Bonum Certa Men Certa

Reactions to the Collapse of Allergan's Scam With the Mohawk Tribe

"Sham" or "scam", depending on who one asks

Scam



Summary: The patent microcosm is aligning itself with a clear scam/bluff, which says a lot about the patent microcosm and its moral depravity

AS we predicted more than 24 hours ago, Monday was dominated by coverage (at least in patent blogs) of the collapse of a dubious Allergan and Mohawk relationship. PTAB isn't impressed by the "scam" of these two 'companies' (one is not actually a company, just a tribe pretending to be one), which conspired to shield patents that the USPTO probably shouldn't have granted.



The CCIA's Josh Landau wrote about it early on Monday:

The PTAB’s answer to this question was a resounding no. First, the PTAB noted that there’s neither case law nor statutory reasons to apply tribal sovereign immunity to agency proceedings like IPR. Second, as I noted back in October, tribal sovereign immunity does not apply to federal administrative proceedings like IPR. The PTAB agreed, finding that tribal sovereign immunity does not apply to IPRs, which are of course federal administrative proceedings. And third, the PTAB noted that in an IPR, the ultimate remedy is applied only to the challenged patent, not to the patent owner. This sort of proceeding isn’t the type of “suit” which traditionally triggers sovereign immunity.

This might also have impacts on state sovereign immunity going forward. While there are good case law reasons to consider the applicability of state sovereign immunity, unlike tribal sovereign immunity, state sovereign immunity also doesn’t apply to federal administrative proceedings and IPR’s structure makes it not the sort of suit which traditionally triggers state sovereign immunity.


Dennis Crouch wrote about that as well. He said that "Allergan owned several patents that it granted to the Mohawk Tribe back in 2017. Although the patents are quite valuable, Allergan actually paid the Mohawk Tribe to take the patents. The scheme allowed Allergan to still exclusively control use of the underlying inventions and potentially benefit from the Sovereign Immunity given to Indian Nations within the United States."

Well, it obviously did not work. Kevin Noonan, another patent maximalist, said "this clearly is not the end of the matter; it remains to be seen whether the Board quickly follows with a Final Written Decision on the merits (due within the statutorily mandated twelve months on March 31st) or whether the Tribe files a Notice of Appeal on this issue (although the availability of such an appeal, likely to be considered interlocutory in nature, is uncertain; it is unlikely the PTAB will certify the question or otherwise facilitate an early appeal)."

Scott McKeown said that the "Federal Circuit will review both the PTAB’s state and tribal sovereign immunity decisions in the short term."

It seems very unlikely to be overturned.

Watchtroll hates PTAB so much that he is willing to defend this patent scam. Here is what he wrote yesterday:

“The Tribe is a sovereign government that cannot be sued unless Congress unequivocally abrogates its immunity or the Tribe expressly waives it,” wrote attorneys for the Tribe in the Motion to Dismiss. “Neither of these exceptions apply here. As Patent Owner, the Tribe is an indispensable party to this proceeding whose interests cannot be protected in its absence.”

[...]

If this panel really believes this, if the entire PTAB really believes this, god help patent owners!

[...]

Whether you believe the Saint Regis Mohawk tribe deserves to dismiss these IPR proceedings by asserting sovereign immunity isn’t really the issue. Even if this winds up being the correct legal determination (which I seriously doubt), patent owners deserve better.


These so-called 'patent owners' [sic] would be better served without such scams in their 'support'. It just makes the patent system look rather bad and ripe for corruption. Here's what Managing IP wrote yesterday:

The PTAB rules that sovereign immunity does not apply in the closely-watched case in which Allergan transferred patents to a Native American tribe, and that the proceedings can continue even without the tribe’s participation in view of Allergan’s retained ownership interests in the challenged patents

The Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) has ruled that sovereign immunity does not apply to inter partes review (IPR) in the closely-watched case in which Allergan transferred patents to a Native American tribe.


“The only reservation that I had with the decision was that the PTAB did not come out and use the words: sham deal,” this comment said. It went further:

By not doing so, it injects ambiguity, as it is the "sham deal" designation that carries the legal effect that the PTAB enacted.


A Federal judge has already called it a "sham". Many others called it a "scam".

It would be a lot better for the legitimacy of the patent system to just leave it all behind and not openly/publicly defend such a "scam" or "sham". Every time lawyers/attorneys express their support for the scammers they promote the perception that they too are scammers or sympathetic towards scams.

Recent Techrights' Posts

[Meme] 'Secure' Boot in a Nutshell
Ask Microsoft if it is "safe" to boot Linux
A 3-Year Campaign to Coerce/Intimidate Us Into Censorship: Targeting Guest Writers (Intimidation)
Some high-profile people have told me that the serial defamer is a "monster" (their word), so why would Neil Brown wish to help him?
 
[Meme] 3 Years Later
If you're going to start a fight, make sure you can handle it
When You Leave a Bad Employer and Move on to Better Things
Perhaps my main mistake was not resigning from my job sooner
No, Your Site Likely Does Not Need WordPress
I was one of the first users of WordPress
GNU/Linux in Cameroon: Rising Steadily While Windows Falls From 99% to Just 6%
If one also counts mobile (mostly Android)
Monkey See, Monkey Share
on deprivation of users
From 0.17% to 10% or More (GNU/Linux in Dominica)
Dominica isn't well known, but it does seem to have embraced Chromebooks in recent years
Links 28/05/2024: Tensions in East Asia, UK Mandatory National Service
Links for the day
Gemini Links 28/05/2024: NetCrawl and Living in Lagrange
Links for the day
Guardian Digital, Inc (linuxsecurity.com) Handed Over Its Web Site to Chatbots That Generate SEO Garbage
They need to be called out on it
statCounter Sees Microsoft Windows at Below 1% in American Samoa
Not even 1%!
Windows Down to 60% of Guam's Desktops/Laptops and Down to a Quarter Overall
No wonder Microsoft is panicking
Today in UEFI 'Secure' Boot Debates (the Frog is Already Boiling and Melting)
Over at LQ today
[Meme] A "Modern" Web's Message in a Bottle
So-called 'security'
Brittany Day: Still Chatbot Slinging, Producing Fake 'Articles' About "Linux"
random garbage produced (and censored) by Microsoft
Almost 4k Gemini Capsules, 5th Anniversary Only Weeks Away
The Web will continue to deteriorate
Microsoft: $1 Million a Day for Contempt of Court Orders (Justice Department)
Microsoft behaves as if it's 100% exempt from laws
Catbodia? In Cambodia, Microsoft's Windows Fell to All-Time Low of Less Than a Quarter.
Cambodia is leaving Microsoft behind
[Meme] Deadnaming
Guess who uses a name that was deprecated well over a decade ago?
New Press Report Explains Microsoft Severance and Quiet (Undisclosed) Layoffs
Some people will call this "loophole", whereas others will opine that it is outright illegal (but kept secret to circumvent scrutiny)
Global South is Android/Linux (Windows Era Has Come to an End Already)
I've decided to take a quick glance at South American trends for all operating systems
[Meme] Unified Patent Troll
Unified Patent Court remains illegal and unconstitutional
The European Patent Office is Sinking
Officials (or national delegates) at the European Patent Organisation have long been warned about this (by staff representatives from the European Patent Office), but they ignored the warnings
Summer in the Air
We have a good pace going on owing to health, positivity, inertia and good software tools
GNU/Linux Activity in Belize
From an economic point of view, Microsoft needn't worry about Belize, but when it comes to preserving the Windows monopoly/monoculture Belize matters
Links 28/05/2024: Back to MP3, NVIDIA Sued by Authors
Links for the day
Gemini Links 28/05/2024: Bad Beach and TLS
Links for the day
Microsoft Windows Fell From 100% to Just 7.5% in Sierra Leone
Based on statCounter
In Benin, Microsoft's Windows Fell Below 10%, GNU/Linux Surged to 6% or Higher on Desktops/Laptops
That's nearly 7% - a lot higher than the average in Africa
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Monday, May 27, 2024
IRC logs for Monday, May 27, 2024
Delayed Series About Dr. Richard Stallman
A lot of the attacks on him boil down to petty things
[Meme] Elephant in the Asian Room
With ChromeOS included GNU/Linux is at 6% across Asia
GNU/Linux in Bangladesh Up From 0.5% to Over 4% (Windows Slid From 95% to 18%)
Bangladesh is one of the world's most densely-populated countries
A 3-Year Campaign to Coerce/Intimidate Us Into Censorship: Targeting Several Webhosts (in Collaboration and Conjunction With Mentally-Ill Flunkies)
Every attempt to nuke the current hosting failed, but it's still worth noting
Links 27/05/2024: One Month Left for ICQ, More Openwashing Highlighted
Links for the day
Gemini Links 27/05/2024: Back to GNU/Linux, Librem 5 Assessed
Links for the day
StatCounter (or statCounter) Has Mostly Recovered From a Day's Downtime (Malfunction)
Some of the material we've published based on the statCounter datasets truly annoys Microsofters
Google: We Don't Have Source Diversity, But We Have Chatbot Spew in Place of Sources (and It's Not Even Accurate)
Search engines and news search never looked this bad...
[Meme] Security is Not a Failure to Boot (or Illusion of Security Due to 'Unknown' System)
Red Hat is largely responsible for this mess
What is Secure Boot?
Security means the user feels safe and secure - i.e. confident that the machine would continue to work following a reboot or a system upgrade (or kernel upgrade)
StatCounter (or statCounter) Has Been Broken for Nearly 24 Hours. Who Benefits? Microsoft.
StatCounter is broken right now and has been broken for nearly 24 hours already
Links 27/05/2024: Chatbots Generate Hateful Output, TPM Performance Scrutinised
Links for the day
David Heinemeier Hansson (DHH) Realises What He Should Have Decades Ago
seeing that DHH is moving away from Apple is kind of a big deal
Reinvigorating the Voice of GNU/Linux Users (Not Companies Whose Chiefs Don't Even Use GNU/Linux!)
Scott Ruecker has just announced his return
"Tech" in the Context of Even Bigger Issues
"Tech" (or technology) activism is important; but there's a bigger picture
A Decade of In-Depth Coverage of Corruption at the European Patent Office (EPO)
The world needs transparency and sunlight
Hopefully Not Sunset for StatCounter
We hope that StatCounter will be back soon.
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Sunday, May 26, 2024
IRC logs for Sunday, May 26, 2024
Links 27/05/2024: Self-Publishing, Patent Monopolies, and Armed Conflicts
Links for the day
Gemini Links 27/05/2024: Tethering Connection and PFAs
Links for the day
Imagine Canada Enabling Rapists to Harass Their (Rape) Victims
This analogy is applicable because abusers are empowered against the abused
A 3-Year Campaign to Coerce/Intimidate Us Into Censorship: Targeting My Old "Tweets"
This was basically an act of vandalism no better and no worse than UEFI restricted boot
Links 26/05/2024: Google 'Search' Morphing Into Disinformation Factory, Discussion of Maze of the Prison Industrial Complex
Links for the day
In the Pacific (Mostly Islands Around Oceania) GNU/Linux Grew a Lot
Microsoft cannot compete fairly
A Toast to Tux Machines
Food ready for the party, no photos yet...
IBM/Red Hat Failing to Meet Its WARN Obligations in NC (STATE OF NORTH CAROLINA), or Perhaps It's Constantly Delaying the Layoffs
IBM isn't named even once
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Saturday, May 25, 2024
IRC logs for Saturday, May 25, 2024
GNU/Linux in Greenland
The sharp increases for GNU/Linux started last summer
The Sheer Absurdity of the EPO's Career System Explained by EPO Staff
"Staff representation has previously pointed this out to management, and the career system has been the reason for several industrial actions and litigation cases initiated by SUEPO."
[Meme] Productivity Champ Nellie Simon: It Takes Me 3+ Weeks to Write 6 Paragraphs
Congrats to Nellie Simon!
It Took EPO Management 3+ Weeks to Respond to a Letter About an Urgent Problem (Defunding of EPO Staff)
The funny thing about it is that Nellie Simon expects examiners to work day and night (which is illegal) while she herself takes 3+ weeks to write a 1-page letter
Staff Union of the EPO (SUEPO) in The Hague Taking Action to Rectify Cuts to Families of Workers
they "are active in challenging this measure via the legal system"