EditorsAbout the SiteComes vs. MicrosoftUsing This Web SiteSite ArchivesCredibility IndexOOXMLOpenDocumentPatentsNovellNews DigestSite NewsRSS

06.10.08

Reader’s Thoughts on Mark Shuttleworth’s Response (Regarding Microsoft Codecs)

Posted in Free/Libre Software, GNU/Linux, Mono, Patents, Ubuntu at 2:45 pm by Dr. Roy Schestowitz

It was only several hours ago that this mailing list thread came to our attention. Therein, Mark Shuttleworth addresses a post from Boycott Novell. An anonymous reader took it upon himself to respond to it. His response is quoted below in full. Context and background can be found here.


“FOSS distros shouldn’t be a vector for licensing problems…”If Mark Shuttleworth wants to be unambiguous about it, he needs to state “is not and shall not” make a deal for closed codecs. I know that comes close to splitting hairs, but his answer will help prevent unpleasant surprises.

If he’s dealing with proprietary codecs, or general Microsoft technology, he should be wise from the mistakes of others: there’s a trail of out of work CEOs that thought that their company should remain “willing to work with Microsoft, under reasonable and transparent conditions, to further goals that we share” e.g.

“I once preached peaceful coexistence with Windows. You may laugh at my expense — I deserve it.”

Be’s CEO Jean-Louis Gassée

Mark’s not dumb. He shouldn’t try to act dumb. Just how would Canonical survive a deal with Microsoft when no other company to-date has?

However, that’s not as concrete as the mono infection which is listed on the project page:

Subnotebooks, especially those with small HDs or SSDs don’t have 100′s of GB to spare for mono-bloat for just a few packages. Subnotebooks, especially those with low power CPUs don’t have the gigacycles to deal with mono’s bloat spaghetti code. FOSS distros shouldn’t be a vector for licensing problems, like the ones still unresolved after (10?) years of mono.

Note F-Spot:
     http://www.canonical.com/netbooks

Note mono infection:


$ apt-cache depends f-spot
f-spot
  Depends: dbus
  Depends: libart-2.0-2
  Depends: libatk1.0-0
  Depends: libc6
 |Depends: libc6
 |Depends: <libc6.1>
  Depends: <libc0.1>
  Depends: libcairo2
  Depends: libexif12
  Depends: libflickrnet2.1.5-cil
  Depends: libgconf2.0-cil
 |Depends: libgl1-mesa-glx
  Depends: <libgl1>
    libgl1-mesa-glx
    libgl1-mesa-swx11
  Depends: libglade2.0-cil
  Depends: libglib2.0-0
  Depends: libglib2.0-cil
  Depends: libgnome-vfs2.0-cil
  Depends: libgnome2.0-cil
  Depends: libgnomeui-0
  Depends: libgnomevfs2-0
  Depends: libgphoto2-2
  Depends: libgphoto2-port0
  Depends: libgtk2.0-0
  Depends: libgtk2.0-cil
  Depends: libgtkhtml3.16-cil
  Depends: libjpeg62
  Depends: liblcms1
  Depends: libmono-addins-gui0.2-cil
  Depends: libmono-addins0.2-cil
  Depends: libmono-cairo2.0-cil
  Depends: libmono-corlib2.0-cil
  Depends: libmono-sharpzip2.84-cil
  Depends: libmono-sqlite2.0-cil
  Depends: libmono-system-data2.0-cil
  Depends: libmono-system-web2.0-cil
  Depends: libmono-system2.0-cil
  Depends: libmono2.0-cil
  Depends: libndesk-dbus-glib1.0-cil
  Depends: libndesk-dbus1.0-cil
  Depends: libx11-6
  Depends: libxcomposite1
  Depends: mono-runtime
  Depends: sqlite
  Depends: sqlite3
  Recommends: dbus-x11
  Recommends: dcraw

I fought to mention that subnotebooks are often being used in environments/situations where the instability caused by mono causes more harm than in more relaxed situations.

Share this post: These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Reddit
  • co.mments
  • DZone
  • email
  • Google Bookmarks
  • LinkedIn
  • NewsVine
  • Print
  • Technorati
  • TwitThis
  • Facebook

If you liked this post, consider subscribing to the RSS feed or join us now at the IRC channels.

Pages that cross-reference this one

16 Comments

  1. Rui Miguel Silva Seabra said,

    June 10, 2008 at 6:04 pm

    Gravatar

    apt-cache depends fubar will list you all the packages fubar depends on.

    apt-cache rdepends fubar will list you all the packages depending on fubar.

    For f-spot it’s:
    apt-cache rdepends f-spot
    f-spot
    Reverse Depends:
    ubuntustudio-graphics
    ubuntu-desktop
    gobuntu-desktop

  2. Victor Soliz said,

    June 10, 2008 at 6:42 pm

    Gravatar

    Rui Miguel Silva Seabra: So metapackages intended to install f-spot among other things, depend on f-spot, hmnn…

  3. Woods said,

    June 11, 2008 at 12:18 am

    Gravatar

    ubuntu-desktop depends on F-Spot?
    Doesn’t that mean that removing F-Spot would also remove ubuntu-desktop package?
    Either rdepends reports that a bit funnily or it’s a new development in Hardy, since in 7.10 I could still rip out mono et al. without a problem (I hit the ubuntu-desktop problem when trying to rip out Evolution, if memory serves me…)

    That is bad news indeed, since it would mean that removing mono et al. would break the desktop pretty badly. If memory serves me, lack of ubuntu-desktop-package will cause problems when upgrading your installation.
    (disclaimer: I haven’t tried out Hardy, so this is just speculation)

  4. Roy Schestowitz said,

    June 11, 2008 at 12:47 am

    Gravatar

    Would it be worth posting a separate inquiry/mention of this?

  5. Woods said,

    June 11, 2008 at 1:21 am

    Gravatar

    >Would it be worth posting a separate inquiry/mention of this?

    Well, apparently rdepends also lists “Recommended” and “Suggests”-fields (http://osdir.com/ml/debian.apt.devel/2003-08/msg00044.html) so this would, fortunately, be a false alarm (this time)

    Only to way to be sure is to boot up Hardy, rip out mono et al. and see what happens (sigh, I guess it’s download-time after all…:-) )

  6. Roy Schestowitz said,

    June 11, 2008 at 1:25 am

    Gravatar

    Yes, I realise it’s a false alarm a while ago in thew IRC channel where this was brought up.

  7. Chris Lees said,

    June 11, 2008 at 6:56 am

    Gravatar

    You know, you can rip out Mono without twisting Apt into circles. Just find out what files are in the Mono package, and then delete them. I must say, I’ve never heard of Mono causing problems with the rest of the system, even on subnotebooks. In short, I’m accusing boycottnovell.com of FUD.

    Remaining willing to work with Microsoft should always be a possibility, should there be a culture shift in the corporation. We’ve seen enough culture shifts in computing to know it can happen. As for the codecs, maybe you should write a rabid article about how terrible Fluendo is, because they sell licenses for the Windows Media codecs (https://shop.fluendo.com), and then advise your readers to remove all Gstreamer packages from their systems?

  8. Roy Bixler said,

    June 11, 2008 at 8:43 am

    Gravatar

    : You know, you can rip out Mono without twisting Apt into
    : circles. Just find out what files are in the Mono package,
    : and then delete them.

    That’s a bad idea and could cause you other (technical) problems down the road.

    : I must say, I’ve
    : never heard of Mono causing problems with the rest of the
    : system, even on subnotebooks. In short, I’m accusing
    : boycottnovell.com of FUD.

    Whereas I call it being outspoken and having an opinion. I happen to agree with it and consider it a bad idea to promote Microsoft APIs, always playing catch-up. It’s been tried before and we’ve all seen the results of the defunct competitors who tried this. This is aside from the issue of possible software patents.

    : Remaining willing to work with Microsoft should always be a
    : possibility, should there be a culture shift in the corporation. We’ve seen
    : enough culture shifts in computing to know it can happen.

    That’s unlikely but possible. Trust should be earned over time and I see no change in Microsoft’s culture so far.

  9. Roy Schestowitz said,

    June 11, 2008 at 8:47 am

    Gravatar

    IBM is one among others who were betrayed by Microsoft. It’s a pattern without any exception I can think of. See http://boycottnovell.com/2007/12/01/antitrust-letters-doj/

  10. Needs Sunlight said,

    June 11, 2008 at 9:09 am

    Gravatar

    If rdepends also lists “Recommended” and “Suggests” fields, that’s probably a bug which can and should be fixed upstream.

  11. Miles said,

    June 11, 2008 at 9:52 am

    Gravatar

    Whereas I call it being outspoken and having an opinion.

    Exactly, so let’s not confuse opinion with fact ;-)

    Since the opinion is one of fear, uncertainty, and doubt – it is also by definition FUD.

  12. RyanT said,

    June 11, 2008 at 12:26 pm

    Gravatar

    I’ve never seen or heard anything about mono making a system more unstable, and in fact myself have uninstalled mono completely, with no problems at all. At the same time, I noticed no performance changes.

    FFS get this through your thick skull – despite what many people have pointed out, you continue to ignore that these are just codecs that the only way to legally acquire are to actually pay for them, and how in the world does this represent a further, larger deal in the leagues of Novells.

    Also, anything involving taking out Evolution isn’t a problem with infection – I myself through experience have found many, completely safe normal packages have ended up taking out important things (including desktop packages) without any intention. It is a dependency problem, not suspicious infection. You just have to make sure to check the changes to ensure anything that’s not needed to take out isn’t.

    Agreed with Miles said, this is FUD. A shame as I quite like this site too.

  13. Roy Schestowitz said,

    June 11, 2008 at 12:44 pm

    Gravatar

    Ryan,

    The intention is not to cause alarm or incite panic. It’s supposed to show dangers where they exist so that they can be addressed or avoided. I guess there’s no gentle way to put this, but we at least try. Sorry if you find this counter productive…

  14. Lovecraft said,

    June 11, 2008 at 6:57 pm

    Gravatar

    As I understood it they were taking steps to allow OEM’s to have legally licensed codecs for things that end users would see as critical. What the hell is the big deal. We all dislike Microsoft, but the vitriol this site spews over the most minor concessions, all in the name of principle is crazy. Who exactly is alright? Give this site a few years and they’ll have blacklisted every distro with more than a thousand users.

  15. RyanT said,

    June 11, 2008 at 7:58 pm

    Gravatar

    Sorry for me little outburst.

    Roy, you seem like your heart’s in the right place and all, but as I see it, this site has very real danger of falling into the same trap as many other sites with similar campaigns.

    While they rally against bias, and show themselves as the white knights of the land, they get caught up ina trap, and go in circles around their own speculation, do a complete around-the-world and end up out the other side exactly what they were against and trying to avoid – bias.

    I don’t think you’ve gone there yet, but as each day passes, more and more you get too far ahead of yourself in certain things, you take certain bits of logic too far or present it in a way that is alarming or incites panic, even if not intended.

    Please, step out of this little world once in a while as a grounder – read some articles of the opposing side (well written, well thought out ones, not the raving ones that are often pointed out). If you spend too much time in this little world of boycott novell, you could end up in a downward, overly conspiratorial spiral that’ll make people take this site a lot less seriously.

    Sometimes you can be on the mark, but more and more I think you can get ahead of yourself, the recent Ubuntu codecs deal being the one that has been the straw to break the camels back. Not just because it is a well loved distribution, but because the logic takes too big a jump for people to believe, and is also too narrow of a view.

    Be more thorough, both in your research of Novell and of subjects like this where things like mono performance and the like come out of nowhere without seemingly much backup, but also in widening your view. Stop constantly focusing on the MS side of things all the time, or trying to imply the MS influence, because you are heading into a spiral of over selling things and seeing other things that might not be there.

    And, just to make sure it’s seen, I’ll post what I put in the other codecs thread here:

    Adding in proprietary codecs would only be limiting choice if you couldn’t in any way choose any other form of codec, or re-encode the file to another one.

    You are removing choice, because you are not allowing people to view content in formats they already use, amongst many others. You are causing more harm than good – you are putting up flimsy, unnecessary barriers, especially when you consider that without those codecs, then how are people supposed to change their files into new, open formats instead?

    The only way to do it is transition, which is exactly what Netbook Remix is doing. Including the codecs for people that need, and including the open formats too, ready and waiting to be converted to. They wouldn’t be able to do that without the proprietary codecs in the first place so they can read and convert them, meaning no transition, no more FOSS converts,etc etc.

    Why do you think OpenOffice includes support for MS Office foramts? Because people still have documents in taht format, and the only way you’re going to get new people and get them to transfer over completely, you have to be compatible with said formats in the first place, otherwise there’s no way to access or change formats.

    By not having the codecs, they would be blocking themselves from a much larger audience ripe for transition.

  16. Roy Schestowitz said,

    June 11, 2008 at 10:07 pm

    Gravatar

    @ Lovecraft: No, we don’t blacklist more distributors. Maybe these posts were not comprehended. Mark Fink’s messages deceived a great deal in that regard.

    @ RyanT: Thanks for the insightful thoughts. I largely agree with what you say. I’ll probably post a clarification later on (it requires a long explanation).

What Else is New


  1. Links 2/9/2014: GNU/Linux in BBC, Calls Against systemd

    Links for the day



  2. Links 1/9/2014: Poettering on systemd, ITNews on DBMSs

    Links for the day



  3. Moving Away From Windows to GNU/Linux and the Abandonment of Windows as the Modest Proposal These Days

    Morale of GNU/Linux and an embrace of GNU/Linux is very high, despite recent propaganda from Microsoft MVPs and boosters (primarily security-themed and Munich-themed FUD)



  4. Korean Press Slams Microsoft Over Patent Extortion Against Linux/Android as New Abuses Resurface

    Harsh words from the national press of South Korea as Nokia's role in Microsoft's anti-Linux tactics becomes more apparent



  5. More Good News About Patents and Their Demise in the United States

    A roundup of news about software patents and patent trolls in the land where these thrive



  6. Links 31/8/2014: Linux 3.12.27, Akademy 2014

    Links for the day



  7. Links 30/8/2014: Jailhouse 0.1, *buntu 14.10 Beta

    Links for the day



  8. Links 28/8/2014: Many New Games, CTO of Red Hat Steps Down

    Links for the day



  9. We Are Gradually Winning the Battle Against Software Patents

    The once-elusive war on software patents is finally leading to some breakthrough and even the Federal Circuit reinforces the trend of software patents' demise



  10. Free/Open Source Software (FOSS) Companies Versus FOSS Moles (VMware, Sonatype, Xamarin)

    A look at three entities which pretend to be pro-FOSS but are actually FOSS-hostile and very much determined to replace FOSS with proprietary software



  11. Links 27/8/2014: GNU/Linux in Space, China, LinuxCon

    Links for the day



  12. FUD Against Google and FOSS Security Amid Microsoft Windows Security Blunders

    In the age of widespread fraud due to Microsoft Windows with its back doors there is an attempt to shift focus to already-fixed flaws/deficiencies in competitors of Microsoft



  13. Microsoft Spin Watch: IDG Turns to More Microsoft Propaganda, Hires Microsoft Boosters

    Media in Microsoft's pocket is telling Microsoft's lies and deceives the public for Microsoft's bottom line



  14. Microsoft's Massive Tax Evasion Becomes Better Known

    A new report about Microsoft's admission that it plays dirty tricks with tax (sometimes using moles in government) is increasing awareness of Microsoft's criminal aspects



  15. Links 25/8/2014: China's Linux Revolution Imminent

    Links for the day



  16. Links 24/8/2014: GNU/Linux Specialisation and Benchmarks

    Links for the day



  17. Links 23/8/2014: GNU/Linux Growth

    Links for the day



  18. Microsoft-Funded Attacks on Android Security and Patent/Copyright

    A look back at examples of people who smear Android and are receiving (or received) money from Microsoft



  19. Blowback in Chile and Munich After Microsoft Intervention

    Microsoft's attacks on the digital sovereignty of countries involves lobbying, corruption, an attack on standards (e.g. ODF), an attack on FOSS policies, and even an attack on accurate reporting (truth itself)



  20. The End of Microsoft is Nigh

    A look back at a tough year for Microsoft and a not-so-promising future



  21. Links 22/8/2014: Linux Foundation LFCS, LFCE

    Links for the day



  22. UPS Burned by Microsoft Windows, Gives Away Massive Number of Credit Card Details

    UPS is the latest victim of Microsoft's shoddy back door with software on top of it (Windows); attempts to blame FOSS for data compromise actually divert attention from the real culprit, which is proprietary software



  23. Microsoft's Funding of ALEC and Other Systemic Corruption

    Microsoft role in writing of laws by proxy, via groups such as ALEC



  24. Microsoft is Still Preying on British Taxpayers, Playing Politics

    Some news from the UK showing how Microsoft uses politics to extract money out of taxpayers, irrespective of their preferences



  25. Microsoft's Patent Troll Intellectual Ventures is Collapsing as 20% of Staff Laid Off

    More good news regarding the demise of patents as Microsoft's leading patent proxy is collapsing more rapidly than anyone ever imagined and software patents too are collectively doubted



  26. Links 21/8/2014: Conferences of Linux Foundation, Elephone Emerges

    Links for the day



  27. Links 20/8/2014: Linux Event, GNOME Milestone

    Links for the day



  28. Corruption Watch: Microsoft Lobbying Designed to Kill Chile's Free Software Policy and Promote Microsoft With Subsidies, More Dirty Tricks Emerge in Munich

    icrosoft is systematically attacking migrations to GNU, Linux and Free software, using dirty tricks, as always



  29. Vista 8 Such a Disaster That Even Microsoft Cannot Cope With It, Vapourware Tactics Start Early

    Microsoft's Windows-powered services are failing and Windows gets bricked by Microsoft patches, whereupon we are seeing yet more of Microsoft's vapourware tactics (focusing in imaginary, non-existent versions of Windows)



  30. On BlackBerry and Other Patent Trolls

    A roundup regarding patent trolls, starting with the bigger and latest joiner, BlackBerry's new patents apparatus


CoPilotCo

RSS 64x64RSS Feed: subscribe to the RSS feed for regular updates

Home iconSite Wiki: You can improve this site by helping the extension of the site's content

Home iconSite Home: Background about the site and some key features in the front page

Chat iconIRC Channel: Come and chat with us in real time

CoPilotCo

Recent Posts