Bonum Certa Men Certa

Help Fight Patent Bullying From Shazam -- Spread This Code!

Gorilla



Summary: This post looks at patent bullying against Free software and it calls for the spreading of source code which Shazam unlawfully tries to remove from the Internet

EARLIER TODAY we wrote about NetApp's threats against ZFS distributors. As one blogger put it:

Enterprise Strategy Group senior analyst Terri McClure wonders why NetApp didn't hit Nexenta with the same letter since Nexenta supplies its ZFS software to multiple storage vendors.

"If NetApp did it would make sense – stop a number of vendors instead of just one. It certainly makes you wonder why they would single out Coraid, people could read into this that NetApp sees Coraid as a threat. Coraid's NAS product is pretty new but the underlying platform has been on the market a while and is solid, at a really aggressive price point," said McClure.

"[NetApp] just spent a couple of hundred dollars in lawyer's fees and took a competitor out of the market. Quick and easy, but a little disappointing, too. At the end of the day, ZFS is open source, and while there is no way to predict how the settlement talks between Oracle and NetApp will turn out, you can't really un-open source ZFS," she said.

There's still no word from NetApp on the matter.


The "patent troll, NTP, is back, buoyed dosh from RIM," says Glyn Moody, who found this new article.

NTP, a patent-holding company best known for prying a settlement of more than $600 million from the maker of the BlackBerry, is now suing the other big names in the smartphone industry: Apple, Google, Microsoft, HTC, LG and Motorola, writes The New York Times’s Steve Lohr.

The suits, filed late Thursday afternoon in federal district court in Richmond, Va., charge that the cellphone e-mail systems of those companies are illegally using NTP’s patented technology.


We mentioned NTP before and so did Patent Troll Tracker. Speaking of trolls, earlier today we wrote about Shazam's patent bullying. That previous post gave just the gist of it and the discussion at Slashdot ought to say more. From the summary:

"The code wasn't even released, and yet Roy van Rijn, a Music & Free Software enthusiast received a C&D from Landmark Digital Services, owners of Shazam, a music service that allows you to find a song, by listening to a part of it. And if that wasn't enough, they want him to take down his blog post (Google Cache) explaining how he did it because it 'may be viewed internationally. As a result, [it] may contribute to someone infringing our patents in any part of the world.'"


Jan Wildeboer calls it "Patent Infringement Madness" and another post Wildeboer says "is (a) a blog entry or (b) patent infringement? I say (a) Shazam says (b)"

Two readers urged us to make a mirror just in case (other people ought to mirror this too, in order to ensure that Shazam will lose hope of successfully censoring perfectly legal Dutch code).

Patents are supposed to encourage publication of ideas, not to suppress them. The following code is not in any way infringing Shazam copyrights.






Creating Shazam in Java





A couple of days ago I encountered this article: How Shazam Works



This got me interested in how a program like Shazam works… And more importantly, how hard is it to program something similar in Java?

About Shazam

Shazam is an application which you can use to analyse/match music. When you install it on your phone, and hold the microphone to some music for about 20 to 30 seconds, it will tell you which song it is.

When I first used it it gave me a magical feeling. “How did it do that!?”. And even today, after using it a lot, it still has a bit of magical feel to it.
Wouldn’t it be great if we can program something of our own that gives that same feeling? That was my goal for the past weekend.

Listen up..!

First things first, get the music sample to analyse we first need to listen to the microphone in our Java application…! This is something I hadn’t done yet in Java, so I had no idea how hard this was going to be.

But it turned out it was very easy:



1 final AudioFormat format = getFormat(); //Fill AudioFormat with the wanted settings


2 DataLine.Info info = new DataLine.Info(TargetDataLine.class, format);
3 final TargetDataLine line = (TargetDataLine) AudioSystem.getLine(info);


4 line.open(format);
5 line.start();

Now we can read the data from the TargetDataLine just like a normal InputStream:



01 // In another thread I start:


02   


03 OutputStream out = new ByteArrayOutputStream();




04 running = true;


05   




06 try {


07     while (running) {




08         int count = line.read(buffer, 0, buffer.length);


09         if (count > 0) {


10             out.write(buffer, 0, count);


11         }


12     }


13     out.close();


14 } catch (IOException e) {


15     System.err.println("I/O problems: " + e);


16     System.exit(-1);


17 }


Using this method it is easy to open the microphone and record all the sounds! The AudioFormat I’m currently using is:



1 private AudioFormat getFormat() {




2     float sampleRate = 44100;


3     int sampleSizeInBits = 8;


4     int channels = 1; //mono




5     boolean signed = true;


6     boolean bigEndian = true;


7     return new AudioFormat(sampleRate, sampleSizeInBits, channels, signed, bigEndian);




8 }

So, now we have the recorded data in a ByteArrayOutputStream, great! Step 1 complete.

Microphone data

The next challenge is analyzing the data, when I outputted the data I received in my byte array I got a long list of numbers, like this:



01 0


02 0


03 1


04 2


05 4




06 7


07 6




08 3


09 -1




10 -2


11 -4




12 -2


13 -5


14 -7


15 -8


16 (etc)

Erhm… yes? This is sound?



To see if the data could be visualized I took the output and placed it in Open Office to generate a line graph:

Ah yes! This kind of looks like ’sound’. It looks like what you see when using for example Windows Sound Recorder.

This data is actually known as time domain. But these numbers are currently basically useless to us… if you read the above article on how Shazam works you’ll read that they use a spectrum analysis instead of direct time domain data.
So the next big question is: How do we transform the current data into a spectrum analysis?

Discrete Fourier transform

To turn our data into usable data we need to apply the so called Discrete Fourier Transformation. This turns the data from time domain into frequency domain.
There is just one problem, if you transform the data into the frequency domain you loose every bit of information regarding time. So you’ll know what the magnitude of all the frequencies are, but you have no idea when they appear.



To solve this we need a sliding window. We take chunks of data (in my case 4096 bytes of data) and transform just this bit of information. Then we know the magnitude of all frequencies that occur during just these 4096 bytes.

Implementing this

Instead of worrying about the Fourier Transformation I googled a bit and found code for the so called FFT (Fast Fourier Transformation). I’m calling this code with the chunks:



01 byte audio[] = out.toByteArray();


02   


03 final int totalSize = audio.length;


04   


05 int amountPossible = totalSize/Harvester.CHUNK_SIZE;


06   


07 //When turning into frequency domain we'll need complex numbers:




08 Complex[][] results = new Complex[amountPossible][];


09   


10 //For all the chunks:


11 for(int times = 0;times < amountPossible; times++) {


12     Complex[] complex = new Complex[Harvester.CHUNK_SIZE];




13     for(int i = 0;i < Harvester.CHUNK_SIZE;i++) {


14         //Put the time domain data into a complex number with imaginary part as 0:


15         complex[i] = new Complex(audio[(times*Harvester.CHUNK_SIZE)+i], 0);




16     }


17     //Perform FFT analysis on the chunk:




18     results[times] = FFT.fft(complex);


19 }


20   


21 //Done!

Now we have a double array containing all chunks as Complex[]. This array contains data about all frequencies. To visualize this data I decided to implement a full spectrum analyzer (just to make sure I got the math right).
To show the data I hacked this together:





01 for(int i = 0; i < results.length; i++) {




02     int freq = 1;


03     for(int line = 1; line < size; line++) {


04         // To get the magnitude of the sound at a given frequency slice


05         // get the abs() from the complex number.


06         // In this case I use Math.log to get a more managable number (used for color)


07         double magnitude = Math.log(results[i][freq].abs()+1);


08   


09         // The more blue in the color the more intensity for a given frequency point:




10         g2d.setColor(new Color(0,(int)magnitude*10,(int)magnitude*20));


11         // Fill:


12         g2d.fillRect(i*blockSizeX, (size-line)*blockSizeY,blockSizeX,blockSizeY);


13   


14         // I used a improviced logarithmic scale and normal scale:




15         if (logModeEnabled && (Math.log10(line) * Math.log10(line)) > 1) {




16             freq += (int) (Math.log10(line) * Math.log10(line));


17         } else {




18             freq++;


19         }




20     }


21 }

Introducing, Aphex Twin

This seems a bit of OT (off-topic), but I’d like to tell you about a electronic musician called Aphex Twin (Richard David James). He makes crazy electronic music… but some songs have an interesting feature. His biggest hit for example, Windowlicker has a spectrogram image in it.
If you look at the song as spectral image it shows a nice spiral. Another song, called ‘Mathematical Equation’ shows the face of Twin! More information can be found here: Bastwood – Aphex Twin’s face.



When running this song against my spectral analyzer I get the following result:

Not perfect, but it seems to be Twin’s face!

Determining the key music points

The next step in Shazam’s algorithm is to determine some key points in the song, save those points as a hash and then try to match on them against their database of over 8 million songs. This is done for speed, the lookup of a hash is O(1) speed. That explains a lot of the awesome performance of Shazam!

Because I wanted to have everything working in one weekend (this is my maximum attention span sadly enough, then I need a new project to work on) I kept my algorithm as simple as possible. And to my surprise it worked.

For each line the in spectrum analysis I take the points with the highest magnitude from certain ranges. In my case: 40-80, 80-120, 120-180, 180-300.





01 //For every line of data:


02   




03 for (int freq = LOWER_LIMIT; freq < UPPER_LIMIT-1; freq++) {




04     //Get the magnitude:


05     double mag = Math.log(results[freq].abs() + 1);


06   


07     //Find out which range we are in:




08     int index = getIndex(freq);


09   




10     //Save the highest magnitude and corresponding frequency:


11     if (mag > highscores[index]) {


12         highscores[index] = mag;


13         recordPoints[index] = freq;


14     }


15 }




16   


17 //Write the points to a file:




18 for (int i = 0; i < AMOUNT_OF_POINTS; i++) {




19     fw.append(recordPoints[i] + "\t");


20 }




21 fw.append("\n");


22   




23 // ... snip ...


24   




25 public static final int[] RANGE = new int[] {40,80,120,180, UPPER_LIMIT+1};


26   


27 //Find out in which range




28 public static int getIndex(int freq) {




29     int i = 0;


30     while(RANGE[i] < freq) i++;


31         return i;


32     }


33 }

When we record a song now, we get a list of numbers such as:





01 33  56  99  121 195


02 30  41  84  146 199


03 33  51  99  133 183




04 33  47  94  137 193




05 32  41  106 161 191


06 33  76  95  123 185


07 40  68  110 134 232




08 30  62  88  125 194


09 34  57  83  121 182


10 34  42  89  123 182




11 33  56  99  121 195




12 30  41  84  146 199


13 33  51  99  133 183


14 33  47  94  137 193




15 32  41  106 161 191


16 33  76  95  123 185


If I record a song and look at it visually it looks like this:


(all the red dots are ‘important points’)

Indexing my own music

With this algorithm in place I decided to index all my 3000 songs. Instead of using the microphone you can just open mp3 files, convert them to the correct format, and read them the same way we did with the microphone, using an AudioInputStream. Converting stereo music into mono-channel audio was a bit trickier then I hoped. Examples can be found online (requires a bit too much code to paste here) have to change the sampling a bit.

Matching!

The most important part of the program is the matching process. Reading Shazams paper they use hashing to get matches and the decide which song was the best match.

Instead of using difficult point-groupings in time I decided to use a line of our data (for example “33, 47, 94, 137″) as one hash: 1370944733
(in my tests using 3 or 4 points works best, but tweaking is difficult, I need to re-index my mp3 every time!)

Example hash-code using 4 points per line:



01 //Using a little bit of error-correction, damping


02 private static final int FUZ_FACTOR = 2;


03   


04 private long hash(String line) {


05     String[] p = line.split("\t");


06     long p1 = Long.parseLong(p[0]);


07     long p2 = Long.parseLong(p[1]);




08     long p3 = Long.parseLong(p[2]);


09     long p4 = Long.parseLong(p[3]);


10     return  (p4-(p4%FUZ_FACTOR)) * 100000000 + (p3-(p3%FUZ_FACTOR)) * 100000 + (p2-(p2%FUZ_FACTOR)) * 100 + (p1-(p1%FUZ_FACTOR));


11 }

Now I create two data sets:

- A list of songs, List<String> (List index is Song-ID, String is songname)
- Database of hashes: Map<Long, List<DataPoint>>



The long in the database of hashes represents the hash itself, and it has a bucket of DataPoints.

A DataPoint looks like:



01 private class DataPoint {


02   


03     private int time;


04     private int songId;




05   


06     public DataPoint(int songId, int time) {


07         this.songId = songId;


08         this.time = time;


09     }


10   




11     public int getTime() {


12         return time;


13     }


14     public int getSongId() {


15         return songId;


16     }


17 }

Now we already have everything in place to do a lookup. First I read all the songs and generate hashes for each point of data. This is put into the hash-database.
The second step is reading the data of the song we need to match. These hashes are retrieved and we look at the matching datapoints.

There is just one problem, for each hash there are some hits, but how do we determine which song is the correct song..? Looking at the amount of matches? No, this doesn’t work…
The most important thing is timing. We must overlap the timing…! But how can we do this if we don’t know where we are in the song? After all, we could just as easily have recorded the final chords of the song.

By looking at the data I discovered something interesting, because we have the following data:

- A hash of the recording
- A matching hash of the possible match
- A song ID of the possible match
- The current time in our own recording
- The time of the hash in the possible match



Now we can substract the current time in our recording (for example, line 34) with the time of the hash-match (for example, line 1352). This difference is stored together with the song ID. Because this offset, this difference, tells us where we possibly could be in the song.
When we have gone through all the hashes from our recording we are left with a lot of song id’s and offsets. The cool thing is, if you have a lot of hashes with matching offsets, you’ve found your song.

The results

For example, when listening to The Kooks – Match Box for just 20 seconds, this is the output of my program:



01 Done loading: 2921 songs


02   


03 Start matching song...




04   


05 Top 20 matches:




06   


07 01: 08_the_kooks_-_match_box.mp3 with 16 matches.




08 02: 04 Racoon - Smoothly.mp3 with 8 matches.


09 03: 05 Röyksopp - Poor Leno.mp3 with 7 matches.


10 04: 07_athlete_-_yesterday_threw_everyting_a_me.mp3 with 7 matches.


11 05: Flogging Molly - WMH - Dont Let Me Dia Still Wonderin.mp3 with 7 matches.


12 06: coldplay - 04 - sparks.mp3 with 7 matches.


13 07: Coldplay - Help Is Round The Corner (yellow b-side).mp3 with 7 matches.


14 08: the arcade fire - 09 - rebellion (lies).mp3 with 7 matches.




15 09: 01-coldplay-_clocks.mp3 with 6 matches.


16 10: 02 Scared Tonight.mp3 with 6 matches.




17 11: 02-radiohead-pyramid_song-ksi.mp3 with 6 matches.


18 12: 03 Shadows Fall.mp3 with 6 matches.




19 13: 04 Röyksopp - In Space.mp3 with 6 matches.


20 14: 04 Track04.mp3 with 6 matches.




21 15: 05 - Dress Up In You.mp3 with 6 matches.


22 16: 05 Supergrass - Can't Get Up.mp3 with 6 matches.


23 17: 05 Track05.mp3 with 6 matches.


24 18: 05The Fox In The Snow.mp3 with 6 matches.


25 19: 05_athlete_-_wires.mp3 with 6 matches.


26 20: 06 Racoon - Feel Like Flying.mp3 with 6 matches.


27   




28 Matching took: 259 ms


29   




30 Final prediction: 08_the_kooks_-_match_box.mp3.song with 16 matches.


It works!!

Listening for 20 seconds it can match almost all the songs I have. And even this live recording of the Editors could be matched to the correct song after listening 40 seconds!

Again it feels like magic! :-)

Currently, the code isn’t in a releasable state and it doesn’t work perfectly. It has been a pure weekend-hack, more like a proof-of-concept / algorithm exploration.

Maybe, if enough people ask about it, I’ll clean it up and release it somewhere. Or turn it into a huge online empire like Shazam… who knows!





Comments

Recent Techrights' Posts

The End of Red Hat
expect many more layoffs soon
Only Hours Into the New Year People Already Discuss the Next Round of Layoffs at Red Hat/IBM
2026 will be another tough year for Red Hat and IBM
 
Slopwatch Still Dead, Not Enough LLM Slop About "Linux"
this is the desirable thing
LibXML2 Will Carry on (Without or With the Name "LibXML2")
The proprietary software boosters are projecting
Gemini Links 02/01/2026: ThinkPad, SHARP Zaurus, Lagrange Handheld Support
Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Thursday, January 01, 2026
IRC logs for Thursday, January 01, 2026
Links 01/01/2026: "Biophobia" and Renewed Effort to Locate MH370
Links for the day
Gemini Links 01/01/2026: Bot Accounts Online and Reading in 2025
Links for the day
IBM’s and Red Hat’s "Operation Evolution initiative" Just Long, Fancy Term for Bluewashing, Redundancies, Layoffs
Gerstner is still alive, but he's shorter and more arrogant
Designing a Better Mousetrap or Tools for the SSG
Static Site Generators (SSGs) - unlike all modern Content Management Systems (CMSs) - are so simple that extending them is easy
Links 01/01/2026: 1930 Works in the Public Domain, Electricity Pricing 'a Mystery'
Links for the day
Firefox is Toast Because It Got Toasted by Mozilla
Firefox cannot keep above 2% and hasn't been able to for quite some time
Ignore the LLM Slop and the Noise, Microsoft is in a Death Spiral
So what does Microsoft have left to sell?
Red Hat is Vanishing Before Our Eyes
With some Red Hat staff "transitioning" we wonder if it's an HR hack, wherein they "reset the clock" on employment duration so as to lessen severance obligations
In 2025 Microsoft Lost Palau
Palau now has GNU/Linux at steadily high levels
Microsoft Mocked UNIX/Linux for Not Handling Dates After 2038, Microsoft Breaks Down on 2026!
Only a truly moronic company would design it that way
Another New Year's Resolution: Public Domain Sources, Credits
In addition to our first one
Combatting Slop Images (and ClownFlare)
we won't use or reuse slop images
A New Year's Resolution: Maximal Transparency
We'll do our very best to be transparent about everything that's going on, even legal matters
Gemini Links 01/01/2026: 2025 Comes to a Close and Capsular Gemlog Manager
Links for the day
Free Software Foundation (FSF) Raised About 1.3 Million Dollars in the Past Couple of Months!
the FSF's Board now has 10 people in it
2026 IBM Phaseout of Red Hat
Red Hat won't fare any better than most IBM acquisitions
Microsoft Budget Issues, XBox Thrown Under the Bus
They're cutting budget. Soon they'll cut the staff.
EPO People Power - Part XXI - Europe's Second-Largest Institution Became a Corrupt For-Profit Company Run by Drug Addicts
it'll be the demise of the Rule of Law in Europe and maybe a death blow to the EU (eventually), not just the EPO
Another Very Productive Year Commences
"a total of over 17,000 pages in a year"
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Wednesday, December 31, 2025
IRC logs for Wednesday, December 31, 2025
Fiji: GNU/Linux Has Risen From Almost Nothing to Almost 5% in Recent Years
It's not as small as people are led to believe
Gemini Links 31/12/2025: Blogosphere is Growing and New Year Begins
Links for the day
Recruiters Don't Use Microsoft LinkedIn, Spammers Use LinkedIn
One of my best friends, a university professor, lost all of his life's savings due to Microsoft LinkedIn
You've Only Wasted Your Life in Social Control Networks
In a sense, social control media is a giant delusion
2025 Was a Very Bad Year for Social Control Media
statCounter sees a gradual demise in Social Control Media access
Don't "Go Paperless", Go Paperful [sic] (for What Really Matters)
Why should we favour paper use sometimes? Well, many reasons.
Complexity Considered Harmful: We Used to Run an Operating System on 64KB of RAM, Not 64GB of RAM (a Million Times More)
"Initially confined to single-tasking on 8-bit processors and no more than 64 kilobytes of memory"
The Slop Industry is Failing So Badly (Mountains of Debt, Losses) That It's Merging With the SPAM Industry
we reckon that Google will eventually delist all slopfarms, recognising they're just a form of SPAM
Links 31/12/2025: Cheeto Pushing for More Wars, ‘Security is a Shared Responsibility’
Links for the day
Enshittification of Postal Services Isn't Technological Advancement
Societies that say the aim is to "go digital" and eliminate paper trail aren't advanced; they're moving backwards
IBM Starts 2026 a Much Smaller Company (Not Homage to Gerstner)
People who get bluewashed out of their job (or bluewashed into unemployment) are gagged by NDAs
XBox is Likely Dead Already, But the Threat It Posed to Us All for Two Decades Isn't Over
"the Xbox was never about gaming and merely served as a test bed for DRM in commodity systems."
Ahead of 2026 Mass Layoffs at Microsoft the Tree Gets Shaken to See Who 'Falls' (Resigns/Retires)
"We had a quiet meeting last week about budget realignment. No one said layoffs, but it’s clear where the focus is shifting."
Almost 6,5000 Pages in 2025, Aiming Higher in 2026
if we can keep focused, then quantity will increase
Microsoft XBox Having a "Dog Ate My Homework" Moment: No New Console Until 3 Years From Now... Because "RAM Prices"
Who will ever remember this in 2028? Nobody.
Gemini End of Year Capsules Tally (Based on Lupa) Shows About 10% Growth
What a difference a year makes
Gemini Links 31/12/2025: New Resolution, Reverse Hexdump, and Programming Languages
Links for the day
Dr. Andy Farnell Explains Why Chatbots Became Dishonesty on Top of Dishonesty (Hiding Usage of Dishonest Salads of Words)
new article from CyberShow
Links 31/12/2025: Nvidia Faces Bubble-Bursting Moment, Saudi Oil Money Pumped Into Chatbots to Keep the Energy Waste Going (Circular Financing Again)
Links for the day
Richard Stallman's First Talk in a U.S. College Since 2018
Greetings from Georgia Tech!
EPO People Power - Part XX - Why António Campinos Chose to Put His Cokehead Friend on 'Sick Leave'
EPO Cocainegate will be covered for months to come
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Tuesday, December 30, 2025
IRC logs for Tuesday, December 30, 2025