04.20.19

Gemini version available ♊︎

Largest Patent Offices Try to Leave Courts in a State of Disarray to Enable the Granting of Fake Patents in the US and Europe

Posted in America, Europe, Law, Patents at 4:00 am by Dr. Roy Schestowitz

Nonsensical patent offices that put the litigation ‘industry’ ahead of the real industry. They’re not representative of the public at all.

French EPO

Summary: Like a monarchy that effectively runs all branches of government the management of the EPO is trying to work around the judiciary; the same is increasingly happening (or at least attempted) in the United States

THE SUBJECT of software patents in Europe goes a long way back. I had written about it before this site even existed, before Brimelow ran the EPO and back in the days another French President (not Battistelli and Campinos) was in charge. He, unlike the latter two, was actually a scientist and one whom the staff generally respected. We wrote a lot about him over the years and showed staff generally respected him (not everyone but many).

The main issue today is that there’s no separation of powers; virtually none. Europe’s patent system became a monstrosity, only limited in part by a court system that is federated and untouched by the EPO’s (and EU’s) clout.

“EPO is also not following the rule of law,” as Benjamin Henrion put it a couple of days ago, and “it is an administration shielded by diplomatic immunity, and cannot be sued for maladministration. And the Commission is supporting this kind of institution for the Unitary Patent, while not even compatible with the treaties…”

“The main issue today is that there’s no separation of powers; virtually none.”The European Patent Office (and Organisation) is just some island inside Europe and it does whatever it pleases, irrespective of the interests and opinions of actual Europeans. Who benefits? Law firms. Not necessarily European ones, either.

Recently we’ve seen lots and lots of ‘articles’ (ads by law firms) about patents on maths, nature, and life. Here in Lexology one can see Bardehle Pagenberg’s Bastian Best continuing his promotion of illegal software patents (as he has done for a decade). Best wrote much more about it a fortnight ago. His employer is probably the loudest proponent of software patents (and has been for quite some time). They even tweeted this before the weekend: “Software patents: How are they examined at the @EPOorg? Here’s our patent attorney @bastianbest explaining the legal framework with simple examples.”

They just look for loopholes and then promote these.

“They just look for loopholes and then promote these.”Kilburn & Strode LLP’s Paul Briscoe and Kristina Cornish meanwhile drool over patents on nature and life — granted illegally or in defiance of the EPC. Kilburn & Strode has also just published this rather crude call to “File! File! File!” So say patent agents who profit from lots of fake patents that are actually worthless but lead to legal bills. File applications, file lawsuits etc. Lexology is full of this nonsense every single day and it says “[t]he clarion call comes from patent attorneys and inventors alike” even though what we have here is lawyers speaking ‘for’ inventors without naming any.

The EPO has meanwhile retweeted this French front group of patent law firms. This year, for the first time, the EPO has been calling for "MedTech" patents — an intentionally misleading term. The EPO pretends software patents are “life-saving” and “for SMEs”, soon to be parroted by this front group which said “Medtech CII event to raise awareness among SMEs…”

It has nothing to do with SMEs, but the EPO and patent maximalists are nowadays cooperating in their shameless propaganda.

We’re meanwhile seeing similar moves in the US. Haynes and Boone LLP’s Chad Hammerlind, for example, has chosen a nonsensical and misleading headline by which to twist the reality surrounding the Federal Circuit. 35 U.S.C. § 101 continues to be followed by courts (see our daily links for the latest examples) and patent maximalists are desperate to find new ways to bypass the courts, in essence pursuing patents they know to be invalid (as per the law).

“It has nothing to do with SMEs, but the EPO and patent maximalists are nowadays cooperating in their shameless propaganda.”Contrary to what these maximalists keep saying in recent days, none of that is changing. The US Congress isn’t bringing software patents back; some readers sent us headsups about it (for Techrights to cover). See the comments at the bottom of this post with a misleading headline from Kevin E. Noonan. These are just a handful of bribed politicians, the usual suspects (the same old ones), trying to push through software patents for their sponsors. They tried and failed. Trying again because it’s spring? There are several more articles like these, e.g. this from Ropes & Gray LLP’s Scott McKeown and several from Watchtroll. Eileen McDermott of Watchtroll says “Change May Be Coming: Members of Congress Release Framework to Fix Patent Eligibility Law,” but they have been saying it for years (around the same time). Each time it makes some headlines it only lasts a few days or weeks but nothing happens at the end; it never happens. It dies after summer recess every time. Each year. What we have here is just a handful of people with ties to the litigation industry who cannot quite tell US Congress what to do on software patents and Eileen McDermott is smart enough to know it. They have tried it for years and failed. As a journalist she should know this. She wrote: “Senators Thom Tillis (R-NC) and Chris Coons (D-DE)—respectively, Chair and Ranking Member of the Senate Judiciary Subcommittee on Intellectual Property—and Representatives Doug Collins (R-GA-9), Ranking Member of the House Judiciary Committee; Hank Johnson (D-GA-4), Chair of the House Judiciary…”

She later wrote another piece titled “Reactions Roll in On Congress’s Proposed 101 Framework: ‘The Right Approach’ or ‘A Swing and a Miss’?”

As if the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) sets the rules for Congress or some people who profit from patent maximalism get to decide on the law which governs them.

Surely McDermott can see what’s happening here, partly in light of comments such as: “As is evident from these comments, reasonable people can differ. Unfortunately the Supreme Court will have the last word (absent amending the Constitution, which won’t happen over a patent question). The Court is not final because it is infallible but rather it is infallible because it is final. And I don’t ever see getting a bunch of patent lawyers on the Court, which may be the only way to bring sanity to this area of the law.”

Dennis Crouch joins the ‘fun’. Yesterday he was trying hard (yet again) to promote this software patents’ alleged ‘revival’ in the US. All these patent maximalists never in their entire life wrote a single line of code. And here they are lending a voice to the politicians who suit their agenda (while demonising the rest). To quote Crouch:

Basics of the framework are to create a defined, closed list of subject matter category exclusions: Fundamental scientific principles; Products that exist solely and exclusively in nature; Pure mathematical formulas; Economic or commercial principles; Mental activities. Under the framework, a patent would not be eligible based upon “simply reciting generic technical language or generic functional language.” At the same time, the framework suggests that “practical applications” should be patent eligible. Finally, the framework calls for a divide-and-conquer approach — making clear “that eligibility is determined by considering each and every element of the claim as a whole and without regard to considerations properly addressed by 102, 103 and 112.”

Surely these patent maximalists’ ‘blogs’ know that it isn’t “new” or “news” at all. Days ago Crouch’s site linked to this article from Malathi Nayak dated March 26th, 2019. It says “Sens. Thom Tillis and Chris Coons have outlined four principles for new patent eligibility legislation in a message to technology and pharmaceutical company representatives and others in advance of a fourth closed-door meeting on their effort.”

“They have been doing this for years (especially Coons) and it never got anywhere.”Their latest press release is dated April 17th, 2019. It involved nontechnical politicians, funded by corporations, working as fronts for law firms. But they call it “bipartisan” (misdirection).

Suffice to say, the patent trolls’ lobby (IAM) participated in this push, but kept it behind paywall (out of critics’ sight). To quote the tweet: “At a well-attended meeting in Washington DC on Wednesday attempts to frame legislation for the reform of the Section 101 patent eligibility regime in the US ran into familiar problems.”

They have been doing this for years (especially Coons) and it never got anywhere. We’ve meanwhile noticed that Gene Quinn came back the other day, only to attack PTAB i.e. the usual. Attacking judges. Watchtroll’s specialty. That there’s a USPTO revolving doors problem isn’t surprising and it’s a shame that Watchtroll does not disclose who it works for, either. That would kind of give away the hypocrisy (“A Story of Ethics and Optics: Former PTAB Judge Matt Clements Now Works for Apple”).

Speaking of nepotism, Iancu has come under fire again.

“Things work a lot better at present than they did before; unless you’re a patent lawyer…”United for Patent Reform wrote: “EFF states that @USPTO’s eligibility guidance “effectively instructs examiners on how to narrow the #Alice v. CLS Bank decision instead of how to apply it correctly,” and calls it “contrary to law.” Read their full comments…”

The EFF has moved on since. In the latest “Stupid Patent of the Month” (titled “How Landmark Technology’s Terrible Patent Has Survived” and composed by Joe Mullin because Daniel Nazer left to join Mozilla) the EFF slams circus clown Iancu whom Donald Trump gave a job after his firm had worked for him. To quote Mullin:

There’s an increasing insistence from the highest echelons of the patent world that patent abuse just isn’t a thing anymore. The Director of the U.S. Patent Office, Andre Iancu, has called patent trolls—a term for companies that do nothing but collect patents and sue others—mere “monster stories,” and suggested in a recent oversight hearing that it was simply name-calling.

But whatever you call them—trolls, non-practicing entities, or patent assertion entities—their business model, which involves stockpiling patents to sue productive companies rather than making goods or services, continues to thrive. It’s not hard to find examples of abusive patent litigation that make clear the threat posed by wrongly-issued patents is very real.

Take, for instance, the patents that Lawrence Lockwood owns. These patents have been used to sue companies, large and small, for nearly 20 years now. Through his company Landmark Technologies and his earlier company PanIP, more than 100 lawsuits have been filed against businesses—candy companies, an educational toy maker, and an organic farm, to name a few. Because these companies engage in “sales and distribution via electronic transactions,” or use an automated system “for processing business and financial transactions,” Landmark says they infringe one of its patents.

Those lawsuits don’t account for the other companies that have received licensing demands, but have not been sued in court. The numerous threats made with Lockwood’s patents are made clear both by news accounts of Lockwood’s activity, as well as the several small business owners that have reached out to EFF after being targeted by Lockwood’s patents.

If the patent microcosm thinks that a handful of not-so-familiar politicians will miraculously change patent law, then the patent microcosm refused to learn from the past. Technical people will stand in their way and 2019 will be yet another year of failed ‘reform’ attempts. Things work a lot better at present than they did before; unless you’re a patent lawyer…

Share in other sites/networks: These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.
  • Reddit
  • email

Decor ᶃ Gemini Space

Below is a Web proxy. We recommend getting a Gemini client/browser.

Black/white/grey bullet button This post is also available in Gemini over at this address (requires a Gemini client/browser to open).

Decor ✐ Cross-references

Black/white/grey bullet button Pages that cross-reference this one, if any exist, are listed below or will be listed below over time.

Decor ▢ Respond and Discuss

Black/white/grey bullet button If you liked this post, consider subscribing to the RSS feed or join us now at the IRC channels.

DecorWhat Else is New


  1. IRC Proceedings: Monday, September 20, 2021

    IRC logs for Monday, September 20, 2021



  2. Links 20/9/2021: Emmabuntüs Debian Edition 4 1.00, DXVK 1.9.2, and NVIDIA 470.74 Graphics Driver

    Links for the day



  3. Richard Stallman's Talk in Ukraine Two Days Ago (in Person)

    Richard Stallman explains his stance on Invidious (released under the AGPLv3) in his new (in-person) talk



  4. Microsoft and the EPO: A History of Threats and Suppression Against the Free Press

    Bribed and blackmailed media isn't covering EPOnia's corruption anymore; somebody should, but that's not as easy as it may seem on the surface (not even for a distant outsider)



  5. [Meme] The B4 Summit: Baltic Benoît Battistelli in Belarus

    It should not be surprising that when Benoît Battistelli and António Campinos get to 'fix' their own election by the EPO‘s Administrative Council that very same Administrative Council will later rubber-stamp virtually every proposal of theirs, even unlawful proposals



  6. Links 20/9/2021: Telegram Desktop 3.1, Arcan as Operating System Design

    Links for the day



  7. [Meme] Looting Europe and Taking Away From the Office

    The staff of the EPO is being robbed by corrupt officials, who arrogantly assume that they can get away with anything (because they have facilitators all over Europe)



  8. IRC Proceedings: Sunday, September 19, 2021

    IRC logs for Sunday, September 19, 2021



  9. Formally Challenging the EPO and Microsoft for Apparent Efforts to Suppress Reporting With Evidence of Crimes, Including Violations of EPO Data Protection Guidelines

    The largest cross-institutional European den of corruption, the EPO, will be hearing from lawyers and hopefully from public officials too. The criminal behaviour is long overdue for review and the Administrative Council too should be investigated (for repeatedly abetting this behaviour, for personal gain).



  10. Links 20/9/2021: Linux 5.15 RC2 and pgAdmin 4 5.7 Released

    Links for the day



  11. [Meme] Warning - Tree Felling in Progress

    Warming up for our next EPO series



  12. Links 19/9/2021: Sparky 2021.09, Whisker Menu 2.6.0, HarfBuzz 3.0, and gThumb 3.12

    Links for the day



  13. EPO Management is Hiding Under the 'Cloud' While Violating Privacy Laws

    Facing a barrage of scrutiny for outsourcing the EPO's systems to Microsoft, the EPO has just arranged yet another expensive PR stunt, looking to somehow 'normalise' the unacceptable and the likely illegal



  14. Maintenance and Development Updates

    We've been doing a lot of work on the back end (or operations) of Techrights, more so this past month, and we're almost ready to resume the normal publication pace



  15. [Meme] Microsoft Says Its Paying Clients (Like EPO) Don't Violate Privacy Law

    The ever-so-docile EPO will gladly oblige when companies like Microsoft lie about the legality of their industrial espionage operations, masked as “clown” computing (and other buzzwords)



  16. Coming Soon: EPO Series on Lawlessness

    Some time soon we’ll start an important series about the EPO, seeing that the management of the EPO is panicking and trying to put out the fire created by prior ones (more on that shortly)



  17. Links 19/9/2021: Jolla's Sailfish OS 4.2 and FreeBSD Technology Roadmap

    Links for the day



  18. IRC Proceedings: Saturday, September 18, 2021

    IRC logs for Saturday, September 18, 2021



  19. Links 18/9/2021: LibreOffice 8.0 Plans and Microsoftcosm Uses WSL to Badmouth 'Linux'

    Links for the day



  20. Links 18/9/2021: GIMP 2.10.28 Released and Azure Remains Back Doored

    Links for the day



  21. IRC Proceedings: Friday, September 17, 2021

    IRC logs for Friday, September 17, 2021



  22. Links 17/9/2021: Ubuntu 18.04.6 LTS, Manjaro 21.1.3, “2021 is the Year of Linux on the Desktop”

    Links for the day



  23. Links 17/9/2021: WSL Considered Harmful

    Links for the day



  24. [Meme] Microsoft Loves Linux Bug/Back Doors

    Microsoft is just cementing its status as little but an NSA stooge



  25. Lagrange Makes It Easier for Anybody to Use Gemini and Even Edit Pages (With GUI)

    Gemini protocol and/or Gemini space are easy for anyone to get started with or fully involved in (writing and creating, not just reading); today we take a look at the new version of Lagrange (it was first introduced here back in March and covered again in April), which I installed earlier today because it contains a lot of improvements, including the installation process (now it’s just a click-to-run AppImage)



  26. IBM is Imploding But It Uses Microsoft-Type Methods to Hide the Demise (Splits, Buybacks, and Rebranding Stunts)

    A combination of brain drain (exodus) and layoffs (a lack of budget combined with inability to retain talent or attract the necessary staff with sufficiently competitive salaries) dooms IBM; but the media won't be mentioning it, partly because a lot of it is still directly sponsored by IBM



  27. IRC Proceedings: Thursday, September 16, 2021

    IRC logs for Thursday, September 16, 2021



  28. [Meme] 70 Days of Non-Compliance

    António Campinos would rather fall on his sword than correct the errors or work to undo the damage caused by Team Battistelli, which is still at the EPO



  29. EPO “Board 28” Meeting: Imaginary Dialogue Between EPO President Campinos and the Chair of the Administrative Council, Josef Kratochvíl

    The EPO‘s chaotic state, which persists after Benoît Battistelli‘s departure, is a state of lawlessness and cover-up



  30. Links 16/9/2021: Linux Mint Has New Web Site, LibreOffice 7.2.1, KDE Plasma 5.23 Beta, and Sailfish OS Verla

    Links for the day


RSS 64x64RSS Feed: subscribe to the RSS feed for regular updates

Home iconSite Wiki: You can improve this site by helping the extension of the site's content

Home iconSite Home: Background about the site and some key features in the front page

Chat iconIRC Channel: Come and chat with us in real time

Recent Posts