Bonum Certa Men Certa

The German Constitutional Court Needs to Recognise That the EPO's Tribunals Are Not Independent and EPC Has Not or Isn't Being Honoured for Quite Some Time Now

Video download link



Summary: The software patents situation at the EPO isn't being resolved and probably cannot be resolved as long as corrupt management besieges judges who were all along supposed to be entirely autonomous and unafraid of Office management

THE EPO isn't functioning. Granting lots and lots patents is "functioning" in the same sense pouring oil into the ocean (or up from the bottom of the ocean like BP did a decade ago) is "extracting"...



"The notorious bodyguard from the EPO is also in prison. Will the people he 'guarded' (with illegal weapons) join him?"At this moment of time, given the opportunity to speak to patent examiners discreetly (European patent examiners) you're almost always guaranteed to hear that patent granting collapsed in terms of quality or validity, which are pretty much the same thing (surrogates). Even the EPO's own studies (internal) confirmed this, but the EPO muzzled those who studied the matter. That's just how defunct the Office has become. It's a truth- and science-denying institution, eager to just pile up loads of money and then plunder that money by shrewdly-engineered schemes and scams. Nicolas Sarkozy is in prison. Who's next? The notorious bodyguard from the EPO is also in prison. Will the people he 'guarded' (with illegal weapons) join him? Some are connected to Sarkozy.

The lockThe only astounding thing, as pointed out in the video above, is that there seems to be coordinated silencing in patent blogs, which seem highly determined to suppress discussion about all that, even in the comments section.

Recently, besieged judges decided to "play it safe" and say OK to a President who had pressured them to approve software patents. We've covered it before and we have cited some 'coverage' (from self-serving law firms) in Daily Links since then. No real reporting or journalism about it, just shameless marketing from lawyers looking to profit from European software patents, even of courts throw these out. Just like Benoît Battistelli, António Campinos is pressuring the judges to rule in a particular way, which means there's no independence at all. Even by their own admission. In the weekend we caught up with two more pieces about it, both from law firms and their front groups. Or media operatives.

The video above discusses this self-serving post which said: "Hot off the press: The EPO has issued a decision on G1/19, which relates to the question of inventive step and simulations/simulators."

It's actually a day late, not "Hot off the press..."

"As a brief summary," they said, "the Enlarged Board of Appeal has ruled that a simulation of a technical system can solve a technical problem by producing a technical effect going beyond the simulation's implementation on a computer."

Did the Board have independence? No. More laughable was this ridiculous puff piece about "hey hi", which spoke to no software professionals or representative body of theirs. They spoke to representatives of patent trolls, such as Bristows. They said: "The EPO’s enlarged board of appeal handed down the decision (G1/19) yesterday, March 10, holding that the established case law on computer-implemented inventions (CIIs) also applied to computer-implemented simulations."

Where are the actual software professionals? Nowhere. Where's the mention of the lack of judicial independence? Nowhere, of course. We're meant to just blindly believe that the issue went away. Like magic!

Dr Ingve Björn Stjerna has meanwhile translated Justice Huber's remarks on EPO complaints. A day after the decision above he published the following in his Web site:



Constitutional court judge Prof. Huber on the situation at the European Patent Office (11/03/2021)

As is known, several constitutional complaints against acts of the European Patent Office are currently pending before the German Constitutional Court (“BVerfG”), in which, inter alia, a violation of the fundamental rights to effective legal protection (Art. 19 (4) GG) and to the lawful judge (Art. 101 (1) sentence 2 GG) is complained of (cf. docket no. 2 BvR 2480/10, 2 BvR 421/13, 2 BvR 786/15, 2 BvR 756/16 and 2 BvR 561/18).

In the newest edition of one of the leading German commentaries on the German Grundgesetz, BVerfG judge Prof. Peter Huber, who is the judge rapporteur in the above-mentioned constitutional complaint proceedings, comments on the situation at the European Patent Office with regard to Art. 19 (4) GG as follows (von Mangoldt/Klein/Starck/Huber, Grundgesetz, 7th ed. (2018), Art. 19 GG, para. 540 ff., footnotes have been removed, translation from German):

“Against this background, the increasing erosion of the suspensive effect through the Europeanization of administrative procedural law (…) does not lead to a conflict with the claim to validity of the legal protection guarantee of Art. 19 (4), even if it encourages the trend towards a reduction of the German level of legal protection.

The same principles apply to the European Patent Office in Munich, which was established on the basis of the Convention on the Grant of European Patents (EPC) concluded on 5 October 1973, and has the task of granting a ‘European bundle patent’ as an intergovernmental body within the meaning of Art. 24 (1) in a uniform granting procedure according to uniform requirements. Its decisions can be appealed (Art. 106 EPC), these appeals are decided by Boards of Appeal with judicial independence (Art. 23 EPC). Their proceedings are designed in a judicial way, their activities are materially judicial in nature.

The compatibility of this possibility of appeal with the minimum standard of effective legal protection required by the Grundgesetz (Art. 24 (1), 79 (3), 19 (2) and (4)) is not hindered by the fact that the Boards of Appeal are not courts institutionally separated from the European Patent Office (Art. 15 EPC). This is because, on the one hand, the demands for structural congruence between the German legal system and intergovernmental bodies within the scope of application of Art. 24(1) did not prevail, and, on the other hand, the minimum level of effective legal protection required by Art. 19 (2), which must not be fallen short of even in the case of supranationalization of jurisdictional functions, is marked less by the institutional separation of the second and third powers than by the possibility of having any infringement of rights reviewed by an appeal to an independent body in a judicial procedure. This minimum is guaranteed under the EPC.“

The relevance of these comments with regard to the prospects of success of the aforementioned constitutional complaint proceedings is left to the reader’s assessment.



The part which bothers us says: "Its decisions can be appealed (Art. 106 EPC), these appeals are decided by Boards of Appeal with judicial independence (Art. 23 EPC). Their proceedings are designed in a judicial way, their activities are materially judicial in nature."

Is there no recognition at the FCC that the EPC has long been violated by the EPO? Or that judges at Boards of Appeal complain about their lack of judicial independence?

"Those quotes are not good news for us," one Free software activist told us.

We mostly agree. It's important to convey the simple fact that the Boards or tribunals of the EPO aren't functioning and questions about their independence are being squashed. Contrary to what today's "Kat" would wish for us to think...

Recent Techrights' Posts

EFF Still Uses and Relies on Donald Trump's Friend (Elon Musk) for Campaigning and It Gets No Response (Except From FFII's President)
...He reminds them the issue isn't just "bad patents" or "patent trolls"
OpenSource.net, Which OpenSource.org (OSI) Said Would Continue OpenSource.com (IBM/Red Hat), Has Been Dead for a Month
Open Source Initiative is not an ally; it's a Microsoft front group
Latest in OSI's Blog Affirms Its Status as Microsoft Front Group, Sponsored by Microsoft to Promote Microsoft Agenda and Lobby for GPL Violations
Even the staff is paid by Microsoft; they hardly hide this anymore
OpenAI: If OpenAI Survives Another 2 Years, It'll be About 30 Billion Dollars in Cumulative Losses/Debt
So if Microsoft cushions those losses (to delay the bubble's implosion; Microsoft uses the bubble to fake its "market cap", as does NVIDIA), its debt will skyrocket
Perils for Patent Eligibility Restoration Act (PERA) and PREVAIL (Efforts by the Litigation 'Industry' to Bring Back Software Patents and Crush Challengers at PTAB)
The EFF and FSF seem to have caught up with it
 
Links 15/11/2024: The Onion Buys Crank's Site, More Publications Quit Twitter/X
Links for the day
Gemini Links 15/11/2024: Boredom and New Blog with Gemini Support
Links for the day
Iceland: Microsoft Windows Down to All-Time Low of 60% on Desktops/Laptops
It also fell sharply across all form factors
Large British Newspaper (The Daily Telegraph) to be Composed by Microsoft Chatbots Instead of Journalists?
"engagement" is not accuracy or quality
FSFE Now Taking Bribes From Microsoft, Its Gold Donor (the Highest Payment Possible)
A sellout does not get any bigger than "Gold Donor"
One of the Largest B2B YouTube Channels?
It makes the Linux Foundation look rogue; it plays along with all this
Free Software is for Everybody
today's Linux Foundation shamelessly and recklessly promotes discrimination
Coming Soon: More Reports About the European Patent Office (EPO)
EPO corruption has made Europe a lot poorer
Filipinos Love GNU/Linux
Philippines as seen by statCounter
[Meme] Poverty Not an Issue
To know who the EFF fronts for, check who's funding the EFF
EFF Stories For Next Year
The EFF isn't what it seems
Windows 10? No, Windows at 10% (in Angola)
That's how statCounter sees things anyway
Wintertime in Techrights
2025 should be an exciting year for us and we look forward to spring
About 80% of Red Hat Blog is the 'Hey Hi' Nonsense (Ponzi Scheme)
The official Red Hat RSS feeds have been drowned out by "AI" nonsense
[Meme] If This is How Wall Street Really Works, People Should be Terrified
"OpenAI worth $150 billion with a $15 billion loss"
Red Hat Has Become a Buzzwords Vendor, Not a Linux Company
Red Hat is quickly becoming a joke of a company or "90% marketing"...
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Thursday, November 14, 2024
IRC logs for Thursday, November 14, 2024
Phoronix Did Not Cover This...
1,000 people fired at AMD is not news
Links 15/11/2024: LF Talks About Patent Trolls, Advancing a Warning About "Buy Nothing Day"
Links for the day
Alexander Wirt (formorer), Wayward people & Debian censorship
Reprinted with permission from Daniel Pocock
Gemini Links 14/11/2024: Infocalypse and "Multiple Monitorings"
Links for the day
Links 14/11/2024: The Web We Lost Coming Back, X/Twitter Crashing
Links for the day
Links 14/11/2024: Politics, Climate, and Instability
Links for the day
Links 14/11/2024: EmacsConf and Flounder
Links for the day
Links 14/11/2024: Science and the Demise of Microsoft-Connected USPTO Director
Links for the day
For "X" to Die the Media and Politicians Will Need to Quit (Then, Advertisers Will Lose Interest, Even for Political Ads)
Fewer people are still there anyway
Debian GNU/Linux and Free Software Developer Daniel Pocock in Irish Elections This Month (Dublin Bay South)
Polling day in 15 days
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Wednesday, November 13, 2024
IRC logs for Wednesday, November 13, 2024
Bob Should Tell Alice About What GitHub (Which Linux Foundation Outsources Code to) Does to Entire Nations, Following Donald Trump's Policies
"What's next, preventing access to Linux from non-NATO countries? Putting NSA backdoors in the kernel?"
Layoffs as Happy Stories in the Corporate Media
It's based on a longstanding pattern
It Took The Guardian More Than 2 Years of Musk to Realise What Twitter Was and It Took Twitter 4 Years of a President Trump to Realise What Trump Was
Trump was deplatformed only a fortnight before Biden became president anyway
[Meme] Google 80%, Windows 2%
"I'm going to f---ing bury that guy, I have done it before, and I will do it again. I'm going to f---ing kill Google."
Microsoft's Market Share Falls to 2% in Haiti
Throw in Android (now 80% of "the market") and Windows is down to 2%
Gemini Links 13/11/2024: Magic of Walking and Lest We Forget
Links for the day
Links 13/11/2024: USPTO Director Kathi Vidal ('Former' Microsoft Rep) Resigning, Censorship After Car Ramming Attack in China
Links for the day
Microsoft: Layoffs, Outsourcing, and R.T.O. as Cover for Mass Layoffs Without Severance Pay
Microsoft had mass layoffs pretty much every month this year
[Meme] The Addicted Lolicon Throwing Stones
"They've found my RMS attack site"
Jonathan Carter & Debian betrayed Joel Espy Klecker
Reprinted with permission from Daniel Pocock
Links 13/11/2024: Red Tape War and Programming Experiences
Links for the day
Links 13/11/2024: "Make Your Laptop Last FOREVER" With GNU/Linux, 23andMe Mass Layoffs, Intel 'Resignations' Layoffs Loophole
Links for the day
In Switzerland, GNU/Linux Reaches Record Highs, But What About the Corruption?
Pocock is a disappointed citizen of Switzerland
More Than 3 Years After Vista 11's Release More Chinese Computer Users Still Use Vista 7 (Than "11")
it was "officially" released October 5, 2021
At BetaNews, "Most Commented Story" Is Not a Story But LLM Slop! (Readers Talking to Bots)
They make fake stories with provocative headlines and then boast that these get many comments
[Meme] Swiss Lawyers/Attorneys Who Fake Qualifications and Rob People
Switzerland mostly guards its reputation by censorship of media
Just How Slow Has the News Industry Become?
We're drowning in garbage from fake publishers
Things That Still Work OK (But We're Being Shamed for Using)
Using old stuff is nothing to be shamed of (or afraid to do)
Free Software is About Collaboration
WordPress limits it
Even the Managing Editor of BetaNews is Doing Slop and Spam
A Fish Rots From The Head Down
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Tuesday, November 12, 2024
IRC logs for Tuesday, November 12, 2024
PERA Bill in US Senate Strives to Crush Caselaw, Making Patents on Mathematics and Algorithms 'Great Again'
Follow the money
BetaNews is Beta-Testing the Site as LLM Slop With Microsoft Propaganda Thrown In
Many of the people there are Microsoft boosters and they use slop as "filler" (for marketing)
Evolution of euthanasia & WIPO UDRP similarities exposed by W. Scott Blackmer
Reprinted with permission from Daniel Pocock
Gemini Links 13/11/2024: Phasing Out 3G, Brian Kernighan Books, Tcl/Tk, Time to Ditch x86
Links for the day