05.14.17

Gemini version available ♊︎

The US Supreme Court Consults USPTO Director Michelle Lee Regarding the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) Which is Invalidating Software Patents With CAFC’s Approval

Posted in America, Patents at 5:05 pm by Dr. Roy Schestowitz

The Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit (CAFC) continues to concur with PTAB about 80% of the time and sometimes goes even further by invaliding patents that PTAB deemed acceptable

Punch

Summary: Software patents continue to get knocked out by the Leahy-Smith America Invents Act (AIA) whose introduction of PTAB gave a helping hand to companies that are susceptible to abusive litigation (with bogus patents)

THE “AIA” reform, passed by Obama half a decade ago, has been good. It gave us the the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB). PTAB invalidates a lot of software patents (thousands of them), sending out the message or signaling the demise of such patents in general, owing to Alice from the US Supreme Court.

“PTAB invalidates a lot of software patents (thousands of them), sending out the message or signaling the demise of such patents in general, owing to Alice from the US Supreme Court.”As one can imagine and even expect, the patent microcosm is up in arms over this. It is trying hard to decapitate the USPTO and to shame the Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit (CAFC) into slowing PTAB down (shame on Patently-O).

The other day, writing about AIA in this post, Patently-O took note of the US “PTO’s low-quality examination of software and business methods in the late 1990s and early 2000s.”

“The problem was, all along, the granting of any patents on software and business methods, irrespective of so-called ‘quality’ (whatever that means, it’s a distraction often used by proponents of software patents who look for excuses).”No, the problem isn’t low-quality “examination of software and business methods.” The problem was, all along, the granting of any patents on software and business methods, irrespective of so-called ‘quality’ (whatever that means, it’s a distraction often used by proponents of software patents who look for excuses).

Based on another post from Patently-O, Michelle Lee is still in charge of the USPTO (don’t believe villainous rumours and insults), which means that AIA/PTAB/reform is defended. Here is the relevant part:

After receiving party briefs in this case, the Supreme Court requested a responsive brief from the Michelle Lee in her role as PTO Director on the constitutionality of the AIA trial system. That brief has now been by the new acting Solicitor General Jeff Wall who handled a number of patent cases in private practice.

We certainly hope that the highest US court recognises that practicing companies love AIA (and Lee), whereas it’s the parasites who attack everything. We’ve looked around for news about PTAB just before the weekend and all we found was stuff about IPRs, CAFC, and Alice:

There happens to be a new CAFC case (nonprecedential) which Patently-O covered by stating: “In its final written decision, the PTAB sided with the patentee – holding that IPR-challenged claims were not obvious. U.S. Patent No. 6,945,013 claims 18-20 (aseptic bottling at > 100 bottles per minute). On appeal, Nestle has successfully argued that Board incorrectly construed the claim term “aseptic.””

“We certainly hope that the highest US court recognises that practicing companies love AIA (and Lee), whereas it’s the parasites who attack everything.”Patently-O tends to cherry-pick cases that help the patent maximalists, but that’s nothing new. By contrast, Patently-O covered this case where CAFC was going further than even PTAB, invalidating patents on software in spite of PTAB tolerating these.

Here is the Cisco petition:

After the PTO initiated an inter partes reexamination, the patentee (Cirrex) dropped the original claims (1-34) and added new claims (35-124) of its ‘082 patent.[1] In its final decision, the PTAB affirmed the examiner’s decision that most of the added claims were invalid as lacking written description support. The Board did, however, find five of the claims patentable. On appeal, the Federal Circuit partially reversed – finding all of the claims invalid as lacking written description support.

PTAB, based on another such example, helps fend off patent trolls that go after a patent trolls feeder, Ericsson. “In a non-precedential decision,” Patently-O showed, “the Federal Circuit has rejected IV’s procedural due process claim against the PTAB – holding that the PTAB is free to construe claims in ways that differ from any party proposal and without first providing notice of its off-book construction.”

“If Lee was replaced by someone like Battistelli, they would be doomed for ‘daring’ to reduce the number of patents (or so-called ‘production’).”Notice the role of Microsoft’s patent troll here (IV).

Software patents are generally dropping like flies as at PTAB, for instance, the “first quarter of this year saw the most inter partes reviews (IPRs) filed on record,” IAM admits, citing data from Lex Machina again. Here is the relevant part:

But which law firms lead the way in terms of their performance at the PTAB? Some data providers, such as Lex Machina, provide fairly comprehensive breakdowns of how many reviews a firm has filed and how they have fared for their clients, by tracking things like the numbers of cases they have had instituted, the number that have been denied and the number that have settled.

We certainly hope that PTAB (similar to the appeal boards at the EPO) will see a growing number of petitions. If Lee was replaced by someone like Battistelli, they would be doomed for 'daring' to reduce the number of patents (or so-called 'production').

Share in other sites/networks: These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.
  • Reddit
  • email

Decor ᶃ Gemini Space

Below is a Web proxy. We recommend getting a Gemini client/browser.

Black/white/grey bullet button This post is also available in Gemini over at this address (requires a Gemini client/browser to open).

Decor ✐ Cross-references

Black/white/grey bullet button Pages that cross-reference this one, if any exist, are listed below or will be listed below over time.

Decor ▢ Respond and Discuss

Black/white/grey bullet button If you liked this post, consider subscribing to the RSS feed or join us now at the IRC channels.

DecorWhat Else is New


  1. Links 24/03/2023: Microsoft's Fall on the Web and Many New Videos

    Links for the day



  2. IRC Proceedings: Thursday, March 23, 2023

    IRC logs for Thursday, March 23, 2023



  3. Links 24/03/2023: Social Control Media Bans Advancing

    Links for the day



  4. Links 24/03/2023: GNU Grep 3.10 and Microsoft Accenture in a Freefall

    Links for the day



  5. Links 23/03/2023: RSS Guard 4.3.3 and OpenBSD Webzine

    Links for the day



  6. Experiencing 15 Years of LibrePlanet Celebration Firsthand as a Volunteer: 2023 - Charting the Course

    Article by Marcia K Wilbur



  7. [Meme] Grabinski the Opportunity

    Reports of European Patents being invalidated (judges do not tolerate fake patents) have become so common that a kangaroo court becomes a matter of urgency for the EPO‘s Benoît Battistelli and António Campinos; will the EU and the EPO’s Administrative Council go along with it, helping to cover up more than a decade of profound corruption?



  8. Union Syndicale Fédérale Cautions the EPO's Administrative Council About Initiating an Illegal Kangaroo Court System for Patents (UPC) While EPO Breaks Laws and Sponsors the Ukraine Invasion

    Union Syndicale Fédérale (USF) is once again speaking out in support of the staff union of Europe's second-largest institution, which lacks oversight and governance because of profound corruption and regulatory capture



  9. Investigation Underway: Sirius 'Open Source' Embezzled/Stole Money, Robbed Its Own Staff

    In light of new developments and some progress in an investigation of Sirius ‘Open Source’ (for fraud!) we take stock of where things stand



  10. [Meme] Sirius 'Open Source' Pensions: Schemes or Scams? Giving a Bad Name to Open Source...

    What Sirius ‘Open Source’ did to its staff is rightly treated as a criminal matter; we know who the perpetrators are



  11. Sirius 'Open Source' Under Investigation for Pension Fraud, Several Pension Providers Examine the Facts

    2 pension providers are looking into Sirius ‘Open Source’, a company that defrauded its own staff; stay tuned as there’s lots more to come. Is this good representation for “Open Source”? From a company that had many high-profile clients in the public sector?



  12. Links 23/03/2023: Sparky 2023.03 Special Editions and SUSE Changes CEO (Dirk-Peter van Leeuwen)

    Links for the day



  13. Links 23/03/2023: Linux 6.2.8 and XWayland 23.1.0

    Links for the day



  14. IRC Proceedings: Wednesday, March 22, 2023

    IRC logs for Wednesday, March 22, 2023



  15. Apple 'Porn' Filter

    Guest post by Ryan Farmer: Apple and US State Governments Developing System to Require People to Report Themselves for Watching Porn.



  16. 3.5 Years Later Gemini Protocol and Geminispace Are Still 100% Community-Controlled

    Community-centric alternatives to the World Wide Web have gained traction; one of them, Gemini Protocol, continues to grow in 2023 and we're pleased to report progress and expansion



  17. Windows Falls to 16% Market Share in India (It was 97% in 2009), Microsoft Layoffs Reach India Too

    This month’s picture from the world’s most populous nation does not look good for Microsoft (it looks good for GNU/Linux); anonymous rumour mills online say that Microsoft isn’t moving to India but is actually firing staff based in India, so it’s a case of shrinking, not offshoring. When even low-paid (much lower salaries) staff is discarded it means things are very gloomy.



  18. Links 22/03/2023: GNOME 44 “Kuala Lumpur”

    Links for the day



  19. Microsoft Has Also Infiltrated the OSI's Board of Directors After Rigged Elections

    Weeks ago we warned that this would happen and for the third or fourth time in 2 years the OSI’s election process broke down; today the Open Source Initiative (OSI) writes: “The polls just closed, the results are in. Congratulations to the returning directors Aeva Black…” (Microsoft employee)



  20. Links 22/03/2023: Official Thunderbird Podcast Starts

    Links for the day



  21. IRC Proceedings: Tuesday, March 21, 2023

    IRC logs for Tuesday, March 21, 2023



  22. Many More Microsoft Layoffs Later Today

    Yesterday we shared rumours about Microsoft layoffs being planned for later today (there were 3 waves of layoffs so far this year). There are several more people here who say the same. How much noise will Microsoft make in the “media” in order to distract? Will the chaffbot "ChatGPT" help create enough chaff?



  23. Links 21/03/2023: JDK 20 and GNOME 43.5

    Links for the day



  24. Germany's Lobbyists-Infested Government Sponsors the War on Ukraine via the European Patent Office (EPO)

    The chief UPC ‘judge’ is basically seeking to break the law (and violate constitutions, conventions etc.) to start a kangaroo court while dodging real courts, just like Vladimir Putin does



  25. [Meme] The Meme That Team UPC (the Collusion to Break the European Laws, for Profit) Threats to Sue Us For

    António Campinos and Team UPC are intimidating people who simply point out that the Unified Patent Court (UPC) is illegal and Klaus Grabinksi, shown above, strives to head a de facto kangaroo court in violation of constitutions and conventions (the UK does not and cannot ratify; Ireland hasn’t even held a referendum on the matter)



  26. Microsoft is Sacking People Every Month This Year, Even Managers (While Sponsored Media Produces Endless Chatbot Chaff)

    Lots of Microsoft layoffs lately and so-called ‘journalists’ aren’t reporting these; they’re too busy running sponsored puff pieces for Microsoft, usually fluff along the “hey hi” (AI) theme



  27. 3 Months Late Sirius 'Open Source' Finally Deletes Us From the Fraudulent 'Meet the Team' Page (But Still Lists Many People Who Left Years Ago!)

    Amid fraud investigations the management of Sirius ‘Open Source’ finally removed our names from its “Meet the Team” page (months late); but it left in the page about half a dozen people who left the company years ago, so it’s just lying to its clients about the current situation



  28. Amid Fraud at Sirius 'Open Source' CEO Deletes His Recent (This Month) Past With the Company

    Not only did the Sirius ‘Open Source’ CEO purge all mentions of Sirius from his Microsoft LinkedIn account; he’s racing against the clock as crimes quickly become a legal liability



  29. Web Survey Shows Microsoft Falling Below 15% Market Share in Africa, Only One Minuscule African Nation Has Windows Majority

    A Web survey that measured Microsoft Windows at 97% in Africa (back in 2010) says that Windows has become rather small and insignificant; the Microsoft-sponsored mainstream media seems to be ignoring this completely, quite likely by intention...



  30. Rumours of More Microsoft Layoffs Tomorrow (Including Managers!), Probably Azure Again (Many Azure Layoffs Every Year Since 2020)

    Amazon is laying off AWS staff and Microsoft has been laying off Azure staff for 3 years already, including this year, so it seems like the “clown computing” bubble is finally bursting


RSS 64x64RSS Feed: subscribe to the RSS feed for regular updates

Home iconSite Wiki: You can improve this site by helping the extension of the site's content

Home iconSite Home: Background about the site and some key features in the front page

Chat iconIRC Channel: Come and chat with us in real time

Recent Posts