Blogging Pioneer Dave Winer: Pleading for Richard Stallman

Guest Editorial Team

2021-05-18 23:51:31 UTC
Modified: 2021-05-18 23:51:31 UTC

Reprinted from the original

I feel so sad about what's happening to Stallman.#
He's 68. I know what that's like, I'm 65. #
He has fixed his whole existence on a single idea that software should be free. Not free of charge, but free to use and to adapt. It's not that far from the kind of openness I believe in, that I believe is an ethical responsiblity for developers. #
It's useful to have a person like Stallman around, consistently marking an extreme view. It's like knowing there's a North Star, you may not be going to it, exactly, but knowing where it is makes it possible to go other places. And some people agree with Stallman in total, and to them he's their leader.#
Now, if you step back and look at what's being said about him, basically people don't like things he says or the questions he asks. I read these things completely factoring out the non-factual stuff, where they tell you what his questions mean in some pure sense, when what they're really saying is what these questions mean to them. To a reasonable person imho they're just questions. Some people don't argue with questions, they just ask them. For the people who attack him, it's the opposite, their questions are accusations. #
I think Stallman is actually a naive innocent, almost child-like harmless person. That's based on years of observing him, being connected through communities. Maybe he did terrible things I don't know about. But maybe you have too. Is this how we're going to coexist? All of us worrying about who's going to make a credible case for destroying each others' lives? This isn't about Stallman, it's about your sense of justice and how far it extends, and how unfair that is for the rest of us who fear being judged by you. #
PS: A quote from a 1994 blog post: "I try not to get offended on principle." I was quoting someone else, but I've remembered that. Just because I should be offended, doesn't mean, if I'm not actually offended, that I have to pretend I was. #
PPS: If you still think Stallman should be destroyed, go see Lives of Others, a wonderful film about intellectuals in East Germany during the Cold War. #

Recent Techrights' Posts

The Corrupt Lecture the Non-Corrupt - Part II - It's About Politics, Not Science: Tomorrow we'll discuss what the cocaine proponents (or apologists) deem to be "ethics"
SLAPP Censorship - Part 52 Out of 200: Phil Golding Appointed Bar Standards Board (BSB) Chief, Misogyny Must End: How many rules will they "bend" or even breach?
Links 20/04/2026: Chatbots Motivate Manslaughter, GAFAM’s ‘Tobacco Moment’: Links for the day
Throwing Rocks in Houses of Glass: Lots of "virtue-signalling" against ICE
Links 20/04/2026: Brave Origin Nightly, Scuttling USAID Gives 'Soft Power' to China, and White House Gives Money to Russia (Through Oil Sales): Links for the day
EPO Cocainegate Escalates - Part II - "Cocaine Communication Manager" Luis Berenguer is Back Without Punishment: Latest on Luis Berenguer
Gemini Links 20/04/2026: "I Hate Computers" and "Why I de-Googled": Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...: GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Sunday, April 19, 2026: IRC logs for Sunday, April 19, 2026
If You're Against War, Why Would You Pay IBM Red Hat?: Red Hat's largest clients aren't geeks; they're militaries
Uplifting Mood in Manchester: Looking behind - and ahead - after a day of relaxation
SLAPP Censorship - Part 51 Out of 200: On Perjury and What It Means to Take Third-Party Funding to Attack Reporter and His Family (in Another Continent): threats of prison sent to my wife
The Corrupt Lecture the Non-Corrupt - Part I - EPO Management Talks About "Ethics" While Cocaine Users Run the Office: Let's start with the basics
EPO Cocainegate Escalates - Part I - Cocaine Abuse in Family of Campinos (President’s Office): at the EPO's management you can do illegal drugs and still represent Europe's second-largest institution
Gemini Links 19/04/2026: Big Brother and the Telescreen, Syncing Gemini Capsule With a Makefile: Links for the day
Links 19/04/2026: Introducing “Fighting Fascism” Podcast and Kyiv Mass Shooting: Links for the day
Links 19/04/2026: Mass Layoffs at GAFAM Again (10% Laid Off), Azure Capacity Problems (Enshittification): Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...: GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Saturday, April 18, 2026: IRC logs for Saturday, April 18, 2026
GAFAM Decided to Stop 'Old' Formats From Working, Format-Shifting Treadmills Resemble the Certificate Cartel Keeping Everybody Forever Chasing Rotations: Lots of extra chores because those who control the browsers decided that "too much choice" is bad, so they'll break "old" sites and make multimedia that's "old" not work anymore (not playable)
Nothing But Vapourware Since XBox Leadership Ousted and Mass Layoffs Will Come Soon: We just don't know the exact date/s... yet
Gemini Links 18/04/2026: Guix and WikiReader: Links for the day
Network Maintenance Next Friday: We must be doing a terrific job so far given how much money gets spent trying to silence us
"The Work-to-rule is Having Effect" at the European Patent Office (EPO): The media knows how to contact SUEPO, but it's clearly not doing it
Improving the Sites, Not Bloating Them: Sites need to evolve over time. Many conflate evolution with bloat (as if more complexity is desirable).
SLAPP Censorship - Part 50 Out of 200: The Time Staff of Law Firm Burgess Mee Was Showing Up in Letters Sent for a Serial Strangler From Microsoft: Family-friendly? No.
Next Week the Star of the "EPO Reality TV Show" Will Likely be Absent (Absconding the Tough Reality of Widespread Unrest): He tarnishes the legacy of that surname and the country's image by spouting out lies and hurling abusive insults (lots of the "f word") at staff
What EPO Staff, the Staff Union of the European Patent Office (SUEPO), and Europe Want and Need: Who should be served by patents?
Speculations That IBM's CEO is on His Way Out: IBM has mass layoffs, but the media is not covering this [...] IBM is a company in the loo, a firm in a state of rapid disintegration
Slopwatch Was Deprecated, It's Not Coming Back: LLMs that produce many words very fast (and waste a lot of energy in the process) cannot compete with authentic news sites
WELCOME to The Cyber|Show @ Geminispace!: Andy set things up this past week
Links 18/04/2026: Microsoft's PR Department (Waggener Edstrom) and CEO's Wife Buys NPR (BillPR, Now BallmerPR) as Independent/Public Service Media Dims Down: Links for the day
Gemini Links 18/04/2026: Chronic Pain and CodingFont Game: Links for the day
Links 17/04/2026: "I Hate the Internet" and Fake Wallet in Apple App Store: Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...: GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Friday, April 17, 2026: IRC logs for Friday, April 17, 2026