03.05.19

Gemini version available ♊︎

The Technical Board of Appeal Will Need True Independence to Squash Software Patents at the EPO (T 0489/14)

Posted in Europe, Patents at 2:55 am by Dr. Roy Schestowitz

It totally and patently lacks that at the moment, by its very own admission

Judicial independence
Reference: Judicial independence

Summary: The EPO has been going dark and shady when it comes to abstract patents in Europe (courts reject these, but the Office still grants these); will that change in T 0489/14?

THE prestige associated with the European Patent Office (EPO) is long gone. The conditions for workers aren’t attractive, the quality of the work is not high, and the experienced/talented examiners are leaving/retiring (or have already left/retired). Some people and some companies aren’t aware of it yet; they’re stuck in the past — way back when the EPO was best bar none. Talicia’s pursuit of a European Patent has just been noted in this new press release, but have they paid attention to the high rate of rejection in European courts (judges in effect overturning examiners’ decisions)?

“The Federated European Patent Register provides information regarding the legal status of EU patents,” Oya Yalvaç (Deriş Patents and Trademarks Agency) wrote yesterday, perhaps conflating the EPO with the EU (a big no-no, especially as there’s no UPC). Pertinent patents are being assessed in NPOs or at the EPO, then (sometimes, in case of lawsuits) to be judged by national courts, which have repeatedly rejected European software patents, at times blasting the EPO for intentionally misinterpreting the EPC and grossly bypassing policy of European authorities. Seeing how António Campinos is flagrantly and shamelessly violating the rules, however (disclosure about this from last Friday), should we be surprised? They’re so nonchalant about it. They fear nothing. They’re immune.

Sadly, EPO judges still lack independence. They casually complain about this. As we noted last week, they will soon issue a judgment on software patents. Here is what World Intellectual Property Review wrote about it yesterday:

The European Patent Office’s (EPO) Technical Board of Appeal has referred questions relating to computer-implemented inventions to the Enlarged Board of Appeal (EBA).

This is the second time that questions relating to the patentability of software have been considered by the EBA, according to law firm Venner Shipley.

“Indeed, it could be the first case that the EBA actively decides on a point of fundamental importance: although the EBA considered a referral in G 3/08 (Programs for computers), it declined to hand down a decision, ruling that the referral was inadmissible,” said a release from Venner Shipley.

The law firm drafted and prosecuted the patent application, which covers an invention for modelling pedestrian movement which can be used to help design or modify venues such as a railway station or stadium.

Outside the circles of law firms’ media we also see some writings from law firms directly. John Leeming (J A Kemp), for example, has just said:

EPO Technical Board of Appeal 3.5.07 has, in case T 0489/14 (Pedestrian simulation/CONNOR), referred questions to the Enlarged Board of appeal concerning what is to be considered technical in the fields of design and simulation. The cases of Designing optical systems/Philips and Circuit Simulation I/Infineon have long been cited as precedent that the design or simulation of a technical system is itself technical and eligible for patent protection. However, some more recent cases have put limits on that proposition, suggesting that the technical system must be defined with sufficient specificity and that the purpose of the simulation might also be relevant.

[...]

The Board accepted that the simulation in Connor was analogous to that in Infineon and so ought to be patentable under the reasoning of Infineon. However, the Board “is not fully convinced” by the reasoning of Infineon and the questions referred could overturn or reduce the precedent effect of Infineon.

The first question referred to the Enlarged Board seeks to test Board 3.5.07′s view that “a technical effect requires a direct link with physical reality” and that it is not enough for technical character that a technical (i.e. physical) system is simulated. However, a negative answer to this question would imply that no modelling or simulation inventions were patentable.

The second question, to be addressed if the Enlarged Board considers that something more than merely simulating a technical system is required, asks what more is required. The question implies that it is at least necessary that the simulation be based on technical principles underlying the systems. This would perhaps exclude some recent cases relating economic modelling of wind farms and mobile phone networks.

The final question addresses the common fall-back position in simulation and design cases: to include a step of manufacturing or controlling something physical. This has long been thought to be a safe port of last resort, especially since the UK case of Halliburton v Comptroller-General of Patents [2011] EWHC 2508 (Pat). If the Enlarged Board were to decide that inclusion of such features is not sufficient to save a claim to a design or simulation method, a great many cases would be affected.

The problem is, Campinos has already made himself a bad reputation for tantrums, irrational firings, and probably a better masked Battistelli-like temper. Remember Judge Corcoran? He was attacked by Battistelli just before he could finalise his decision to reject a software patent of an EPO partner. How can his colleagues rule peacefully against patent maximalism? It’s not the “safe” option when governed by brutes like Battistelli and his French friends.

Share in other sites/networks: These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.
  • Reddit
  • email

Decor ᶃ Gemini Space

Below is a Web proxy. We recommend getting a Gemini client/browser.

Black/white/grey bullet button This post is also available in Gemini over at this address (requires a Gemini client/browser to open).

Decor ✐ Cross-references

Black/white/grey bullet button Pages that cross-reference this one, if any exist, are listed below or will be listed below over time.

Decor ▢ Respond and Discuss

Black/white/grey bullet button If you liked this post, consider subscribing to the RSS feed or join us now at the IRC channels.

DecorWhat Else is New


  1. [Meme] The B4 Summit: Baltic Benoît Battistelli in Belarus

    It should not be surprising that when Benoît Battistelli and António Campinos get to 'fix' their own election by the EPO‘s Administrative Council that very same Administrative Council will later rubber-stamp virtually every proposal of theirs, even unlawful proposals



  2. Links 20/9/2021: Telegram Desktop 3.1, Arcan as Operating System Design

    Links for the day



  3. [Meme] Looting Europe and Taking Away From the Office

    The staff of the EPO is being robbed by corrupt officials, who arrogantly assume that they can get away with anything (because they have facilitators all over Europe)



  4. IRC Proceedings: Sunday, September 19, 2021

    IRC logs for Sunday, September 19, 2021



  5. Formally Challenging the EPO and Microsoft for Apparent Efforts to Suppress Reporting With Evidence of Crimes, Including Violations of EPO Data Protection Guidelines

    The largest cross-institutional European den of corruption, the EPO, will be hearing from lawyers and hopefully from public officials too. The criminal behaviour is long overdue for review and the Administrative Council too should be investigated (for repeatedly abetting this behaviour, for personal gain).



  6. Links 20/9/2021: Linux 5.15 RC2 and pgAdmin 4 5.7 Released

    Links for the day



  7. [Meme] Warning - Tree Felling in Progress

    Warming up for our next EPO series



  8. Links 19/9/2021: Sparky 2021.09, Whisker Menu 2.6.0, HarfBuzz 3.0, and gThumb 3.12

    Links for the day



  9. EPO Management is Hiding Under the 'Cloud' While Violating Privacy Laws

    Facing a barrage of scrutiny for outsourcing the EPO's systems to Microsoft, the EPO has just arranged yet another expensive PR stunt, looking to somehow 'normalise' the unacceptable and the likely illegal



  10. Maintenance and Development Updates

    We've been doing a lot of work on the back end (or operations) of Techrights, more so this past month, and we're almost ready to resume the normal publication pace



  11. [Meme] Microsoft Says Its Paying Clients (Like EPO) Don't Violate Privacy Law

    The ever-so-docile EPO will gladly oblige when companies like Microsoft lie about the legality of their industrial espionage operations, masked as “clown” computing (and other buzzwords)



  12. Coming Soon: EPO Series on Lawlessness

    Some time soon we’ll start an important series about the EPO, seeing that the management of the EPO is panicking and trying to put out the fire created by prior ones (more on that shortly)



  13. Links 19/9/2021: Jolla's Sailfish OS 4.2 and FreeBSD Technology Roadmap

    Links for the day



  14. IRC Proceedings: Saturday, September 18, 2021

    IRC logs for Saturday, September 18, 2021



  15. Links 18/9/2021: LibreOffice 8.0 Plans and Microsoftcosm Uses WSL to Badmouth 'Linux'

    Links for the day



  16. Links 18/9/2021: GIMP 2.10.28 Released and Azure Remains Back Doored

    Links for the day



  17. IRC Proceedings: Friday, September 17, 2021

    IRC logs for Friday, September 17, 2021



  18. Links 17/9/2021: Ubuntu 18.04.6 LTS, Manjaro 21.1.3, “2021 is the Year of Linux on the Desktop”

    Links for the day



  19. Links 17/9/2021: WSL Considered Harmful

    Links for the day



  20. [Meme] Microsoft Loves Linux Bug/Back Doors

    Microsoft is just cementing its status as little but an NSA stooge



  21. Lagrange Makes It Easier for Anybody to Use Gemini and Even Edit Pages (With GUI)

    Gemini protocol and/or Gemini space are easy for anyone to get started with or fully involved in (writing and creating, not just reading); today we take a look at the new version of Lagrange (it was first introduced here back in March and covered again in April), which I installed earlier today because it contains a lot of improvements, including the installation process (now it’s just a click-to-run AppImage)



  22. IBM is Imploding But It Uses Microsoft-Type Methods to Hide the Demise (Splits, Buybacks, and Rebranding Stunts)

    A combination of brain drain (exodus) and layoffs (a lack of budget combined with inability to retain talent or attract the necessary staff with sufficiently competitive salaries) dooms IBM; but the media won't be mentioning it, partly because a lot of it is still directly sponsored by IBM



  23. IRC Proceedings: Thursday, September 16, 2021

    IRC logs for Thursday, September 16, 2021



  24. [Meme] 70 Days of Non-Compliance

    António Campinos would rather fall on his sword than correct the errors or work to undo the damage caused by Team Battistelli, which is still at the EPO



  25. EPO “Board 28” Meeting: Imaginary Dialogue Between EPO President Campinos and the Chair of the Administrative Council, Josef Kratochvíl

    The EPO‘s chaotic state, which persists after Benoît Battistelli‘s departure, is a state of lawlessness and cover-up



  26. Links 16/9/2021: Linux Mint Has New Web Site, LibreOffice 7.2.1, KDE Plasma 5.23 Beta, and Sailfish OS Verla

    Links for the day



  27. If Git Can be Done Over the Command Line and E-mail, It Can Also be Done Over Gemini (Instead of Bloated Web Browsers)

    In order to keep Git lean and mean whilst at the same time enabling mouse (mousing and clicking) navigation we encourage people everywhere to explore gemini://



  28. Techrights Examines a Wide Array/Range of Gemini Clients/Browsers

    After spending many months examining an array of different types of software for Gemini (including but not limited to clients/browsers) we take stock of what exists, what's supported (it varies a bit), and which one might be suitable for use by geeks and non-geeks



  29. Links 16/9/2021: KStars 3.5.5 and Chafa 1.8

    Links for the day



  30. Trusting Microsoft With Security is a Clown Show

    A quick and spontaneous video about this morning's post regarding a major new revelation that reaffirms a longstanding trend; Microsoft conflates national security (back doors) with security


RSS 64x64RSS Feed: subscribe to the RSS feed for regular updates

Home iconSite Wiki: You can improve this site by helping the extension of the site's content

Home iconSite Home: Background about the site and some key features in the front page

Chat iconIRC Channel: Come and chat with us in real time

Recent Posts