Bonum Certa Men Certa

The EPO’s Overseer/Overseen Collusion — Part XVII: The Non-Monolithic Nordic Bloc

Series parts:

  1. The EPO's Overseer/Overseen Collusion — Part I: Let the Sunshine In!
  2. The EPO’s Overseer/Overseen Collusion — Part II: A “Unanimous” Endorsement?
  3. The EPO’s Overseer/Overseen Collusion — Part III: Three Missing Votes
  4. The EPO’s Overseer/Overseen Collusion — Part IV: The Founding States
  5. The EPO’s Overseer/Overseen Collusion — Part V: Germany Says “Ja”
  6. The EPO’s Overseer/Overseen Collusion — Part VI: A Distinct Lack of Dutch Courage
  7. The EPO’s Overseer/Overseen Collusion — Part VII: Luxembourgish Laxity
  8. The EPO’s Overseer/Overseen Collusion — Part VIII: Perfidious Albion and Pusillanimous Hibernia
  9. The EPO’s Overseer/Overseen Collusion — Part IX: More Holes Than Swiss Cheese
  10. The EPO’s Overseer/Overseen Collusion — Part X: Introducing the Controversial Christian Bock
  11. The EPO’s Overseer/Overseen Collusion — Part XI: “General Bock” - Battistelli's Swiss Apprentice?
  12. The EPO’s Overseer/Overseen Collusion — Part XII: The French Connection
  13. The EPO’s Overseer/Overseen Collusion — Part XIII: Battistelli's Iberian Facilitators - Spain
  14. The EPO’s Overseer/Overseen Collusion — Part XIV: Battistelli's Iberian Facilitators - Portugal
  15. The EPO’s Overseer/Overseen Collusion — Part XV: Et Tu Felix Austria…
  16. The EPO’s Overseer/Overseen Collusion — Part XVI: The Demise of the Austrian Double-Dipper
  17. YOU ARE HERE ☞ The Non-Monolithic Nordic Bloc


Jesper Kongstad and his deputy Anne Rejnhold Jørgensen
The Danish representatives: Jesper Kongstad and his deputy Anne Rejnhold Jørgensen



Summary: We start our investigation of how countries in northern Europe ended up voting on the unlawful "Strike Regulations" at the EPO and why

In this part we turn our attention to the delegations representing the EPO's Nordic states and look at the positions that they took on Benoît Battistelli's "Strike Regulations" in June 2013.



To begin with, it's worth noting that three of these states - namely, Denmark, Norway, Iceland - have established a regional body called the Nordic Patent Institute (NPI) for the purpose of promoting collaboration in patent-related matters, in particular in the area of the Patent Cooperation Treaty (PCT) administered by WIPO in Geneva.

The establishment of such a regional institute was first mooted at a meeting of the Nordic Council of Ministers in September 2003. This led to the publication of a "Feasibility Study on the Establishment of a Joint Nordic PCT Authority" in September 2004 which proposed various models for co-operation.

"Such fundamental divergences of opinion among the Nordic delegations commonly occur in relation to EPO affairs. Each delegation tends to follow its own line and they rarely, if ever, achieve an overarching consensus or act as a monolithic bloc."However, when discussions started, no consensus could be achieved on the question of which model should prevail. This led to Finland and Sweden backing out of the discussions and, to this day, they remain outside the NPI.

Such fundamental divergences of opinion among the Nordic delegations commonly occur in relation to EPO affairs. Each delegation tends to follow its own line and they rarely, if ever, achieve an overarching consensus or act as a monolithic bloc.

Back in June 2013, the Administrative Council was chaired by the head of the Danish delegation: Jesper Kongstad, a figure who needs no introduction to readers of Techrights.

"...it is rumoured among EPO insiders that Battistelli literally had Kongstad "in his back pocket". According to these rumours, Battistelli arranged for "his" Council Chairman to be paid the equivalent of a Principal Director's salary from EPO funds."Kongstad had previously acted as the Deputy Chairman of the Council following Battistelli's election as Chairman in March 2009.

In the summer of 2009, both Battistelli and Kongstad - the Chairman and Deputy Chairman of the Council - announced that they were standing as candidates in the race to elect a successor to Alison Brimelow, the departing President of the Office.

After a couple of inconclusive rounds of voting, the two rivals eventually agreed to a "pact" which saw Battistelli being elected as President of the Office and Kongstad assuming the position of Council Chairman.

In his subsequent role as Council Chairman Kongstad always acted in very close concert with the Office President Battistelli.

"Although no official investigation has ever been carried out into this suspected act of corruption, the rumours come from credible inside sources and have a high degree of plausibility."Indeed, it is rumoured among EPO insiders that Battistelli literally had Kongstad "in his back pocket". According to these rumours, Battistelli arranged for "his" Council Chairman to be paid the equivalent of a Principal Director's salary from EPO funds.

Although no official investigation has ever been carried out into this suspected act of corruption, the rumours come from credible inside sources and have a high degree of plausibility.

If true, these rumours would certainly explain a lot about Kongstad's behaviour as Council Chairman during the "Battistelli era" and why he was prepared to endorse so many manifestly flawed and controversial measures submitted to the Council by Battistelli.

Battistelli and Kongstad
It is rumoured among EPO insiders that Battistelli literally had Kongstad "in his back pocket" and had arranged for "his" Council Chairman to be paid the equivalent of a Principal Director's salary from EPO funds.



In any event, Kongstad gave his unqualified endorsement to the "Strike Regulations" submitted to the Council by Battistelli for adoption in June 2013.

"...Kongstad gave his unqualified endorsement to the "Strike Regulations" submitted to the Council by Battistelli for adoption in June 2013."However, Battistelli's Great Dane only had a partial success in persuading his Nordic peers to support the proposed full frontal assault on the fundamental rights of EPO staff.

More precisely, the pro-Battistelli position taken by the Danish delegation was followed by Iceland and Finland but opposed by Sweden and Norway.

Borghildur Erlingsdóttir and her deputy Elfa Íshólm Ólafsdóttir
The Icelandic representatives: Borghildur Erlingsdóttir and her deputy Elfa Íshólm Ólafsdóttir



At the time in question, the Icelandic delegation was headed by Borghildur Erlingsdóttir who was assisted by her deputy Elfa Íshólm Ólafsdóttir, the Head of the Icelandic Patent Office's Finance and Operation Division.

"In the case of the "Strike Regulations" of June 2013, Icelandic support for this contentious proposal may have been influenced by another factor."Historically, the Nordic microstate of Iceland used to be a dependency of Denmark until it became independent in 1944. In relation to EPO affairs, the Icelandic delegation generally tends to follow the position taken by its Danish hegemon.

In the case of the "Strike Regulations" of June 2013, Icelandic support for this contentious proposal may have been influenced by another factor.

By a curious coincidence, a mere fortnight before the 136th Council meeting took place in Munich, the great and good of the "European Patent Network" convened in Reykjavík to discuss "how to bring co-operation forward in order to improve the quality and efficiency of the European patent system, and thus better serve industry".

"It's not clear who exactly footed the bill for this extravaganza but it's quite probable that the bulk of the funding came out of the EPO's coffers."This "co-operation meeting" which was hosted by the Icelandic Patent Office was attended by representatives of the EPO and its member states as well as representatives of the EUIPO/OHIM in its observer capacity.

It's not clear who exactly footed the bill for this extravaganza but it's quite probable that the bulk of the funding came out of the EPO's coffers.

Needless to say Battistelli was in attendance and he took advantage of the occasion to pose for a photo-op with the Icelandic Minister of Industry and Commerce, Ragnheiður Árnadóttir, and the Director General of the Icelandic Patent Office, Borghildur Erlingsdóttir.

Lutz and Battistelli in Iceland
Lutz and Battistelli with Minister of Industry and Commerce Ragnheiður Árnadóttir (2nd from right) and head of the Icelandic Patent Office Borghildur Erlingsdóttir (right) in Reykjavík (12 June 2013).



Given the attention which Battistelli lavished on the Icelanders in advance of the Council's 136th Meeting, it's hardly surprising that he succeeded in capturing their vote for all of the "reforms" which he put on the agenda at that meeting, including the "Strike Regulations".

"Given the attention which Battistelli lavished on the Icelanders in advance of the Council's 136th Meeting, it's hardly surprising that he succeeded in capturing their vote for all of the "reforms" which he put on the agenda at that meeting, including the "Strike Regulations"."All things considered, the voting record of the Icelandic delegation on the EPO's Administrative Council during the Battistelli era at the EPO gives the impression that it was well and truly "captured".

In March 2015, the Icelandic press reported excitedly that the head of the delegation - Borghildur Erlingsdóttir - had been appointed to the Board of the Administrative Council, the exclusive "inner circle" which prepares the agenda for the Council's quarterly meetings.

"All things considered, the voting record of the Icelandic delegation on the EPO's Administrative Council during the Battistelli era at the EPO gives the impression that it was well and truly "captured". "A couple of years later at the 159th meeting (warning: epo.org link) of the Council in March 2019, she advanced to the position of deputy Chair of the Council.

Borghildur's advancement among the ranks of the Administrative Council delegates may have been a coincidence but many EPO insiders believe that it was intended as recognition of her earlier support for "le système Battistelli".

"Borghildur's advancement among the ranks of the Administrative Council delegates may have been a coincidence but many EPO insiders believe that it was intended as recognition of her earlier support for "le système Battistelli"."In her spare time, Borghildur who comes from Seltjarnarnes near Reykjavík has enjoyed something of a career as a sportswoman. She is well known in Iceland as a keen practitioner of powerlifting at the Grótta sports club in Seltjarnarnes.

According to Icelandic reports, she was the national champion in the 57 kg category and has also held the Icelandic record in the knee-bend in that weight category.€ 

Unfortunately, like most of her peers on the EPO's Administrative Council, Borghildur seems to have been a bit too eager to bend the knee before the tyrant Battistelli.

Powerlifiting-Borghildur-Erlingsdottir
The former Icelandic powerlifiting champion Borghildur Erlingsdóttir seems to have been a bit too eager to bend the knee before EPO tyrant Battistelli.



Her current performance as deputy Chair of the Administrative Council - in particular her continued eagerness to bend the knee before Battistelli's successor António Campinos - is unlikely to win her any awards, at least not among EPO staff.

Borghildur-Trophies
Borghildur's performance as deputy Chair of the Administrative Council - in particular her continued eagerness to bend the knee before Battistelli's successor Campinos - is unlikely to win her any awards among EPO staff.



Getting back now to the events of June 2013, the official record shows that even if the Icelanders were prepared to follow the lead of their Danish hegemon, other Nordic states were less positive about the merits of Battistelli's proposals.

As we will see in more detail later on, both Sweden and Norway withheld their support.

As a matter of fact, the Norwegian delegation was one of the few delegations that bothered to perform due diligence by referring the matter to the national Ministry for Labour.

"In the end, the well-founded scepticism of Sweden and Norway was not sufficient to dissuade the remaining Nordic state - Finland - from following the Danish lead."The Norwegian Ministry of Labour [PDF] responded by issuing a negative opinion on the compatibility of the proposed "Strike Regulations" with generally recognised principles of international law which are enshrined in conventions of the International Labour Organisation. This was enough to deter the Norwegian delegation from voting in favour. The Swedish delegation followed suit.

In the end, the well-founded scepticism of Sweden and Norway was not sufficient to dissuade the remaining Nordic state - Finland - from following the Danish lead.

In the next part, we will take a closer look at the Finnish delegation and consider what might have induced it to give its agreement to the adoption of such a patently unlawful proposal.

Recent Techrights' Posts

Links 31/12/2024: Another Jeju Air Plane Has Severe Landing Gear Issue (Cannot Blame Birds Anymore), Turku Quits Twitter/X
Links for the day
2025 Coming. "Lawsuits are temporary. Glory is forever. Go public."
another promising year for us
Free Software Foundation (FSF) Raises about $50,000 After Saying We Should Put Pressure on Microsoft, Might Exceed $300,000 in Total Before 2025 (Boston Time)
FSF fund-raiser now at 292k US dollars. Spectacular growth, rising at a pace of about $20k per day!
Brittany Day Unleashes Microsoft Propaganda About Linux, Likely Generated by Microsoft LLM to Strategically Googlebomb a Topic
Yes, it's definitely LLM slop
Gemini Links 31/12/2024: Default Apps 2024 and Google News RSS Woes
Links for the day
Links 31/12/2024: 'Open'AI Has Run Out of Money Again, Venezuela Fines TikTok, Germany Warns X/Twitter Over Election Interference, Google Search Takedowns Out of Control
Links for the day
Gemini Links 31/12/2024: Google's Evil and VF-1 1.0.0 is Out
Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Monday, December 30, 2024
IRC logs for Monday, December 30, 2024
Links 30/12/2024: Arrest Warrant for South Korean President Yoon, Experts Contest 'Bird Strike' Narrative for Crash Blame
Links for the day
[Meme] Systemd-Max
Why is everything - even aviation - getting so much worse?
Links 30/12/2024: Bad Year, Sxmo/PostmarketOs, and Gemlog/Tinylog
Links for the day
Just a hobby, it won't be big and professional like GNU. It'll be controlled by Microsoft due to administrative neglect.
Get well soon, Linux
Free Software Foundation (FSF) Raised About 20,000 Dollars Today
FSF funds now near 275k dollars. Growing VERY fast today.
Massive Gains for GNU/Linux in Australia This Year
Windows lost clout and Android was the biggest gainer
New IRS Filing Shows That the Most Dominant Company in the Linux Foundation is Microsoft
The 'Linux' Foundation devotes only about 2% of its budget to Linux (skeleton crew). It invests a lot more money in the Ponzi scheme of Microsoft and Scam Altman.
[Meme] Who's the Linux Boss?
Bill Gates is a lot more interesting anyway
In 2024, Under Linux Foundation Management, Linux.com Produced and Published Only 5 Articles
Remember when Linux.com had 3-4 original articles per day?
Trying to Informally Police or at Least Report LLM Slop About "Linux" (and Several Related Topics)
Do they deserve public humiliation/condemnation? Yes, as that might be the only way to nip this in the bud
Links 30/12/2024: Fentanylware (TikTok) Concerns and Aftermath of Cut Cables
Links for the day
A Free Software Foundation (FSF) Led by Dr. Richard Stallman Can Still Raise a Lot of Money
Give people more time (e.g. until end of January) and maybe hit the target
Is Microsoft's Plundering of Africa Coming to an End?
Microsoft had many layoffs in Africa this year
Microsoft Windows Down From 23% to 20% This Year in Asia (Android Up From 54% to Almost 60%)
Less and less of Windows, more of the Linux-powered Android
15 Years Ago Mozilla Firefox Had Over 50% of the Slovakian Market, Now Google's Chrome Has Over 70%
Peaked at 72.4% earlier this year
Remembering When Photography Meant Realistic Captures of Reality, Not "Hey Hi" (AI) and 'Instagrammed' (Filtered, Manipulated)
Fake pictures predate the "hey hi" hype; Instagram in particular was full of these
Good Gains for Android for GNU/Linux in New Zealand This Year
Notice that GNU/Linux rose to its highest point (this month)
2024 a Record Year for Android (Almost 50% "Market Share"), Which is Now Bigger in Europe Than Microsoft Windows
a look at Europe
Apple's Main Stronghold (North America) at Risk From GNU/Linux
Apple had several rounds of layoffs in the US this year
Wishing for a Wikileaks Renaissance in 2025
as a site that facilitates whistleblowers, hosting large leaks
statCounter: Microsoft Windows Down a Percent This Year in South America, GNU/Linux Up to 3.2%
Microsoft down, freedom up
[Meme] Getting Banned From Social Control Media 2 Days or Two Weeks Before Leaving Office
Seems like interference using dinners with an insurrectionist
The Threat of Googlebombing and LLMs
There are many Carters, but search engines and LLMs lack the "logic" (or common sense) to tell the difference
Social Control Media (Not Just TikTok) is a "Modern Challenge" to Democracy
Society is worse off with Social Control Networks
Jimmy Carter on Globalisation of "Tech"
Carter's legacy in the area of science (and technology)
IBM's Bad Leadership is a Threat to GNU/Linux
We worry that since Red Hat controls so much of the GNU/Linux stack difficulties at IBM will result in divestment
The True Importance of Diversification
Monopoly or monoculture breed fragility
Putting Some Eggs in the Geminispace Basket
Do not bet on the future of the Web
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Sunday, December 29, 2024
IRC logs for Sunday, December 29, 2024
Gemini Links 30/12/2024: Countdown to New Year, Tinylogging, and LLM Hype
Links for the day
Incredible! Beta'News' Now Runs Ads as 'Articles' About 'Hey Hi' (AI), Written by LLMs
Does it get any more rogue than this?
This New Talk Helps Explain Why Crimes at the European Patent Office (EPO) and Patent Policy Deficits Remain Unaddressed by the European Commission
Corporations write and enforce the law
Our Most Relaxing Christmas Ever?
this Christmas was our most calm every (in recent memory at least)
Bad Year for Microsoft in India (and Another All-Time Low, Windows at 12% "Market Share")
Microsoft is the next Intel
Keeping Online Even During Wars
the Internet is still quite robust
Enshittification is Everywhere
Computer Science has been reduced to just "computer" (spyphone)
Fascistic Regimes and Their Justices Will Leverage Social Control Networks to Their Advantage (Power Grab), They Won't Protect Constituents From Them
"controlling the voices and all the narratives, including the press because they too buy into the lies that it is a communications medium"
Move to GNU/Linux and Save the Planet, CCC Talk Explains
video of the talk
New Year's Resolution for Techrights: No More Very Short Posts
If we publish memes, as above, then we'll try to at least contextualise them somewhat
The Free Software Foundation (FSF) Tells Us All to "Keep Putting Pressure on Microsoft"
"Grassroots organization against a corporation as large as Microsoft is never easy"
Links 29/12/2024: Phytium Sells Chinese CPUs and Landing Gear Malfunction Crashes Plane in Korea
Links for the day
Links 29/12/2024: Facebook Wants More Bots and Slop, Whistleblowers and Bloggers Under Attack
Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Saturday, December 28, 2024
IRC logs for Saturday, December 28, 2024