EditorsAbout the SiteComes vs. MicrosoftUsing This Web SiteSite ArchivesCredibility IndexOOXMLOpenDocumentPatentsNovellNews DigestSite NewsRSS

08.30.10

Paul Allen’s Patent Troll Obviously Did Not Sue Microsoft, But Why Did Amazon Get a Free Pass?

Posted in GNU/Linux, Microsoft, Patents at 10:33 am by Dr. Roy Schestowitz

Bezos gives lecture

Summary: An analysis of what makes Amazon unique in the eyes of Microsoft and its patent trolls; why the Interval Licensing case is unlikely to be settled, just like i4i’s

SOFTWARE patentor Amazon was not sued by Microsoft co-founder, who used his patent troll to sue just about every large Internet company [1, 2, 3]. How come? Well, Amazon and Microsoft are neighbours and Amazon has been getting occupied by former Microsoft employees at the highest levels (no wonder Amazon is now paying Microsoft for GNU/Linux, even for Red Hat servers). Writers are mystified by the fact that Interval did not take on Amazon. At Groklaw, for instance, Pamela Jones’ initial reaction was: “He isn’t suing Microsoft or Amazon. He is suing in addition Facebook, AOL, eBay, Netflix, Office Depot, OfficeMax, Staples, Yahoo and YouTube. Because a billion or more is never enough.”

It is similar to what several other people have said, including this blogger:

Allen is one of the world’s richest people, with a fortune that Forbes magazine estimates as over $13 billion.

“This is yet another example of the cynical use of the American legal system to extort money out of successful companies — in the name of protecting innovation and innovators. Shame on Paul Allen for being part of it,” wrote a blogger at the Web site of Forbes Magazine about this almost classic act of patent trolling. It should not be surprising that Microsoft Florian decided to “redefine open standards, redefine troll, redefine democracy,” according to the FFII, which responds to Florian’s latest posts which defends the indefinsible. “Why Paul Allen doesn’t want to be a troll” is the title of that post.

David Kappos recently said that the patent office he runs actually creates jobs. Jones, a paralegal by trade, begged to differ at the time and now she says: “Don’t anyone ever again tell me that patents stimulate the economy and create jobs. They line the pockets of a few, while killing off creative endeavors by everyone else. What jobs are these patents creating? What jobs do any patent trolls’ patents create? Jobs for lawyers, but really, who else?”

Here is another article Jones found about Amazon being excluded from the massive lawsuit (it covers Facebook, which is partly owned by Microsoft):

Patent lawsuit du jour: Paul Allen versus the world (but not Microsoft or Amazon)

[...]

Fortunately, those companies also can afford the legal bills. That may not be the case for many smaller Web sites. So at what point will the chief executives of America take a break from complaining about the “uncertainty” of Washington economic policy to notice the massive uncertainty created by an out-of-control patent system?

A settlement is said not to be likely.

Final point: The vast majority of patent cases settle. Here, however, all of the parties have large amounts of cash-on-hand. In addition, some of the defendants are repeat patent infringement defendants. Those factors tend to make settlement less likely.

i4i is not willing to settle, either. Its people want to bar Microsoft. But Microsoft won’t leave them alone until they run out of money, apparently. Might it reach SCOTUS?

Microsoft has petitioned the U.S. Supreme Court to overturn a $290 million patent ruling in a long-running dispute with i4i Inc. of Toronto over the use of technology known as custom XML in Microsoft Word.

i4i is not a patent troll. Fortunately for us, despite its pro-software patents policy it is causing a lot of damage to Microsoft Office and to OOXML. Microsoft should be sued like this a lot more frequently; maybe then it will decide that software patents are no longer its friend.

Share this post: These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Reddit
  • co.mments
  • DZone
  • email
  • Google Bookmarks
  • LinkedIn
  • NewsVine
  • Print
  • Technorati
  • TwitThis
  • Facebook

If you liked this post, consider subscribing to the RSS feed or join us now at the IRC channels.

Pages that cross-reference this one

9 Comments

  1. gnufreex said,

    August 30, 2010 at 11:31 am

    Gravatar

    If I had to guess, I would say that Allen wants to prove a point: `If you want to be in IT industry, you have to pay royalty to Microsoft’

    One quote by some Microsoftie regarding competition: “We have to whack them, to make them understand our value.”

    Novell and Amzon already payed, so he is leaving them alone. I think he also left out Salesforce.com and other Microsoft tools.

    -Redmond delenda est
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carthago_delenda_est

    Dr. Roy Schestowitz Reply:

    You know what might be helpful? Let’s compile a list of the hundreds of companies that cross-license with Microsoft. Among Facebook, AOL, eBay, Netflix, Office Depot, OfficeMax, Staples, Yahoo and YouTube (Google), none that I know of cross-licenses with Microsoft and they are all US-based — that’s where software patents are valid.

    gnufreex Reply:

    That’s good idea. I think Facebook is spreading SilverBlight, but don’t have patent deal with M$FT. Others don’t too.

    IBM have a deal, and it is not sued by Allen. Oracle has a deal because Sun had. Samsung has Microsoft deal…. HP too (they are even managed by Microsofties). VMware is managed by Microsofties, but I don’t think it has a patent deal, Red Hat is protected by the OIN and probably Allen don’t have a patent that might hit them. Canonical too, and it is too small fish… and Canonical helps Microsoft with Mono.

    HTC has Microsoft deal….

    I think there is some other common denominator we are missing. He didn’t sue exactly every Microsoft competitor that is not paying privilege to Microsoft. What else those companies have in common? Maybe the fact they are all into Cloud Computing. Maybe they all use FOSS in some part of their infrastructure, or they depend on Microsoft and still use some competing technology.

    Stales is full of Microsoft advocates and Windows devotees, it doesn’t make sense to sue them…

    Just thinking out loud.

    gnufreex Reply:

    That should say Staples, not Stales.

    twitter Reply:

    Microsoft betrays everyone, so action against Staples and Office Depot are not too surprising. Perhaps the companies were not making Microsoft enough money and the company decided to shake them down like so many other Windows vendors. The exception of importance is Microsoft, which proves Allen’s continuing affiliation.

    I’m enjoying the sudden outbreak of common sense that the suit is creating. Pretty soon, everyone will realize that software patents should be eliminated.

    Dr. Roy Schestowitz Reply:

    Let’s not forget Apple’s role in this whole M.A.D.ness (including investment in the world’s largest patent troll, IV).

    As I wrote in identi.ca just minutes ago, Paul Allen and Steve Jobs show that life-threatening disease can make predators out of humans rather than make them compassionate.

  2. The Mad Hatter said,

    August 30, 2010 at 7:14 pm

    Gravatar

    Even Gene Quinn who is very pro-patent thinks that Paul Allen is a patent troll.

    Microsoft Co-Founder Paul Allen Sues Apple, Google, Facebook, Yahoo and Others for Patent Infringement

    Gene and I are usually on different ends of most issues, but not this time.

    Dr. Roy Schestowitz Reply:

    Yes, I was about to point this out in tomorrow’s post.

What Else is New


  1. Under Distributed Denial of Service Attacks Lately, But We're Too Robust For Those

    Efforts to take Techrights offline have been ramped up lately; but it's not working and it hardly even distracts us from publishing



  2. The Art of Giving: Why Free Software Will Inevitably Survive Attacks Against It

    Societies that share and look after their peers/neighbours will always be better off than predatory societies, which breed exploitation, distrust, discord and eventually systemic collapse



  3. 'Journalism' in 2020: Far More Articles About What Computer Linus Torvalds Bought Than About Linux Releases

    Yesterday's (or late Sunday's) Linux announcement (RC7) is symptomatic of a broader issue we've long spoken about; it restricts people's ability to express an opinion, which can cloud any meritorious and substantial debate about technical matters journalists cannot grasp or comment on (it takes more effort and research)



  4. Links 25/5/2020: Wrapland Redone, DebConf20 Plans, Many More Games

    Links for the day



  5. Media Covers WSL Like People Actually Use This Trash (a Failed Distro Which Only Works With Windows)

    Lots of abundantly redundant puff pieces have appeared in paid-for (by Microsoft) media this past week covering WSL/2, but that's grossly disproportional to the people who care and actually use those types of things (because money talks, not technical substance)



  6. Working From Home on Patent Monopolies Would Lower Their Quality and Perceived Legitimacy

    The patent system wherein people grant monopolies from their sofas and bedrooms isn't helping the already-eroded perception/image of patent offices that mostly grant patents to massive multinationals (and far too many patents overall)



  7. The Attitude of António Campinos Toward Courts and Toward Justice Same as Benoît Battistelli's

    6 years down the road we're still dealing with unaccountable tyrants who laugh at the law, laugh at lawmakers and disregard law enforcers (like the Trump regime across the Atlantic)



  8. IRC Proceedings: Sunday, May 24, 2020

    IRC logs for Sunday, May 24, 2020



  9. Asking Microsoft If It Loves Linux is Like Asking Google If It's Evil

    The media keeps bombarding us with lousy, weakly-sourced messages about Microsoft regretting its stance on “Open Source” and loving “Linux” (both are lies that are very easily debunked), so journalism has an existential problem and maybe too much dependence on ad money (a form of bribery) from “Big Tech” that does “clown computing” and “apps”



  10. Features Considered Harmful

    "But the benefits of Free software, free candy and new features are all meaningless, if the user isn't in control."



  11. Free, as in “App”

    "As everyday users, we need to be able to configure our applications, and this process must/needs to be made as easy and understandable as possible."



  12. Links 25/5/2020: Linux 5.7 RC7 and TeleIRC 2.0.0

    Links for the day



  13. Links 24/5/2020: TUXEDO Computers on AMD, Ardour 6.0 is Out

    Links for the day



  14. Trust Microsoft With Everything Including Your Life

    A timely if not apt meme about the state of Windows-powered hospitals, which very often end up foreign-operated (taken over by crackers in another country)



  15. When the Response to Hospitals Being Systematically Cracked Through Microsoft Products Like Windows is... Blocking the Competition of Microsoft

    People keep dying because Microsoft Windows, poorly designed with NSA back doors in it, falls into the hands of malicious actors (sometimes overseas, sometimes using leaked tools of the NSA itself) and guess who takes the blame when hospitals grind to a halt due to this…



  16. IRC Proceedings: Saturday, May 23, 2020

    IRC logs for Saturday, May 23, 2020



  17. Ode to the 'Orange One'

    Bush Senior and Junior, Hillary/Bill Clinton and now António Battistelli (or Benoît Campinos); are we dealing with monarchies/monarchs and pledges of allegiance or with public institutions beholden to the public, to be governed by the law?



  18. Home Working at the EPO: Your Corporate, Global Monopolies Will Be Rubber-stamped From Private Homes

    We’re expected to believe that EPO employees working under the noses of Microsoft (in another continent!) with kids running around will be able to be both productive and professional; staff already complains about working until midnight and beyond, without any conceivable separation between career and personal life



  19. To Understand Why “Inner Source” is a Cheap Corporate Ploy if Not a Free Software-Hostile 'Scam' Look Who's Behind It

    It's rather easy to see that the O'Reilly-connected and Bill Gates-connected leadership of InnerSource Commons (ISC) doesn't register this fake 'charity' to promote Software Freedom but to fight against it under the guise of "open" (openwashing)



  20. Microsoft: We Were Wrong About Open Source and That's Why We 'Liberate' Code... From 1983 (and We Won't Accept Code Changes, Either!)

    The tiresome openwashing efforts from Microsoft verge on the farcical, but the Microsoft-funded media plays along with it all regardless



  21. The Unitary Patent and Unified Patent Court Book

    The Unified Patent Court (UPC) propaganda must be confronted; there's a book in the making about UPC lies and the anatomy of this legislative coup attempt by litigation fanatics (who profit from monopolies, patent trolls and so on)



  22. Links 23/5/2020: Oracle Solaris 11.4 SRU21, Wine-Staging 5.9

    Links for the day



  23. Spillover: Team UPC Trying to Fill Up the Cup 'Half Empty'

    The European Patent Office's (EPO) corruption is mirrored in UPC corruption; the former hasn't yet seen its downfall due to this corruption and the latter is already up in flames, no matter how media sites (are paid to) spin it, giving false hope for the sake of lobbying by Team UPC



  24. The EPO Continues to Publicly Brag About Granting Illegal Patents to Fake 'Production' (It's Not Really Production But Abuse of the Granting Authority)

    Patents on life, nature and mathematics serve to highlight the degree of corruption embraced by EPO management, eager to fake ‘production’ in order to hoard money, which is then stolen and misused in other ways



  25. GNOME Settlement With Patent Troll Fails to Address/Tackle the Software Patent and Software Patents in General

    GNOME settles with the troll on terms that are superficially friendly towards Free software; however, more could be done to actually defuse matters on legal if not precedential grounds



  26. IRC Proceedings: Friday, May 22, 2020

    IRC logs for Friday, May 22, 2020



  27. Fiduciary Technology: Why It's Often Impermissible to Use Microsoft (But It's Done Anyway)

    "As such and if your CTO isn’t actively moving tooling out of the Microsoft ecosystem like bailing water out of a sinking ship, then you should probably be looking for a new CTO."



  28. Links 23/5/2020: FreeBSD 11.4 RC1, Wine 5.9

    Links for the day



  29. Links 22/5/2020: App Icon Preview 2.0.0, dav1d 0.7.0, LibreOffice's New Icons

    Links for the day



  30. Freedom Is Not Possible Without Privacy

    Privacy was the subject of today's feature article; let's not forget how essential a concept it is to guard against encroachments, no matter the given excuses


RSS 64x64RSS Feed: subscribe to the RSS feed for regular updates

Home iconSite Wiki: You can improve this site by helping the extension of the site's content

Home iconSite Home: Background about the site and some key features in the front page

Chat iconIRC Channel: Come and chat with us in real time

Recent Posts