06.11.10

Gemini version available ♊︎

Constructive Critics Defend Spectators’ Freedom, So Why Do Passive Observers Criticise Them?

Posted in Free/Libre Software, FSF at 5:32 pm by Dr. Roy Schestowitz

Richard Stallman

Summary: An exploration of FSF disdain, including the special case of Richard Stallman who is the public face of this organisation

ON NUMEROUS occasions — and last year in particular [1, 2] — we wrote many posts that explain why people who report negative news are often portrayed as “bad guys”. As those who speak out against injustice, they put themselves out there, sometimes to be attacked by the same large entities which they stand against.

Our readers too sometimes ask, why is it that critics are portrayed as “bad guys” rather than those who fight for the rights of the very same people who sometimes criticise them? Well, that’s just a fact of life and it applies not only to IT. Incitement against critics is more organised than most people realise (there are whistleblowers).

People from the United States have probably witnesses the right wing (Fox News et al.) daemonising Michael Moore and making him look extreme (which he is not) for daring to stand up for his neighbours’ health, not the cartels which profit from mortality. We have just found a recent video where Wendell Potter and Bill Moyers explain this. The Ogg Theora version is just partial for technical reasons.


As everyone can see, the multi-trillion dollar ‘Medical Industrial Complex’ is trying to radicalise the image of Michael Moore, who is simply the messenger. If they can squash the messenger, then they can extrapolate this to squash anyone who bears the same message. The same type of tactics are being used against the FSF and Richard Stallman in particular. Too few people pay attention to what he says and instead they pay attention to those with a financial agenda against him. In their minds they have a radicalised vision of the messenger, who is an atheist and pacifist; it’s intentional and it is part of the propaganda. The following posts about Richard Stallman hopefully help clarify common misconceptions:

There are many other people — myself included — who are being daemonised based on falsehoods and one common tactic is to make the messenger look radical or dangerous. The goal is to prevent people from communicating with the target, referencing it, or even just mentioning it.

Anyway, earlier today we found this rant about the FSF and here is one response to it.

Campaigns like DefectiveByDesign or Windows7Sins are *very*small* things compared to the rest.

That you should choose your position over them rather than the whole, and totally demonstrate you missed the point of software freedom, is really revealing that you don’t give a damn about your community’s software freedom.

You just want, like a spoiled child, to run all the software you want at your will, regardless of whether you’re infringing the law.

Openuniverse responds to the part of this rant which says: “I am a very positive person, even if I might might look ranty or grumpy from time to time,”

“…and whether you believe it or not,” Openuniverse writes, “stallman is exactly the same. but if a friend tells you you’ve got crap on your face, you have choices- you can thank them and wipe it off (free software,) you can leave it on and not care (non-free software,) or you can find friends who won’t even tell you- the latter is called the “open source” movement, and these people like having stallman’s ideas pre-chewed for them. it’s always an option, don’t let anyone tell you different.”

In a separate message, Openuniverse writes that “there’s a surely unintended, very subtle question i found amidst this article- does “open source” give microsoft something to “support” while using it against free software? (much like foreign exploitation of the confederacy in the civil war)”

“[D]oes “open source” give microsoft something to “support” while using it against free software?”
      –Openuniverse
This is an issue that we covered last night with regards to Apple. This issue was mentioned many times before; companies like Apple and Microsoft love the term “Open Source” when they are using it to remove the “F” from FOSS. Apple increasingly uses this trick, the other one being the trick of “UNIXwashing” (associating oneself with the reputation of code one exploits, BSD in this case). Separately, writes Openuniverse: “it’s amazing that people will take “windows7sins” literally, when stallman is a strong atheist and doesn’t believe in sin- i mean, it’s a serious joke, but it’s still a joke”

The same thing happens with “virgin” jokes and parodies about organised religion. Some people who want to daemonise Stallman pretend not to understand the humour (or maybe their humour meter is just broken).

On the other hand, Stallman and the FSF do have some real critics and it is worth recognising that they exist. Jos Poortvliet from KDE, for example, sent me the following messages earlier today: “he is right. FSF often kills opportunities for FOSS with companies by dumb behaviour like that, unreasonable and extreme.”

He then added: “besides FSF dislikes constructive (or any) criticism alot. Maybe FSF hurts FOSS more than it helps these days.”

“Anyway it doesn’t hurt me,” Poortvliet concluded, “so I usually stay away from the FSF flames, let them screw up I don’t care. FSFE does lot better btw”

This is a matter of personal opinion and Poortvliet deserves to be heard about it. My personal belief is that the FSF promotes more than just software freedom and that’s what makes it controversial in some circles. It makes the FSF an easier (more vulnerable) target, offering more ‘dirt’ to those who constantly mine for it.

“Microsoft does not like negative or even objective press coverage and they have a tendency to be a bully about it. If something appears that they don’t like, they have the ability to punish the publication.”

Knight-Ridder New Media President Bob Ingle

Share in other sites/networks: These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.
  • Reddit
  • email

Decor ᶃ Gemini Space

Below is a Web proxy. We recommend getting a Gemini client/browser.

Black/white/grey bullet button This post is also available in Gemini over at this address (requires a Gemini client/browser to open).

Decor ✐ Cross-references

Black/white/grey bullet button Pages that cross-reference this one, if any exist, are listed below or will be listed below over time.

Decor ▢ Respond and Discuss

Black/white/grey bullet button If you liked this post, consider subscribing to the RSS feed or join us now at the IRC channels.

A Single Comment

  1. your_friend said,

    June 11, 2010 at 6:51 pm

    Gravatar

    Jos Poortvliet’s quoted statements are not constructive criticism, they are the same old slander that’s always been thrown at the FSF and Richard Stallman. Constructive criticism would point out exactly what behavior had been foolish and recommend positive action that achieves the desired goals without compromising principles.

DecorWhat Else is New


  1. Links 29/11/2022: Bodhi Linux 7.0.0 Coming

    Links for the day



  2. IRC Proceedings: Monday, November 28, 2022

    IRC logs for Monday, November 28, 2022



  3. Links 29/11/2022: Whonix 16.0.9.0 and SalixLive Xfce 15.0

    Links for the day



  4. António Campinos Could Not Possibly Choose a Worse Time to Show Solidarity With Communist China

    The Unified Patent Court or "Unitary Patent" gets promoted in the same blog post or news item that celebrates dictatorship; that seems appropriate given the nature of the Unified Patent Court, which is a gross violation of laws and constitutions in a high-level institutional way



  5. Blogs Are Better and Gemlogs (Blogs Over Gemini) May be Best

    There seems to be a growing and already-widespread realisation that Twitter sucks and some people rightly suggest that we pivot back into blogging (Twitter is often blamed for the demise of blogs)



  6. Links 28/11/2022: Snal Linux 1.24 and Thunderbird Android Update

    Links for the day



  7. Links 28/11/2022: OpenRGB 0.8 and Introduction of KIO AFC

    Links for the day



  8. Links 27/11/2022: Linux 6.1 RC 7

    Links for the day



  9. IRC Proceedings: Sunday, November 27, 2022

    IRC logs for Sunday, November 27, 2022



  10. Links 27/11/2022: Rocky Linux 9.1 Released

    Links for the day



  11. Links 27/11/2022: Pinafore Born

    Links for the day



  12. Spamnil Seems to Have Quit Paying for Clickfraud Bots to Fake His 'Popularity'

    Based on the past month, Spamnil seems to have stopped (at least temporarily) relying on bots to fake his alleged popularity; through the Linux Foundation he has done great damage since the destruction of Linux.com, now a defunct site



  13. Better Let the 'Ad' 'Industry' (Spying Galore) Just Collapse

    To recover reputation Phoronix will need to quit the heavy, obtrusive, privacy-violating ads and the corporate 'gifts' that evidently and demonstrably changed the site's direction



  14. 2023 Will be a Pivotal Year for Techrights

    As we quickly approach the last month of the year, here's a look back at a wonderful year for Techrights (but not for the world in general) and a look at the year ahead



  15. IRC Proceedings: Friday, November 26, 2022

    IRC logs for Saturday, November 26, 2022



  16. Links 27/11/2022: EasyOS 4.5.2 and Pixel Wheels 0.24.0

    Links for the day



  17. Microsoft is the Problem, Not the Solution

    The media is doing anything it can to suppress discussion about the national or international security crisis caused by Microsoft; instead, some publishers go as far as lionising Microsoft, portraying it as the 'Jesus' of computer security



  18. GNU Emacs Pointing to Microsoft Servers With Microsoft Ads (Spying) and Other Brainwash

    An attempt to study another Gemini client resulted in a disturbing revelation; Unless something went very wrong, it seems like GNU Emacs doesn't exercise caution with users' privacy; it leaks out information to Microsoft in its Web browser mode



  19. Links 26/11/2022: Maui 2.2.1 and Wine 7.22

    Links for the day



  20. IRC Proceedings: Friday, November 25, 2022

    IRC logs for Friday, November 25, 2022



  21. Legislating Against Free Software in the United States and in Europe, Thanks to Lobbying by Microsoft et al

    There’s legislation that would discriminate against Free software, boosted by Microsoft and its creeping interests, which include the so-called ‘Linux’ Foundation (a force of corporate occupation against the GNU/Linux community and its collective interests)



  22. Unitary Patent Lobbying: Stacked UPC Panel With 250 People in Attendance Spun as “3000 Viewers Followed the Conference” (a Lie)

    Bolstering the criminal acts of António Campinos from the EPO is a supportive “conference in Brussels” which was more like staged Unified Patent Court (UPC) propaganda for lobbying purposes; Kangaroo courts are being promoted to legitimise fake European Patents, granted in violation of the European Patent Convention (EPC)



  23. [Meme] Monopolies Presumed Valid

    The EPO is trying to put patent maximalists in charge of a court it wishes to control, in effect dismantling independent auditory functions for the granting of European Patents



  24. “Bringing Teams Together” at the EPO Means Exactly the Opposite

    The European Patent Office’s (EPO) staff is complaining that the EPO's “Bringing Teams Together” or “New Management of Office Space” is basically done without consulting staff and to the detriment of staff, in effect making life miserable for those who can stop or prevent unwarranted monopolies



  25. Links 25/11/2022: Bugfixes in Linux and podlators 5.00

    Links for the day



  26. Links 25/11/2022: Uruk GNU/Linux 3.0 and Ubuntu Touch OTA-24 Released

    Links for the day



  27. Geminispace Can Graduate at 3,000 Capsules Quite Soon (2,900 This Week)

    From less than 500 capsules to 2,900 capsules in 24 months? That's how quickly Gemini is spreading.



  28. [Meme] Kiss the Ring (of the Patent Litigation Mafia)

    Patent litigation giants and their international lobbies/clients are working to create an absurd situation where the courts themselves exist in violation of constitutions, laws, and international conventions (they're also run by corporations)



  29. This Won't End Well for the UPC Lobby (Unitary Patent Profoundly Discredits the Rule of Law)

    Unified Patent Court (UPC) lobbyists may be acting jubilant and triumphant, but they're in effect dancing on the grave of the real legal system they're working to bury, replacing it with something that cannot and will not stand



  30. Taking Communications Private With Mumble (Privacy by Self-Hosting and End-to-End Encryption)

    The prospects of self-hosting for communications have improved greatly; for voice chat, Mumble is definitely worth a look


RSS 64x64RSS Feed: subscribe to the RSS feed for regular updates

Home iconSite Wiki: You can improve this site by helping the extension of the site's content

Home iconSite Home: Background about the site and some key features in the front page

Chat iconIRC Channel: Come and chat with us in real time

Recent Posts