The Problem With Software Patents in the United States

Dr. Roy Schestowitz

2012-04-07 14:53:14 UTC
Modified: 2012-04-07 14:53:14 UTC

Important case about patents on life can help reform the system, but there's more...

Surgery

Summary: News analysis and patent lawyers' take in light of some encouraging developments in the fight against algorithmic exclusions

THE past year has brought a lot of press coverage that's hostile towards software patents. Increasingly, people are being informed and are brought into the side of real justice, not what's written on paper because some lawyers (typically politicians) help fellow lawyers.

"You really can receive a software patent for almost anything these days," says this new article from CNET. The context is this: "This time, Facebook is countersuing Yahoo, charging that Yahoo violated 10 of its patents. This move, of course, comes less than a month after Yahoo sued Facebook for allegedly infringing on 10 of its patents.

"Facebook's countersuit shouldn't surprise anybody; it was always going to fight fire with fire, especially since Yahoo started this unnecessary fight. It's the same reason Facebook purchased 750 patents from IBM last month -- it needed more ammunition in a patent arms race that is quickly escalating.

"But I'm shocked by some of the patents over which these two companies are suing each other. One of Yahoo's patents focuses on the "optimum placement of advertisements on a webpage", while Facebook has two patents that cover a "system for controlled distribution of user profiles over a network." Yahoo owns the patent for a "method to determine the validity of an interaction on a network", but "generating a feed of stories personalized for members of a social network" belongs to Facebook."

A lawyer and proponent of software patent seems concerned about the following new development:

Last week the United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit issued a curious decision in Ergo Licensing, LLC v. CareFusion 303, Inc. This decision should send chills down the spine of everyone who has patents in the software space, and needs to be carefully considered by all those who draft patent applications in the software space.

It does seem like, provided more people are made well-informed about software patents, the lawyers who run for office will need to deliver real change and remove software patents. Engineers never approved the emergence of such patents, it was never really for them but for the leeches.

With this good news we return to Easter idleness. More patent news will come soon. ⬆

RMS Was Right 35 Years Ago: Stallman’s viewpoints have remained the same
Fedora is IBM and There's Hardly Any Community Left: It's more like an onboarding mechanism for unpaid labour at (and for) IBM
Gemini Links 29/01/2026: Naps, Letting Go, and Terribly Cold Weather: Links for the day
Links 29/01/2026: Kennedy Center Officials Resigning and Amazon to Cut 16,000 Jobs: Links for the day
Goodbyes to Red Hat and IBM: PIPs let them do the same with less "wasted" on severance or with obscene narrative-shaping
The Need to Understand the Projection Tactics Against RMS: There's an old and common saying (or "wisdom") about who's guilty when there's a fart in elevators (lifts)
Links 29/01/2026: Neocities Is Blocked by Microsoft, “Intellectual Freedom Centers” as the New "Intelligent Design": Links for the day
Microsoft XBox Dying Not Only as a Console, Reveals Microsoft: Microsoft is trying to rebrand or repurpose the brand
Don't be Mistaken, Microsoft Boasts About Money That Does Not Exist and Revenue (Buying From Oneself!) Is Not Income: the company's debt grew
IBM's Financial Performance in IBM's Own Words: Money Down, Debt Up Sharply: IBM isn't a healthy company
In Dominica, GNU/Linux Has Risen to All-Time High in 2026: a lot of America is moving to Free software this year
The "Alicante Mafia" - Part XV - EPO is on Strike Tomorrow, Lots to be Angry About (Except Money): We'll soon finish the series
Gemini Links 29/01/2026: "Lady Audley's Secret" and "The Value Of Our Fear" (Carney's Speech): Links for the day
Emmanuel Macron on Europe's GAFAM Addiction/Dependence: "There is No Such Thing as Happy Vassalage": Microsoft has long worked to prevent commodification
It's Official, Mass Layoffs at IBM Again (2026): In a matter of days we'll just see how much IBM's debt has grown
Over at Tux Machines...: GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Wednesday, January 28, 2026: IRC logs for Wednesday, January 28, 2026
Laos and Microsoft: About 10% Windows, 0% Bing: There are many more nations like it
EPO Technical Meetings Show no Breakthroughs, a Strike Goes Ahead This Friday: Apparently there was another (fourth) meeting today [...] The industrial actions are working already
Google News as the Sole Source of Slop About "Linux", a Feeder of Slopfarms or Serial Sloppers: At least it's no longer hard to 'contain' the slop problem, knowing which domains are the culprits and seeing that Google is their main 'feeder'
IBM to Announce 'Results' Shortly, Expect Lots of Chaff Like "Quantum" and "Hey Hi" (Nothing Material to Show): We're still seeing layoffs and an exodus
Links 28/01/2026: ChatGPT Has Financial Problems, White House Sharing Fakes (or Deepfakes) in Official Accounts/Sites: Links for the day
Gemini Links 28/01/2026: FlatCube NES Port Finished and "Why I Still Write on the Small Web in 2026": Links for the day
Upcoming Techrights Series About the Public Appearances of Richard M. Stallman (RMS) in the United States: we plan to drop all pretences about "Open Source" and instead focus on Software Freedom
Upcoming Techrights Series About the Experiences of EPO Insiders: We'll start the new series some time next week
Links 28/01/2026: Microsoft Ordered to Stop Spying on School Children, Apple's Brand Tarnished by Its Complicity With Human Rights Abusers: Links for the day
Upcoming Techrights Series About the Failure of the Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA) to Stop Hired Guns Who Work for Americans That Abuse Women: The SRA has demonstrated nothing but considerable incompetence at many levels
The "Alicante Mafia" - Part XIV - The EPO Vice-President Steve Rowan and the Hidden Alicante Connection is a Big Deal: We'll soon take a closer look at Ernst
Gemini Links 28/01/2026: Particle and AirMIDI: Links for the day
Amandine Jambert (EDPB/CNIL/FSFE), motive for lying, trust in blockchain and encryption: Reprinted with permission from Daniel Pocock
Over at Tux Machines...: GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Tuesday, January 27, 2026: IRC logs for Tuesday, January 27, 2026
Expect More XBox Layoffs Shortly: As expected
Links 27/01/2026: Japan-China Feud Escalates Again, "Iran's Internet Blackout Persists": Links for the day
Online 'Gathering' Held Today to Organise Industrial Actions in EPO, Strikes Will be Starting Shortly: "Online Extraordinary General Meeting on Action Plan"
It's Not About What You Know, It's About Who You Know (and Stay Quiet About the Cocaine): This is not an organisation that exists to ensure laws are followed
FOSDEM 2026: democracy panel: FSFE uses women as stooges, gerrymander: Reprinted with permission from Daniel Pocock
Must Use Proprietary JavaScript to Submit Feedback to the European Commission About Moving From GAFAM to Free Software: Nevertheless, go tell them why Software Freedom would benefit Europe's defence and economy
Distortion of the Facts About Mass Layoffs at IBM: more layoffs are ahead
Gemini Links 27/01/2026: "Waiting Isn't a Waste", Posting from Lynx, and Bookmarks: Links for the day
Links 27/01/2026: "Oracle Debt and TikTok Transition Troubles Vex the Ellison Media Empire", Richard Stallman Quoted on Copyrights: Links for the day
Steven Field (Red Hat) Speaks of "Recent Layoff" (RA/Wave) in Red Hat: IBM really doesn't like it when people talk about "RAs"
The "Alicante Mafia" - Part XIII - Is EPO Vice-President Steve Rowan in Cahoots With the "Alicante Mafia"?: that deserves much media attention, political intervention, and condemnation
A Week Ago We Contacted the EPO's Stephen (Steve) Rowan About Cocainegate: Tomorrow we'll write some more about Rowan
“Wikilaundering” Explained: "London PR firm rewrites Wikipedia for governments and billionaires"
IBM Reports 'Results' Tomorrow, Expect More "RAs" (Mass Layoffs): they use words like "efficiency", "optimisation", "AI", "pivot", "modernisation" and so on
Earlier This Month Microsoft Lunduke Said in Public It Was Good That Renee Good Was Murdered, Now He Mocks or Demonises People for Saying the US is Unsafe: Don't be easily conned by demagogues
Google News and "Linux" Slop: Why won't Google be interested in tackling this issue? Instead Google has been trying to participate in this issue.
IBM Kills Red Hat in the Darkness: What IBM does to Red Hat is malicious
IBM Red Hat's Goal Is Not Real Security (It Probably Never Was): Spies and trolls are very malicious people and sometimes they're the same thing
With Absurd Lies About Slop, Which Lacks Intelligence or Financial Potential, GAFAM and IBM Will Twist Mass Layoffs as 'Efficiency Drive' or 'AI Pivot': More layoffs are on the way
Animal Advocacy Works: All it takes is effort and determination
EPO Strike This Week: What has happened to Europe?
Over at Tux Machines...: GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Monday, January 26, 2026: IRC logs for Monday, January 26, 2026

The Problem With Software Patents in the United States

Recent Techrights' Posts