Friendly 'Boycott Novell' Supportes Robbed of Voice

Dr. Roy Schestowitz

2008-11-16 15:47:51 UTC
Modified: 2008-11-16 21:09:06 UTC

[was: "Novell Does Not Like Being Criticised," but corrected later]

Achtung Polizei

WHY WOULD ~~Novell and/or its affiliates~~ organisers of a Free sofwtare conference suppress friendly opposition to Novell? A group of Free software supporters spread material that explains why Novell is harmful to freedom, but they needed to confront policemen just to voice their views.

What ever happened this world we're living in? Arky has some photos and a concise explanation.

Here is blow by blow account of trouble that brewed up on the second day of National Conference on Free Software 2008 in Cochin university. The activists put up posters against the Novell Corp (the main sponsor of this event) at the Free Software exhibition complex.

The organisers called up Kochi police and man handled the Anivar Aravind a former student of the Cochin University and a well known free software activist.

Here are some comments that add to the overall message.

In theory anyone should be free to promote free software; in practice what's happening is quite alarming. What's free software without free speech and free thought and its own brand of dissent and how can this conference's organizers miss that?

I'm glad Anivar and others stood up. Conference organizers' discomfort with them is understandable, but they clearly don't "get" free software, which is clearly a grassroots movement that has nothing to do with police state. They don't get it at all when they send police to handle known faces in the community.

[...]

I'm willing to be corrected of all this "prejudice", but what just happened has only substantiated my worries. I'm glad you were there to report this incidence, let's now look forward to the organizer's version of The Truth (TM).

With censorship and control, it is easier to tell one's twisted version of the 'truth'.

The following addendum also adds rather disturbing information:

I updated the blog and posted few more photos from the main venue of the event and preparations for the protest.

Most of the mobile phones were taken and pictures deleted, I was lucky enough to get out in time.

"Quickly. Quickly. Got to destroy the evidence."

Fortunately, the word is spreading pretty fast.

Free Software Activist Anivar Aravind is mishandled by police at National Conference on Free Software 2008 organized in Cochin university. The Free Software activists where protesting against the biggest enemies of Free Software, Novell who is the sponsor of the event !!!!

This is also discussed in local mailing lists. Here are some early messages.

On Sun, Nov 16, 2008 at 2:04 PM, Praveen A <pravi.a@gmail.com> wrote:
> >
> > ---------- Forwarded message ----------
> > From: Rakesh 'arky' Ambati <rakesh_ambati@yahoo.com>
> > Date: 2008/11/15
> > Subject: [FSUG-Bangalore] Boycott Novell Protesters Man-handled at
> > National Conference on Free Software 2008
> > To: fsf-friends@mm.gnu.org.in, fsug-bangalore@mm.gnu.org.in

"Novell offers enterprise infrastructure software and services that
help customers leverage proprietary and open source solutions. These
solutions lower cost ..." www.novell.com

It is evident that the services from Novell Corp do not respect nor
appreciate "freedom", as conceived and promoted by Free Software
Foundation.

Whose agenda are being protected, when Free Software activists' are
refused to register their disagreement through non-violent means of
protest ?

What is wrong in voicing objections to concerns about hijacking the
services of Free Software communities where the ends and means do not
justify any of the principles of Free Software ?

CK Raju,
IIT Kharagpur

There is more from Delhi.

From: Linux Lingam <linuxlingam@gmail.com>
Date: 2008/11/16
Subject: Re: [ilugd] Fwd: [FSUG-Bangalore] Boycott Novell Protesters
Man-handled at National Conference on Free Software 2008
To: The Linux-Delhi mailing list <ilugd@lists.linux-delhi.org>,
rahul@efyindia.com, pkr@cybermedia.co.in

that is the *first* instance of an MNC taking a visibly hostile and
tangible stance against foss and foss-supporters in india. does not
bode too well if that MNC also happens to be a partner of microsoft.

novell owes an apology to the indian foss community.
meanwhile, i don't know about you,
but i haven't touched openSUSE or any novell product since their
controversial tie-in with microsoft.

regards
niyam

Thanks to all those who organised this awareness campaign. We were not informed about this until after the act.

The actions taken against innocent dissemination of information speak volume about suppressors of Freedom. It makes them look intolerant and desperate for control of minds. ⬆

Comments

Arun

2008-11-16 19:22:03

Dont put all the blame on Novell. It was organisers of the event who kept silent on the fact that Novell is a sponsor for this event. And then disallowed peaceful protest.
bobinson

2008-11-16 20:30:16

"Novell Does Not Like Being Criticised"

As Arun mentioned above, there is a correction required here. It wasn't Novell who called police. It was the ignorance of the organizers of the conference which caused the issue. The politics of the state and agenda playes the major role here. Even if you look at my blog post, I am not blaming Novell for the incident, but I was pointing out the ignorance of the organizers about Free software. As a fellow blogger commented, they made the event "National “non-free” Software Conference" (http://njaan.wordpress.com/2008/11/16/free-software-conference-at-cusat/)

PS: it will be great to have OpenID enabled here.
Roy Schestowitz

2008-11-16 21:03:04

Thanks. I misread it. I'll correct the text.
bobinson

2008-11-16 21:11:42

@Roy Schestowitz

thats really great :)

In short, the whole thing was like an anti tobacco conference sponsored by a cigarette brand.
Roy Schestowitz

2008-11-16 21:26:40

They don't sell much tobacco though. They just give the pipes.
suresh

2008-11-17 02:31:25

Novell had threatened that they won't give the sponsorship money when they saw the anti-Novell posters in the stall.So the blame on Novell is not totally out of place.
Roy Schestowitz

2008-11-17 03:00:57

Yes, I saw Arky writing this and I will elaborate in a later post. It sounds like older stories.

Thanks.

"All hell broke lose when novell guys saw the 'Bycott Novell' handouts pasted right across their booth and said they won't pay up any sponsers money they owe to the event organisers. They took their ire by kicking out the activists and tearing up the posters.

"The event website has all the information about the people behind the event."

http://www.fsdaily.com/Community/Boycott_Novell_Protesters_Man_handled_at_National_Conference_on_Free_Software_2008
Tom

2008-11-17 04:46:06

Since these kinds of events are private events, "free speech" rules don't apply: the organizers are fully within their rights to have you removed from the premises.

Should they? I don't see why not. If they have secured sponsorship from Novell, obviously, they disagree with you; from their point of view, your posters are slander. Why should they allow you to slander the corporate sponsor of the event?

Personally, I do disagree with your views and characterization of Novell. If you showed up at some event I'm running, I'd probably ask you to leave. And if you don't leave when asked to (for whatever reason), the matter becomes a matter of security.
Joe

2008-11-17 05:39:33

Looks like the protesters got MUCH more publicity than they had hoped for!
Patrick McGoldrick

2008-11-17 05:42:19

"your posters are slander."

You misunderstand slander.

Slander is an untruthful oral (spoken) statement about a person that harms the person's reputation or standing in the community.

No-one has implied that what they were saying about Novell was untrue.
Needs Sunlight

2008-11-17 09:30:55

@Tom: Cool. So by your reasoning, then M$ can go around "sponsoring" all sorts of conferences and workshops just to be able to tell competitors to get out. Doing that directly would violate the sneaky tactics outlined years ago by their planners, so don't expect to see M$ execs getting their hands dirty throwing groups out, that's for M$ partners like Novell or for M$ fascades like BSA and FAST.
Roy Schestowitz

2008-11-17 09:49:29

Needs Sunlight,

They have already pretty much done that.
Kieran

2008-11-17 09:51:37

This 'Needs Sunlight' guy sounds suspiciously like Slashdot's very own troll twitter, who is already whipping up a shillstorm over there:

http://yro.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=1031407&cid=25783351

Bad, bad sockpuppets, bad.
Roy Schestowitz

2008-11-17 09:55:13

Will silly ad hominem attacks please end?
Headmonkey

2008-11-17 10:02:07

Lets analyse this situation, from the real worlds viewpoint, and not that of a religious software freedom baby zealot.

Novell and/or the conference organizers, undoubtedly, rented the space to hold the conference. Its their space, to speak their voice, for however long they rented it. To blame Novell and/or the conference attendees for having the zealots thrown out, or claiming they don't have the right to have the zealots thrown out, is like saying, I can come to your rented apartment, and call your wife a whore, and your kid a dumb ass, and assert my right to free speech while doing so, without you being able to call the police and have me removed from your rented apartment.

I really wish the free software community, which I am a part of, and whos products I use and enjoy, would stop portraying themselves as lunatics in public, and spend their time improveing the quality of their code. If they feel the need to comment on source code, for gods sakes, start commenting your source code.

Free software cannot promote itself, by unleashing an armanent of negativity towards for fee or closed source companies and their products. The free software community should be minding its own business, and promoting and developing its own products, and advertiseing the virtues of its adoption and use.
Kenney

2008-11-17 10:05:19

What Arun said is the truth. The communists and their feeder organisations are to blame. Novell paid the money and got screwed. But now it looks like every one is afraid to even speak about the organisers and their attempts to brand the event a communist thing.
bobinson

2008-11-17 10:15:38

Kenney, I agree with you.
JJMacey

2008-11-17 10:55:12

Hi All,

Wow, I'm surprised to see such activism regarding a meeting. I'm sure that you know that Slashdot has picked this up.
Roy Schestowitz

2008-11-17 11:00:08

Yes, this took me by surprise and I was asleep at the time. I'm surprised the site did not go down (unless it did at one stage). The response to the event of Kerala was also a surprise. We were not responsible for any of this.

The person responsible sent me this some hours ago:

Posters available from below link http://images2.wikia.nocookie.net/fci/images/0/00/Boycottnovell.pdf

Statement from Swathanthra Malayalam computing http://fci.wikia.com/wiki/SMC/StatementOnNCFS2008Kochi
stephanruby

2008-11-17 11:07:31

Please post some more pictures/videos.

Recovering those deleted pictures from your mobile shouldn't be a problem with something like: http://www.snapfiles.com/opinions/Zero_Assumption_Digital_Image_Recovery/Zero_Assumption_Digital_Image_Recovery.html Thanks

- stephanruby (on slashdot.org)
Zenwalker

2008-11-17 12:01:06

Great to see the link i referenced to you getting published here soon.

Thanks Roy.
Roy Schestowitz

2008-11-17 12:04:49

I'm preparing a followup post that's more comprehensive. This was just a quick one.
Ragsagar

2008-11-17 12:36:48

@zenny

nice job buddy!
Billy

2008-11-17 15:21:20

Putting pressure on Novell is totally fair. They should be distancing themselves from the likes of these people.
Kenney

2008-11-18 00:43:04

I have a few questions about the incident

http://www.kenneyjacob.com/2008/11/17/who-is-the-real-culprit-novell-or-cusat/
Dr Known

2008-11-18 07:01:23

Closed source software businesses promote Collusion in the industry. Open source software businesses promote Competition in the industry.
devidas

2008-11-21 03:33:28

@ Kenney,

The fault ain't with Communist Government ruling the state. The fault was, as far as my knowledge about the event is concerned, with the organizers who failed to see the Microsoft-Novell tie-ups, and made them the sponsors.
Shankar Anand

2008-11-21 09:01:53

I completely agree with HeadMonkey. It was a conference that Novell had sponsored. These protesters did not have any business entering Novell's stall and pasting anti-Novell posters in Novell's stall or on Novell's name/log on the conference advertisement boards.

If they wanted to protest, they should have done it outside the premises.

As HeadMonkey said, this "is like saying, I can come to your rented apartment, and call your wife a whore, and your kid a dumb ass, and assert my right to free speech while doing so, without you being able to call the police and have me removed from your rented apartment."
Roy Schestowitz

2008-11-21 09:34:16

You seem to be missing the point that it was not a Novell event, it was carried under the FOSS banner, and it was not disclosed that a proprietary software company (Novell) would have it sort of hijacked to deceive. See this later post.

Links 16/08/2025: "Hey Hi (AI) Data Centers Are Driving Up Electricity Bills for Everyone" and the Case Against Booking.com: Links for the day
Links 16/08/2025: Loners and Vacation, Climate Issues: Links for the day
Links 16/08/2025: Chatbots Bad for Kids, Software Patents Apple Battle: Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...: GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Friday, August 15, 2025: IRC logs for Friday, August 15, 2025
Slopwatch: WebProNews and Google News Promoting Fake Articles About "Linux": Google News is being flooded by these slopfarms, so when Linux news is being sought online (via Google News) many people will read bots that spew out FUD
Original European Patent Convention (EPC, 1973), Routinely Violated by the European Patent Office, Now in Geminispace: hundreds of thousands of European Patents must be immediately revoked
Gemini Links 16/08/2025: Politics and Alhena 5.2.8: Links for the day
Gemini Links 15/08/2025: Leasehold, Slop Bubble, and Xobaqu: Links for the day
Links 15/08/2025: Flight Attendant Strike, Floods, and Tropical Storms: Links for the day
Links 15/08/2025: German Government Falls Short on Free Software, Russians Breach EU Systems: Links for the day
Microsoft is Still Losing Cyprus: The market share goes down, so share prices go up
Microsoft Accenture is in Trouble: For one thing, its debt doubled in a matter of months
News Will Slow Down and Slop Will Contribute to the Slowdown: In recent years every time there was some holiday or major break the number people who "came back" shrank
Upgrading IRC Network of Techrights: a new version of the daemon we've used since 2021 was released very recently
X.Org is Still Not Dead: Oracle still developing it
"Register Debate Series" About Microsoft in the UK is Controlled by Microsoft (US): The Register is run by Microsoft "Analysts", so the debate is doomed from the get-go
IBM is a Terrible Model for Red Hat: "Most likely caused by laying off too many people"
Microsoft Problems in Palestinian Territory and Israel: Microsoft stock (share price) goes up when market share goes down
Microsoft is getting ready to cause many employees to resign: Having already laid off many workers earlier this month, it now tries another approach
Slave is Not a Bad Word, We Need to Use It Sometimes: Who does such exclusion of words benefit? What sort of expression will be deemed impermissible and subjected to CoC enforcement?
National Day of Action: "This Friday, August 15th, there is an organized, petition-based, protest of Wells Fargo in major cities across the US," Richard Stallman wrote
Our Gemini Editions Now Contain 100,000+ GemText Pages: Our Gemini Editions aren't small, even if Gemini Protocol is still the 'underdog'
"Maybe the Problem is You": they probably felt like they had no choice because they really needed this Microsoft money
The Relations Between the United States and Europe Deteriorate, Should Europe Continue to Rely on American Tech Giants?: The shallow notion that made-in-USA software is fairly safe for Europe to rely to is coming to a standstill
Techrights and Tux Machines Running as Usual During Vacations: No interruptions, maybe temporarily slowdowns
GNU OS, Powered by Hurd: Choice is good, as long as choices exist that respect the users' freedom
Gemini Links 15/08/2025: ADHD and "Random Weird Things": Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...: GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Thursday, August 14, 2025: IRC logs for Thursday, August 14, 2025
"Article 52. PATENTABLE INVENTIONS" in the European Patent Convention: Some time tomorrow we'll have a complete local copy of the EPC
Serial Slopper (SS) Still at It, Still Misusing Plagiarism Tools and Cheatware for Images and Text About "Linux": All the slopfarms are a very big problem
Reddit Deletes Stuff, But Not for Being False or Misleading: Yet another one of those articles that speak of a man in his 50s as if he's terminally ill
Times of India and India.com Are Clickbait and LLM Slop: Google continues to reward bad actors
The More "Market Share" Microsoft Loses, The Higher the Shares Go: People joke about the same sort of thing in relation to IBM
To OIN, Software Patents Are Not a Problem: Had software patents ceased to exist, OIN too would cease to exist and its staff would be unemployed.
Microsoft's Bankruptcy in Russia is Only the Beginning: Due to politics it mostly makes sense that Windows is being phased out, also in part due to policy changes
Microsoft-Funded Publishers Lied to Us About Vista 10 and Now Advocate Us Owning Nothing: They want you to own nothing, but they also want you to buy a PC on which to become Microsoft's slave and they make it harder if not practically impossible to remove Windows
Articles Promoting and Celebrating Wayland Are LLM Slop: New example (100% slop)
European Patent Office (EPO) Reformation Project: It's a stain on the EU's reputation
The Register MS, Dominated by American Editors, Says UK Should be Run (Digitally) by Microsoft US: The Register MS is sponsored by American money, run by Americans, and its chief editor is a Microsofter from the US
Slopwatch: Google News and Other Slopfarms: Google News is rewarding sites that misuse LLMs and cheat the Web
Gemini Links 14/08/2025: Drought, Climate Experiments, and LLM Slop Considered Detrimental: Links for the day
Links 14/08/2025: Second-hand ThinkPad and Enhanced Surveillance on Chipsets from the United States: Links for the day
Moral Standards From the Masters of Linux: They get hung up on minor language issue and promote this crazy theory that racism will go away if only everyone spoke a little differently (no matter where he or she came from)
Links 14/08/2025: Data Brokers Hiding Opt-Out Pages From Google, "Fight Chat Control": Links for the day
FSF Infrastructure Under Constant Attack: The disconnect (literally) has had an effect on credibility
Feels Like The Register MS is Trying to Diversify a Bit: If The Register MS goes back to being The Register US (or UK), that will be a nice improvement
Gemini Links 14/08/2025: Reading Journal and LLM Fatigue Revisited: Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...: GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Wednesday, August 13, 2025: IRC logs for Wednesday, August 13, 2025

Friendly 'Boycott Novell' Supportes Robbed of Voice

Comments

Recent Techrights' Posts