Bonum Certa Men Certa

The EPO's War on Justice and Assault on the Law -- Part 4: The President of the Boards of Appeal

Previously in this series:



EPO posse
Carl Josefsson (left) together with Vice President Raimund Lutz, Haar Mayor Gabriele Müller and Administrative Council Chairman Christoph Ernst at the inauguration of the Boards of Appeal premises in December 2017.



Summary: A deeper look into the 'sausage factory' that is EPO tribunals certainly helps us understand the inherent bias of many decisions, including a recent decision on European software patents like a controversial simulation patent

The current Chairman of the Enlarged Board of Appeal in case no. G 1/21 is Carl Josefsson.



Readers who are familiar with EPOnia will be aware that, in parallel to his judicial role as Chairman of the Enlarged Board, Josefsson also has a managerial role as the so-called "President of the Boards of Appeal".

The office of the "President of the Boards of Appeal" is an innovation of the Battistelli era.

This position was created in the context of the 2016 reform of the Boards of Appeal which was triggered by the "constitutional crisis" unleashed by the decision R 19/12 in May 2014.

Back in 2014, the Boards of Appeal were under the management of a Vice-President, the Vice-President of DG3. By an established practice which had no formal legal basis, the Vice-President of DG3 also held the position of Chairman of the Enlarged Board of Appeal.

In R 19/12, the Enlarged Board examined this dual role of the Vice-President of DG3 and came to the conclusion that it involved a conflict of interest which potentially compromised the independence of the Vice-President of DG3 in the exercise of his judicial function as Chairman of the Enlarged Board of Appeal.

"In R 19/12, the Enlarged Board examined this dual role of the Vice-President of DG3 and came to the conclusion that it involved a conflict of interest which potentially compromised the independence of the Vice-President of DG3 in the exercise of his judicial function as Chairman of the Enlarged Board of Appeal."There were a number of possible solutions to the conflict of interest identified in R 19/12. For example, it would have been possible to have considered separating the positions of the Vice-President of DG3 and Chairman of the Enlarged Board, or removing the Vice-President of DG3 from managerial activities under the authority and influence of the EPO President.

However, the mere fact that the EBA had had the temerity to issue such a decision enraged Battistelli. He expected his "vassals" - which he understood to include the members of the Boards of Appeal - to play their part in papering over the cracks.

Any attempt to expose issues that deserved to be tackled in the public interest was condemned as "sabotage" or "treason".

According to those close to the centre of action, Battistelli perceived the EBA's actions in issuing R 19/12 as a provocation and an attempted "judicial coup d'état".

Kid judge: I want! I approve!It is reported that he went completely ballistic when R 19/12 landed on his desk. From that moment on Battistelli seemed to be hell-bent on pursuing his own private feud against the Boards of Appeal as he swore that he would make them pay dearly for their perceived lèse-majesté.

The level of Battistelli's displeasure at R 19/12 can be gauged from the fact that the decision which was originally issued in German was not translated into the EPO's two other official languages (English and French) and it has never been published in the EPO's Official Journal.

Like other EBA decisions of which Battistelli disapproved - for example, G2301/15 (warning: epo.org link) and G2301/16 (warning: epo.org link) - R 19/12 is only accessible online via the case law database of the Boards of Appeal.

Battistelli's solution to the "constitutional crisis" unleashed by R 19/12 was to draw up an elaborate window-dressing scheme for a "reform" of the Boards of Appeal.

"Battistelli's PR machine promoted this scheme as enhancing the "perception of independence" of the Boards while at the same time he was careful to ensure that in reality those irksome in-house judges would kept on as short a leash as possible."His plan for "reform" created a new "Boards of Appeal Unit" which was to be headed by a "President of the Boards of Appeal". For good measure, the new unit was to be banished beyond the Munich city boundaries to the adjoining municipality of Haar.

Battistelli's PR machine promoted this scheme as enhancing the "perception of independence" of the Boards while at the same time he was careful to ensure that in reality those irksome in-house judges would kept on as short a leash as possible.

Cutting through the PR smoke-screen and examining the small print of the "reform", it is difficult to see how it enhanced the independence of the Boards in any meaningful way.

Prior to the reform, the Boards were headed by a Vice-President whose appointment was governed by the primary legislation of Article 11 of the EPC and was the sole prerogative of the Administrative Council.

After the reform, the Boards are now headed by the "President of the Boards of Appeal" whose appointment is governed by the secondary legislation of Implementing Rule 12a of the EPC.

"The competences of the President of the Boards of Appeal are subject to a "delegation of powers" from the President of the Office which has never been properly clarified."As we have noted previously, in contrast to the Articles of the EPC - which can only be changed by a diplomatic conference and the unanimous consent of all contracting states - the Implementing Rules can be changed at the drop of a hat by a simple majority of the Administrative Council.

Rule 12a of the EPC specifies that the President of the Boards of Appeal "shall be appointed by the Administrative Council on a joint proposal made by the Committee [of the Administrative Council] established under Rule 12c, paragraph 1, and the President of the European Patent Office."

This provision gives the President of the Office a de facto veto over the appointment of the head of the Boards of Appeal, a power which he never had prior to the reform.

The competences of the President of the Boards of Appeal are subject to a "delegation of powers" from the President of the Office which has never been properly clarified.

As long as Battistelli remained in office, the mysterious "Act of Delegation" was never published.

As a matter of fact it was only published in July 2018 (warning: epo.org link) after Battistelli's successor António Campinos had taken over at the helm of the European Patent Office.

But even this belated publication by Campinos has not fully clarified the scope and limitations of the delegation.

It is also particularly noteworthy that Article 4 of the Act of Delegation allows the President of the Office to unilaterally revoke the delegation.

Although this supposed to happen in "close co-operation with the Administrative Council", the prerogative of revocation lies with the President and there are no enforceable checks and balances to prevent abuse by a despot such as Battistelli.

A year later in 2017, Battistelli managed to persuade the Administrative Council to copper-fasten his control over the Boards by adopting CA/D 4/17 [PDF] (as images below) which stipulates that the nomination of a deputy for the President of the Boards of Appeal is subject to the agreement of the President of the Office.

All in all, a lot of questions about the "reform" of the Boards of Appeal and its effects on the independence of the Boards remain unanswered to this very day.

"In the coming parts we will take an in-depth look at the lucky beneficiary of this "legal fudge", namely Carl Josefsson, the Swedish judge who was appointed to fill the newly-created position of "President of the Boards of Appeal"."But when the package was proposed in June 2016, the Administrative Council was completely under the sway of Battistelli and his "protector" Kongstad and it obediently voted the "reform" through with hardly a murmur of dissent.

In the coming parts we will take an in-depth look at the lucky beneficiary of this "legal fudge", namely Carl Josefsson, the Swedish judge who was appointed to fill the newly-created position of "President of the Boards of Appeal".

CA/D 4/17 page1

CA/D 4/17 page 2

Recent Techrights' Posts

New Techrights Turns 2
Today starts the third year of the SSG-based Techrights
What Scares Them the Most is Independent News Sites That They Cannot Control and Censor
Wikileaks was a good example of this
If You Don't Control Your Online Platform, Then Someone Else is Controlling You
be (or become) independent
The Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA) Has a Policy on Racism and Sexism
In then future we'll show the misogyny and racial slurs
Links 22/09/2025: Murdochs Might Join Fentanylware (TikTok) 'Investors' (Masters), United Kingdom Recognises Palestinian Statehood
Links for the day
The 50-Pound Note Experiment and the "War on Cash"
Britain is actually seeing a rebound in cash payments, and it's not a temporary phenomenon
 
MAHA is a Lie, Public Officials Never Valued Citizens' Health (They Still Value Private Businesses, Their Sponsors)
Reject demagogues
Free Software Foundation (FSF) Has a New Press Kit for the Weekend After Next Weekend (40th Anniversary)
miles better than social [sic] media [sic] quips, moderated by narcissists and oil tycoons.
Microsoft Had Two Waves of Mass Layoffs This Month (That We Know of) and It'll Get Worse for Microsoft Soon
Will the axe fall again by month's end?
Gemini Links 23/09/2025: Happy Equinox, Photronic Arts, and Perception Cognition
Links for the day
Lessons We've Learned After 17 Years of American Hosting
GAFAM is "all-in" with the "Trump agenda"
Back to Normal Now, We Plan to Do More In-Depth Series (or Multi-part Stories)
Articles (or series thereof) that contain philosophy are important to us
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Monday, September 22, 2025
IRC logs for Monday, September 22, 2025
Microsoft Media is Panicking Amid Mass Layoffs Every Month, H-1B Fees, and "Seattle’s Tech Scene in Trouble"
In "late stage Microsoft", copyleft becomes proprietary
The Next Wave of IBM/Red Hat Layoffs Being Discussed Already
Red Hat is sort of disappearing the way Tivoli did
Oracle Started This Year With Slop. Then It Stopped.
Passing fads are like this
Distros That Run on PCs Made 20 Years Ago and Don't Use Systemd
Betas for now
The Complaint About Brett Wilson LLP - Part I - Abusing British Women on Behalf of American Men Who Abuse American Women
Transparency is important to us, so we've decided to make this series
Slopwatch: Google News and the Evident Slopfarm Infestation
This is what people get about Linux when they query Google for Linux
Gemini Links 22/09/2025: Esperanto Music History and Apps For Android
Links for the day
Links 22/09/2025: More American 'Censorship' (Retaliation for Journalism), Cheeto "Might Be Losing His Race Against Time"
Links for the day
The Blob Slop
Give me more words, give me some text
Slopwatch: Blaming the Victims for Microsoft's Failures and Plagiarising Phoronix
That's what Google has been reduced to: slop and slopfarms
Links 22/09/2025: Breaches, Windows TCO, and Arrests
Links for the day
Gemini Links 22/09/2025: Rabbit Hole and DeGoogling Fairphone
Links for the day
Links 22/09/2025: Russian War Planes Invade NATO Airspace While Dihydroxyacetone Man Escalates Attack on Free Speech Because of Critics
Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Sunday, September 21, 2025
IRC logs for Sunday, September 21, 2025
Links 21/09/2025: "Hey Hi" (Hype) Under Fire, Fakes Identified; Tesla Burns Family
Links for the day
Google's Software is Malware and Malware in Mobile Devices
Originally posted by Rob Musial
Links 20/09/2025: Hegemony Coming to a Close, Luigi Mangione Ruled Not Terrorist
Links for the day
Gemini Links 21/09/2025: "Charlie Kirk Was a Hateful Piece of Shit" and Slop Code Attempted by Microsofter
Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Saturday, September 20, 2025
IRC logs for Saturday, September 20, 2025