Bonum Certa Men Certa

Bavarian State Parliament Has Upcoming Debate About Issues Which Can Thwart UPC for Good

Bavarian State Parliament due to debate motion about the EPO Boards of Appeal

Bavarian State Parliament debate



Summary: An upcoming debate about Battistelli's attacks on the EPO Boards of Appeal will open an old can of worms, which serves to show why UPC is a non-starter

A preliminary discussion is scheduled to take place at the next sitting of the EU Affairs Committee of the Bavarian State Parliament at 12:30 on Tuesday 20 February 2018.



It is expected that the motion will then be forwarded for a debate before a plenary session of the Parliament some time within the next couple of weeks.

An image of the motion (in German) is shown above along with an English translation below.

Bavarian State Parliament

17th Parliamentary Term 06.02.2018 Printed matter 17/20577

Motion

Dr. Hubert Aiwanger, Florian Streibl, Prof. (Univ. Lima) Dr. Peter Bauer, Dr. Hans Jürgen Fahn, Thorsten Glauber, Eva Gottstein, Joachim Hanisch, Johann Häusler, Dr.. Leopold Herz, Nikolaus Kraus, Peter Meyer, Prof. Dr. Michael Piazolo, Bernhard Pohl, Gabi Schmidt, Dr. Karl Vetter, Jutta Widmann, Benno Zierer and parliamentary group (FREIE WÄHLER)

Safeguard the independence of the Boards of Appeal at the European Patent Office

The State Parliament wishes to adopt the following resolution:

The State Government [of Bavaria] is called upon to advocate at federal and European level the adoption of measures within the European Patent Office to safeguard the independence of the Boards of Appeal and thus to ensure effective legal protection.

Explanatory statement:

A number of documented incidents, as set out below, raise serious doubts about the independence of the Boards of Appeal of the European Patent Office (EPO). The apparent loss of legal certainty requires action as soon as possible.

1. On 6 December 2017, the Administrative Tribunal of the International Labour Organisation (ILOAT) ruled that a judge of the Boards of Appeal who had been unlawfully suspended was to be immediately reinstated in his official position, that the house ban imposed on him was to be lifted and that compensation for damages was to be paid (Judgments Nos. 3958 and 3960). In doing so, the ILOAT confirmed that the involvement of the EPO President was detrimental to the independence of the Boards of Appeal, because he had acted as both party and advisor to the Disciplinary Body for the EPO judges in internal disciplinary proceedings. This gives rise to the criticism that insufficient attention was paid to the separation of powers in this regard. After all a suspension by the Administrative Council can only be formally take place if the Enlarged Board of Appeal makes a proposal to that effect. At the time in question, however, after the Office Administration had made a written intervention in the ongoing proceedings, the judicial body refused to do so due to this interference and terminated the proceedings without a proposal. Even after the Geneva judgement of December 2017, the Administration initially refused the unlawfully suspended judge access to the EPO premises. Only after some delay did the President of the Boards of Appeal grant the right of entry but his competence was limited to announcing this for the premises in Haar. Ultimately, the unjustly suspended judge was prevented from exercising his - intrinsically independent - judicial position until the end of his term of office.

2. Leading lawyers, such as the former Federal Constitutional Court judge Prof. Dr. Siegfried Broß, have long questioned the independence of the Boards of Appeal. For example, in an interview with the specialist journal JUVE on 29 October 2015, he pointed out that the Boards of Appeal could not be recognised as having the character of a court of law quality, given that there was an obvious overlap in terms of staffing between the President of the Office and the supervision of the Boards of Appeal. In the meantime, a reform of the Boards of Appeal was initiated by the summer of 2016 which resulted in the spatial separation of the Boards of Appeal by moving to Haar at the end of 2017. However, there was no fundamental change to the administrative structure: the President remains the head of both the administration and the Boards of Appeal. In this way, he continues to have influence both in terms of staffing and resources.

3. At least partly due to this background, there are a number of constitutional complaints against decisions of the EPO pending before the Federal Constitutional Court (BVerfG) in which the legal structure of the proceedings before the Boards of Appeal is alleged to be unconstitutional (see the BVerfG's Annual Preview 2017): Az. 2 BvR 2480/10, Az. 2 BvR 421/13, Az. 2 BvR 756/16, Az. 2 BvR 786/16). Without trying to anticipate a final court decision at this juncture, it at least deserves to be noted that, for diverse reasons, several complainants have had serious reservations from a constitutional perspective about the rule-of-law conformity of the proceedings and have thus felt compelled to submit their concerns to the Federal Constitutional Court. Accordingly, this development provides additional confirmation of the findings set forth under 1 and 2. A particular highlight in this regard is the recent request by the Federal Constitutional Court to the German President not to sign off the implementing laws for the European Unitary Patent. This occurred against the background of a successful application for a temporary injunction (Case No. 2 BvR 739/17), which is likely to raise concerns about the rule of law in proceedings before the EPO. Finally, the question of the independence of the Boards of Appeal will also have a significant impact on the proposed Unitary Patent should the EPO be entrusted with the issuing of patents with unitary effect despite the existing deficiencies in the system of legal protection.

The aforementioned shortcomings in this area clearly create considerable uncertainty because, it is feared that both definitively rejected patent applications and finally revoked patents can no longer be examined by independent judges. Hence, important fundamental questions arise about the constitutional conformity of the appeal structures in the EPO. This is why the state government must take appropriate action at federal and European level so that the existing deficiencies in the system of legal protection are redressed and the prestige of this international organisation is not subject to further damage.



They hopefully understand the importance and urgency of this matter.

Recent Techrights' Posts

Traf-O-Data, the Company That Jeffrey Epstein's BFF (Bill Gates) (Co)Founded 53 Years and Went Out of Business Due to Heavy Losses
Who will die first, Bill or Microsoft?
A Note on SimilarWeb
Or why SimilarWeb is meaningless for more than 99% of the sites on the Web
IBM Said to be Shutting Down Offices or Sites in the United States
the press can no longer avoid admitting that IBM moves many jobs to India
LLM Slop as Attack Vector on the Reputation of Linux
The attacks on Linux have escalated to information warfare
 
Techrights Has Dealt With More Potent SLAPPs Than Violent Microsofters Begging to Hide What They Did to Women
I became accustomed to SLAPPs
Links 04/04/2025: Fury in South Korea, Flight MH370 Remains Mystery
Links for the day
Gemini Links 04/04/2025: Anger and Raspberry Pi CM4
Links for the day
Links 04/04/2025: LLM Slop Bubble Bursting and Korea Music Copyright Association Bans Slop 'Music'
Links for the day
Why Microsoft's Shares Sank Almost 20% in Recent Months (the Bubble is Imploding)
verified press reports from the past 24 hours
GNU/Linux Rises to Almost 5% in Algeria While Windows Sinks to All-Time Low
GNU/Linux grew tenfold
Where to Get More Gags
A valued reader recommended that to us
Links 04/04/2025: Tech Stock (Inc. GAFAM) Fall, Google Pretends to Do End-to-End Encrypted Emails (With Google in Control)
Links for the day
To Participate in Fedora Diversity You Must Use Proprietary Software
Not for the first time either
Yandex About to Be Three Times Bigger Than Microsoft (Bing) in Asia
That's about 60% of the world's population
Gemini Links 04/04/2025: Decoupling Updates, Elaho as Gemini Client
Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Thursday, April 03, 2025
IRC logs for Thursday, April 03, 2025
Microsoft's Trouble in Africa and Asia
A new all-time high for GNU/Linux
Brett Wilson LLP Reported to the Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA)
The saddest thing in all this is that law firms can maintain high standards shall they wish to
Links 03/04/2025: Tariff Pains and C.D.C. Cuts
Links for the day
StatCounter: Microsoft is Masking a Disaster, It's Way Behind DeepSeek Already and Interest in LLMs Has Waned
it turns out the money "raised" for "Open" "AI" may not even exist at all
Links 03/04/2025: SoftBank Money for Microsoft "Open" "AI" Probably Doesn't Even Exist, Wikimedia Foundation Blasts LLM Nuisance While Microsoft Admits Demand Has Shrunk
Links for the day
Gemini Links 03/04/2025: Patch Panel and Pictures
Links for the day
Islamic Republic of Iran: GNU/Linux at All-time High This Month, Windows Falls to 12%
Vista 10 is up this month despite being "end of life" (EoL) soon
Indonesia: All-Time Highs for GNU/Linux
What's noteworthy right now is the growth of GNU/Linux
statCounter Says GNU/Linux Usage is Up Again (Internationally)
some preliminary April data
Only on April 1st Can the Free Software Foundation Associate With Microsoft's Open Source Initiative (OSI)
We saw some pranks that day linking the FSF to Microsoft (e.g. "endorsing" Windows)
Confirmed in the Mainstream Media: A Lot of Microsoft "Workloads" Were Just LLM Slop (Helping to Fake Growth for Years, as Microsoft Had Paid "Open" "AI" to Become a "Client") and Demand is Rapidly Waning, Datacentres Canceled and/or Shut Down
Anything to facilitate further accounting fraud
Taiwan's Media Covers Closure of Microsoft's "AI" Lab, It's Time to Talk About the Gradual Death of Windows and Implosion of the "AI" Bubble
Earlier this week we showed that mostly Asian media had the 'nerve' to mention Microsoft silently shutting down its 'AI' lab
IBM Gets Rid of Kelly Chambliss as Mass Layoffs Reported in IBM Consulting, IBM Loses Key Contracts/Graft
IBM Consulting has been in disarray lately
More Gains for GNU/Linux, Based on Web Surveys
the Steam site shows rapid growth for "Linux" this month
Slopwatch: Anti-Linux Articles, Not Even Written by Humans
Why aren't Web sites more vocal about this problem?
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Wednesday, April 02, 2025
IRC logs for Wednesday, April 02, 2025
Links 03/04/2025: Apple Fined Over Secret Surveillance, "Elegant Writer For A More Civilized Age"
Links for the day
Gemini Links 02/04/2025: Books and Cold Tea
Links for the day
Links 02/04/2025: More Layoffs, Nokia Again Takes Advantage of Illegal and Unconstitutional Patent Court With Nokia Staff as 'Judges'
Links for the day
Links 02/04/2025: Seizures and Returns to Windows of 24 Years Ago
Links for the day
LLM Slop Helps Obscure and Distort News About Layoffs (IBM, GAFAM)
It's hard to find accurate information
Links 02/04/2025: Microsoft Developers Are Threatening to Go on Strike, World Backup Day Noted
Links for the day
Gemini Protocol Has Growing Appeal (the Web Got Too Bloated and Full of LLM Slop)
For any "data plan" with bandwidth limits or "tiers" it would be cheaper to use/browse Geminispace
The Web Can Survive LLM Slop, But Only If We Collectively Shun and Discourage Serial Sloppers
Doing nothing ought not be a possibility
Amid Secret Shut-downs and Mass Layoffs at Microsoft (4 Waves of Layoffs in 3 Months of 2025) Some Microsoft Staff Expected to Go On Strike
workers going on strike
Gemini Links 02/04/2025: No more on Mastodon and Gemini Mention Script in Go
Links for the day
Over at Tux Machines...
GNU/Linux news for the past day
IRC Proceedings: Tuesday, April 01, 2025
IRC logs for Tuesday, April 01, 2025
My Motion Disbarring or “Striking Off” Brett Wilson LLP for Enabling Violent Americans Who Try to Crush Microsoft Critics in the United Kingdom by Multiple SLAPPs
"Guns for hire" (for Microsoft people who received Microsoft salaries)
The U.S. Patent and Trademark Office Hijacked Again by Patent Litigation Industry, as President Cheeto Prioritises Aggressors
The "mafia" has taken over the "industry" and the Federal system (justice and constitutions trampled upon)
Ubuntu Slop and FUD Manufactured With LLMs and Funded (by Oneself) 'Studies'
Slop and FUD are ruining the Web