Bonum Certa Men Certa

Software Patents: How Europe Lost Its Sovereignty

Koekelberg's Basilica



Summary: The first part of a series about the unitary patent and its attempted last-minute passage

CONVENTIONAL wisdom says that when corporations accumulate joint desire to have a new law, sooner or later they will get it, some time, somehow.



Over the years we have covered the many attempts to legalise software patents in Europe. More recently, politician were 'pulling an ACTA' and using the same tactics they use to pass ACTA to also pass software patents (although not explicitly so). This one propaganda page is titled: "A unitary European patent and a unified European patent litigation system – political agreement by the end of 2011?"

"More recently, politician were 'pulling an ACTA' and using the same tactics they use to pass ACTA to also pass software patents (although not explicitly so)."Well, guess who that page is from? "David Sant, software patent representative of the EPO, now works for TaylorWessing, the Lehne company," claims the FFII's president. For those who do not know the scandals of Lehne, see previous posts such as this.

Here are some instructions for those wishing to contact politicians who are less corrupt. "The European Union is rushing to impose," says the author, "with as less discussion as possible, a unitary patent, despite the risk that this project could introduce software patents in Europe by giving away a lot of powers to the democratically uncontrolled extra-EU European Patent Office (EPO), and despite all warnings that the legal basis of the regulation on the unitary patent is likely to not comply with EU Treaties. In such a situation, only a massive citizen rally could prevent the unitary patent to end up as a stillborn project, in the detriment of the EU innovation policy. In order to inform Members of the European Parliament (MEPs), here are some guidelines and concrete suggestions to act by contacting them." It is probably not too late for reasons we will show in later parts.

Here is a post on the subject which says "it seems that we head now to the meeting of the Competitiveness Council on 5 December with a danger that these bad agreements might be agreed at a political level; and with the prospect of them being formally adopted during the Danish Presidency in the first half of 2012. Such agreements should be a cause of celebration. But they would not be. There is a groundswell of opinion in industry that the proposals must be looked at again afresh. Likewise at their annual Venice meeting at the end of last month, the European patents judges voted unanimously against the current form of Court agreement. Hence, it is to be hoped that even at this late stage, the politicians will listen to the users and Judges. No doubt regardless of whether agreement is, or is not reached, the Polish announcement will be triumphal. Hence we must look carefully at precisely what is said. Hopefully the announcement from Warsaw will be pure rhetoric, and no agreement will have been reached. We await the announcement with baited breath."

The outcome of this we are going to cover later. The press release of the Polish Presidency says self-serving things and the observers say that "the Polish presidency has "hit a wall" because of the opposition over the location of the central patent court "

One news site claims frustration at the presidency. To quote:

Poland's European affairs minister said the "biggest disappointment" of his country's EU presidency, largely seen as successful under the difficult circumstances of the eurozone crisis, was the failure to take on board Bulgaria and Romania in the EU border-free Schengen area.



We wrote about the Polish presidency in [1, 2, 3, 4].

In the next few posts we shall continue covering the unitary patents from more angles. It is depressing news, so we preferred not to cover it during Christmas (and yesterday was unsuitable because we had made the front page of Slashdot , so the site was generally slow and fragile).

Recent Techrights' Posts

Wikipedia - Funded by Slop-pushing Companies and 'Broligarchs' - Gave Benefit of the Doubt to Slop, Then Regretted It
Wikipedia sucks. Without slop it'll suck a little less.
Passage of Wealth Upwards, Blaming the Victims
Tim Sweeney's net worth is 5.1 billion USD according to Forbes
EPO Strike Begins Today and It's the Longest One Yet (Can Last a Year)
Where's the media?
People Discuss Rumours of Mass Layoffs at IBM Becoming Public in 1-2 Weeks
IBM is killing its brand or its "goodwill"
 
Did IBM Pay thestreet.com for Puff Pieces? (Like It Did With Forbes)
If so, there is no disclosure
Payoffs of Lifelong Commitments
"The Lifelong Activist"
Links 30/03/2026: "We Can’t Income-Tax Ultra-Elites"; "The Pirate Bay’s Oldest Torrent Turned 22"
Links for the day
Today, Europe's Second-Largest Institution (EPO) Goes on Strike That Can Last Until 2027. Nobody in the Media Covers This!
"We stand with the protesters"
When the Cost (or Time) of Maintenance Exceeds the Value
In recent years it seems like more people learn to remove things from their lives, not add more things
More Media Needs to Tell the Public Slop is a Giant Bubble, It Should Stop Taking "Sponsorship" Money to Inflate This Bubble
If enough of (what's left of) the media changes its tune and quits being a parrot of GAFAM, then we can debate slop like grown-ups
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Sunday, March 29, 2026
IRC logs for Sunday, March 29, 2026
Trying to Hide One's Abuses by Imposing Silence on Critics ("My Profile Was Private")
With enough daylight, sooner or later everyone knows you are a vampire
Fedora Badges System Shows the Demise of Fedora Under IBM
IBM isn't good at keeping what it buys
IBM is Sunsetting Red Hat, It Only Uses the Brand and the Shell
IBM buys or spins off companies as containers for "toxic assets" and debt
Cisco Systems is a Still Weak Spot With Bug Doors
nothing to offer except storytelling
Gemini Links 30/03/2026: Approaching April and Arvelie Calendar
Links for the day
No Daylight Saved
Is there still any practical reason for this ritual?
Microsoft Azure Does Not Have "Hiring Freezes", It Has Had Mass Layoffs Every Year Since 2020
Things are always a lot worse than Microsoft formally or publicly acknowledges
SLAPP Censorship - Part 27 Out of 200: Using the Tor Network to Hide From Consequences
Only 1-2 weeks after the countersuit the Canadian attempted to deplatform several Web sites
The Limits of Inclusion
Inclusion with caution isn't "opinionated"; it's a defence mechanism, sometimes a survival instinct
Almost 20 Years After Microsoft/Novell
The mission has not changed, but the priorities evolve all the time
LLM Slop Kills Sites, as Sites That Adopt Slop Are Doomed
People won't subscribe to such sites and visit them if they recognise it's just slop
Links 29/03/2026: Indonesia Cracks Down on Social Control Media Addiction, China Becomes World’s Scientific Superpower
Links for the day
Fedora at the Mercy of Microsoft Because of Back-Doored Kick-Switch Boot
We'll soon revisit the defamation attacks on Torvalds
Links 29/03/2026: Water Shortages and No Kings Rallies
Links for the day
The Old Days
In the early days of this site (2006) it was mostly just a couple of people, plus comments
Gemini Links 29/03/2026: Return to Gopherspace, "Zen of Marking Playing Cards"
Links for the day
The Real XBox is Dead, So Microsoft is Calling Everything "XBox" Now
It even wanted to run a campaign to convince everybody that XBox is not actually a console
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Saturday, March 28, 2026
IRC logs for Saturday, March 28, 2026
Open Web Destroyed by Centibillionaires, Says Anil Dash of Blogging Fame
Blogging was going through its 'prime years' about 20 years ago
"Linux" Slop Going Away, Microsoft et al Pay 'Linux' Foundation to Promote Slop
It's a timely reminder that the Linux Foundation exists to promote whoever pays the Linux Foundation, even pedophiles and companies that attack the GPL
Links 28/03/2026: Microsoft's LinkedIn a National Security Risk, Microsoft's Slop "Ambitions Face Investor Scrutiny Amid Soaring Costs"
Links for the day
Gemini Links 28/03/2026: "Finding My Base Tone", "Astrobotany", and BugoutBack/OFFLFIRSOCH
Links for the day
Links 28/03/2026: More Worldwide Bans on Social Control Media (Harms to Adolescents), Protests in US Against Dictatorship
Links for the day
SLAPP Censorship - Part 26 Out of 200: Asking for Documents and Information You Already Have, Even Letters and E-mails That You Yourself Sent!
barristers are expensive
Gemini Links 28/03/2026: Echo Delay and 0x0.st
Links for the day
Rumours of More IBM Mass Layoffs at Beginning of April
IBM is not doing well
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Friday, March 27, 2026
IRC logs for Friday, March 27, 2026