Bonum Certa Men Certa

A Sham and a Scam: How Patent Extremists Continue to Promote a Mohawks and Allergan Ploy Against PTAB, Even After Oil States

Totem



Summary: Watchtroll carries on promoting the 'case' of Allergan, which is grossly misusing tribal immunity to protect dodgy patents that it uses to deny access to medicine

THE patent extremists have become truly unpleasant. They not only ousted the Director of the USPTO (Michelle Lee, who was pretty good) but they are also SLAPPing me in an effort to silence me. They are legal bullies for a living (threatening companies and suing companies), so why stop short? Why not threaten officials, publishers and bloggers too?

St. Regis Mohawk Tribe, along with Allergan, came up with what many people online have dubbed a "scam"; for daring to point this out the perpetrators send me threats by E-mail and also threats to my door (using special couriers). This, as far as I can tell, has not been condemned by anyone inside the patent microcosm, only people outside it. SLAPP is apparently fine with these thugs.

"St. Regis Mohawk Tribe, along with Allergan, came up with what many people online have dubbed a "scam"; for daring to point this out the perpetrators send me threats by E-mail and also threats to my door (using special couriers)."24 hours ago Patent Docs, which had promoted this "scam" many times before, advertised this event of Kirkland & Ellis LLP. The Intellectual Property Law Association of Chicago (IPLAC) will have one of those stacked 'panels' on the patent "scam" which is misusing tribes to avoid being held to justice.

Watchtroll has also just promoted -- yet again -- this patent "scam" of Mohawks and Allergan, basically seeking to dodge the law so as to avoid PTAB. Here is how Watchtroll put it:

On April 18th, counsel representing the St. Regis Mohawk Tribe and the multinational pharmaceutical firm Allergan filed an appeal brief at the Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit. The appellants are appealing from a series of inter partes review (IPR) proceedings at the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) where the Board made the controversial decision to deny motions to dismiss the IPRs on a sovereign immunity defense raised by the St. Regis tribe. On appeal, St. Regis and Allergan asks the Federal Circuit to determine whether the PTAB erred either in holding that tribal immunity does not apply to IPR proceedings and in deciding that Allergan was the “effective patent owner,” enabling the IPRs to proceed in the St. Regis tribe’s absence even if tribal immunity applied.

[...]

Even if the PTAB were to correctly identify Allergan as an “effective owner” of the patents, appellants argue that the Board still should have dismissed the IPRs on the sovereign immunity defense as the tribe is an indispensable party to the proceedings. By refusing to do so, the PTAB acted against precedent set by the Supreme Court in 2008’s Republic of the Philippines v. Pimentel, where the Court found that the case may not proceed “when a required-entity sovereign is not amenable to a suit.” The PTAB further failed to follow the reasoning stemming from the Federal Circuit’s 2010 decision in A123 Systems v. Hydro-Quebec, where the Federal Circuit found that proceeding without a sovereign posed a significant risk of prejudice as the sovereign could have lost rights without the opportunity to defend its interests.


The following day Watchtroll carried on supporting the patent "scammer" (Allergan) whose goal is to avoid scrutiny of its patents so that it can deny access to medicine. Arie Michelsohn totally dismisses ethical grounds and overlooks the "scammy" elements. As if it's for the "greater good" of patent extremists. Allergan’s side/argument was boosted as follows:

A case in point can be found in Allergan’s “second wave” of Restasis patents, which were obtained by the drug company late in the term of the original Restasis patents that expired in 2014—and which sought to effectively extend this term by nearly a decade. These second-wave patents include U.S Patent No. 8,629,111 (“the ‘111 patent”), which was asserted along with several others against three generic drug companies in the Eastern District of Texas, and which Judge Bryson of the Federal Circuit, sitting by designation, found invalid last October.


Notice the difference between the Eastern District of Texas and CAFC.

"If Allergan is so confident that its patents are worth the paper they've been given by the patent office, then it won't see need in spending about 10 million dollars for some US-based tribe to participate in a "scam" (arranged through dodgy shells)."There's a reason why limits on patent scope are necessary. The most important question is, where or why should we put limits on patents? There must be limits, based on economic/scientific evidence. Otherwise patents won't be worth the paper they're printed on. Writing about Eli Lilly v Actavis a few days ago, IP Kat published this post regarding "the Scope of Patent Protection" in Singapore.

If Allergan is so confident that its patents are worth the paper they've been given by the patent office, then it won't see need in spending about 10 million dollars for some US-based tribe to participate in a "scam" (arranged through dodgy shells).

Recent Techrights' Posts

FSF Has Made It Halfway to Its Target (Funding Goal) a Week Before Christmas Day
$400,000 definitely seems reachable now, especially if they extend the "deadline"
Saving What's Left of Decent and Independent Journalism on the Web
We increasingly (over time) try to make local copies (hosted on our server) of important documents; it's hard to rely on third parties
 
Links 19/12/2024: Magnitude 7.3 Earthquake and Privacy Camp
Links for the day
Gemini Links 19/12/2024: Port Of Miami Explosion, TurboQOA, Gnus
Links for the day
Fake Articles About 'Linux'
Dated yesterday
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Wednesday, December 18, 2024
IRC logs for Wednesday, December 18, 2024
[Meme] The Master Churnalist
Speaking of press releases being passed off as "journalism"
Spamnil's TFiR: Still Pretending Press Releases Are 'Articles' (TFiR 'Originals' as Plagiarism or Fluff)
Same as last year
Links 18/12/2024: Zakir Hussain Dies, TuneIn Layoffs
Links for the day
Links 18/12/2024: Karate Love and Advent of Code
Links for the day
Windows (or Microsoft) Has Become the "One Percent" (Market Share) in Chad
How long before it falls below 1%?
Arvind Krishna, IBM's CEO, Will Eventually Suck Up to Donald Trump Like His Predecessor Did or the Watson Family Did With Adolf Hitler
Literally Hitler
Being a Geek Need Not Mean Being Sedentary
"In the past 18 months," Berkholz writes, "I’ve lost 75 pounds and gone from completely sedentary to fit, while minimizing the effort to do so (but needing a whole lot of persistence and grit)."
GAFAM Kissing the Ring of the Mafia Don
"resistance" to dictatorship and defenders of democracy?
Slop Spaghetti From the Chef, Second Time Today
Fresh slop ready out the oven!
IBM - Like Microsoft - Lies About the Number of People It's Laying Off (Several Tens of Thousands, Not Counting R.T.O. "Silent" Layoffs and Contractors/Perma-Temps)
How many waves of silent layoffs have we seen so far at IBM this year?
Links 18/12/2024: EU Launches Probe Into TikTok (At Last!)
Links for the day
Links 18/12/2024: Doha/Qatar Trafficking, Bloat Comfort Zone, and Advent of Code 2024
Links for the day
[Meme] Microsoft's Latest Marketing Pitch
"Stop Being Poor; buy a new PC with TPMs"
In South Africa, a Very Large Nation, Web Developers Can Already Ignore Microsoft Browsers (Edge Measured Below 3% in 55 Nations)
The dumb assumption you must naively test with Microsoft browsers is no longer applicable in a lot of places
Open Source Initiative (OSI) is the Voice of Bill Gates and Satya Nadella
Not hard to see what they've done with the money
Microsoft Boasts That Its (Microsoft-Sponsored) "Open Source AI" Propaganda Got Cited in Media (That's Just What the Money Did)
This is a grotesque openwashing campaign
In Many Places Around the World, Perhaps as Expected, Yandex is Nearly Bigger Than Microsoft (Like in Several African Countries)
Microsoft may soon fall to "third place" in search
Keeping Productive This Christmas
We've (pre)paid for hosting till almost January 2026 and fully back on the saddle
IBM and Canonical Leave Money on the Table Because Microsoft Pays Them Not to Compete and Instead Market Windows, WSL, Microsoft 'Clown Computing', and TPMs
Where are the regulators?
Other Editors Who Agree "Hey Hi" (AI) is Just Hype But Won't Say So Publicly as It Might Upset Key Sponsors
Some media would gladly participate in a scam to make money
Brian Fagioli's Latest "Linux" Article Appears to be Fake
Another form of plagiarism/ripoff using bots?
IBM (and Red Hat) is a Patent Troll, Still Leveraging Software Patents to Extract Money Out of Other Companies by Suing Them
Basically, when it comes to patents, IBM is demonstrably part of the problem, not the solution
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Tuesday, December 17, 2024
IRC logs for Tuesday, December 17, 2024
[Meme] When the People Who Falsely Accuse You of Pedophilia Turn Out to be Projecting
When you attack something or someone using falsehoods, as happens a lot to Richard Stallman (RMS), there's risk that the attacks will backfire, badly
In Some Countries, Such as Greece, Almost 80% of Windows Users Are on Vista 10 and About 85% Need to Move to GNU/Linux for Security Patches
Vista 11 was a failure
[Meme] They Don't Want the Public to Know What "Responsible Encryption" Really Means
They also blame "China" for their own back doors (because China learned how to exploit those)
The Linux Foundation's Certificate Authority (CA) Significantly and Suspiciously Raises the Number of Certificates It Issues (Quantity Increase/Inflation) by Lessening Their Lifetime in the Name of 'Security' (That Barely Makes Sense!)
LE made 3 months the "standard" for most, soon to become just 6 days instead of 6 months?
Why I Continue to Believe That at the End Software Freedom Will Win
a short and incomplete list of factors which I believe contribute to the sentiment that we can - and will - win the battles over hearts and minds in the "Tech" realm
Links 17/12/2024: More China Sanctions, GOP Scheming to Prop Up Fentanylware (TikTok)
Links for the day
Gemini Links 17/12/2024: The Streisand Effect and Productivity-systems Desiderata
Links for the day
Technology: rights or responsibilities? - Part X
By Dr. Andy Farnell
Links 17/12/2024: More "Tesla Autopilot" and "Hey Hi" (AI) Blunders
Links for the day
Instead of Promoting GNU/Linux (or Ubuntu) Ahead of Vista 10's EoL Canonical is Marketing Microsoft's Proprietary Software
It's like Canonical employs people who work for Microsoft, not for Canonical
Links 17/12/2024: Many Abuses by Microsoft and War Updates From Ukraine
Links for the day
Content Management Systems (CMS) Bloat/ Static Site Generators (SSG) Trouble
some Web site management stories
DEI Room at fedoraproject.org Pretty Much Dead
We're not against diversity but against its weaponisation by greedy people who do not value diversity at all
The "Latest Technology News" at BetaNews is Slop About Slop
This is at the very top of the "news" (front page) at the moment
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Monday, December 16, 2024
IRC logs for Monday, December 16, 2024