EditorsAbout the SiteComes vs. MicrosoftUsing This Web SiteSite ArchivesCredibility IndexOOXMLOpenDocumentPatentsNovellNews DigestSite NewsRSS

05.30.18

St. Germain’s “Système Lamy” and Its EPO Clone – Part 3: Shooting the Messengers and Defaming Opponents

Posted in Europe, Patents at 3:44 pm by Dr. Roy Schestowitz

Firing squad

Summary: How Battistelli emulated — sometimes using nearly identical words — “Système Lamy” and what’s coming up in Saint-Germain-en-Laye, where Péricard and his Deputy Mayor for culture, Battistelli, seem to be getting ready for a large lump of EPO cash

In Parts 1 and 2 we looked at some of the features common to the “Système Lamy” in St. Germain-en-Laye and its EPO clone. In Part 3 we continue and conclude our study of the close political symbiosis between Battistelli and his fellow ENArque, Emmanuel Lamy.

Shooting the messenger and defaming opponents

“They have also showed themselves to be well-versed in techniques for defaming or “smearing” their opponents.”Both Lamy and Battistelli have demonstrated considerable enthusiasm and ability when it comes to “shooting the messenger”. They have also showed themselves to be well-versed in techniques for defaming or “smearing” their opponents.

Shooting the messenger

Lamy’s ad hominem attacks on Emmanuel Fruchard from the Saint-Germain Autrement opposition group in connection with the SIDRU “toxic loans” affair are illustrative of his style in this regard.

“The proposition that because Fruchard’s professional background enabled him to understand the technical details of the case he should have refrained from alerting the citizens of St. Germain to the risks of the “structured debt products” contracted by SIDRU is patently absurd.”In September 2011 Lamy used an interview with the local news paper, Courrier des Yvelines, as an occasion for a public attack on Fruchard [PDF] when he tried to discredit him by denouncing him as “a person who has participated in the design of so-called toxic products”:

“In this affair the Mayor of St. Germain denounces the attitude of the elected opposition councillor from St. Germain, Emmanuel Fruchard (Socialist Party) ‘I find it shocking that a person who has participated in the design of so-called toxic products is giving us moral lectures’, he says.”

CdY Lamy 14/9/2011

Lamy was evidently referring to Fruchard’s professional career as a quantitative mathematician and risk modelling expert which involved financial engineering and analyst positions with banks such as Credit Lyonnais and Lazard Frères & Cie in Paris as well as work in the area of financial software development as Director of Financial Engineering at Summit Systems in New York.

JSG 662, 13/2/2015

The proposition that because Fruchard’s professional background enabled him to understand the technical details of the case he should have refrained from alerting the citizens of St. Germain to the risks of the “structured debt products” contracted by SIDRU is patently absurd.

“Over at the EPO, Lamy’s acolyte “Sun-King” Battistelli has notched up an impressive hit-list of irksome “messengers” during the eight years of his unbridled “reign of terror”.”It just goes to show that Lamy was more interested in “shooting the messenger” than in responding to the problems to which Fruchard was trying to draw attention.

The following year during a meeting of the municipal council which took place in July 2012 Lamy accused Fruchard of causing harm to St. Germain because of his persistent attempts to investigate and clarify the details of SIDRU’s “toxic loans”:

“He accused Emmanuel Fruchard of turning the matter into a “personal fight” and uttered an incredible remark: by saying what you are saying, “you are causing harm to us”!!”

One of the most ridiculous accusations raised by Lamy against his political opponents came in September 2011 when he accused the members of the Saint-Germain Autrement group of “engaging in politics” – as if municipal councillors were prohibited from doing so!

The Saint-Germain Autrement group responded as follows:

“The Mayor accuses us of engaging in politics. Well yes indeed, derived from the Greek word politikos, politics covers everything that has to do with the governance of a community. And we will continue to express our vision and the aspirations we perceive about all matters concerning the life of our municipality, whether or not it upsets Mr. Lamy.”

Over at the EPO, Lamy’s acolyte “Sun-King” Battistelli has notched up an impressive hit-list of irksome “messengers” during the eight years of his unbridled “reign of terror”.

One of his first victims was Bernard Paye, the former head of Internal Audit at the EPO. According to reliable sources Paye was prominent in efforts among the EPO’s expatriate French community to canvass the French Administrative Council delegation against the endorsement of Battistelli’s candidature as EPO President in 2009.

If these stories are true, then they probably help to explain why Paye ended up as a prime target on Battistelli’s hit-list.

“Battistelli achieved international notoriety for the kind of vicious “smear tactics” he employed against his perceived opponents.”Paye’s openly stated opposition to Battistelli’s proposals for the abolition of the independent Audit Committee reporting to the Administrative Council led to his “elimination” as head of Internal Audit and to his subsequent forced assignment to a “fictitious” post as “Senior Advisor planning and preparation of the unitary patent” in October 2011. This vexatious transfer was later quashed by the ILOAT in its Judgment No. 3699 of 6 July 2016 and the Tribunal awarded Paye the sum of 12 000 Euros in moral damages and costs. See ILOAT 3699 [PDF].

Other more prominent and well-documented cases of irksome “messengers” who ended up as victims of Battistelli’s firing squad include staff representatives and staff union officials in Munich and the Hague, as well as a member of the Boards of Appeal.

Battistelli achieved international notoriety for the kind of vicious “smear tactics” he employed against his perceived opponents.

“It should be noted that Lamy — to his credit — never attempted to defame his political opponents as “Nazis”.”The title of one of his in-house EPO memos — “Defending our values”issued in October 2015 [PDF] bears a curious similarity to the style of language used by Lamy in the Journal de Saint Germain. By a strange coincidence Lamy used an almost identical title for one of his polemical broadsides directed against the opposition group Saint-Germain Autrement in 2007: “Fidèles à nos valeurs” (published in issue no. 512 of the JSG)

JSG

It should be noted that Lamy — to his credit — never attempted to defame his political opponents as “Nazis”. Perhaps such cheap and patently transparent “smear tactics” would not have had much resonance in a local municipal political context in France. Or perhaps Lamy was simply smarter than Battistelli and realised the risks of such dubious tactics backfiring as they ultimately did for Battistelli in the more sophisticated cosmopolitan environment of the EPO.

“The SIDRU “toxic loans” saga provides plenty of examples of Lamy’s modus operandi in this regard.”In any case the response of the EPO staff union to Battistelli’s “Defending our values” memo of October 2015 is still worth reading: “Not our values” [PDF].

Disclaiming responsibility for one’s own mistakes

Lamy and Battistelli have also shown themselves to be consummate masters of the fine art of disclaiming responsibility for one’s own mistakes and projecting the blame for any errors and failures onto others.

The SIDRU “toxic loans” saga provides plenty of examples of Lamy’s modus operandi in this regard.

From 2007 onwards Lamy appears to have been in a constant state of denial about the “toxic loan” problem and his own role in the affair.

In the beginning he simply denied that there was any issue to be discussed and made extravagant claims that the “structured debt products” which had been contracted under his chairmanship had resulted in impressive tax savings for the citizens of St. Germain-en-Laye.

Such claims were easy to make because the applicable accounting regulations for municipal and intercommunal associations like SIDRU assumed that such public bodies did not dabble in speculative financial products and consequently did not require the official accounts to include figures for the longer-term projected liabilities of such “structured debt contracts” (that is to say, the so-called “latent” or estimated losses over the lifetime of the loan).

Towards the end of 2010, as reported in the current affairs magazine L’Express in September 2011 [PDF], the competent local public audit body (Chambre Régionale des Comptes d’Île de France) began an investigation into the management of SIDRU and it published its report in May 2012.

Amongst other things the report [PDF] of the Chambre Régionale des Comptes (CRC) found that “SIDRU has taken risks that are incompatible with the principle of prudence that governs all public management” and spoke of “…an unpredictable speculation operation with unlimited risk”. Referring to the consequences of the dramatic rise in the applicable interest rates which occurred in 2011 the report noted that: “From 2011, [the toxic loans] will be transformed into net financial charges, to the point of jeopardising SIDRU’s financial equilibrium”.

The Saint-Germain Autrement opposition group issued a press release summarising the findings of the CRC report and noting that it had confirmed their warnings about the “toxic loan” time-bomb ticking away at SIDRU.

Lamy responded by publishing a statement on behalf of the UMP majority group in issue no. 611 of the Journal de Saint Germain under the title: “Gestion de nos déchets – du positif!” [Translation: “The management of our waste – positive news!”].

JSG 611, 6/7/2011

In this statement the CRC report was presented in terms which suggested that it had vindicated the management of SIDRU! Amongst other things, it was claimed that the report did not put the management of SIDRU into question and that it had “validated SIDRU’s accounts”. According to the statement the CRC report also “endorsed the measures which [SIDRU] had undertaken to secure the two swaps”.

A further milestone in SIDRU’s “toxic loan” saga was reached with the first instance judgment relating to the DEPFA loan which was delivered by the Paris Tribunal de Grande Instance (TGI) on 29 January 2015 [PDF].

“Unfortunately Lamy’s optimism proved to be unfounded as the appeal proceedings before the Court of Appeal of Paris ended with a complete rout for SIDRU.”The TGI found that the DEPFA Bank had been at fault due to a failure to comply with its duty to warn SIDRU of the risks inherent in the loan contract. Nevertheless it rejected SIDRU’s request for an annulment of the contract and ordered it to pay outstanding loan amounts of the order of 10 million Euros.

The opposition group Saint-Germain Autrement published a detailed analysis of the TGI judgement on its website and concluded that it was a significant defeat for SIDRU.

Lamy’s response to the TGI judgment was to publish a “puff piece” in issue no. 611 of the JSG claiming “a first victory for SIDRU” along with a “spin-doctored” statement on behalf of the UMP majority group announcing that an appeal would be filed to ensure a final legally binding judgment in favour of SIDRU.

Unfortunately Lamy’s optimism proved to be unfounded as the appeal proceedings before the Court of Appeal of Paris ended with a complete rout for SIDRU.

“At the next meeting of the municipal council of St Germain on 16 November 2016 Lamy was obliged to defend himself in the face of questions tabled by opposition groups.”In its judgement of 4 November 2016 [PDF] the Court of Appeal revised the first-instance judgement to the further detriment of SIDRU and found it liable for all claims by DEPFA which in total amounted to just over 20 million Euros!

The Court of Appeal also underlined Lamy’s personal responsibility in the affair:

“The SIDRU is an informed party to the contract, whose director, Emmanuel Lamy, Mayor of the commune of Saint-Germain-en-Laye, ENArque, head of mission for general economic and financial control for the Ministry of Finance, had all the skills required to understand and analyse the possible consequences of both a strong rise in the Euro against the Dollar and a strong rise in the Swiss Franc against the Euro even if such a scenario had been presented as unlikely”.

In a statement published in the “Free Opinion” forum of issue no. 697 of the JSG the Saint-Germain Autrement group spoke in terms of a “damning judgment” against Lamy: “SIDRU: le jugement accable E. Lamy”.

JSG 697, 18/11/2016

At the next meeting of the municipal council of St Germain on 16 November 2016 Lamy was obliged to defend himself in the face of questions tabled by opposition groups.

According to a commentary written by Jean-Claude Merle, a former municipal councillor of the neighbouring municipality Marly-le-Roi, Lamy basically tried to dodge the question of his personal responsibility in the matter by referring to the collective responsibility of the 15 municipal councils that were the stakeholders of SIDRU as well as the roles of other authorities such as the regional prefect and the regional Chamber of Auditors.

“The public record indicates that Lamy remained in a state of denial about his personal responsibility for the SIDRU toxic loan crisis right up to the very end.”In a further “spin-doctored” statement on behalf of the UMP majority group in issue no. 697 of the JSG published on 18 November 2016, Lamy again tried to suggest that everybody else apart from himself was to blame for the débâcle. He even suggested that the real problem was that in contrast to other European countries French courts were too lenient with regard the “excesses” of banks in such cases!

In December 2016 the Agir pour Saint-Germain conservative opposition group which had become increasingly vocal in its criticism of Lamy’s role in the SIDRU affair published a statement in the “Free Opinion” forum of the JSG in which they deplored the fact that despite repeated calls for him to account for his role in the affair he had not seen fit to offer an apology for his mistakes nor had he even made any attempt to explain himself:

“And yet, in the City Council as in the Community Council, the Mayor having been questioned by our group about his mistakes and his responsibility did not deign to make amends, nor even explain himself.”

The public record indicates that Lamy remained in a state of denial about his personal responsibility for the SIDRU toxic loan crisis right up to the very end.

The EPO “Sun-King” Battistelli has shown a similar propensity to dodge responsibility for his own mistakes and to project the blame for problems and failures at the EPO onto any convenient scapegoats.

“The EPO “Sun-King” Battistelli has shown a similar propensity to dodge responsibility for his own mistakes and to project the blame for problems and failures at the EPO onto any convenient scapegoats.”Battistelli’s preferred official narrative is that he is the “good guy” who has been the hapless victim of a relentless “defamation campaign” organised by the EPO staff union SUEPO as claimed for example in an interview published in World Intellectual Property Review in September 2014 [PDF] (“AIPPI 2014 Battistelli accuses EPO union of defamation”).

EPO insiders can provide innumerable examples of Battistelli’s attempts to divert attention away from his own mistakes and to ridicule or belittle well-founded criticisms of his failures and excesses by independent observers.

One prominent example should suffice to give a flavour of the “Sun-King’s” modus operandi in such matters.

Following the judgment of the Hague Court of Appeal in favour of the EPO staff union SUEPO in February 2015 Battistelli used the EPO’s official website to issue a public denial that the EPO was violating fundamental human rights. (warning: epo.org link)

“Battistelli’s legal “enforcer” at the EPO, Raimund Lutz, can also be seen lurking in the background in one of the photos.”The statement opened with a rather bizarre reference to “a strange rumour [which] has recently spread across Europe in some media, political circles and even with national judges: that the EPO has not been respecting fundamental human rights.”

At that time the IPKat website was still publishing articles on EPO affairs and the pseudonymous Merpel was inspired to conduct a critical review of the EPO’s statement: “[A]s will be clear from her comments … she does not agree with much of the substance of the EPO post, and indeed finds the title quite astonishing.”

A close political symbiosis

The close political symbiosis between Lamy and his fellow ENArque Battistelli was plain to see during the hosting of the annual EPO-SIPO Heads of Offices meeting which by a strange and unexplained stroke of good fortune took place in St. Germain-en-Laye on 5 October 2016 [PDF].

“The 2016 SIPO event appears to have been a “dress rehearsal” for the 2018 European Inventor of the Year Award which is soon to be held in St. Germain-en-Laye.”The event was celebrated in an extensive “puff piece” [PDF] which appeared in issue no. 695 of the JSG complete with colour photos of Battistelli and Lamy and Commissioner Shen of the Chinese State Intellectual Property Office. Battistelli’s legal “enforcer” at the EPO, Raimund Lutz, can also be seen lurking in the background in one of the photos.

SIPO JSG 695

SIPO Lamy and Battistelli

The 2016 SIPO event appears to have been a “dress rehearsal” for the 2018 European Inventor of the Year Award which is soon to be held in St. Germain-en-Laye.

It would appear that Battistelli’s collaboration with the Mayor of St. Germain in such matters is continuing via Lamy’s successor, Arnaud Péricard.

“In particular, the inimitable duo seem to be taking great care to ensure that there is not too much advance publicity about the extravaganza in the local media and in the municipal council perhaps in order to avoid unwanted public scrutiny and awkward questions as to how exactly St. Germain came to be chosen as the venue a mere three years after the event had been held in nearby Paris.”All the signs indicate that the new Mayor, Péricard, and his Deputy Mayor for culture, Battistelli, are colluding closely in the preparations for the Inventor of the Year Award which is scheduled to be hosted in the municipal theatre, Théâtre Alexandre Dumas, on 7 June 2018.

In particular, the inimitable duo seem to be taking great care to ensure that there is not too much advance publicity about the extravaganza in the local media and in the municipal council perhaps in order to avoid unwanted public scrutiny and awkward questions as to how exactly St. Germain came to be chosen as the venue a mere three years after the event had been held in nearby Paris.

We suppose that readers of the “local Pravda” can look forward to another extensive “puff piece” with convenient photo-ops for the Mayor and Deputy Mayor in due course.

Share this post: These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Reddit
  • co.mments
  • DZone
  • email
  • Google Bookmarks
  • LinkedIn
  • NewsVine
  • Print
  • Technorati
  • TwitThis
  • Facebook

If you liked this post, consider subscribing to the RSS feed or join us now at the IRC channels.

Pages that cross-reference this one

What Else is New


  1. Links 23/2/2020: PipeWire 0.3 and Osu!

    Links for the day



  2. FSF's Interim Co-President Alexandre Oliva on Being Cancelled

    It was reading this that I realized I’d been cancelled myself. In my case, I was painted misogynist and transphobic, and for a post in which I supported women but denounced a crowd of men twisting the feminist cause, that I share, to attack rms, as if he wasn’t a feminist himself; and in which I express curiosity as to what pronoun to use to refer to zero women to paint me as someone who disregards gender identities and their pronouns.



  3. Good People Need to Run for Free Software Foundation (FSF) Board Positions After an FSF Coup Threw in the Towel, Pushing Out the Founder

    "I have been hit, but not knocked out, and my campaign for free software is not over." --Richard Stallman, October 2019



  4. IRC Proceedings: Saturday, February 22, 2020

    IRC logs for Saturday, February 22, 2020



  5. Alexandre Oliva's Message About Cancel Culture at the FSF

    Being cancelled is no fun. In my case, it was for standing for a friend who got canceled for defending someone else from an accusation that was later proven false.



  6. Links 22/2/2020: Polish Government Increases GNU/Linux Use, Samza 1.3.1

    Links for the day



  7. Being Rich Does Not Imply Being Smart (Especially When One is Born Into Wealth)

    Presenting the 'genius' (college dropout, but that does not matter when the yardstick of wisdom is wealth alone), with his own predictions overlaid on top of his photo from the show of Bloomberg (another 'genius' whose supposed brilliance is measured using money alone)



  8. The Rise and Fall of Free Software

    "We simply need to make the movement less corporate, and more grassroots."



  9. Why You Should Adopt Debian 10, Not Vista 10 (Windows Vista With Microsoft's Latest Surveillance Add-ons)

    A little personal story and recommendation of Debian "Buster" (10) or Devuan (whose developers persist)



  10. Ethics by Exclusion

    It's the same old philosophical question; can excluding those who are perceived to be intolerant be seen as an act of tolerance?



  11. Even Worse Than Microsoft Inside the Board of the OSI

    The OSI has accepted people from companies that actively attack Software Freedom and there may be more on their way



  12. ZDNet Continues to Stuff Its 'Linux' Section With Proprietary Software of Microsoft

    The above is what the "Linux" section of ZDNet is going to look like throughout the weekend (and this is hardly unusual, either)



  13. IRC Proceedings: Friday, February 21, 2020

    IRC logs for Friday, February 21, 2020



  14. Links 21/2/2020: EasyOS 2.2.11 Released, Microsoft's Control of the Linux Foundation Increases and More Binary Blobs Arrive

    Links for the day



  15. IRC Proceedings: Thursday, February 20, 2020

    IRC logs for Thursday, February 20, 2020



  16. Video: LinuxWorld 1999, Torvalds and Stallman

    LinuxWorld 1999, Torvalds and Stallman



  17. GNU World Order is a Personal Sacrifice, LinuxWorld Just Business

    As the Linux Foundation shows, Linux is just business (and proprietary software) as usual, software patents included, whereas it’s GNU that continues the Free Software Movement’s battles



  18. Links 20/2/2020: Oracle Solaris 11.4 SRU18, Mesa 20, VirtualBox 6.1.4

    Links for the day



  19. Open Source Did Not Win, It Was Assimilated to and by Proprietary Software

    Don’t fall for the whole “Open Source has won!” spiel; You know we’ve lost the battle (and were in effect gradually conquered) at OSI and elsewhere when those who speak for the OSI are Michael Cheng (Facebook), Max Sills (Google), and Chris Aniszczyk (Linux Foundation); they say “Open Source Under Attack” (FOSDEM talk) but their employers are the ones attacking and they downplay openwashing



  20. Former Microsoft Employees Don't Like Talking About Past and Present Microsoft Back Doors (Designed for Spy Agencies)

    In a typical Microsoftian fashion, once they cannot defend the illusion/delusion that Microsoft values security the 'Softers' run away and block any further debate



  21. Techrights Warns Against Impending Extradition Efforts (Passage of Julian Assange to His Death in the United States)

    Imprisonment of journalists who are effective at exposing crimes (of the powerful, not petty crimes) must never be condoned



  22. Team UPC: Many Mouths and No Ears

    The mental condition of Team UPC gets more worrisome by the week



  23. Team UPC Insults Judges Because the UPC is Dead and UPC Lobbyists Have Nothing Left to Lose

    More judge-shaming tactics are in the mix; Team UPC seems to feel like there's nothing left to lose as the UPC is already dead (hope itself is next to die)



  24. IRC Proceedings: Wednesday, February 19, 2020

    IRC logs for Wednesday, February 19, 2020



  25. China Bashing is Grounded in Fear (That They Can Simply Do Better Than the West)

    The atmosphere of hate towards China — fuelled partly by a white supremacist in the White House — is unhelpful and insulting; dignity and understanding is the way to go



  26. IRC Proceedings: Tuesday, February 18, 2020

    IRC logs for Tuesday, February 18, 2020



  27. FFII Press Release: Germany Can No Longer Ratify the Unitary Patent Due to Brexit and the Established AETR Case-law, says FFII

    Germany cannot ratify the current Unitary Patent due to Brexit and the established AETR case-law. The ratification of the UPC (Unified Patent Court) by Germany would constitute a violation of the AETR case-law, which was used during the EPLA negotiations in 2006 to consider a deal with non-EU countries, such as Switzerland.



  28. DRM (Proprietary Software) Already Makes Mozilla Firefox Broken, Unreliable, Undependable (Dependent on Binary Blobs)

    More people are beginning to realise that Mozilla resorted to self-harming DRM and self-inflicted damage that impacts Firefox; can Mozilla (re)join the anti-DRM coalitions?



  29. EPO and Other Patent Updates Over RSS

    Site syndication (over RSS feeds or XML/Atom) is vastly better than what became popular in recent years (censored, centralised, discriminatory "Social Control Media"); here are some feeds of interest



  30. When It Comes to a Unitary Patent System, Bad (or Intentionally Dishonest) Legal Advice Has Become the Norm

    The Unified Patent Court and Unitary Patent (UPC and UP, respectively) reinforce the old saying about lawyers being liars, doing anything to attract clients (to take their money); the UPC is basically dead, but fiction, falsehoods and outrageous fantasies still find their way into Web sites of law firms


RSS 64x64RSS Feed: subscribe to the RSS feed for regular updates

Home iconSite Wiki: You can improve this site by helping the extension of the site's content

Home iconSite Home: Background about the site and some key features in the front page

Chat iconIRC Channel: Come and chat with us in real time

Recent Posts