Alan Cox in 2002: “Microsoft Has Publicly Stated That it Has Patents on Critical Parts of .NET and Will Enforce Them”

Dr. Roy Schestowitz

2009-09-22 11:43:13 UTC
Modified: 2009-09-22 11:43:13 UTC

Summary: Memorable and foresighted words from one of the top Linux developers

A FEW MONTHS ago Microsoft confirmed Alan's statements, which can be found in this interview with Slashdot that contains a lot more:

What are your feelings on Microsoft's .NET and any initiatives to make the technology work on Linux?

Alan [Cox]: Microsoft has publically stated that it has patents on critical parts of .NET and will enforce them. If you think that .NET is a good idea, or cloning .NET is a good idea, remember you won't have a US market unless they find you amusing enough to allow to live on. And if you think Microsoft can be trusted on this look at their recent activities against Samba.

The system itself is mildly interesting as a technology. Its yet another virtual machine, roughly equivalent to picojava in capabilities. It has an interesting way to self generate IDL, but one which their own papers say cannot represent all programming languages.

The more dangerous parts of all this are not so much .NET but chunks of the model that not only the .NET product and the Java standards rely on. Things like xmlrpc, soap and the stuff on top of them are designed to "interwork through firewalls". A better phrase would be "go through the firewall like a knife through butter in a way that prevents the companies involved monitoring the activity".

In summary, Microsoft's .NET is a legal threat, it is just an imitation of Java, and it is a security issue. ⬆

Related posts that mention Alan Cox:

Comments

Yuhong Bao

2009-09-22 16:36:37

"and it is a security issue" Most of the content in that article talks about Vista being a security issue, not Mono.

Recent Techrights' Posts

Too Hard for IBM to Keep Everybody Silent About How the Company Has Gone South: IBM is busy trying to keep disgruntled or ex workers silent using NDAs
Microsoft Windows Falls to All-Time Low of ~60% in Switzerland, GNU/Linux Among Top Gainers: What will it take for mainstream media (not just geeks' site) to cover it?
Mainstream Media on "Practical Survivalism": Suffice to say, panic buying begets more panic and price surges
Cloud Computing as a Cloud of Smoke (Your Hosting Provider is a "Legitimate" Military Target): When a French datacentre went up in flames people joked that the "cloud" meant a cloud of smoke
Andreas Tille Congratulates Sruthi Chandran Before the Election for Debian Project Leader (DPL) is Even Over: Andreas Tille, the current Debian Project Leader (DPL) who has been in this role for nearly 24 months
When You Try to Change the World for the Better and Somehow They Find a Way to Say You Are the Villain: Don't be a fool. Don't fall for inversions of narratives.
Slop Was a Flop and Energy Crisis Will be Slop's Final Blow: Today we see no slopfarms in Google News
Links 05/04/2026: "Taiwanese Airlines to Hike Fuel Surcharges 157%" and Openly Racist Voter Suppression Starts in the US: Links for the day
Gemini Links 05/04/2026: Playing with Hyprland and Migrating Antenna Filters: Links for the day
Links 05/04/2026: "Confidential Computing" as Proprietary Bundle of False Promises and "The Web Is an Antitrust Wedge": Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...: GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Saturday, April 04, 2026: IRC logs for Saturday, April 04, 2026
SLAPP Censorship - Part 34 Out of 200: The Necessity of Transparency, Illuminating Garrett's and Graveley's 'Tag-Team' Act, Misusing the British Docket (From Far Away in America) in Efforts to Hide Bad Behaviour: Transparency is paramount
Red Tape at Red Hat (IBM): Now the guiding principles are the whims and moods of people who peddle buzzwords to manipulate IBM's share prices
The So-called 'AI' (Slop) Companies Will Have the Plug Pulled: It can vastly accelerate this bubble's implosion
Dr. Andy Farnell on a "Technology Plan B": based around Free software
Windows Lows Across the Mediterranean: Judging by this month's data from statCounter
The Future of the Net is 'in Space': Gemini Protocol is growing and GemText remains the same, so it's made to endure
Linux Foundation Profits From Scams, Fraud, and Grifting: Don't be misled by the name "Linux Foundation"
Microsoft Transmits Malware and Back Doors to GNU/Linux Servers, Media Points the Finger at Everyone But Microsoft's Servers: Is Microsoft too poor to vet and check what it hosts and transmits?
Gemini Links 04/04/2026: "Fuzz Guy", "Reusing Old Computers with Arch Linux and DWM", and Bubble v10.0 Released: Links for the day
Links 04/04/2026: eBay Scam, "Music Publishers’ X Copyright Lawsuit Officially on Pause": Links for the day
Links 04/04/2026: Social Control Media Verdict and Bans, Whistleblower (Axel Rietschin) Explains How "Microsoft Vaporized a Trillion Dollars": Links for the day
Reaching the End/Event Horizon of LLM Slop: Are we moving towards a post-LLMs world?
Over at Tux Machines...: GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Friday, April 03, 2026: IRC logs for Friday, April 03, 2026
Gemini Links 04/04/2026: STXGE and Computer Relationships: Links for the day
SLAPP Censorship - Part 33 Out of 200: Garrett Sued by My Wife and I, Then His Microsoft Acquaintance Files Another Lawsuit and Our Webhost Receives Legal Threats Too: Today we also show how our solicitor Mark Lewis responded to it
Good Friday, Leaving IBM for Good: Even on holidays
Links 03/04/2026: Rejection of More Software Patents and Social Control Media in Several Continents: Links for the day
Malware in Proprietary Software - Latest Additions by Rob Musial: Original published yesterday in gnu.org
Visual Evidence/Documentation of IBM Dying Like the Dinosaurs: IBM has many of these giant white elephants lying around, with some getting demolished
Links 03/04/2026: USPTO’s Latest Greenwashing and Internet Blackouts Impact Journalists in War Zones: Links for the day
SLAPP Censorship - Part 32 Out of 200: Garrett Made Spurious Requests (Later Withdrawn) the Same Week Someone He Later Spoke to by E-mail Sent Threats to Our Webhost: The "plot thickens" because there's a multi-party tag-team act, as confirmed by Garrett after he had sworn on the Bible
IBM is a Dying Company, Nowadays It Kills Red Hat With Slop: when your last day is a national holiday in IBM's country
"Independence Drives" and Community-Run Sites: Independence in reporting is a much-valued trait
When Charlatans Are Only Good at Losing Money and Storytelling (e.g. About Investment in Them): Wait till a a barrel of oil costs $300
What Apple Fans Are Missing: Apple is a bad company
The "Pale Blue Dot" Moment Had Returned: To many people, the "bitter-sweet" observation of how small we are
Saudi Arabia Does Not Rely Much on Microsoft/Windows: Putting aside politics, this is good for Free software
Almost 12 Years of Exposing Corruption in Europe's Second-Largest Institution: The "unready" President is now an abandoned President
Easter Moon Mission and Its Reminder of IBM's Demise: A lot of NASA operations now rely on GNU/Linux
When Power is Scarce and GNU/Linux Has Power: In Cuba, GNU/Linux has long enjoyed high adoption rates
Don't Totally Dismiss the 'Survivalists': 'Survivalists' or similar terms are used to describe a particular mindset of people who prepare for some really awful scenarios
Over at Tux Machines...: GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Thursday, April 02, 2026: IRC logs for Thursday, April 02, 2026
A Much Better Use of Fuel Than Slop: Something positive for a change
Hoping for Peace: There are still many things to be enjoyed, including nature and kind people
Gemini Links 03/04/2026: "Slide Rule Triple Multiplication" and End of "Picture Pages": Links for the day
Rumours of Microsoft Layoffs This Season: Just how much trouble is Microsoft in at this point?
GNU/Linux Measured at All-Time High in Sweden: Can 'influencers' have played a role