Patent Defence Cartels Versus Abolishing Software Patents

Dr. Roy Schestowitz

2011-05-13 16:25:48 UTC
Modified: 2011-05-13 16:25:48 UTC

Summary: Why the "Defensive Patent License" is not part of the solution to the problem Free software is having

"Fighting patents one by one will never eliminate the danger of software patents, any more than swatting mosquitoes will eliminate malaria," Richard Stallman famously alleged. This is why all those patents boosters who claim to be gathering "defensive" patents are totally missing the point or simply lying to everyone. Consider Novell for example. One year it claims to be "defending" Linux with OIN and the following year it sells those patents to Microsoft. Yes, that's "defensive" for you. Take Sun as another example. Those so-called "defensive" patents it had on Java are now being used to sue Google, which happens to share a seat with Oracle inside the OIN. What a failure. And then there are the Microsoft scams, which the company uses to pretend that it's safe to step in Microsoft patents. Nathan Willis helps promote Mono software from a Novell employee despite the fact that Microsoft's MCP leaves legal holes. Legal analyses of that show it to be useless.

There is yet another one of those "defensive" pools and it calls itself (or its proposition) the Defensive Patent License (DPL), which was mentioned here before [1, 2, 3]. It has just given the following talk, as expected.

Direct link (TinyOgg could not do conversion to Ogg, unfortunately)

I have listened to the entire talk and it still falls short of actually eliminating software patents. The speakers are lovable people, but they unhelpfully speak about "Intellectual Property" and parrot some pro-patents talking points. They do not address the issue, or hardly ever do. It's more like a defensive pool, of which there are already several. They try to find legal mechanisms to reduce risk without actually questioning the status quo, instead just taking for granted software patents. They also do not propose much of a solution to patent trolls. As we noted last night, Yahoo! managed to beat one such troll (who targeted Linux), but this is not a sustainable strategy. Linux is already being taxed by some software patents and Red Hat, for example, hides this fact. So did Novell. Software patents need to be eliminated urgently, without exceptions. The FFII, the FSFE and the FSF got it right all along. ⬆

Threats From 'Former' Red Hat (Now IBM) Staff While IBM's Likely Accounting Fraud Attracts Public Scrutiny: We must be getting "warm"
Matthew J. Garrett Has Just Sent a Threat to Put My Wife and I in Prison Because His Own Spouse Says He's a Rapist: What really intimidates him is his own spouse
Amended Input From Software Freedom Institute for EU Consultation on Free Software: "On 3 February 2026 Software Freedom Institute lodged a submission with the European Commission's inquiry into Open Digital Ecosystems"
Nadella's Mindless PR Spam Ahead of the Layoffs 'Snowball' (Adding Up Batches) Turning Into an Avalanche: Based on recent observations, the more puff pieces we see about Nadella, the closer we get to Microsoft "pulling the trigger" on mass layoffs
When Happens to Red Hat If (or When) IBM Collapses: IBM is in flux because its CFO is now implicated in what seems like accounting fraud
IRC Proceedings: Wednesday, February 11, 2026: IRC logs for Wednesday, February 11, 2026
IBM's Stock is Crashing: If it follows the trajectory of its satellite Kyndryl, it can fall and reach as low as $75
Gemini Links 11/02/2026: Sunny Morning and "KiCad Aims to Ease Linux Installation": Links for the day
Microsoft Loses Ground in Switzerland: One issue is, Google and Apple seem to gain at Microsoft's expense
Microsoft Layoffs Must be Very Near (and Very Large): just like IBM
Bringing Attention/Awareness of EPO Corruption and Cocaine Use to the Mainstream Media: What has Europe become? Prey to vultures?
The Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA) Delusion - Part V - Everyone Seems to Agree That SRA is a Sham: We're going to start a new series soon
A Can of WORMS - Part V - Up Next: The Comeback of RMS in the United States: Guess who funds the cancellers
Gemini Links 11/02/2026: Terminator Trilogy and Lagrange in the Apple App Store: Links for the day
Links 11/02/2026: Fentanylware (CheeTok) for ICE, Jimmy Lai Shows Journalism Became 'Crime' in Hong Kong: Links for the day
With Firefox Measured at 2% in the United Kingdom Time is Running Out for Web Site Support for Gecko/Servo Users: The open Web is rapidly dying while Mozilla celebrates and champions slop
Lawsuit reactions: EFF behaviour reveals zombification, censorship: Reprinted with permission from Daniel Pocock
Links 11/02/2026: $700 Billion Slop Bill, Social Control Media Under Political Fire for Deliberate Health Harms: Links for the day
Mobbing at the European Patent Office (EPO) - Part VI - Attacks on Staff and Attacks on the Law Merit Another New Series: new series coming shortly
IBM's Financial Engineering (Accounting Fraud) Shell, Kyndryl Holdings Inc, is Insolvent: If this was done by the very same people who still run IBM, can we expect any better from "Sugar Daddy" IBM?
2026 a Very Productive Year and We Have Many Big Stories to Tell: maybe we'll produce 8,000 new articles/pages by year's end
Clownflare is in Trouble as Its Debt More Than Doubled in Less Than a Year, Expect Further Enshittification: Clownflare isn't free
After the Next Wave of Microsoft Layoffs Washington State Could be #1 for US Layoffs: Microsoft Corp shares were down yesterday
EPO's Local Staff Committee The Hague (LSCTH): The EPO is Generally “Managed by Excel” (Microsoft): The current management has basically defined corruption to be "success"
With an IBM Company Down Over 75% After Apparent Accounting Fraud the IBM Insiders Want Answers From James Krabanaugh: He has no technical qualifications
Over at Tux Machines...: GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Tuesday, February 10, 2026: IRC logs for Tuesday, February 10, 2026
A "horrible week (hebdomada horribilis?) for the Solicitors Regulation Authority" (SRA): The SRA is part of the SLAPP problem
EPO's Central Staff Committee (CSC) on EPO Social Dialogue: They've refrained from mentioning the industrial actions
Google Still Helping the Slop Pyramid Scheme, Encouraging Plagiarism Too: Google is a plagiarism company and it wants public solidarity for plagiarism by LLMs
The Register MS is Promoting Ponzi Scheme for Financial Fraud/Accounting Fraud Company, The Register MS Gets Paid to Do This: Published 6 hours ago
IBM's Kyndryl Managed to Fall to Less Than a Quarter of Its Past Year's High: Imagine IBM falling to $75
Gemini Links 10/02/2026: "The Luminous Dead", Matrix, and Containers: Links for the day
Links 10/02/2026: Media Freedom Feels Dead in Hong Kong and Grammys, Superbowl Becoming Politics: Links for the day
Kyndryl CFO Harsh Chugh Comes From IBM (17+ Years): Who would want such a position?
IBM RAs (or PIPs) in London, England?: They try to keep the lid on it
International Buybacks Machines: Will the current US administration/regime look into IBM's accounting or only its mini me's?
IBM Could be the Next Kyndryl, a Dinosaur With Accounting Fraud: Many shareholders (or even pension funds) are taking a big hit today
Ian Murdock Died in San Francisco 10 Years Ago. Cops Led to His Death.: 10 years ago Ian Murdock died after cops had messed him up
US/Europe divergence: health & safety, criminality & Debian harassment culture: Open Digital Ecosystems submission F33370170: Reprinted with permission from Daniel Pocock
Links 10/02/2026: Splinternets and "Meta Goes to Trial in a New Mexico Child Safety Case": Links for the day
Russia and China Best Off Without GAFAM: What if they abandoned GAFAM?
Will Finns Put Out the Online Cigarettes?: More people recognise that the child porn site formerly known as "Twitter" and Cheeto/Pooh-tin controlled TikTok are no longer trustworthy
As the US Economy Sags Microsoft Layoffs Carry on (Now in Larger Waves Like 15,000 Per Season or 30,000+ Per Year): They try to avoid "negative" topics
GNU/Linux at 3.99% in Australia: now that Australians can no longer keep Vista 10
Microsoft Windows Falling: analytics.usa.gov Shows Rapid Erosion of Windows Market Share Since 'End of 10' (Vista 10)
Microsoft Windows Hits All-Time Low in The Netherlands in 2026: Europe needs to rid itself or wean itself off GAFAM
SRA: SLAPPs From Russian War Criminals and American Men Who Strangle Women Are Acceptable: The SRA, by inaction, is complicit in this
The Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA) Delusion - Part IV - Machos in Charge of the House (and System), Even If the Faces Are Female (Optics): basically a Windows/Microsoft (US) shop
From Weber Shandwick (Microsoft PR) to Brett Wilson LLP (Hired Gun of the Serial Strangler of Microsoft): they basically tried to charge me a lot of money for a PR project of someone who strangled women
The Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA) is Not a Regulator, It's Part of the Litigation "Industry" in the UK (They Overlap Each Other): Does nothing except talk about SLAPPs
Brett Wilson LLP Seems to Have Done for Roberto Foa What It Did a Year Earlier for the Serial Strangler from Microsoft: Repeat abusers (of the legal system) will misuse it as long as regulators do nothing
In Finland, Microsoft Falls Behind Yandex (Russia): Bing has had many layoffs in recent years
Security More Advanced in Geminispace Than on the Web (Bloat): For real security, use Geminispace capsules, not Web sites
Slop at Microsoft is a Miserable Failure, Now Microsoft Takes the "Vista Route" (Paying People to Say Good Things About It): This is brainwash, it's meant to delay the implosion of the bubble
Rumours About February 2026 Microsoft Layoffs: Silent Layoffs or 30,000 Culled Tomorrow: Sooner or later (and soon) Microsoft will need to say something and file some WARN notifications
GNU/Linux at 12% in Guam, Based on statCounter (Compared to 2-3% a Year Ago): Guam's "uptick" in GNU/Linux usage started weeks after "end of 10"
Where We Stand With the Winter Series: We'll need to protect names and sources
Fighting Slop With the Public Domain (and Why Slopfarms Perish Faster Than New Ones Appear): We can combat the nonsense by producing more human-made works until the slop bubble implodes
After Employee Reviews at IBM Staff Expects Another Large Wave of PIPs and "RAs" (Layoffs): From what we can see in the "public Web"
Gemini Links 10/02/2026: "The Last Messiah", Discord for Adults: Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...: GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Monday, February 09, 2026: IRC logs for Monday, February 09, 2026
Is Europe Abandoning Digital Opium?: GAFAM-controlled social control media

Patent Defence Cartels Versus Abolishing Software Patents

Recent Techrights' Posts