Bonum Certa Men Certa

The Linux Kernel Needs to Reject Rust for the Same Reason Linus Torvalds Rejects GitHub (Where Rust is Hosted and Developed)



Summary: Developing frameworks on Microsoft servers is a very bad idea (it has also led to censorship of Microsoft critics); this is the last thing Linux needs to become dependent on at this stage

MOST of the code I've written in my lifetime is C code. C is relatively easy (compared to C++, which I mostly dislike). The above video, which isn't terribly old, is Torvalds' response to a question regarding using more programming languages in the kernel.



"This is not a new problem and we've written about it a number of times, including this past summer."Lately we've been posting in Daily Links about half a dozen links about efforts to put Rust inside the kernel (search for "Rust Linux" or similar). Putting aside Mozilla's fiscal woes (it plans to turn Rust into a foundation, just like Mozilla itself), Rust has an issue with free speech and it's too friendly towards Microsoft or towards proprietary software (need proprietary software like GitHub to contribute and communicate; Mozilla is OK with DRM!). This is not a new problem and we've written about it a number of times before, including this past summer. This predates severe actions by overzealous Reddit moderators; some contributors expressed concerns about the project's CoC, which they thought accomplished the opposite of inclusiveness (excluding people with particular viewpoints, technical or otherwise, fostering groupthink instead).

For a number of years we've 'lobbied' Rust to "delete GitHub," but the project never listened. Instead the project seems to have warmed up further... to Microsoft. Just like the Linux Foundation, which nowadays outsources almost all the code to Microsoft.

That's of course just my personal opinion and I unapologetically stick with it. Over the years I saw a number of other things that worried me, both in the Rust 'community' and its steward (Mozilla). This sort of extra 'politics' isn't what will benefit Linus and Linux. Heck, maybe in the future they can hypothetically find some way to sanction Linus/Linux over his/its use or supposed misuse of language/programming language (words like "master" in Linux or curse words from Linus). In the Debian talk/Q&A he was asked about curse words; he said he had rejected mannerism/politics (cultural differences) or political correctness games; guess what happened shortly afterwards and remember who the enforcers typically are.

Recent Techrights' Posts

Sami Tikkanen Explains Rust Language and Its Goals
"Sompi" (the nickname of Sami Tikkanen) has weighed in
Mauritius: Windows at All-Time Low, Down From 96% to 17%
Put in simple terms, people choose to connect from the "phone" (running Linux), not some laptop running Windows
Many IBM Layoffs Reported Today in Europe and North America
there's definitely a lot going on today
The GNU Manifesto is 40. Here's the Original Print (1985).
Some unpleasant people want to replace GNU with Microsoft-controlled (GitHub) Rust copycats
Unixmen Seems to Have Died After Turning Into a Slopfarm and Spamfarm, Is LinuxSecurity.com Next?
Better to not publish anything at all than to resort to fake garbage.
What Happened to the Open Source Initiative (OSI) Elections: More People Begin to Speak Out
Kuhn set another bonfire ablaze
2025 Rumours of IBM Layoffs in Marketing Likely True, Online Powwow Drops More Clues
Expect over 10,000 layoffs this year (at IBM alone)
 
"Rust People" Are a Threat to BSD Too (the Licence Isn't the Main Issue, Nor is the Proprietary Microsoft Hosting)
BSDs aren't written in Rust, so BSD developers should buckle up
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Tuesday, March 18, 2025
IRC logs for Tuesday, March 18, 2025
Links 19/03/2025: Gardening Season and the Web Without an Audience
Links for the day
Links 18/03/2025: ‘Meritless’ Defamation Suit Thrown Out, InterDigital Software Patents Headed for the Bin Too
Links for the day
These Strange Web Statistics From The Bahamas Show Windows Falling From 93% to Less Than 5%
There are about half a million there
Gemini Links 18/03/2025: Weather and Resisting "MAGA"
Links for the day
Links 18/03/2025: New Apple Blunders and Windows Disliked by Users
Links for the day
Once Again 'Losing Track' of Who the Clients Are, The Serial Harasser and Strangler from Microsoft
Timing is everything
Android (With Linux) Rises to Record Highs in Hong Kong and in Macao
Looking quite bad for Microsoft
Distractions. Distractions Everywhere.
distracting from the real solution
EPO Concerns About the Education and Childcare Allowance Reform (ECAR) and School Liaison Officer (SLO)
The public deserves to know as it impacts thousands of families
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Monday, March 17, 2025
IRC logs for Monday, March 17, 2025
Links 17/03/2025: Weather Changing and Connecting Docker to Localhost
Links for the day
Microsoft Windows Barely Exists in Haiti Anymore
This trend in Haiti is a "story in progress"
The EPO Might Face Critical 'Brain Drain' (Abandonment by the Most Experienced Patent Examiners) This Year
"a number of colleagues might feel compelled to inform the Administration before the end of May 2025 of their intention to retire as of 1 December 2025."
Links 17/03/2025: Forced Labour and Memory on Tenstorrent
Links for the day
Links 17/03/2025: Live Nation’s DOJ Antitrust Battle Carries on, as Does the Demise of the "Hey Hi" Bubble
Links for the day
Links 17/03/2025: "Badly Misled About Covid" and "Gag of America"
Links for the day
The Lie or Half-Truth of Clownflare (or Equivalents) Improving Things
It may seem "cheap" (temporarily) and "fast", but that's just bait
Free Speech Around the World is Curtailed in the Name of "Protecting Us"
We have spent many years speaking about how to combat this trend
Enshittification of Online Media
Now more than ever we must fight for independent press
War Readiness Means Removing Every Windows Installation and CALEA-Compliant Equipment
Finland is vulnerable for a whole bunch of reasons
Reporting Facts is Not a Privacy Violation
Techrights has long valued and defended privacy
In the Russian Federation (Russia), Microsoft Isn't Even the 1%
the government builds "homegrown" (not pertinent parts of them) distros with which to replace Microsoft, not just Windows
Gemini Links 17/03/2025: "Hack the Planet", Klingnauer Stausee, and Enshittification
Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Sunday, March 16, 2025
IRC logs for Sunday, March 16, 2025