After Alice, Patent Trial and Appeal Board is Invalidating Software Patents and Other Abstract Patents

Dr. Roy Schestowitz

2016-02-29 13:00:44 UTC
Modified: 2016-02-29 13:00:44 UTC

PTAB

Summary: A quick look at the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) and why patent lawyers, patent trolls (who typically use software patents) and other patent aggressors are afraid of it, more so after Alice (a landmark 2014 case against abstract software patents)

THOSE who are not patent lawyers might not know that PTAB, according to Wikipedia, "was formed on September 16, 2012 as one part of the America Invents Act."

"Patent lawyers, suffice to say, are growing nervous and comparing PTAB to all sorts of terrible things."That was less than a couple of years before Alice, which effectively killed many software patents in the US (and shed doubt on the rest). The EPO too has boards of appeal, even though Battistelli seems to be trying to crush them (the unfilled open positions strategy, as the BBC reported on earlier today -- the latest round of Tories versus NHS), possibly because of the UPC (some speculations insinuate this). At the same time he opens the door to software patents, which the boards have historically been relatively sceptical/critical of.

According to this new article from the EFF: "Today EFF filed our response brief in the appeal of our successful challenge to Personal Audio’s podcasting patent. Back in April 2015, the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) ruled in our favor and invalidated all of the patent claims we challenged. Personal Audio appealed this decision to the Federal Circuit."

We covered this at the time (April 2015, just under a year after Alice) and we were pleased with the outcome. Patent lawyers, suffice to say, are growing nervous and comparing PTAB to all sorts of terrible things.

"Watch what a tragedy this has become for business method and software patents."Consider this MIP article titled "PTAB taking a harder line on CBM institution". It says: "More covered business method petitions are now being denied institution by the Patent Trial and Appeal Board than granted, with the Board seemingly narrowing what qualifies as a CBM patent" (that's good, but not for patent lawyers).

Also new from MIP is this article titled "Institutional change: PTAB issues to watch in 2016". To quote: "PTAB petition filing has increased every year since the post-grant proceedings became available in September 2012. According to figures from Docket Navigator, a record 1,797 petitions were filed last year, up 7% on the 1,677 filed in 2014. Inter partes review (IPR) petitions accounted for 92% of the filing last year."

Watch what a tragedy this has become for business method and software patents. It's about time. Let the patent lawyers squirm, twist the facts, and whine... ⬆

Rust Outsources its Financing (or Financial Control) to Microsoft: How long before the third "E"?
IBM's Shares Fell Nearly 13% in One Day (Including After Hours): its main product is false promises
European Patent Office (EPO) Series: "Operation Influencer": Costa's political career was far from finished
GNU/Linux Usage Rising Among Gamers, But "Hardware Survey Data Not Available.": Not anymore, not for now anyway
Quantum Quantum Quantum Quantum (Pump, Then Dump): What has IBM become?
KDE Has Long Used Dragons, and Dragons Come From Hatched Eggs: That Microsoft Lunduke tries to paint this as some "trans agenda" thing says a lot about Microsoft Lunduke and his COVID-19-damaged brain
IBM Announces 5 Billion Dollars "Invested" in "AI", in "Security", and 10 Billion Dollars for "Quantum", But IBM Does Not Have This Kind of Money (It's Fake News to Manipulate the Share Price): IBM has fast-growing debt and liabilities, it does not intend to invest this kind of money, it's a smokescreen and false promises timed to alleviate the sagging share price (52-week low)
SLAPP Censorship - Part 97 Out of 200: Garrett in Hiding (From the Simple Observable Fact He's Closely Connected to the Microsofter Who Strangles Women, Tells Women to Kill Themselves, and Worse): They use one another; they are coordinating this via the SLAPP industry in another continent
Links 04/06/2026: Microsoft Threatening Security Researcher for Naming Back Doors in BitLocker, "Demand is Booming for" Old Tech: Links for the day
Gemini Links 04/06/2026: "Word Vomit", Slop", and Moving to Gopher/Gemini: Links for the day
"Format Sovereignty" Can Only be Accomplished With LaTeX or OpenDocument Format (ODF) or Vendor-Neutral Standards for Editable Documents: Microsoft is, in effect, above the law
The Cyber Show on the Importance of Software Freedom and Why GNU/Linux Could Not be Stopped: an excellent article
Drew DeVault Can Still Redeem His Reputation. Revisiting His Attacks (and Attack Site) on Richard Stallman Might be a Good Start.: DeVault has openly apologised (this past spring)
The Register MS is Publishing Paid SPAM; Some of It is Designed to Prop Up the "AI" Pyramid Scheme: The Register MS participates in scams
Over at Tux Machines...: GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Wednesday, June 03, 2026: IRC logs for Wednesday, June 03, 2026
Jumping Up and Down on the Shoulders of Giants, Never Talking About What Bill Gates Did: We're back to 2019
Despite LLM Slop or Chatbots, Our Traffic Has Doubled Since We Moved Everything to the UK (in 2023): The demise of news sites was not what we thought it would be
Software Developers Attacked by Plagiarism Engines Because These Developers Can Teach People How to Exercise Control, Not Outsource to Monopolies of Slop and Back Doors: "Universities should be telling industry what is to be done next, not the other way about. Present education policy has the tail wagging the dog."
Communicating With Freedom - Part I - Developing “Quibble” and Improving GNU LibreJS in the Process: In the next part we shall examine where things currently stand
Quantum Computers Are "All the Rage" (35 Years Ago, What IBM Promises This Year is What People Promised When the CEO Was in His 20s): "Quantum" hype is high on the agenda
How IBM Removes 15% of Its Staff Without Even Checking Performance of Staff (or Calling That "Layoffs"): Performance Improvement Plan (PIP) as veiled RAs
Links 03/06/2026: Mobile Systems, Openwashing, and New Antenna: Links for the day
Canonical as Reseller of Back Doors in "Ubuntu" Clothing: Microsoft is the antithesis of security and autonomy
Romania Used to be Windows Stronghold, But That's No Longer the Case: Windows was once upon a time so ubiquitous that institutions didn't bother supporting anything except it
When Science and Religion Are on the Same Side, United Against Slop Pushers: The "Mathematics Pope" (sometimes known as "Pope Pi") brought together science and religion, united against technofascists who are mostly college drop-outs who abhor women
Links 03/06/2026: "In Turkey, Criticizing a Corporation Can Land You in Jail" and "Court Bans X Account of Turkey's Oldest Newspaper": Links for the day
Web Censorship Benefits the Corrupt and the Criminal: More so when corrupt politicians are in charge
Have a "Lifetime" Without Microsoft: The online rage over this is still ongoing
Internet Archive’s Wayback Machine Undoing Censorship of Corporate Wrongdoing: That won't go away anymore
"For Entertainment Purposes Only" But Everyone Must Adopt It for Work and Governance, Say Anti-Scientific Technocrats: "The present mentality around "AI" is like driving to the gym to use a treadmill - it's walking for people who hate fresh air and beautiful changing scenery."
Gemini Links 03/06/2026: Ian Murdock's Ex-wife Footprint in Debian and Alhena 5.6.1 Released: Links for the day
Irish Company statCounter Recognises It Overestimated Microsoft Windows' Market Share in Ireland: it seems like the Irish people are gradually moving away from Windows
Corporate Media Participates in the Lie That Mass Layoffs at GitLab and Loss of Geographic Footprint in More Than a Third of Countries is "AI" and Thus "Success Story": There's no way to spin this as positive news
Slop Prompting is Not a Coding Skill and Slop Deserves Shunning: Red Hat is hypocritically shunning the very same thing it keeps promoting
IBM colleagues "handed out a PIP and then right after the end date they are gone": Some go into early 'retirement' to save face
SLAPP Censorship - Part 96 Out of 200: When You Receive Death Threats From Anonymous Sockpuppets/Burner Accounts Connected to People Who Strangle Women and Tell Women to Kill Themselves: Women are not objects and my wife ought not be mentioned in "threats to kill" (how cops have described this)
European Patent Office (EPO) Series: A Tale of Two Antónios - Introducing the Other António: António Costa
Over at Tux Machines...: GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Tuesday, June 02, 2026: IRC logs for Tuesday, June 02, 2026
Advertisements as Articles in The Register MS: Trust in media
Social Control Media Does Not Improve Reach, It Wastes a Lot of Time: many people still think that no presence in Social Control Media necessarily means invisibility
Links 02/06/2026: New York Times Debunks "Hey Hi (AI) Layoffs" (Excuse, False Narrative), Sheinbaum Publicly Bemoans US Meddling: Links for the day
Despite Mass Layoffs and Culls Dubbed "Buyouts" Google's Debt Doubled in a Year and It's Desperate for Money (to Pay Salaries and Bills): Google and GAFAM in general have mass layoffs because they have no clear route towards profitability
Gemini Links 02/06/2026: Arch Linux WriterDeck and Papyrix Reader: Links for the day
Bloggers Still Have Considerable Impact on This Planet: Nowadays, in academia almost anywhere in the world, there's growing expectation that lecturers will spend not much of the time doing research or even teaching
The Firing Line Against Techrights: Tomorrow we'll tell a story about campaigns to intimidate us with death threats
The Cyber Show on the Fight Against Technofascism: It's very long (all combined), but nevertheless refreshing
What Efforts to Cancel Richard Stallman Ought to Teach Us About the Media, Including Very Large British Publishers: Richard Stallman is like a modern-age Alfred Dreyfus
After Threats to Greenland Northern Europe Seems to be Moving Away From Microsoft Windows Even Faster: The facts on the ground are, more people/businesses/institutions "get the message"
Claim of 500+ IBM Red Hat Layoffs With Termination Next Month: IBM is doing great... at hiding internal affairs
Slop Did Not Rewire Democracy, It's a Giant Flop: we already see slop giants accepting they'll never make money
The Register MS Embeds in Articles "SPONSORED LINKS" That Link to "AI" Ponzi Scheme/Scam: The circular financing giants are allocating budget for the spam, as do the banks (lenders)
Many Countries Divest From Microsoft: new numbers at statCounter today
European Patent Office (EPO) Series: A Tale of Two Antónios - On the Campaign Trail in Brussels: Part 1
SEO is an Acronym That Stands for Slop Engine Orientation: The Web changed a lot when Web directories, portals, and then social control media gained popularity
IRC Network OFTC is Shedding Off Servers: Down to 17
Julian Assange's Counsel Jennifer Robinson Has Just Won an Award: Jennifer Robinson is relatively young
Schweizerische Bundesbahnen (Swiss Federal Railways) and Richard Stallman: It seems like RMS is receiving endorsement or at least belated recognition from very high-profile institutions
Almost 30 Years After Rob Malda Made Slashdot It Still Inspires New Implementations: Maybe the issue isn't Slash per se, just the complexity of it (which SoylentNews complained about in the past)
Links 02/06/2026: "The Infosec Phrasebook", 'Perfect Randomness' and "Leaving the Tech World Professionally": Links for the day
Faking Demand for Slop: Google's Search Prompt Becomes Slop Prompt (Bait, Switch, Fake Usage): If there is no consent, then it's unsustainable
When You Give People (or Companies) Money to Buy Your Own Products and Then Call It "Revenue": A lot of modern "economics" don't benefit ordinary people (all they get is high inflation rates); they're devaluing money by faking economic activity
IBM is Self-Detonating, the Cheeto-Infused Rally is Another Con by Don: pump and dump
"Quantum" as the "Next Big" Bubble: disappointing and delivering nothing
Links 02/06/2026: "$1.5 Trillion Defense Budget Benefits Billionaire Cheeto Mussolini Supporters", US "Plans to Criminalize Sleeping Outside": Links for the day
Gemini Links 02/06/2026: Organising Oneself and Killing Off Distracting "Notifications": Links for the day
SLAPP Censorship - Part 95 Out of 200: The Growing Risk of Tolerating Men Who Abuse and Physically Assault Women: FOSS should not be a "safe harbour" or "hideout" for criminals
Over at Tux Machines...: GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Monday, June 01, 2026: IRC logs for Monday, June 01, 2026

After Alice, Patent Trial and Appeal Board is Invalidating Software Patents and Other Abstract Patents

Recent Techrights' Posts