The European Patent Office is Attracting Patent Trolls

Dr. Roy Schestowitz

2018-11-18 16:41:23 UTC
Modified: 2018-11-18 16:41:23 UTC

Summary: Enforcement of software patents in Europe by the large patent troll (disguised as a pool) MPEG-LA means that European software developers cannot develop software with full multimedia support (not without sudden disruption to their peace)

THE race to the bottom of patent quality isn't a new thing at the European Patent Office (EPO); it had become very obvious under Battistelli and António Campinos made it worse. Unlike the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO), the EPO is becoming more software patents-friendly over time and it seems to be choosing China as a partner, knowing that Chinese patents are of low quality and barely matter to European Patents (few of which are assigned to Chinese firms). Months ago we explained why "Software Patents Are a Dying Breed of Patents Except in China (and Maybe EPO)" and also published "Racing to the Bottom, the António Campinos-Led EPO Continues to Promote Software Patents, Just Like China".

"Huawei and ZTE are impacted (the Chinese giants) and this can cause an increase in prices all over Europe. Who benefits from all this? the trolls of course..."China is just playing catchup, seeing trade wars and sanctions creeping in. China's government offers incentives to generate/spur many patent applications domestically (literally millions of them) and these may get granted irrespective of quality, prior art etc. This is a recipe for trouble as it opens the door to patent trolls -- an issue that China already wrestles with (being tough and aggressive/oppressive, China already arrests some trolls). This US patent troll/parasite called iPEL [1, 2], which targets China for the most part, is being promoted by Watchtroll this month. Watchtroll has published puff pieces/ads for this notorious patent troll (e.g. "Why Non-Practicing Entities (NPEs) Are Good For China") and we keep seeing lots of articles about China's new appeal procedures/courts. Guanyang Yao (Liu, Shen & Associates) has done an article about it, as did some patent maximalists' sites lately.

Of most interest to us, however, is news about MPEG-LA taxing Chinese companies in the usual ways; These patent trolls are having a good time nowadays in Germany. In Associated Press (press release) and elsewhere they celebrate this enforcement of software patents in Europe. Huawei and ZTE are impacted (the Chinese giants) and this can cause an increase in prices all over Europe. Who benefits from all this? the trolls of course... ⬆

Why I Continue to Believe That at the End Software Freedom Will Win: a short and incomplete list of factors which I believe contribute to the sentiment that we can - and will - win the battles over hearts and minds in the "Tech" realm
Technology: rights or responsibilities? - Part X: By Dr. Andy Farnell
[Meme] When the People Who Falsely Accuse You of Pedophilia Turn Out to be Projecting: When you attack something or someone using falsehoods, as happens a lot to Richard Stallman (RMS), there's risk that the attacks will backfire, badly
In Some Countries, Such as Greece, Almost 80% of Windows Users Are on Vista 10 and About 85% Need to Move to GNU/Linux for Security Patches: Vista 11 was a failure
Saving What's Left of Decent and Independent Journalism on the Web: We increasingly (over time) try to make local copies (hosted on our server) of important documents; it's hard to rely on third parties
[Meme] They Don't Want the Public to Know What "Responsible Encryption" Really Means: They also blame "China" for their own back doors (because China learned how to exploit those)
The Linux Foundation's Certificate Authority (CA) Significantly and Suspiciously Raises the Number of Certificates It Issues (Quantity Increase/Inflation) by Lessening Their Lifetime in the Name of 'Security' (That Barely Makes Sense!): LE made 3 months the "standard" for most, soon to become just 6 days instead of 6 months?
Links 17/12/2024: More China Sanctions, GOP Scheming to Prop Up Fentanylware (TikTok): Links for the day
Gemini Links 17/12/2024: The Streisand Effect and Productivity-systems Desiderata: Links for the day
Links 17/12/2024: More "Tesla Autopilot" and "Hey Hi" (AI) Blunders: Links for the day
Instead of Promoting GNU/Linux (or Ubuntu) Ahead of Vista 10's EoL Canonical is Marketing Microsoft's Proprietary Software: It's like Canonical employs people who work for Microsoft, not for Canonical
Links 17/12/2024: Many Abuses by Microsoft and War Updates From Ukraine: Links for the day
Content Management Systems (CMS) Bloat/ Static Site Generators (SSG) Trouble: some Web site management stories
DEI Room at fedoraproject.org Pretty Much Dead: We're not against diversity but against its weaponisation by greedy people who do not value diversity at all
The "Latest Technology News" at BetaNews is Slop About Slop: This is at the very top of the "news" (front page) at the moment
Over at Tux Machines...: GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Monday, December 16, 2024: IRC logs for Monday, December 16, 2024
Gemini Links 16/12/2024: Invisibles and 20 Years of GNU/Linux on the Desktop: Links for the day
Microsoft's Windows Fell From 98% to Less Than 15% (in 15 Years in Africa): Operating System Market Share Africa
Swaziland: GNU/Linux Leaps to 7.24%, Based on statCounter: Remember that Microsoft had many layoffs this year in Africa
A Birthday Wish: My birthday is a few hours away
[Meme] Definitely Not Your Role Models: Hypocrite Neckbeard Meme
Changes or Variation of Logo at the FSF as 40th Anniversary is Near (Months Away): Next year the FSF turns 40
Mobile Usage Nearly 90% in Maharlika (Philippines)?: Microsoft has become just a footnote
Push Back and Become More Vocal for LLM Abuse and Misuse to Stop: We hope that more people out there (sites too) will call out the people who saturate particular topics on the Web with machine-generated junk
The Media Failed to Hold GAFAM Accountable (and Now It Suffers From It and For It): This recognition of the problem emboldens us to carry on
Botswana: New Highs for GNU/Linux, All-Time Lows for Microsoft: No wonder Microsoft has so many layoffs in Africa this year
Links 16/12/2024: Skinnerboxes ("Smart" "Phones") and Control Social Media Blamed for Fights: Links for the day
Reminder: The Microsoft Person Who Used OpenAI for En Masse GPL Violations Told the Whistleblower to Kill Herself: The evidence (real message)
Links 16/12/2024: emacs, Drawabox, “You Should Have Your Own Website”: Links for the day
In Some Parts of the World, Like Central America and South America, Microsoft is Irrelevant on the Web: Nadella has bet the farm on a Ponzi scheme
[Meme] Microsoft is Not a Country: Reporting crimes is essential for democracy
There's Not Much Time Left for President Biden to Pardon Julian Assange and Signal to Journalists That Exposing States' Crimes or Rich People's Misbehaviour is Lawful: Apathy towards this is part of the problem
Image Fusion is Not 'AI' (LLMs Aren't Either): Such fakes can (and always could) be done by a digital artist, it's just a little more expensive and time-consuming
GNU/Linux at New Highs in Bosnia And Herzegovina: Quite a few Balkan nations show high adoption rates for GNU/Linux
From Scientists to Pigeons: The EPO Has Turned Patent Examination Into a Process Made by Computers and Improperly Trained Staff Which Doesn't Meet the Requirements of the European Patent Convention (EPC): Might as well abolish this entire system if this is the current trajectory
Razik Menidjel Will No Longer be Chief Operating Officer Operations at the EPO: What does the EPC say about slop and should it be updated to deal with trouble such as slop?
Underpaid and Inexperienced Workers Overwhelm the EPO, Granting Many Invalid Patents and Placing Pressure on Veteran Examiners: So-called "production" (giving monopolies) pressure is "compromising the quality of our products" [sic] according to a new report
Over at Tux Machines...: GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Sunday, December 15, 2024: IRC logs for Sunday, December 15, 2024
Links 15/12/2024: Social Control Media Disarray and Software Patent Eligibility Attempted by Litigation Maximalists: Links for the day
Links 15/12/2024: "Internet Era Might Be History's Least-Documented Period", Microsoft’s Telecom Biz Practically Dead: Links for the day
Links 15/12/2024: SQLite Bootstrap, More Terminals, Helix Themes: Links for the day
Two Laptops Up and Running (No Reboots) Since 2023: my main laptops, "vonick" and "bubi", haven't been rebooted since 2023
Links 14/12/2024: Yoon Impeached, "Intel's Death", and "Hey Hi" Hype Causes Warming and Pollution: Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...: GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Saturday, December 14, 2024: IRC logs for Saturday, December 14, 2024

The European Patent Office is Attracting Patent Trolls

Recent Techrights' Posts