Bonum Certa Men Certa

The EPO in Violation of the EPC and Nobody Holds Anyone Accountable for Such Violations

Video download link | md5sum b8da83957e1ea46ad2b8acf1ec3f439f EPC Assassinated Creative Commons Attribution-No Derivative Works 4.0



Summary: Violations of the foundational document of the EPO have become so prevalent that one has to gasp and wonder if EPOnia is basically the EU's Kremlin (the dictators do anything they want, even in clear violation of the constitutions, with post hoc justifications and cover-up)

The Central Staff Committee (CSC) of the EPO has just circulated a latter dated yesterday, coming about 24 hours after the greenwashing of a likely illegal practice from Team Campinos. They bragged about not giving anything physical for a patent, as if this was about saving the planet or something, ignoring all sorts of laws as well as common sense.



Benoît Battistelli made violations of the EPC very routine (he also promoted European software patents using all sorts of lies, just as he did with the UPC), so why can't Team Campinos continue this tradition? Breton doesn't mind, so the EU is basically in their pockets. Illegality is being declared "legal" with no actual explanation or rationalisation.

To quote the CSC's message to EPO staff: "With the current implementation of the Patent Work Bench it is for instance possible that an action (such as a decision to refuse an application under Article 97(2) EPC) sent by the first examiner and approved by all members of the division is later amended by the first examiner without the amendment having to be approved by any other member of the division. Comparing this to the paper file flow, this is equivalent to the first examiner changing the text of the decision after all three members of the division have signed, without informing the other members of the division of the change.

"It may become a serious issue for the reputation of the Office and the perceived integrity of its decisions in the Patent Granting Process. It is easily possible – making use of proper digital signatures for all actions requiring the signatures of the members of the examining division – to provide legally sound proof of both the authenticity of the content of the signed documents as well as the identity of the undersigned.

"In this open letter, we therefore request the Office to swiftly develop a working solution for a truly electronic file flow that meets the requirements of the EPC."

As promised when I recorded the above video (I always do the videos before any of the articles), we're converting the full text of the letter into simple HTML, which will be archived as text, then become richer plain text and GemText:

centralSTCOM@epo.org Reference: sc22025cl Date: 10.03.2022

European Patent Office | 80298 MUNICH | GERMANY Mr Steve Rowan Vice-President DG 1

By email

OPEN LETTER

Formal deficiencies in the fully electronic Patent Granting Process

Dear Mr Rowan,

Since 2020 the Office has developed, with impressive speed, tools to implement a fully electronic Patent Granting Process (PGP). One of the core tools to achieve this goal is the Patent Work Bench (PWB). The conversion to a fully electronic PGP must meet certain standards to be acceptable to both public and staff. We have concerns that the PWB currently fails to meet such standards, in particular as regards its compliance with the EPC.

Among other processes, PWB replaces the paper file flow within the Examining Division to authorise decisions to refuse an application, intentions to grant a patent, or summons to oral proceedings. The EPC requires that each of these actions be signed by all members of the division (Article 97(1) and (2) EPC, Rules 111 and 113 EPC).

However, the PWB is inadequate to meet the requirements of the EPC.

With the current implementation of the PWB it is for instance possible that an action (such as a decision to refuse an application under Article 97(2) EPC) sent by the first examiner of the division and approved by the second member and the chair is later amended by the first examiner without the amendment having to be approved by any other member of the division. Comparing this to the paper file flow, this is equivalent to the first examiner changing the text of the decision after all three members of the division have signed, without informing the other members of the division of the change.




It may become a serious issue for the reputation of the Office and the perceived integrity of its decisions in the PGP, should the public become aware of the unsatisfactory authorisation of electronic actions by the Examining Division. This situation is regrettable because it is easily possible – making use of proper digital signatures for all actions requiring the signatures of the members of the examining division – to provide legally sound proof of both the authenticity of the content of the signed documents as well as the identity of the undersigned, and to avoid embarrassing decisions and judgments (as, e.g., decision J16/17 or AT-ILO Judgments Nos. 1344 and 2417).

We therefore request the Office to swiftly develop a working solution for a truly electronic file flow that meets the requirements of the EPC.

Yours sincerely,

Alain Dumont Chairman of the Central Staff Committee


It's too easy to lose count of the number of times (and ways) the EPO violates then EPC. Who will be held accountable for it? If nobody ever gets punished for it, why will that ever stop? Why does the world not sanction the EPO? Carte blanche for dictators and narcissists encourages them to do more of the same.

Recent Techrights' Posts

European Patent Office (EPO) Reformation Project
It's a stain on the EU's reputation
Slopwatch: Google News and Other Slopfarms
Google News is rewarding sites that misuse LLMs and cheat the Web
Moral Standards From the Masters of Linux
They get hung up on minor language issue and promote this crazy theory that racism will go away if only everyone spoke a little differently (no matter where he or she came from)
 
Techrights and Tux Machines Running as Usual During Vacations
No interruptions, maybe temporarily slowdowns
GNU OS, Powered by Hurd
Choice is good, as long as choices exist that respect the users' freedom
Gemini Links 15/08/2025: ADHD and "Random Weird Things"
Links for the day
"Maybe the Problem is You"
they probably felt like they had no choice because they really needed this Microsoft money
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Thursday, August 14, 2025
IRC logs for Thursday, August 14, 2025
"Article 52. PATENTABLE INVENTIONS" in the European Patent Convention
Some time tomorrow we'll have a complete local copy of the EPC
Serial Slopper (SS) Still at It, Still Misusing Plagiarism Tools and Cheatware for Images and Text About "Linux"
All the slopfarms are a very big problem
Reddit Deletes Stuff, But Not for Being False or Misleading
Yet another one of those articles that speak of a man in his 50s as if he's terminally ill
Times of India and India.com Are Clickbait and LLM Slop
Google continues to reward bad actors
The More "Market Share" Microsoft Loses, The Higher the Shares Go
People joke about the same sort of thing in relation to IBM
To OIN, Software Patents Are Not a Problem
Had software patents ceased to exist, OIN too would cease to exist and its staff would be unemployed.
Microsoft's Bankruptcy in Russia is Only the Beginning
Due to politics it mostly makes sense that Windows is being phased out, also in part due to policy changes
Microsoft-Funded Publishers Lied to Us About Vista 10 and Now Advocate Us Owning Nothing
They want you to own nothing, but they also want you to buy a PC on which to become Microsoft's slave and they make it harder if not practically impossible to remove Windows
Articles Promoting and Celebrating Wayland Are LLM Slop
New example (100% slop)
The Register MS, Dominated by American Editors, Says UK Should be Run (Digitally) by Microsoft US
The Register MS is sponsored by American money, run by Americans, and its chief editor is a Microsofter from the US
Gemini Links 14/08/2025: Drought, Climate Experiments, and LLM Slop Considered Detrimental
Links for the day
Links 14/08/2025: Second-hand ThinkPad and Enhanced Surveillance on Chipsets from the United States
Links for the day
Links 14/08/2025: Data Brokers Hiding Opt-Out Pages From Google, "Fight Chat Control"
Links for the day
FSF Infrastructure Under Constant Attack
The disconnect (literally) has had an effect on credibility
Feels Like The Register MS is Trying to Diversify a Bit
If The Register MS goes back to being The Register US (or UK), that will be a nice improvement
Gemini Links 14/08/2025: Reading Journal and LLM Fatigue Revisited
Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Wednesday, August 13, 2025
IRC logs for Wednesday, August 13, 2025
Hopping From One Set of Buzzwords to the Next
Rotating hype and vapourware
Currys PCWorld Hates GNU/Linux Even Though It Runs the World
If more and more people choose to remove Windows, then Currys PCWorld will feel the financial impact of its dumb policies
Internet Relay Chat and Gemini Protocol Help Us Relive the Net of the Dial-Up Era
The kids were alright
The Register MS Takes More Money to Boost Slop Hype, This Time From Snyk, a Notorious FUD Source
At some stage or at some point they might even decide to stop doing so
"GPT-5" is Another Microsoft Dead Cat Trying to Bounce
The hype, the momentum (or the inertia) is wearing off
Microsoft Windows Losing Its Grip Near Turkey and Russia
The 'corridor' nations connecting Iran to Europe
Slopwatch: LinuxSecurity, Google News, and Serial Slopper (SS)
The slop, the bad, and the ugly
Links 13/08/2025: The “Incriminating Video” Scam and Corruption in South Korea
Links for the day
Gemini Links 13/08/2025: Movie Memories and Mystery Machine Bus
Links for the day
"AI" Hype or LLM Slop is Not About Efficiency, It's About Lowering Standards
It does not seem like IBM is genuinely committed to the same goals (or commitments) as the original Red Hat
Links 13/08/2025: GitHub Trouble and Openwashing by Microsoft OSI With the Typical Buzzwords
Links for the day
If Free/Libre Software is Adding Trillions in Value to the European Economy, Then the European Commission Must Crush Software Patents
Further to what we wrote yesterday
Microsoft Swallows GitHub Losses
Only Microsoft knows how much money it has already lost on GitHub
Gemini Links 13/08/2025: Climate, Coffee, and Deploying Troops in Washington DC After Pardoning 1,000+ Insurrectionists in Washington DC
Links for the day
The Register MS Lowered MS Focus This Week
We hope The Register recognises its errors and tries to make up for them
Learning Ethics From Jeffrey Epstein's Enabler/Client/Ally, Coca-Cola, and Microsoft Accenture
Whatever merits vocabulary changes initially had are being tainted or obscured by later iterations, which tell us to avoid word like "normal", which apparently offend some people (so they argue)
Personal Attacks From Rust People Serve to Confirm They Have Lost the Argument
"The discussion I find around the net so far has no technical merit and centers around ad hominem"
Physical Meters and Purely Mechanical Meters Aren't Dumb; It's Dumb to Mock or Dismiss Them as Antiquated
I've learned a lot this week, both online and over the telephone
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Tuesday, August 12, 2025
IRC logs for Tuesday, August 12, 2025