The GNOME Foundation Arguably Gave a Patent Troll Even More Legitimacy by Settling and Failing to Dismantle Shoddy Software Patents

Dr. Roy Schestowitz

2020-09-11 02:28:19 UTC
Modified: 2020-09-11 02:28:19 UTC

They've legally endorsed software patents

Summary: The IBM-connected GNOME Foundation wants us to think that letting a troll out on the loose is good news or "victory"; but actually, the patents of the troll are still in tact, posing a threat to many and setting no useful precedent (they technically settled over software patents)

THE other day I saw the post -- a belated but very detailed post -- about the GNOME Foundation's patent lawsuit (and counter-suit). It's from an IBMer and we know that IBM is a HUGE fan of software patents. It lobbies for them constantly, not only in the US but everywhere in the world. I was tempted to respond but did not do so until I saw the above video segment. It's a video that I do not fully agree with and mostly disagree with for reasons specified several times before in relation to this particular lawsuit. Basically, the GNOME Foundation amassed a lot of money for a pro bono fight; there's no disclosure/explanation what happened to all that money.

"It may seem like a win for Shotwell, but it's a loss for the overall battle against software patents and arguably, at least by extension, a loss for programming, including Free software."More importantly, however, the patent troll was left with the shoddy patents (not a single one was thrown out), free to sue lots of companies provided their products aren't licensed as Free software or 'open source' (as per the OSI's definition). What's more, the troll got a zero-cost settlement, which can be used as a sort of 'ammo' proving the supposed 'value' of the patent/s at hand. So the GNOME Foundation did not actually complete the job; as IBM or OIN would have liked, they did not challenge software patents and in fact left the troll on the loose. It may seem like a win for Shotwell, but it's a loss for the overall battle against software patents and arguably, at least by extension, a loss for programming, including Free software. That troll is still out there with all those patents. Since GNOME is mostly controlled by IBM (or formerly Red Hat), this whole thing shows how IBM policies supersede Red Hat's. Bruce Perens recently highlighted those problems with OIN, which basically guards software patents from/against Free software-led reforms.

In this particular case the patent could be squashed using prior art, obviousness, and/or abstractness (Sections 101-103), but no such effort was followed through. Microsoft too was reportedly involved. Moreover, the troll in question received these patents from Microsoft's troll, as we noted several times in the past.

The media never bothered covering this properly. Shallow journalism has become the norm, appeasing big sponsors. ⬆

EPO "Cocaine Communication Manager" - Part I - Getting the Word Out About What the 'Alicante Mafia' Did to Europe's Second-Largest Institution: Can't everyone in the European media agree that letting cokeheads run Europe's second-largest institution is a terrible idea?
Google Promoting Slop, Not Journalism: The truth of the matter is, Google is part of this problem and it doesn't seem to care
Another IBM Company (Spawned by IBM) is Hiding the Scale of Layoffs, Just Like Red Hat and Kyndryl: Why is the scale of the layoffs there shrouded in secrecy?
Links 14/02/2026: Financial Woes in Hong Kong and "Hong Kong Journalists Face ‘Precarious’ Future After Jimmy Lai Jailed": Links for the day
Gemini Links 14/02/2026: Fish Shell and Meta Slash-commands: Links for the day
Links 14/02/2026: "Bias and Toxicity in" Slop, Microsoft's Vista 11 System Update Breaks Systems Again: Links for the day
Links 14/02/2026: "Suppression of Free Speech" and "Climate Change Puts Winter Games on Thin Ice": Links for the day
Richard Stallman in the United States - Part I - Huge Audience (Offline and Online), 'Cancel Culture' Attempted and Failed: the comeback of Richard Stallman (RMS) in the United States
GitHub Cannot Survive for Much Longer: Microsoft is trying to just hide the debt
Ed Zitron: Microsoft Is A Decaying Empire That Bet The Future On Making In Excess Of $500 Billion In New Revenue Within The Next 4 To 6 Years From AI — And It Hasn’t Made A Dime In Profit Yet: Microsoft bets its future on a bunch of nothing
Over at Tux Machines...: GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Friday, February 13, 2026: IRC logs for Friday, February 13, 2026
Gemini Links 14/02/2026: "Throwback VR Headset" and OFFLFIRSOCH 2026: Links for the day
IBM's Accounting Claims Don't Add Up: IBM is an enigma. To Wall Street is claims to be doing extremely well, but insiders tell the complete opposite.
Links 13/02/2026: "Cofounders Fleeing MElon’s xAI" and IOC Opposes Solidarity With Ukraine's Fallen: Links for the day
IBM is Becoming "Garbage In, Garbage Out" (GIGO) "Just like Arvind and Krabanaugh." (CEO and CFO, Respectively): There are some decent new comments about IBM this morning
Gemini Links 13/02/2026: Square Function with Diode Network and Calls Against Discord: Links for the day
Links 13/02/2026: SUSE Uses Microsoft Internally, MElon's Company Helps Turn Epstein Files Into Child Abuse (After the Pornography Scandals): Links for the day
If Your Company Lost About 30% of Its 'Value' in 3 Months, Then Maybe It Was Never Worth What You Claimed: Does that make sense?
Pleroma is Dying: The last social control media that I joined was Pleroma
African Browser Choices Show a Growing Problem in the World Wide Web: World Wide Web (WWW) becoming little but a transport layer for a particular proprietary application (Google Chrome) [...] we're back to the late 1990s
Asia and Social Control Media: statCounter reckons it's down from over 10% to just 3% since it began tracking those things
If You Want Digital Freedom, Then Follow Richard Stallman, the "Linux" Brand Has Changed and OSI is Microsoft (GitHub): If you want something stable and predictable, then stick with GNU, the GPL, and GCC
Solicitors Disciplinary Tribunal and SRA Failing to Curb SLAPPs Against People Who Expose Wrongdoing: We'll soon show messages that we transmitted to politicians
Beware the Latest IBM SPAM, IBM is Already Down "After Hours": After a harsh day in Wall Street IBM's shares area already down again (after trading hours)
Radicalism in Our Communities is Mostly Corporate, Not Grassroots: Infiltration and systematic destruction can be shallowly painted as "inducing manners"
Anonymous Threats Against My Wife and Against Yours Truly: Promoting GNU/Linux and condemning people who attack GNU/Linux is not a crime
Decades-Long Microsofter (Darryl K. Taft) and TIOBE Conflate Microsoft GitHub (Proprietary) With FOSS in Microsoft-Sponsored 'News' Site: We do not intend to do a lengthy debunking because we covered this subject several times in the past
Life Gets Better After Social Control Media: Don't become part of these experiments
statCounter Suggests Americans Are Dumping Social Control Media: Are Americans getting fed up with social control media and quitting in droves?
Back Doors and Fake Security: They've militarised everything, even people's home computers
Cost-Cutting and Book-Cooking at IBM: It's like cutting salaries by more than 50%
Over at Tux Machines...: GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Thursday, February 12, 2026: IRC logs for Thursday, February 12, 2026
Microsoft Cuts Continue, Visitor Center in Redmond Shut Down: This goes on and on, leading up to the next giant wave of mass layoffs
Mainstream Media Intentionally Ignoring EPO Strikes: “EPO on Strike!”
Jeffrey Epstein crypto disclosure: uncanny timing, Bitcoin demise, pump-and-dump, ponzi schemes: Reprinted with permission from Daniel Pocock
Gemini Links 12/02/2026: Avoiding Coffee, Trying Ubuntu, and "Open Source Robot": Links for the day
Microsoft Slop CEO Speaks of Layoffs: They will go along with the "replaced by AI" baloney
In Systematic Contempt of the British High Court, Brett Wilson LLP Spent Two Years Lying to Courts and Breaking Rules Against Us: We criticise Brett Wilson LLP quite lot because of its conduct
IBM Kyndryl as "Aggressive “Enron” Accounting": IBM Kyndryl continues to nosedive today
Relationships evidence: Tiago, Tassia, Thais, Antonio & Debian favoritism, nepotism: Reprinted with permission from Daniel Pocock
Debian pregnancy cluster: why it is public interest: Reprinted with permission from Daniel Pocock
IBM Bubble Deflating After James Kavanaugh's Accounting Trick With 'Toxic Assets' Comes Under SEC Scrutiny: If something goes up based on false speculations, bonus numbers and self-serving lies, then it'll come back down, eventually...
The EPO's Corruption and Violation of Rules is Spreading to the United Kingdom (Software Patents): Yesterday a letter was sent to the chief regarding salaries while reminding him of the next strike, which is only 11 days away
State of the Slop, Slopfarms Containment: Slopfarms still exist this year, but their visibility is limited
IBM Continues Tanking Today, Already $58+ Lower Than Recent High, Insiders Explain Why: The same CFO from the inception of Kyndryl is still the CFO at IBM
Links 12/02/2026: Pushback Against, "NATO Is Expected to Step Up Arctic Security": Links for the day
Links 12/02/2026: "Microsoft Just Forked Windows" and Windows Notepad is a Giant Security Hole: Links for the day
Put Criminals in Prison, Not People Who Report the Crimes: Can people be sent to prison for opposing crime?
Windows Has Become Increasingly Irrelevant: There's a very massive wave of layoffs coming Microsoft's way
Our Most Successful Year Ever: The hired guns in London are eager to turn the UK into another China
Slopfarms Waning, But Not Extinct Yet: Metrics show that usage of LLMs is declining
Over at Tux Machines...: GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Wednesday, February 11, 2026: IRC logs for Wednesday, February 11, 2026

The GNOME Foundation Arguably Gave a Patent Troll Even More Legitimacy by Settling and Failing to Dismantle Shoddy Software Patents

Recent Techrights' Posts