Editors • About the Site • Comes vs. Microsoft • Using This Web Site • Site Archives • Credibility Index • OOXML • OpenDocument • Patents • Novell • News Digest • Site News • RSS

03.04.11

The Patent Reform Act is a Joke

Posted in Law, Patents at 11:00 am by Dr. Roy Schestowitz

Writing a check

Summary: Why the “Patent Reform Act” is a waste of time and hardly a progressive piece of proposed legislation

OVER THE past month or so we wrote almost half a dozen posts about the so-called “Patent Reform Act” [1, 2, 3, 4] (also see Patent Reform Act from 2009 and from 2008), which is pushed by several senators, some more controversial than others. The Computer & Communications Industry Association is against it and TechDirt is sceptical too. As we have emphasised right from the start, this “Patent Reform Act” is not actually trying to address the real problems. Erick Robinson, a Senior Patent Counsel at Red Hat, agrees with this interpretation in his new essay which helps show that the “Patent Reform Act” is not quite what people are led to believe; it’s pointless and hardly a real reform, besides the name. But to use his own words:

Congress has been considering some form of patent reform for several years now, beginning with the Patent Reform Act of 2005. Once again, patent reform in is the air, as the Patent Reform Act of 2011 (the “PRA”) has been approved by the Senate Judiciary Committee and is scheduled to be debated by the full Senate this week. Although full reform of the U.S. patent system is needed for many reasons, the PRA has been watered down to a point that minimizes its usefulness. A thorough discussion of the need for patent reform is left for another day. This article provides a short overview of main provisions of the PRA and concludes by noting some potentially useful provisions in earlier versions of the bill that have been left out of the PRA.

The situation with software patents in the United States is rather messy. The opportunistic law firm mentioned in this new page exploits In Re Bilski to make some more money out of patents:

The Juhasz Law Firm introduced an offering named “virtual link” patent claim defense for corporate holders of software patents that are vulnerable to being challenged or struck down in the wake of the Supreme Court Bilski decision of June 28, 2010.

That’s just who/what patents are for. A law firm invents nothing, it’s just a pile of paper. How about a reform that defangs them along with patent trolls, combined with elimination of patents on thought processes? We’ll carry on this discussion in the next post. █

Share this post: These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Reddit
  • co.mments
  • DZone
  • email
  • Google Bookmarks
  • LinkedIn
  • NewsVine
  • Print
  • Technorati
  • TwitThis
  • Facebook

If you liked this post, consider subscribing to the RSS feed or join us now at the IRC channels.

Pages that cross-reference this one

What Else is New

  1. White House Should Identify USPTO as the Problem, Not Patent Trolls

    Continued analysis, accompanied by new stories, of the patent situation and what is needed to address the increasingly recognised harms of patents

  2. British and German Governments Under Siege by Lobbyists of Microsoft and Its Local Partners, Free Software Policy Dumped in Favour of Backdoors-Enabled Binaries

    Following lobbying and perhaps intimidation or bribery, Microsoft binaries with privileged access to them (ripe for cracking by the malpractising NSA/CIA) are being put ahead of Free/libre software, despite the latter being recently mandated

  3. Links 18/6/2013: Ubuntu Linux for Phones Attracts Carriers, Nokia Might be Saved by China/Android

    Links for the day

  4. Judge Jackson Dies While Microsoft Continues to Abuse the System, This Time Using Nokia as a Front

    The abusive behaviour of Microsoft continues unabated long after Judge Jackson warned about the sociopathic management and its dangers

  5. Microsoft Dirty Tricks to Promote Xbox One Vapourware

    The hallmarks of Microsoft -- AstroTurfing, vapourware, developers disdain and interference with journalism -- found sparingly in the gaming consoles scene

  6. Microsoft is Not Done With SCO Yet

    The SCO v. IBM case is reopened, despite a glaring lack of funds, resuming the FUD against Linux

  7. Boycott Best Buy

    The company with history of hostility towards GNU/Linux is now becoming part of Microsoft

  8. Links 17/6/2013: Android's Extended Lead Over iOS, Sony Smartwatch Gets FOSS

    Links for the day

  9. IRC Proceedings: June 9th, 2013-June 15th, 2013

    IRC logs for June 9th, 2013 (and subsequent days until June 15th, 2013)

  10. Upgrading/Updating Techrights

    Server maintenance complete, making pageloads faster and the Web site more robust, hence resilient against attacks

  11. Links 15/6/2013: IBM and KVM, KDE 4.11 Beta

    Links for the day

  12. Confirmed: Microsoft Tells the NSA About Back Doors in Windows

    Official confirmation that the NSA is being notified about ways of hijacking Windows before Microsoft releases fixes

  13. Still Missing the Point of Patent Scope (Patents on Mathematics and Nature) as the Problem in the United States

    Examples of some new reports that deal with the suggested patent reform in the US and why it is misguided

  14. Germany Should Follow the 'Munich Model' and Move to Free Software After PRISM Revelations

    Despite the success story of Munich and the increasing distrust surrounding proprietary software, bureaucrats in Berlin refuse to abandon Microsoft just yet

  15. Bill Gates Looking for Profit in Privatised Oppression in the United Kingdom and Elsewhere

    Famous criminal Bill Gates pays the privatised police forces in the UK to get more profit while keeping popular movements dampened

  16. Links 14/6/2013: Linux Innovation Debated, Video of Megaupload Raid

    Links for the day

  17. As the Battle to Legitimise Software Patents in New Zealand and Europe Carries on, New Systemic Corruption Found

    A roundup of stories from battlegrounds for software patents "as such"

  18. Microsoft Talking Points Planted by Microsoft Staff in the Geek Press

    Microsoft is playing with editorial staff of Slashdot, marketing itself as a FOSS company

  19. A Big Blow to Patents on Software and Genetics in the United States, But Hardly the End

    Little progress made with policy moving in the right direction, but by no means the right and absolute solution to USPTO incompetence

  20. Microsoft Supports Apple in Fight Against Linux/Android, Pushing FRAND

    Microsoft publicly steps forward as part of Apple's war on Linux/Android, making the anti-FOSS alliance more visible than before

  21. Rape Jokes Are Not Going to Save Microsoft

    Microsoft's attempts at being "cool" are not working out and the Vista series is falling to obscurity levels

  22. Glenn Greenwald Should Copy Snowden's Leak for Wikileaks to Publish in Full in Order to Counter Denials of Microsoft et al. (Updated)

    There should be more to come from the whole PRISM/NSA-gate, but the ball is in the court of one activist/lawyer/blogger, Glenn Greenwald

  23. Links 13/6/2013: CyanogenMod Gets Incognito Mode

    Links for the day

  24. Links 12/6/2013: Linux 3.11 Previews, KDE Working in Wayland

    Links for the day

  25. CNN: Where Agenda and Lobbying Trump Facts and Justice

    Corporate propaganda channel is being used by a Microsoft lobbyist to demonise Android -- not companies that attack Android -- by essentially twisting reality

  26. Obama Administration Misuses the 'T Word' (Troll) to Dodge Serious Issues

    Failing to see how patents themselves actually distort the market for everyone (not just some large corporations), Obama wants to wash his hands with legislation that will resolve nothing and legitimise the notoriously unsupervised patent regime

  27. Links 11/6/2013: More on PRISM and Snowden, Linux Mint Increasingly Praised

    Links for the day

  28. PRISM Lite: Bill Gates and Rupert Murdoch Collecting Information About Everybody's Children

    A surveillance scheme for juniors and how it is being used to program the young generation to support patent monopolies of Bill Gates, such as GMO

  29. White House Should Go After the Trolls' Ringleaders, Not Just Patent Trolls

    Why the stance of the White House is misguided and short-sighted in an age when trolls are like mercenaries for players in conspiracies and pyramid schemes of patents

  30. Novell's Acquirer Says the Brand Was Tarnished

    Attachmate's CEO acknowledges that Novell lost much of its lustre when it was acquired

RSS 64x64RSS Feed: subscribe to the RSS feed for regular updates

Home iconSite Wiki: You can improve this site by helping the extension of the site's content

Chat iconIRC Channel: Come and chat with us in real time

Recent Posts