Bonum Certa Men Certa

A High US Court (CAFC) Continues Rejecting Software Patents (Even of Microsoft's Patent Trolls)

Microsoft too has trouble in that court, but will Microsoft change its course?

Sharon ProstSummary: Under Chief Judge Sharon Prost (who took over after the corrupt Randall Ray Rader had been pushed out 3 years ago) CAFC has become the opposite of what it used to be, at least when it comes to patents

THE Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit (CAFC) is where software patents were born. Nowadays, in spectacular and sharp contrast, CAFC is where many software patents come to die (for good). Things have certainly not been the same since Alice.



"Things have certainly not been the same since Alice."Firms that profit from software patents are not happy about this. Some are attacking CAFC judges, whereas others are more polite. Fox Rothschild LLP, for example, was promoting software patents a few days ago and it was pressuring CAFC to allow software patents in defiance of the Supreme Court. It's yet another one of those thousands of rants about Alice and decisions which cite Alice. Here is the original, which was cross-posted (probably for a payment) and said: "In the past year, several Federal Circuit decisions defined situations in which software inventions could be eligible for patenting in the United States. However, two recent Federal Circuit decisions show that the path for patent-eligibility is not yet clear, especially for patents that claim methods of processing or presenting data."

"They'll just carry on asking for the contrary stance/more "clarity", as if the Justices got it all wrong and need to be lectured by the patent 'industry'."This has in it the false assumption that some software patents should be allowed. Or that it all boils down to "clarity". So far this year CAFC has rejected software patents almost all the time. Why don't they just get a clue? The Justices were clear enough about abstract patents, but patent extremists refuse to understand (or pretend not to). They'll just carry on asking for the contrary stance/more "clarity", as if the Justices got it all wrong and need to be lectured by the patent 'industry'.

From Fox Rothschild's conclusion: "The Federal Circuit’s case-specific, and sometimes inconsistent, interpretations of Alice leave software patent applicants, patent litigants, and USPTO Examiners with even less definitive guidance as to the patent-eligibility of software inventions than they had a few weeks ago. And with the Supreme Court’s recent decision to deny certiorari in a case that asked “Whether [a] technological breakthrough is not an inventive concept under the second step of Alice merely because the court believed the breakthrough could theoretically be implemented without a computer,” clarification from a higher authority is not likely on the horizon."

"Seeing the sorts of abuse from the patent microcosm is a testament to its misery and agony."There's no need for "clarification"; what's needed is amendment of USPTO guidelines to altogether end software patents -- something which is rumoured to be work in progress.

Seeing the sorts of abuse from the patent microcosm is a testament to its misery and agony. These people refuse to accept reality. One of them portrayed CAFC as a killer with threats, with words like these: "RecogniCorp's Petition for Cert Re Patent Kill under Alice Threatening Validity of Much if not All Computer Tech: https://dlbjbjzgnk95t.cloudfront.net/0980000/980981/2017-11-01%20petition%20for%20writ%20of%20certiorari%20-%20recoginicorp%20v.%20nintendo.pdf …"

"Microsoft's biggest patent troll (IV) is repeatedly finding out that its large arsenal can be trivially invalidated."There is another case involving Intellectual Ventures (IV), which has had many of its patents found to be invalid under Alice. Here is that word "Kill" again, as in: "Fed. Cir. Affirmed a 12(b)6 Alice Kill of an IV Patent: cafc.uscourts.gov/sites/default/… https://t.co/iNyNZR2POL"

Then came another patent maximalist, stating that the "Federal circuit now wants in on the game of invalidating patents without much work, 101 is just such a convenient, tempting tool https://twitter.com/patentbuddy/status/926482154598608901 …"

Well, it's the law. De facto law.

The above invalidation has since then been covered by Law 360. Microsoft's biggest patent troll (IV) is repeatedly finding out that its large arsenal can be trivially invalidated. According to the following, this troll has now amassed over 70,000 patents:

The Federal Circuit affirmed Friday a lower court ruling that found an Intellectual Ventures patent on screening for “errant” computer files was invalid under the U.S. Supreme Court’s Alice ruling, agreeing that the company failed to show that the patent’s claims were not abstract.

Intellectual Ventures, a major patent licensing company that owns more than 70,000 patents, accused Erie Indemnity Co. and other insurers of infringing four patents through their databases and other software.


As can be expected from Patently-O, there's now some more CAFC bashing. Judges rather than laws are being scrutinised. They're being criticised for knocking out software patents (the Two-Way Media case):

The Federal Circuit’s decision in Two-Way Media is in some amount of tension with the court’s 2016 decision in Amdocs v. Openet Telecom. In Amdocs, the court noted that the claims appeared problematic under Section 101 (abstract ideas), but that the architecture – as specifically described in the specification but more generically claimed – showed that the invention was actually a technological improvement.



Attempts to use Alice to throw out patents (also Two-Way Media) were also covered in another post from Patently-O. For background: "Two-Way sued Comcast (and others) for infringement. However, the district court granted the defendant’s motion for judgment on the pleadings – holding that the claims were invalid as ineligible under 35 U.S.C. Section 101 as interpreted by the Supreme Court in Alice and Mayo. In that process, the district court refused to consider evidence of the patents’ novelty and nonobviousness – holding that such evidence would be irrelevant to a Section 101 inquiry. [...] Note here that the court seemingly offered a road-map for the patentee — a technological arts test — noting that the specifications appear to describe a “system architecture as a technological innovation” but “the claim—as opposed to something purportedly described in the specification—is missing an inventive concept.”"

"They've long attempted to change the debate and warp examination using words alone."Haug Partners LLP's Jon Gordon, writing for IAM (the patent trolls' lobby), says that CAFC already clarifies when/where software patents are banned. To quote: "Patents directed to software-implemented inventions commonly describe and claim the invention in terms of the inventive idea and this disclosure suffices to enable persons skilled in the computer arts to practise the idea. [...] principles are indeed emerging and they show the beginnings of the path to patentability for software-implemented inventions."

The term "software-implemented inventions" seems new; it's like a combination of software patents and CII (computer-implemented inventions) and these are mostly syntactic/semantic tricks. They've long attempted to change the debate and warp examination using words alone. But code is still code, no matter what people call it (code is not an "invention" though, it's development like that of a building or sculpting).

"Microsoft along with its trolls carry on leveraging software patents -- typically behind closed doors -- to demand 'protection' money."These people try hard to study ways of fooling examiners and getting patents past judges as well. Patently-O has taken stock of popular CAFC cases and later recalled MasterMine v Microsoft.

MasterMine v Microsoft was mentioned here back in the summer and again last week when the case suddenly resurfaced. CAFC gave some new life to it and Patently-O then said that "the decision here continues the Federal Circuit’s implicit rejection of the Supreme Court’s Nautilus decision."

"What remains noteworthy, all in all, is CAFC's intolerance of software patents. What's also noteworthy is the patent microcosm's intolerance of CAFC."Well, Microsoft ought to fight against software patents, but this case won't be enough to convince it. Microsoft along with its trolls carry on leveraging software patents -- typically behind closed doors -- to demand 'protection' money. Here is what WIPR wrote about this latest twist:

The US Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit has reignited a patent battle between multinational Microsoft and software company MasterMine Software.

Yesterday, October 30, the Federal Circuit affirmed a lower court’s claim construction of two data-mining patents owned by MasterMine, but reversed the court’s determination that they were indefinite and remanded the case.

In 2013, MasterMine sued Microsoft for infringement of two related patents, US patent numbers 7,945,850 and 8,429,518, at the US District Court for the District of Minnesota.


What remains noteworthy, all in all, is CAFC's intolerance of software patents. What's also noteworthy is the patent microcosm's intolerance of CAFC. It's probably worth commending CAFC for what it is doing, reminding the judges that the real industry (i.e. not mere litigators) support its recent judgments. Its older judgments have been repeatedly overturned by the Supreme Court, so perhaps it's learning to adapt to this new reality.

Recent Techrights' Posts

IBM Layoff Rumours, Large-Scale Implementations Weeks Ahead (in March 2025)
There are some people corroborating
Microsoft Blasted for Adding Insult to Injury: Workers Laid Off Without Prior Notice, Without Severance Payment and Basic Coverage (Like Health), Then Stigmatised as Bad Performers So They Cannot Find a Job Elsewhere
Such stereotypes end entire careers
BetaNews is Still Publishing LLM Slop/SPAM About "Linux"
Assuming it is indeed LLM slop, it seems clear BetaNews has no intention of improving or is simply unable/unwilling to improve
 
Like GAFAM, the EPO is Passing the Financial Pains to Staff
the EPO is operating illegally at this point
Morale at Microsoft Ruined by the Company Labelling Thousands of Workers 'Low Performers', Sacking Them on the Spot and Denying Them Basic Benefits
people laid off as "low performers" go to social control media to bemoan the label
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Tuesday, February 11, 2025
IRC logs for Tuesday, February 11, 2025
Links 11/02/2025: Current state of the Internet and Smallnet Information Services (SIS)
Links for the day
Conservative Estimate: Over 10,000 IBM Workers to Be Laid Off in the Next Two Waves
The morale is low and layoffs are expected soon, with mass layoffs likely happening next month and then again later
Links 11/02/2025: Trade Wars and "Crisis for American Universities"
Links for the day
Parasitic LLM Slop Sites Destroy the Ability to Find "Linux" News in Google News
Remember that Google News laid off lots of its workers
Richard Stallman's English Talk in Italy Less Than 24 Hours Away (Torino) and Then Another Talk in Italy Scheduled (University of Bozen-Bolzano)
He's active and he travels a lot in spite of his medical condition
Links 11/02/2025: Nutritional Poverty, Closure of USAID, More Fictional 'Valuations' Around Buzzwords
Links for the day
Perl Programming Leftovers
recently in perl.org
Microsoft in Africa: From 98% to Less Than 10% in Just 16 Years
Microsoft being on less than 1 in 10 Web-connected devices in Africa is a very big deal
Almost as If MElon Reads Techrights
The joke we started appears to be spreading
Gemini Links 11/02/2025: NeoVim and Deploying Other People's Code
Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Monday, February 10, 2025
IRC logs for Monday, February 10, 2025
Scheduled Maintenance Tomorrow and on Valentines
If the site (or Gemini capsule) is offline for a bit, the maintenance windows are likely the root cause
If Matthias Kirschner Loves Free Software, He'll Change the Name of the Microsoft-Sponsored Organisation He Governs (in Order to Avoid Confusion)
The FSF-EEE does not really like Software Freedom, it just loves money (including Microsoft's)
Soylent News Lessens the Scope of Discussion Due to Persistent Trolling and Online Abuse
if they make it a lot harder for new people to participate, then they limit the "general appeal" and reach
EPO's Local Occupational Health, Safety and Ergonomics Committee (LOHSEC) in The Hague: Workers Are Getting Sicker, Conditions in Which to Assess Patent Applications Deteriorate
"According to the Office statistics the total number of days of absence has gone up from 12.4 to 13.1 total number of sick days per Full Time Equivalent (FTE) from 2023 to 2024."
The Standard Needs to Improve Its Standards for Fact-Checking, Aaron Swartz Had Nothing to Do With Reddit and He Detested the Company That Created It
The Web is already bad enough as it is
When the Livestream of Richard Stallman is Apparently Bury-Brigaded Offline You Finally Learn to Avoid Google/YouTube for Streaming
Please, people, stop uploading to Google/YouTube
New Paper From the EPO Highlights Large-Scale Discrimination at the Office, Where People Are Rewarded for Granting More and More Illegal Patents
Even the Kremlin is probably more competent than this
Links 10/02/2025: Ban on D.E.I. Language, Listeria Risk/Outbreak
Links for the day
Links 10/02/2025: Announcing "Stringless" and Mental Health Improvement
Links for the day
Links 10/02/2025: Facebook Mass Layoffs, "Meta" Did What Aaron Swartz Had Done But to the Tune of 81.7 Terabytes
Links for the day
Microsoft Tarnishing the Brand of Arch
Of course Arch can do whatever it wants, but being associated with Microsoft is a badge of shame
The Ultimate and Inevitable Fall of OpenAI (Even Brave is 'Bigger' Now)
"When you advertise at the Super Bowl, you’ve reached just about every consumer in America. It’s the last stop. If you’re not profitable yet, you never will be."
Adding Slop to Your Blog Only Makes One Assume All the Text is LLM Slop
Simon Coter from Oracle has turned to slop
Macao is Leaving Microsoft Behind
Windows is falling to new all-time lows
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Sunday, February 09, 2025
IRC logs for Sunday, February 09, 2025
Microsoft's WSL (LSW) Shows That It Can Never Love Linux, Only Windows
that's just how Microsoft rolls
Activism in Times of War and a Coup
'Linux' Foundation works for fascism
What the Silencing of Neatnik Tells Us About Linus Torvalds Inside a Microsoft-Dominated 'Linux' Foundation
Is Linus Torvalds free to express his mind as he wishes about every topic, even just any technical topic?
Windows Down to 11.35% in Senegal, as Measured by statCounter
Another all-time low (Windows was at 99% in 2009)
"Latest Technology News" in BetaNews is LLM Slop Promoting OOXML and Proprietary Software at the Expense of LibreOffice and OpenDocument Format (ODF)
Remember that "open-source" and Open Source aren't the same; the former is fake