EditorsAbout the SiteComes vs. MicrosoftUsing This Web SiteSite ArchivesCredibility IndexOOXMLOpenDocumentPatentsNovellNews DigestSite NewsRSS

01.30.18

The EPO’s Central Staff Committee Explains How Battistelli’s Attacks on Judge Corcoran Annul Any Perception of Independence

Posted in Europe, Law, Patents at 1:46 am by Dr. Roy Schestowitz

And the German Constitutional Court should thus can the UPC

Fair trial

Summary: The letter regarding the ‘exile’ of Patrick Corcoran (currently in DG1) is trickling out in spite of efforts to suppress its publication (even internally)

THE staff representatives of the EPO have plenty to worry about because ILO and the AC remain in Battistelli’s pocket and he seems capable of doing whatever he wants without any consequences.

A report which we saw last week mentioned a letter regarding the forced removal (‘exile’) of a judge to The Hague, under the direction (his DG!) of Battistelli. Since then we have tried getting hold of that letter, hoping someone will eventually send it to us.

“The EPO is currently censoring the publication on the Intranet of a CSC open letter to the Delegations of the AC,” SUEPO wrote. “Following a request from the CSC we hereby publish the letter with its accompanying text.”

So here we have censorship by the EPO yet again. Here’s the accompanying text:

AC Disciplinary Case [D1/15] settled?

In its Communiqué of 19 December 2017, the Administrative Council announced that “it took a final decision in a disciplinary case [D1/15] against an employee appointed by the Council – a case which had attracted significant public attention.” and for which the ILO Administrative Tribunal already delivered Judgments 3958 and 3960 ordering the immediate reinstatement of the suspended member of the Boards of Appeal (BoA), whom the Council then declined to re-appoint. The employee was first reinstated in the BoA in Munich for a few days.

In January 2018, the Office informed him that he will be permanently transferred in February 2018 to a post of Senior Expert in Classification expressly created for him in The Hague, pursuant to Art. 41(3) ServRegs.

However, the employee never performed classification work and is instead specialised in substantive examination and legal matters. The assignment to completely new duties is clearly against the interests of the service and betrays the aim of the Office Administration: impose a further covert disciplinary sanction and ultimately engineer a situation of “constructive dismissal” for professional incompetence under Art. 52 ServRegs.

This decision will reopen the discussion on a case meant to be settled.

In its Communiqué, the Council “underlined its expectation that now – after a long period of intense debate – legal peace would be restored.” The ball is now again with the AC if it wants it to be fulfilled.

The letter to the Heads of Delegations of the Administrative Council can be found here.

Your Central Staff Committee

Here is the letter referred to:

Heads of Delegations of the
Administrative Council

Open letter

Forced transfer of a former judge from Munich to The Hague

Dear Heads of Delegations,

In its Communiqué1 of 19 December 2017, the Administrative Council announced that “it took a final decision in a disciplinary case [D1/15] against an employee appointed by the Council – a case which had attracted significant public attention.” and for which the ILO Administrative Tribunal already delivered Judgments 39582 and 39603 ordering the immediate reinstatement of the suspended member of the Boards of Appeal (BoA), whom the Council then declined to re-appoint. The employee was first reinstated in the BoA in Munich for a few days.

In January 2018, the Office informed him that he will be permanently transferred in February 2018 to a post of Senior Expert in Classification expressly created for him in The Hague, pursuant to Art. 41(3) ServRegs. This decision will reopen the discussion on a case meant to be settled:

• First, the Tribunal clearly acknowledged the moral prejudice caused to the employee since December 2014. Transferring him to a country in which he had never lived is a further burden for him and his family. The Office did not fulfil its duty of care by assessing medically whether the employee was fit for a transfer. For medical or personal reasons, the employee may have to refuse to be transferred and in such case the President may decide to terminate his service (Art. 53(1)(b) ServRegs).

________
1 https://www.epo.org/about-us/governance/communiques.html#a36
2 http://www.ilo.org/dyn/triblex/triblexmain.fullText?p_lang=en&p_judgment_no=3958
3 http://www.ilo.org/dyn/triblex/triblexmain.fullText?p_lang=en&p_judgment_no=3960


• Second, the employee never performed classification work and is instead specialised in substantive examination and legal matters. The assignment to completely new duties is clearly against the interests of the service and betrays the aim of the Office Administration: impose a further covert disciplinary sanction
and ultimately engineer a situation of “constructive dismissal” for professional incompetence under Art. 52 ServRegs.

France Telecom, a company formerly including civil servants with lifetime job guarantees in its workforce, organized involuntary transfers of employees in order to pressure them to leave. At the same time the number of suicides increased drastically. Since then, such practices are considered4 to be “particularly disruptive”.

The decision of the Office Administration will also have consequences in pending national proceedings before the German Constitutional Court (Bundesverfassunsgericht), which concern the standing and independence of the BoA. The Court will pay particular attention to the treatment of a former member of the BoA under the authority of a President who was already found by the Tribunal to have a conflict of interest in the matter.

More generally, interested circles will also note how easily the EPO Service Regulations can be misused to (try to) get rid of colleagues, who are supposed to be “permanent employees”, in times where the President of the Office is about to submit to the Council CA/121/175 , a proposal for “modernisation” of the employment framework making the exercise even easier.

In its Communiqué, the Council “underlined its expectation that now – after a long period of intense debate – legal peace would be restored.” The ball is now again with the AC if it wants it to be fulfilled.

Sincerely yours,

Chairman of the Central Staff Committee
cc: Mr B. Battistelli, President of the EPO
________
4 http://www.nytimes.com/2010/04/10/business/global/10ftel.html
5 http://www.epo.org/modules/epoweb/acdocument/epoweb2/304/en/CA-121-17_en.pdf

Battistelli’s EPO suppressed the publication of this letter even internally, so the EPO’s management clearly worries that the letter will be seen, e.g. by the German Constitutional Court (Bundesverfassunsgericht). It can doom the UPC almost instantaneously (if judges see just to what degree the EPO continues to attack judges and disobey orders of judges from ILO).

Share this post: These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Reddit
  • co.mments
  • DZone
  • email
  • Google Bookmarks
  • LinkedIn
  • NewsVine
  • Print
  • Technorati
  • TwitThis
  • Facebook

If you liked this post, consider subscribing to the RSS feed or join us now at the IRC channels.

Pages that cross-reference this one

What Else is New


  1. What It Would Take for Linus Torvalds to Leave Linux Foundation Without the Linux Trademark and Without Linux

    It's nice to think that the founder of Linux can just take his project and walk away, moving elsewhere, i.e. away from the Microsoft-employed executives who now "boss" him; but it's not that simple anymore



  2. The Past Does Not Go Away, Except From Short-Term Memories

    People who are drunk on power and money (sometimes not even their own money) like to portray themselves as the very opposite of what they are; but in the age of the Internet it's difficult to make the general public simply forget the past and "move on..."



  3. IRC Proceedings: Sunday, May 31, 2020

    IRC logs for Sunday, May 31, 2020



  4. Links 1/6/2020: OpenMandriva Lx 4.1 2020.05, Linux Lite 5.0 Release, FreeBSD 11.4 RC2

    Links for the day



  5. It's a Common Mistake and Common Misconception/Error to Treat Microsoft as Just Another 'Large Company' (or 'Big Tech')

    It's a Common Mistake and Common Misconception/Error to Treat Microsoft as Just Another 'Large Company' (or 'Big Tech')



  6. Lessons of Michael Arrington (About Microsoft)

    Microsoft and Bill Gates have a long history bullying their critics; the quote above (or below) shows how even people who advertise with Microsoft are becoming the target of abuse



  7. 'Best' of Both Worlds: GNU/Linux Freedom + Malware With Keyloggers and DRM

    Running a Microsoft-controlled GNU/Linux instance under Vista 10 ("Windows Subsystem for Linux") in the age of virtual machines, dual boot and containers makes as much sense as chopping some carrots to go with the veal meal to appease vegetarian diners



  8. First They Bribe the Employer, Media Lynch Mobs May Follow

    The 'cancel culture' lynch mobs, which leverage social causes (or marginalised groups), remain a convenient means by which to oust one's political/business opposition; but money too is a massive contributing factor and the more one has of it, the easier it is to control media narrative and subversive focus



  9. Upcoming Series Teaser: The Bribery Operation of William Henry Gates III

    Bribery goes a very long way when it comes to the megalomaniac who pays the media to portray him as the world's most generous person



  10. Windows Ransomware Must Not be Unspeakable When People Die in Large Numbers Due to That (and Windows Has Intentional Back Doors)

    Loss of electronic patient records, ransom and downtime among the severe consequences of deploying Microsoft inside hospitals; yet the media rarely names the real culprit (manslaughter charges theoretically possible) and nobody gets punished except those who offer real solutions



  11. IRC Proceedings: Saturday, May 30, 2020

    IRC logs for Saturday, May 30, 2020



  12. Burning the House That Richard Stallman (RMS) Built: An Open Letter to GNU Maintainers Who Opposed RMS

    An open letter to people who petitioned RMS to step down and who outsource GNU projects to Microsoft (GitHub)



  13. Links 30/5/2020: Godot Editor Under Web Browsers, Alpine Linux 3.12.0 and EasyOS 2.3

    Links for the day



  14. EPO's Illegal Patents and Massive Corruption Go Unnoticed by Corporate Media and Sites That Cover Patent News

    Very major corruption scandals still emerge in Europe's second-largest institution and illegal patents get granted as well as promoted; somehow, perhaps miraculously, this no longer seems to bother anybody in the media (corruption and radical policies have been gradually 'normalised')



  15. Never Mind If GNU/Linux Works Better Inside Hospitals and Free Software Not Only Safer But Vastly More Efficient...

    With lives on the line one might expect hospitals to choose what's most secure and generally works best; but in practice there seems to be a leaning towards what bribes best



  16. Sick Alexander Ramsey is Using a Public Health Crisis to Lie About the Unitary Patent, Whose Fall Made Him Redundant and/or Obsolete

    Weaponised media continues to manufacture utterly ridiculous puff pieces for Team UPC, containing intentional lies from beginning to end



  17. IRC Proceedings: Friday, May 29, 2020

    IRC logs for Friday, May 29, 2020



  18. They Came, They Saw, He Died

    Microsoft is an inherently sociopathic company; today's story of AppGet is an important reminder that Microsoft has not changed and isn't changing (Maui is another week-old example of trademark-hijacking tactics by Microsoft)



  19. Microsoft-Connected CloudGuru Doesn't Care About GNU/Linux and Now It's Gradually Killing the BSD/Linux-Centric Jupiter Broadcasting (Bought by Linux Academy)

    Assuming Docker is being 'killed' by Microsoft (or at least hijacked to push Windows, Azure and so on) while the GitHub-hosted (Microsoft) CloudGuru, whose co-founder comes from Microsoft, ‘finishes the job’ with Linux Academy and its assets, it’s time to take stock of a pattern/trend that ruins the media too



  20. What Happened to Docker is a Cautionary Tale About the Not-So-New Microsoft

    It’s hardly shocking that Docker collapsed (mass-scale layoffs) after the company had gotten close to Microsoft and got rid of its very own founder (a Red Hat veteran) while the software is being killed off/co-opted by Microsoft (all over the news this week; we’ve omitted links by intention as it’s only puff pieces, no investigative journalism anywhere); we only ask one thing: is anyone paying attention and, if so, what are the lessons learned?



  21. If You Want to Support and Follow Us 'Properly', Really Simple Syndication (RSS) is Most Reliable and Robust to Censorship

    Our longstanding position on social control media (we reject it and don't participate in it) is only proven ever more justified now that the mere idea of fact-checking is seen as controversial if not illegal



  22. Links 29/5/2020: Genode OS 20.05 and FSF Video Conferencing Service

    Links for the day



  23. IRC Proceedings: Thursday, May 28, 2020

    IRC logs for Thursday, May 28, 2020



  24. Weaponised Media Promoting an Illegal Patent System (UPC), Exploiting Major Pandemic in the Process

    The whole 'unitary' scam/ploy (merely a Trojan horse for litigation and low-quality/invalid patents) is being promoted by Thierry Breton as EU Internal Market Commissioner (in spite of illegalities and constitutional issues), merely reinforcing the view that the EU is rather complicit in the abuses perpetrated by Team Battistelli; the media in the pockets of oligarchs and litigation firms (fronting for these oligarchs) plays along, as usual



  25. Links 28/5/2020: OpenSSH 8.3, New Mesa Release, Raspberry Pi 4 News, Fedora 32 Elections

    Links for the day



  26. The EPO Became a Very Radical Institution

    Projection tactics are doomed to say more about the people who utilise them than about anybody else; the EPO has become so autocratic and corrupt that corruption is seen as normal and workers who explain this corruption are framed as "irrational" or "crazy" or "radical"



  27. IRC Proceedings: Wednesday, May 27, 2020

    IRC logs for Wednesday, May 27, 2020



  28. Allegations That Microsoft Will Ruin Besieged Clinics and Hospitals to Retaliate Against Those Who Name the Culprit

    With a broader picture coming into view, as per the above index, we're starting to wrap up the series while issuing a call for more stories and eyewitness testimonies, exposing the nature of attacks on hospitals (those almost always target Microsoft and others' proprietary software, which is technically unfit for purpose)



  29. Microsoft Has Ideas...

    Based on the pattern of media coverage, composed by Microsoft MVPs and Microsoft-affiliated blogs/sites, confusing the public about the meaning of GNU/Linux is reminiscent of an "Extend" phase



  30. ZDNet Proves Our Point by Doing Not a Single Article About Linux (RC7), Only About Linus and Windows Clickbait Junk

    It seems abundantly clear that nobody wants to cover the actual news about Linux and instead it’s all about which PC Linus Torvalds is using (gossip/tabloid); ZDNet‘s latest two articles are an example of this…


RSS 64x64RSS Feed: subscribe to the RSS feed for regular updates

Home iconSite Wiki: You can improve this site by helping the extension of the site's content

Home iconSite Home: Background about the site and some key features in the front page

Chat iconIRC Channel: Come and chat with us in real time

Recent Posts