07-23 09:49:27

@akf: See https://wiki.ubuntu.com/Gobuntu/pkg-non-free and http://boycottnovell.com/2007/07/16/mono-cleanup/ .

Apparently, there are some big announcements on their way. News just in:

More Big Name PCs With Ubuntu Pre-Installed Coming Soon http://blog.wired.com/monkeybites/2007/07/more-big-name-p.html

"In a recent post on his blog, Shuttleworth encouraged the Ubuntu community to dream up the perfect free software laptop. He also launched a mailing list and a wiki dedicated to the topic that he hopes will help send a "ripple effect" through the PC industry." [emphasis mine]

Let's see how dedication for freedom works out for them. They have been criticised a lot for taking shortcuts (including 'forbidden' drivers and components).
Slated

2007-07-24 11:40:20

I've just completed an audit of Fedora Core 6, and this is the full list of mono dependants and sub-dependants, excluding doc, devel, debug, multi-arch and third-party repo packages:

avahi-sharp banshee beagle beagle-evolution beagle-gui boo bytefx-data-mysql cowbell daap-sharp db4o dbus-sharp drapes evolution-sharp f-spot gecko-sharp2 gmime-sharp gnome-sharp gsf-sharp gtk-sharp gtk-sharp2 gtk-sharp-gapi gtksourceview-sharp ibm-data-db2 ikvm kerry lat mod_mono mono-data mono-data-firebird mono-data-oracle mono-data-postgresql mono-data-sqlite mono-data-sybase mono-debugger monodevelop monodoc mono-extras mono-jscript mono-locale-extras mono-nunit monotone-server mono-web mono-winforms muine nant njb-sharp tomboy xsp

Total: 48 packages.

Presumably Fedora 7 has the same number, or greater. I'll do a similar audit on F7 later.
Anuj Seth

2007-08-05 12:09:33

Its just sad whats happening, first Novell Linspire etc .. then Ubuntu's restricted drivers ... i new theyd push C# into GNOME when I read this a long time back http://lwn.net/2002/0207/a/long-reply.php3 the Novell Microsoft deal confirmed it ... Ubuntus decision to go non alphabetical and put Dell Support as the first topic on their forums (i know its stupid but you know ... ) ... it seems as every distro gets more successful more corporate power play and manipulation come in ... its just really sad (IMHO) ... we linux people like to think that we have a lot of big companies backing us its just free server tools for most .. oh and f-spot etc come as default installs on gutsy tribe 3
Rico Giove

2007-08-10 12:38:11

What scares me more than the patent issue is that anything that is a ms derivative will leave my system open to viruses and security issues.
Brad Bellomo

2007-10-22 21:00:13

What patent issue? Microsoft fully released .NET as open to implementation and encourages it. Neither MS nor anyone else has ever referenced a specific patent of this debate. A desktop platform that truly supports both OS's is in everyone's interest. Lots of big companies have contributed to Linux and the open source world, what is wrong with Microsoft doing so?
Alberto Barrionuevo (FFII)

2007-11-05 21:59:13

Brad, you are confusing .NET with C# and CLI, that are the only parts of .NET that are standardized by ECMA and ISO. But .NET is much more, and Mono(pol) is using much more than these standardized parts. Just read a little:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/.NET_Framework

@@@@@@@@@ Standardization and licensing In August 2000, Microsoft, Hewlett-Packard, and Intel worked to standardize CLI and the C# programming language. By December 2001, both were ratified ECMA standards (ECMA 335 and ECMA 334). ISO followed in April 2003 (ISO/IEC 23271 and ISO/IEC 23270). While Microsoft and their partners hold patents for CLI and C#, ECMA and ISO require that all patents essential to implementation be made available under "reasonable and non-discriminatory (RAND) terms." In addition to meeting these terms, the companies have agreed to make the patents available royalty-free. However, this does not apply for the part of the .NET Framework which is not covered by the ECMA/ISO standard, which includes Windows Forms, ADO.NET, and ASP.NET. Patents that Microsoft holds in these areas may deter non-Microsoft implementations of the full framework. @@@@@@@@@@

Additionally, you are supposing that ECMA is warranty enough to avoid patent threats. Check the two patent (non)licenses of Microsoft for OOXML and you'll check that ECMA is far from any warranty regarding patents. Indeed ISO, who many times grants RAND standards instead of open standards.
Dark Phoenix

2007-12-04 06:00:15

Well, technically this is necroposting, but I feel it needs to be said.

From my viewpoint as a long-time Fedora user, it seems that the Fedora guys have gone to GREAT GREAT lengths to minimize how far into the system Mono penetrates, to the point where it could easily be ripped out at a moment's notice without major loss of functionality.

Also, a few conversations I've had on the Fedora list suggest that the Fedora devs would rather people use Java than Mono for this sort of programming. A good discussion on this is here: https://www.redhat.com/archives/fedora-list/2007-November/msg00772.html
Roy Schestowitz

2007-12-04 06:11:58

Dark Phoenix,

Out greater issue, IMHA(ssessment), is that Moonlight and OOXML translators (C#) will force many of us Linux users to embrace Mono regardless of what DE we use. Microsoft will say "yes, we support you, so just pick that Microsoft-patented Mono software, but be aware that we can sue you." Be alerted as Microsoft has already resorted to extortion, but it does this quietly and businesses that pay Microsoft for 'protection' prefer to keep the settlement deals secret. The last thing we need is for them to be dependent on Mono when much better software can be developed differently.

Touch Grass: Happiness involves what humans have evolved to appreciate, not what humans create to sedate the mind (like skinnerboxes)
The Cyber Show on Technology Having Become a Tool of Mass Psychosis, Not Enablement or Emancipation: Technology as mass psychosis
The Rumour Said That a Second Wave of Microsoft Layoffs Would Come This Week (Ahead of Fake 'Results'), Maybe Tomorrow: Let's wait and see how "MSM" unfold
Karen Melchior Fought the Good Fight: stay tuned for Part 29
This Coming Weekend Marks 4 Years Since We Dumped Content Management Systems (CMSs) in Favour of Static Site Generators (SSGs): the first page dated July 25
Slop's Latest Casualty: The Credibility of Linus Torvalds: If you care about millionaires and billionaires, follow Torvalds (he is already in that "club")
Techrights Will Become More Productive (More Output) Over Time: Big stories about to land
To Wikipedia, "Notability" is Just an Excuse to Hail People Who Serve Billionaires While Marginalising or Defaming the Rest: Wikipedia is an advertising space
Our Series About Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA) and SLAPPs Will Resume Soon: Originally, in 2025, we gave ourselves 6 years (until 2031) to cover these issues, but we've seen since extended that to 10 years (until 2036) because of the amount of material we have
European Patent Office (EPO) Series: The EPO Transparency Gap: Despite the "European" tag in the organisation's name, the European Union has no jurisdiction over the European Patent Organisation
Over at Tux Machines...: GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Monday, July 20, 2026: IRC logs for Monday, July 20, 2026
Links 20/07/2026: Lashes for Songs in Iran, Kurdish Language at Risk: Links for the day
Gemini Links 21/07/2026: The Boss Baby (2017) and 2026 Old Computer Challenge Epilogue: Links for the day
Canonical Staff Acting Like They Aim to Receive Job Offers From Microsoft: There are moreover allegations that Debian will do the same, in the same way Mono boosters infected both distros in tandem or in turn.
Worsening Staff Affairs at Microsoft: Microsoft is managing to piss off many of its own workers
Czech Mate for GNU/Linux on the Way: Czechoslovakia is having none of that "peace for our time" with Microsoft
Nobody Will be Left Who Trusts IBM Anymore: The common theme is, the management must be completely replaced as soon as possible and truth needs to come out
Wall Street is a Bubble and No Company is Worth 5 Trillion Dollars: It's not hard to see which stocks will crash the hardest (or fastest)
The Corrupt Have Historically Tried to Paint Their Exposers as the Real Problem: As usual, there are efforts to shoot or muzzle the messenger
Search Engine Market Share in Italy: Microsoft Falls to Third in Many Countries Including Italy: Expect more layoffs in Bing
Links 20/07/2026: Spotify Drowning in Slop, Expiry of Software Patents in MPEG-4: Links for the day
Gemini Links 20/07/2026: Another Step Towards Owning Personal Data and Gemtext2 Envisioned: Links for the day
European Patent Office (EPO) Series: Public Missions and Private Ambitions: Despite the French government's strong formal pushback, the lobbying momentum generated by Campinos and Negrão proved unstoppable
"DOOM" and "Bloodbath": the State of Microsoft and XBox: Way to piss off fans
Links 20/07/2026: Notes on E-mail Encryption, Torvalds and His Employer Paid a Lot to Promote Slop (Pyramid Scheme): Links for the day
What a Difference Six Years Make...: We are also beta-testing a new feature for the site; we plan to announce it some time soon
When It Comes to Slop, Richard Stallman is Opposite of Linus Torvalds: When it comes to computing, Dr. Stallman has long been a voice of reason
Daniel Pocock is in Mainstream Media This Week: Pocock's haters will absolutely hate this
In His Departure Post, Poul-Henning Kamp (phk) Explains Why Linus Torvalds is Full of "Hot Air" and Slop Bubbles: Having lived through previous bubbles as a UNIX geek, phk cannot be ignored
Whistleblowers Keep Flowing: Later today a police investigator should phone us regarding death threats we've received
We Need Less Gadgets, More Humanity: If people are being honest with themselves, many of the gadgets they claim they "cannot live without" are just excesses and distractions they could definitely leave behind
Technology and Gadgets Got Obese, Just Like Their Users: They now sell us so-called 'phones' for slop
Daniel Pocock in The Guardian This Morning: There is an opportunity here to spread a message, even if Pocock won't win a seat
"Samsung Recently Projected a 19-fold Surge in Second-Quarter Operating Profit", Now There Are Mass Layoffs: In a 9-month period Samsung's debt rose by about 80%
Gemini Links 20/07/2026: Dungeon Meshi/Undertale Crossover, "The Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Dark Web and Beyond": Links for the day
IBM's Control of the Media "Just Showed What Taking Accountability Does Not Look Like": It is no secret that IBM pays the media
Microsoft Loses XBox Lawsuit, But There Are More: The collapse of studios continues
GNU/Linux Approaching International Average in Djibouti: One can envisage further gains for GNU/Linux, seeing Microsoft is in such a bad shape
Daniel Pocock "[t]he Australian Taking on Nigel Farage — from Down Under": This can help raise awareness of some issues
Over at Tux Machines...: GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Sunday, July 19, 2026: IRC logs for Sunday, July 19, 2026
Misleading Coverage in Slashdot Promotes and Openwashes Slop: Piggybacking RMS for the headline seems like a PR stunt of sorts
As Envisioned, a Rebellion and Many Whistleblowers at Microsoft: Whistleblowers ensure Microsoft has totally lost control of the "narrative" (face-saving PR)
Microsoft is a Right-Wing Company: Just remember that when people call Microsoft "woke"
GNU/Linux "Market Share" Rises to About a Quarter in Sudan: Can anyone explain to us why?
Gemini Links 19/07/2026: Visiting Ethiopia, Two Dreams, and Price of Skinnerboxes: Links for the day
Tears in IBM, Company Falls Apart While Management Fakes "Performance" to Take Bonuses: Wall Street is a naked emperor
Telling Our Story: In the coming years we'll have some high-impact stories to share and generally tell without fear of reprisal
Microsoft XBox Studio Leaders Upset at What the New CEO Did: From what we can gather, in 2024 XBox was already entering what's known as a "death spiral". Now it's literally moving down the drain/pipe.
IRC Started in Finland, GNU/Linux Did Not: History is like that
GNU/Linux Rises to 8% in Bhutan, Same as the International Average: Taking note of estimated GNU/Linux share in that country, we see it hovering around the international median/average this month
Links 19/07/2026: "The Voice of Google" and "Chinese Surveillance Tech a Threat to Privacy": Links for the day
Keep Both Eyes on the Ball: At the moment we have six series running in parallel; two of them concern the EPO
'Journalists' Who Help IBM Cover Up Fraud: Journalistic malpractice
The "Modern Linux" Song: Join us now, make the kernel
XBox Layoffs Vastly Bigger Than Microsoft Told the Press, Microsoft Keeps Trying to Change the Subject: Many so-called "XBox fans" are no more
Microsoft Lost 1,200 Billion Dollars in "Market Value", Take a Look at What Happened to Windows: while Windows continues to fall unstoppably GNU/Linux is surging
Links 19/07/2026: People in China Are Buying Feelings and 404 Media Has Third Anniversary: Links for the day
Gemini Links 19/07/2026: Camping, Health, and Hardware: Links for the day
The State of Slopfarms: Slopfarms or LLM slopfarms are a menace and a problem on the Web
GNU/Linux Rising to 6% in Brunei: seventh in the world for GDP (PPP) per capita
Free Software is Like an 'Activist Movement': People who argue strongly in favour of something (even very good things) will attract the wrath of those whom they oppose
Over at Tux Machines...: GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Saturday, July 18, 2026: IRC logs for Saturday, July 18, 2026

Patent Alert: Is GNOME Growing a .NET Dependency?

Comments

Recent Techrights' Posts