EditorsAbout the SiteComes vs. MicrosoftUsing This Web SiteSite ArchivesCredibility IndexOOXMLOpenDocumentPatentsNovellNews DigestSite NewsRSS

07.24.20

Social Justice Hooey Killed the Free Software Movement

Posted in Free/Libre Software, FSF, GNU/Linux, IBM, Microsoft, OSI at 10:15 pm by Guest Editorial Team

Article by figosdev

Sevilla at night

Summary: It’s important to distinguish “social justice hooey” from social justice itself

Many people in our community are in favour of some degree of social justice. The Black Lives Matter movement, launched again into the spotlight by protests against the deaths of George Floyd and Breonna Taylor, is easily as strong as it has ever been. Techrights has run several articles related to some of the more outward effects of this political climate. It’s important to distinguish “social justice hooey” from social justice itself.

“It’s important to distinguish “social justice hooey” from social justice itself.”I am not someone who believes that Free Software needs to cater to a particular swath of the political spectrum exclusively — nor do I think that its leaders (or members) need to pretend they support no other causes than Free Software. If a Free software project wishes to support BLM, I’m okay with that. Others may not be.

What I call “social justice hooey” is limited to certain artifacts that I consider tangential to the movement. I am well aware that others may consider these tangential artifacts to be integral to the whole thing.

“Corporations have always co-opted legitimate social movements.”Although Open Source has always looked for ways to paint itself as more hip, more aware, less bigoted and more progressive than Free software, I consider this an opportunistic ruse. Corporations have always co-opted legitimate social movements.

It’s too far back in progress to imagine Coca Cola trying sponsor the sit-ins of the Civil Rights movement in the 1960s, but it’s not hard to imagine now. “Sitting In? Have a Coke!” The 30th anniversary of the Woodstock music festival was a fine example of big corporations cashing in on events that originally stood against corporate fascist culture.

I consider the pandering of Open Source to any who will listen to be a bug and a feature, dating back to its beginnings when Co-founder Bruce Perens said that he was resigning from OSI due to Free software being overshadowed by its work. He did not mean that OSI’s work was more important, rather that the importance of freedom was being ignored.

My goal with this article is not as much to react to the current events by themselves, but as part of a long-standing pattern that dates back more than a decade — Black Lives Matter only goes back to 2013 as far as I know, so while they’re extremely relevant right now (and if I blamed them for this, I would just say so) the real problem is when progressive causes are co-opted and weaponised against us — not the progressive movements themselves.

“…the real problem is when progressive causes are co-opted and weaponised against us — not the progressive movements themselves.”Free software was always about freedom, while Open Source was created specifically to couch the products (the software) produced by the movement in terms that avoid and sidestep the movement’s revolutionary terms and positions. It existed to make Free software friendly to corporations that didn’t want to hear about why “Intellectual Property” is a term designed to mislead and confuse people, for example. In order to justify co-opting Free software, it had to paint the movement in increasingly unflattering terms, which it did so frequently and dishonestly.

By no means is the movement perfect — freedom attracts all sorts of people, including those who wish to thwart progress. But for the most part, the Free software movement was always comprised of thoughtful and gifted individuals.

Like BLM, which has supporters from every race and many creeds, many of these individuals were outspoken and iconoclastic. In its narcissistic fashion, Open Source has always reserved the right to exhibit an iconoclastic veneer, while complaining that Free software won’t ever be understood, can’t represent its own movement unless everybody acts like a professional (the author of the Linux kernel can’t code in a bathrobe, what will people think?). These sorts of nags are exactly what hypocritical perfectionists do.

“In its narcissistic fashion, Open Source has always reserved the right to exhibit an iconoclastic veneer, while complaining that Free software won’t ever be understood, can’t represent its own movement unless everybody acts like a professional (the author of the Linux kernel can’t code in a bathrobe, what will people think?).”“Good speech. Be sure to stand up straight! It went a little long. Don’t be so rigid, be personable.” Note that the criticism about standing up straight and “don’t be so rigid” is almost contradictory. This isn’t because of nuance or caring, it’s simply arbitrary.

The problem isn’t that Open Source is critical, but that it’s dishonest and conniving. You could never establish this from a few fairly innocuous examples, but when there are decades worth of the same pattern it would be ridiculous to ignore. Whatever the goal of Open Source was, the effect was to sell Free software out to Google, IBM, Apple, Facebook, Amazon and Microsoft.

So what is social justice hooey then?

Social justice hooey is the superficial veneer of things that do actually matter, that will turn all progress into disposable corporate campaigns and slogans. Like McCarthyism, social justice hooey provides a cynical measuring stick for humanity that you either attain (via appearances and conformity) or you don’t. It sorts the “believers” from opportunists — using criteria that puts the opportunists ahead — How “American” was the House Un-American Activities Committee? How “Patriotic” is the PAT-RIOT Act?

“Social justice hooey is the superficial veneer of things that do actually matter, that will turn all progress into disposable corporate campaigns and slogans.”Hooey has nothing at all to to do with sincerity, integrity, humanity, tolerance, honesty, equality, reform, or decency. It’s purely for show; it’s the little flag pin that every presidential candidate is expected to wear to show they’re patriotic. But whether you really care about the things that really matter can’t be determined by what kind of pin you wear. It’s nothing but social cause theatre.

There are lots of ways to address social change, but hooey demands conformity and change that is skin-deep. It’s ironic (or it’s deliberate) that the same injustice based on mistreating people over differences that are only skin deep leads to some people proposing solutions that treat the problem in only a skin deep fashion. This kind of superficiality is exactly where injustice comes from.

“Agreeing on everything” isn’t what “progress” or “progressive” means. Years before Erykah Badu brought “woke” back into popular culture, an acquaintance and shaman told me about people who were “awake.” This was a spiritual matter, and a mind matter, which “woke” has every potential for being as well. You can be politically “woke” and be an atheist, just as you can be “woke” and part of practically any religious background. “Awake” is a state of mind, though I like to think it means you frequently (if not always) work to see past the superficial.

“Full, unquestioning agreement is such a shallow measure of awareness or humanity.”Hooey demands we do the opposite — it demands that we become prostrate to symbolism and conform to superficial expectations.

Full, unquestioning agreement is such a shallow measure of awareness or humanity. Martin Luther King, Jr. and Malcolm X didn’t agree on everything, and if we are “real” (I remember when “real” was a bigger thing than “woke” — I liked “real…”) then we know that no two people actually agree on everything. If we all agreed on everything, we wouldn’t “need” rights at all! (Don’t assume this is a coincidence.)

Freedom means that people who care about a cause (and even those who don’t) retain the freedom to disagree, and to say so. This freedom won’t last if we create the thought police, and it is the corporate thought police — not real social reformers, that are destroying our movement. They are wolves in reformer clothing.

Nobody who really cares about freedom is going to stand by silently while the racist police are replaced with thought police. If you care about freedom, you will ultimately seek solutions to both of these problems.

“Freedom means that people who care about a cause (and even those who don’t) retain the freedom to disagree, and to say so. This freedom won’t last if we create the thought police, and it is the corporate thought police — not real social reformers, that are destroying our movement. They are wolves in reformer clothing.”It’s certainly alright if some people focus on the problems of brutality and racism exclusively. But “solutions” that involve thought conformity and militant thought policing are not the answer, and yet these are exactly the weapons being used (as predicted and warned against more than a year ago, when George Floyd was still alive) to dismantle the Free software movement. If you force people to think the same way, you are forcing them not to think — and not to think about real freedom, but just a hollow shell of it.

I certainly don’t blame George Floyd (RIP) and I don’t blame BLM either — I blame people who are more immediately close to what we do, who are using events and outrage with things like these events opportunistically to take control and attack good people who are real reformers — reformers who may not bow to whatever cynical superficiality and conformity is sometimes proposed.

Iconoclasts aren’t like that just because they’re stubborn and obtuse; they’re stubborn and obtuse because they actually believe in something, and it isn’t just about image.

Systematic injustice has many different angles. Just because you reject a false solution that won’t help, doesn’t mean you’re “for” the problem.

“When rights are not respected, rebellion is inevitable.”Black Lives DO Matter, and everybody has the right both to be free — and to petition for a redress of grievances. That’s simply what the U.S. Constitution says, and lots of people know that it’s been used as toilet paper by every administration since at least the year 2000 (I would say longer.)

When rights are not respected, rebellion is inevitable. The preamble to UDHR warns of this, and while it is particularly applicable to the current climate of protest, I hope we might agree that a climate of rebellion with an expectation of complete agreement is a contradiction in terms.

We are not a corporation, we are many different people who don’t (in any circle) all consider ideas in an exactly identical fashion. Corporations expect much greater conformity than a real community — and that’s the dystopian future of the FSF, sadly. Any side-politics that demand complete conformity should be rejected, and treated as some level of threat to what we do. It’s clear that many have ignored this threat, and have let it take over and partially dismantle our political work already.

None of which is necessary or useful to the sort of reform that Black Lives need to be as free as everyone else. Though I will say that the level of passion, anger and occasional destruction in these protests is most likely justified at this point. What really impresses me is that most people seem to think so as well.

Don’t let Coca Cola, or anything like it, steal this movement and use it against Free software. And if Open Source tries, just tell them they’re not even a social movement — they’re a sold out branch of Microsoft that pays ZDNet to conflate GNU with Linux, Linux with Windows, Stallman with Epstein (who is closer to Bill) and Free software with bigotry. That kind of dishonesty calls for protest and rebellion as well.

“And if Open Source tries, just tell them they’re not even a social movement — they’re a sold out branch of Microsoft that pays ZDNet to conflate GNU with Linux, Linux with Windows, Stallman with Epstein (who is closer to Bill) and Free software with bigotry. That kind of dishonesty calls for protest and rebellion as well.”IBM has put away its racist spy toys which tracked minorities on surveillance cameras as well as minorities, various races and political enemies during the Holocaust, though they are sporting a "woke" flag pin themselves.

Is this really any better than Coca Cola (another Nazi collaborator, which rms has protested for years) co-opting the Civil Rights movement to sell soda?

It doesn’t bother me that Free software dabbles in other aspects of progress. It’s hilarious that Bradley Kuhn has held it against rms for having political opinions outside of the subject of Free software, when Kuhn’s own politics are right on display even while he’s saying this. The introduction of side politics, far from emanating from rms alone, is being used as a tool to silence him and other Free software supporters.

The problem for Free software in general, is that these other aspects of progress are being used as a form of political blackmail. Open Source didn’t invent that sort of dishonest, opportunistic ploy —

They’re simply borrowing it, and after 20 years of hypocritical gestures, people should decide they’ve had enough. Smarter people ought to be dabbling in progress without letting hooey come between some of our best people, and their opportunities to work with us.

It’s no surprise then, that some of our best people are women, racial minorities and former ACLU directors (who are also women) that defend rms against the dishonest, contrived, political blackmail used to manipulate not only the structure of the FSF — but all of its members as well.

“Smarter people ought to be dabbling in progress without letting hooey come between some of our best people, and their opportunities to work with us.”This isn’t a new ploy, even for Open Source and its victims — rms is simply one of the more recent and most prominent losses. I don’t like Linus Torvalds or ESR, but they did the same thing to both of them, and that was dirty too. Torvalds (more recently his boss, Jim Zemlin) did the same thing years ago, comparing Free software to “extremism” and “hate” — which is exactly why no one should fall for the same dishonesty when Kuhn or the FSFE do it to rms himself.

Superficiality is dishonesty — and dishonesty isn’t progress. When we are expected to comply with dishonesty, this is a giant step backwards for a movement — on the verge of systemic failure. Such dishonesty is used as a weapon against us, against our movement — and also against the other movements that it exploits, while distracting us from the more legitimate aspects of these good causes.

Long Live rms, and happy hacking.

Licence: Creative Commons CC0 1.0 (public domain)

Share in other sites/networks: These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.
  • Reddit
  • email
  • Slashdot

If you liked this post, consider subscribing to the RSS feed or join us now at the IRC channels.

Pages that cross-reference this one

Leave a Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

What Else is New


  1. Links 7/8/2020: Ubuntu 20.04.1 LTS and GNU C Library 2.32 Released

    Links for the day



  2. IRC Proceedings: Thursday, August 06, 2020

    IRC logs for Thursday, August 06, 2020



  3. Our Collective Privacy is Under Unprecedented Attacks and Privacy is Now Conflated With Bad Hygiene, Not Just Criminality

    At warp speed the "War on cash" or "War on anonymous transactions" is moving ahead; now that COVID-19 infects a lot of people we're led to assume that mass surveillance saves lives not because of counter-terrorism but because of contact-tracing or whatever (in practice it's hardly effective, but it's conditioning people to give up any remnants of their privacy)



  4. The Psychology of Developers

    "It turns out, there are ways around a free license -- you can make software "less free" or more imposing, without changing the license at all."



  5. Social Justice is Fine... When It is Not Just a Shallow Marketing Ploy

    Don't let well-meaning concepts such as "Social Justice" become mere buzzwords or tools of corporate propaganda (greedy people's objectives disguised as populism)



  6. Site Upgrades Likely Coming Soon

    After more than 28,000 posts are published it might be time to move from the WordPress x.9.x LTS to something newer (5.5 is about to be released); we explain why it’s not as simple as it might first seem



  7. Focus on the Big Issues, Not the Words

    The pattern that is emerging in recent months if not years is that words hurt and therefore contributors to code must shut up about injustices, including corporate misbehaviour



  8. Computing vs. Marketing

    “The important lesson here is that Windows is NOT a computer — it is actually a horrible thing that people DO to a computer, and to themselves.”



  9. Release: Several Police Reports About Searching the Home of Bill Gates' Engineer (Stockpiles of Child Pornography Found Along With Illegal Firearm)

    The final part of the first installment from Seattle PD, this one focusing on people who searched the home to find a lot of underage pornographic material being amassed



  10. Video: Microsoft-Sponsored 'Copyleft' Conf (Keynote Sold to Microsoft, a Serial GPL Violator and Primary FUD Source) Features Previous FSF (Co)President and RMS Ouster

    There's now a video online of the debates in CopyleftConf 2020



  11. Miseducation

    "...the real crime (OLPC founder Nicholas Negropontes word for it) is that schools aren't teaching computers at all -- they're doing application training."



  12. [Meme] RMS Succeeded by a Microsoft Sponsor

    Congratulations to the FSF, which elected a president almost a year after pushing RMS (its founder) out; but questions need to be answered by the new president, who apparently sees nothing wrong reinforcing the Microsoft monopoly, participating in a PR ploy designed to distract from the notorious ICE contract, and even paying Microsoft (as if it deserves the money)



  13. Controlling Your Computing

    "We at least want our software to be free, and for a while, that was possible. We want software to be free again, so let's talk about what made it free, what made it less free, and what could hopefully improve in the future."



  14. User Libre: Free Computing For Everyone, Start With Perfection

    "As the threats to user freedom evolve, so too must the response to those threats. So long as freedom remains the first priority, worthwhile responses will give more power to every user, and keep limits on how much control can be imposed by developers."



  15. IRC Proceedings: Wednesday, August 05, 2020

    IRC logs for Wednesday, August 05, 2020



  16. Release: Search Warrant and Reports on Findings When Bill Gates' Engineer Arrested for Pedophilia

    Readers can finally see all the details about what was taken (portable drives, laptop, desktop etc.) and what was found when a search was executed at the home of Bill Gates' engineer while he was at Bill's house (where he worked regularly); as far as we are aware, the police never searched Bill's house and computers



  17. Links 6/8/2020: FSF Has New Chief, LibreOffice 7.0, Linux App Summit Goes Online

    Links for the day



  18. Links 5/8/2020: Wayfire 0.5 and Plasma Browser Integration

    Links for the day



  19. IRC Proceedings: Tuesday, August 04, 2020

    IRC logs for Tuesday, August 04, 2020



  20. SUSE is Still Pushing Microsoft Proprietary Software and Bragging About the Novell Patent Collusion With Microsoft

    SUSE seems to have learned no lessons after the aftermath of its (or Novell’s) Microsoft patent scam, which had been negotiated partly by Miguel de Icaza (now working directly for Microsoft) before causing Novell to collapse and offload its patents to Microsoft (‘TikTok operandi’ or asset stripping); the past cannot be left behind if SUSE — like Novell — celebrates and perpetuates that past



  21. Release: 29 Pages of Internet Access Report About Pedophile Working for Bill Gates at His Home

    As we’ve found nothing too sensitive in the document, today we’re finally disclosing and publishing the second release (first one published yesterday); this includes network addresses used on the devices of the engineer of Bill Gates, who had a laptop and external hard drives (portable) with plenty of child pornography (imagery and videos)



  22. Links 4/8/2020: Kodachi 7.2, Collabora Office 6.4

    Links for the day



  23. [Meme] Nadella is Doing With Donald Trump What Ballmer Did With Elop and Icahn to Steal Other Companies (Nokia and Yahoo, Respectively)

    The illegal (attempted) confiscation of a Chinese company to distract from or compensate for Microsoft's collapse reminds us that Microsoft is only getting worse and more malicious under Nadella, who is happy to liaise with a hugely corrupt and racist regime



  24. We Don't Really Know How Many People Died With (or From) COVID-19 and How Many Will Die After Home Recovery or Release From Hospital

    The coronavirus pandemic that began last year as an epidemic (COVID-19) is still a very serious problem, even half a year after its widespread arrival in Europe; it's important to emphasise the importance of not down-playing this problem (which is far from solved) because social control media is full of junk



  25. IRC Proceedings: Monday, August 03, 2020

    IRC logs for Monday, August 03, 2020



  26. Release: Police Report About Arrest of Bill Gates Engineer for Pedophilia (Detained at Residence of Bill Gates)

    Today we release 15 pages (amongst almost 3,000 pages we have) about the Jones arrest; this includes details about what happened when the detectives came to the home of Bill Gates



  27. Bill Gates' Personal Engineer Rick Jones is Connected to Other Child Pornographers. One Key Contact Works (or Worked) Indirectly for Microsoft.

    MagicHour listed Microsoft among their clients, as we noted before, and the full (redacted for child porn reasons) name is Brett Paine. We had reached out to the employer (several of us, separately), but we never received any reply.



  28. Links 3/8/2020: Linux 5.8, GNU Linux-libre 5.8, Libinput 1.16, Rust 1.45.2, Julia 1.5

    Links for the day



  29. IRC Proceedings: Sunday, August 02, 2020

    IRC logs for Sunday, August 02, 2020



  30. [Meme] Is It Not a Layoffs Round When You Rebrand It?

    More and more Microsoft layoffs; but the media is hardly interested in reporting those and/or analysing the growing scale of the layoffs (about half a dozen rounds of layoffs this summer alone)


RSS 64x64RSS Feed: subscribe to the RSS feed for regular updates

Home iconSite Wiki: You can improve this site by helping the extension of the site's content

Home iconSite Home: Background about the site and some key features in the front page

Chat iconIRC Channel: Come and chat with us in real time

Recent Posts