EditorsAbout the SiteComes vs. MicrosoftUsing This Web SiteSite ArchivesCredibility IndexOOXMLOpenDocumentPatentsNovellNews DigestSite NewsRSS

07.21.10

Links: GNU/Linux Desktop Merits Noted, Canonical Spreads Proprietary IBM Software

Posted in GNU/Linux, IBM, News Roundup, Servers, Ubuntu at 10:47 am by Dr. Roy Schestowitz

Bluish clouds

Summary: Further catch-up with GNU/Linux news (mostly from last week)

GNU/Linux

  • Of Hardware and OSs

    Currently, Linux systems take the very high end machines (any machine more powerful than a fully tricked out MacPro {read supercomputers and mainframes}) and the very low end machines (phones, routers, palm-tops, PVRs).

  • Stop Apologizing For Linux!

    There’s almost nothing that desktop Linux can’t do. A modern Linux desktop is probably a better choice for 95% of the heavy Internet service using population than the big commercial behemoth that dominates the desktop. I’m not saying Windows doesn’t have its place or that it doesn’t do the job for a lot of people, but Linux is better, faster, stronger, safer, and sexier than anything else out there. It’s cool. It rocks. It dramatically increases your sex appeal. And if you’ve got a 64 bit processor instead of 32, that goes double. What more do you want?

  • 10 things that drive me crazy about current operating systems
  • Fun

    • Using Compiz As A Window Management Tool

      You’ve seen the wobbly windows, you’ve seen the cube, you’ve seen the raindrops. Compiz is just a bunch of useless eye candy right? Wrong. While the flashy effects get most of the attention, Compiz is a top-notch window manager in its own right. In fact, it’s got so many workspace and window management tools that many people use Compiz for years without ever knowing about some of the most useful features. This guide will cover each of the best window management plugins for Compiz and explain how each can be used to create a more productive desktop, with or without wobbly windows.

    • Pimp my Linux desktop!

      Linux, which I’m using at the moment, comes with a pretty standard blue-themed Gnome desktop common to several distros- Debian, Mandriva and Fedora- distinguished only by a branded wallpaper.

      It’s a simple and elegant theme, but over the last few days I’ve been customising my desktop, changing the theme and icons. The new theme is a dark one which I think suits my laptop with its grey-bordered screen.

  • Desktop

    • Has Linux lost the desktop battle?

      Even I have done it. I don’t think you can be a Linux blogger without having done at least one post about how this year is the year the Linux desktop will take over the world. However, no matter how many people seem to write about it. The year the Linux desktop takes over the world always seems to fall through the cracks. Sometimes I think that there must be some Pinky foiling the Linux Brains plans :)

      But! The pundits cry, Linux is gaining market share every year. Surely it will win the Linux desktop prize soon. Nay! Say the naysayers, at the rate Linux is gaining desktop market share even those not born yet will have one foot in the grave before Linux has any significant rating. Which one is right?

    • Linux: No bloatware, popups, and annoyances

      GNU/Linux has the answer to these annoyances, and it is this: they are simply not there. Why? Because the software is written by developers that are not trying to sell you something.

    • China and the Year of the GNU/Linux Desktop

      It’s an old joke by now that this year will be the year of the GNU/Linux desktop – just like last year, and the year before that. But now there’s a new twist: that this year will be the year of the GNU/Linux smartphone – with the difference that it’s really happening.

      That’s mainly being driven by the huge success of the Linux-based Android system, but it’s not the only open source system here. There’s also webOS and MeeGo, both of which have their loyal fans. What that means is that whichever of these takes off, the open source world will benefit.

      [...]

      If Baidu does come out with its own Android rival, that could help to achieve two things. It would finally take open source into the Chinese mainstream, and help to ensure that Linux unequivocally becomes the world’s leading operating system for smartphones – if not on the desktop.

    • PT: “Nearly all school children getting familiar with open source’

      Almost all school children in Portugal are becoming familiar with using open source, including the Linux operating system, says Paulo Trezentos, founder of Caixa Mágica Software.

      By the end of this year, the company’s eponymous Linux-based operating system will have been installed on 890,000 school PCs and school laptops, he says. “In a country with a population of 10 million, this means that Linux is reaching the majority of the young people.”

    • 5 ways to use bootable Linux live discs

      In the almost 20 years since Linux was first released into the world, free for anyone to use and modify however they like, the operating system has been put to a lot of uses. Today, a vast number of servers run Linux to serve up Web pages and applications, while user-friendly versions of Linux run PCs, netbooks, and even Android and WebOS phones.

      One incredibly useful way that Linux has been adapted to the needs of modern computer users is as a “live CD,” a version of the operating system that can be booted from a CD (or a DVD or, in some cases, a USB drive) without actually being installed on the computer’s hard drive. Given the massive RAM and fast CPUs available on even the lowest-end computers today, along with Linux’s generally lower system requirements compared to Windows and Mac OS X, you can run Linux quite comfortably from a CD drive.

  • Server

    • Canonical bundles Linux, IBM database for the cloud

      Canonical is offering enterprises a chance to try cloud computing via a virtual appliance that bundles Ubuntu Linux with the IBM DB2 Express-C database running on the Amazon EC2 (Elastic Compute Cloud) public cloud platform.

      The free appliance, which features Ubuntu Server Edition 10.04, also can be deployed in private cloud configurations.

Allegation: Organisation Close to Microsoft ‘Unlimited Potential’ (EDGI) Helps Derail GNU/Linux in Russian Schools

Posted in Asia, Europe, GNU/Linux, Microsoft, Windows at 7:06 am by Dr. Roy Schestowitz

Train station in Russia

Summary: New anonymised paper is produced to make a case against GNU/Linux in schools and government corruption is said to influence decisions on operating systems

ON MANY occasions in the past we explained how Microsoft was preventing Russian schools from moving to GNU/Linux as planned. We last summarised this in March and one year ago we wrote about the "manuals" trick. Someone dropped some information and links for us last night. It concurs with what we learned before, but there is new evidence which is concrete. Below we have the raw logs.

mpak hi all Jul 21 03:22
mpak a couple of news from Russia Jul 21 03:22
mpak Russian project of free software for school is endangered by a “group of experts” claiming that Linux and free software are not suitable for schools Jul 21 03:23
cubezzz3 why unsuitable? Jul 21 03:24
mpak they published a report where they claim that: Jul 21 03:24
mpak - it is too difficult to install and setup Jul 21 03:24
mpak - qualified techs needed to support and maintain it Jul 21 03:25
cubezzz3 ridiculous Jul 21 03:25
mpak - MFD and printers are not well supported Jul 21 03:25
mpak - some software doesn’t work well Jul 21 03:25
cubezzz3 my installs from 2004 are still fine Jul 21 03:25
cubezzz3 MFD from HP are fine, others I’m not sure Jul 21 03:26
mpak - no educational guides were made by the ministry of education Jul 21 03:26
cubezzz3 anyways, I avoid MFD Jul 21 03:26
mpak - existing educational guidelines are not aligned with the free software Jul 21 03:26
mpak - MS office documents cannot be opened correctly Jul 21 03:26
cubezzz3 it is a huge problem mpak Jul 21 03:27
cubezzz3 so don’t use MS file formats :) Jul 21 03:27
cubezzz3 very simple Jul 21 03:27
mpak - teachers need additional training to use new software Jul 21 03:27
mpak - etc Jul 21 03:27
cubezzz3 how about some reasons on the other side? Jul 21 03:27
cubezzz3 Microsoft -> Giving money to a U.S. company Jul 21 03:27
mpak whole report is available here: http://www.infox.ru/infox/expert_judgement.pdf Jul 21 03:27
TechrightsBot Title: Not a web page! Aborting application/pdf type .::. Size~: 0 KB Jul 21 03:27
cubezzz3 that can’t really be too popular right? :) Jul 21 03:27
cubezzz3 OK Jul 21 03:28
mpak can you see the link? Bot complains on me Jul 21 03:28
cubezzz3 yes Jul 21 03:28
mpak the report is in Russian, of course, it is 3mb pdf Jul 21 03:28
mpak there is an article with a preliminary analysis of the report Jul 21 03:28
mpak http://tiny.cc/v0a7f — Rus-to-Eng translation of the article Jul 21 03:29
TechrightsBot Title: Google Translate .::. Size~: 1.01 KB Jul 21 03:29
cubezzz3 ok, mpak first of all Jul 21 03:29
cubezzz3 consider what the schools did _before_ MIcrosoft came along Jul 21 03:29
cubezzz3 obviously they functioned OK right? Jul 21 03:29
cubezzz3 so it’s definitely wrong to say you have to use MIcrosoft Jul 21 03:29
mpak yep. Jul 21 03:30
mpak so the article says that the report is largely “anonymous” Jul 21 03:30
mpak people didn;t bother to put their names on it Jul 21 03:30
cubezzz3 yeah :) Jul 21 03:30
ender2070 meaning they didnt want to Jul 21 03:30
cubezzz3 they don’t want backlash Jul 21 03:30
cubezzz3 we didn’t even use MIcrosoft when I was at school Jul 21 03:31
cubezzz3 we used Commodore PETs Jul 21 03:31
cubezzz3 Russia has good programmers Jul 21 03:31
DaemonFC hmmm, the latest Chrome dev build truncates downloads to the first 40 MB :P Jul 21 03:32
mpak but the organization that made it works closely with Microsoft on their Unlimited Potential program Jul 21 03:32
mpak it* == report Jul 21 03:32
DaemonFC Chromium it is then Jul 21 03:32
cubezzz3 so there should be a healthy GNU/Linux or FOSS community in Russia I think Jul 21 03:32
ender2070 chromium > chrome Jul 21 03:32
cubezzz3 yeah so it’s basically bullshit :) Jul 21 03:32
DaemonFC cubezzz3: their government doesn’t frown on unlicensed sharing of Windows Jul 21 03:32
ender2070 think of it like this, chromium is debian, chrome is ubuntu Jul 21 03:32
DaemonFC so they probably all have Pirate XP user groups :) Jul 21 03:32
cubezzz3 well don’t break copy right law Jul 21 03:32
DaemonFC it’s Russia Jul 21 03:33
DaemonFC :P Jul 21 03:33
cubezzz3 well maybe, I don’t know Jul 21 03:33
cubezzz3 Lots of European Linux people Jul 21 03:33
ender2070 you kidding? Jul 21 03:33
ender2070 they almost threw a teacher into a gulag Jul 21 03:33
cubezzz3 Russia is a big part of Europe Jul 21 03:33
ender2070 for pirating microsoft products Jul 21 03:33
mpak guys, please see it this way: government in Russia is very corrupted Jul 21 03:34
cubezzz3 mpak, no text? Then I can use google translate Jul 21 03:34
DaemonFC doesn’t Russia have that big MP3 site the government won’t shut down Jul 21 03:34
DaemonFC that’s selling unlicensed music Jul 21 03:34
mpak they will use any means to get more money Jul 21 03:34
ender2070 thats gone Jul 21 03:34
cubezzz3 ok, so why give money to Microsoft? Save your money Jul 21 03:34
cubezzz3 easy :) Jul 21 03:34
mpak hah, it is a usual scheme Jul 21 03:35
cubezzz3 Canada isn’t any better Jul 21 03:35
cubezzz3 we are like Microsoft North here Jul 21 03:35
mpak you’re government official, you pay money from budget to some company to buy their products, this company pays you back 30% in cash Jul 21 03:35
mpak that’s how it works in Russia Jul 21 03:36
cubezzz3 ok, but that is still 70% to Microsoft Jul 21 03:36
cubezzz3 yeah, I get it Jul 21 03:36
mpak if Microsoft wins this school project, Microsoft will receive just 70% of money, and 30% will be stolen Jul 21 03:36
cubezzz3 we didn’t have that problem before Jul 21 03:37
mpak 30% is just an example. in real life it could be 10% to company and 90% stolen Jul 21 03:37
cubezzz3 yes, that is a problem Jul 21 03:37
cubezzz3 many many systems better than Microsoft though Jul 21 03:37
mpak if the organization that made the report will convince government to push MS-oriented program Jul 21 03:37
cubezzz3 why pick the worst? Jul 21 03:38
mpak they will receive more money and wil be able to steal a half Jul 21 03:38
cubezzz3 see, that is not a philosophical problem like open source/ closed source Jul 21 03:39
cubezzz3 it is a social problem Jul 21 03:39
cubezzz3 a people problem Jul 21 03:39
cubezzz3 well you can complain to the government I suppose Jul 21 03:39
DaemonFC Microsoft even made it so that Windows 7 ultimate will accept any language pack Jul 21 03:39
DaemonFC it’s practically gift wrapped for pirates :P Jul 21 03:40
mpak i will complain to the government that the government steals money? :) Jul 21 03:40
cubezzz3 I complained to CBC, government of Canada and my municipal government too :) Jul 21 03:40
cubezzz3 heh Jul 21 03:40
cubezzz3 sure complain to the newspapers Jul 21 03:41
cubezzz3 complain to the radio stations Jul 21 03:41
cubezzz3 I fixed my councilman’s computer one time so he had to listen to me Jul 21 03:41
cubezzz3 at least they used pdf Jul 21 03:41
mpak oh, i need to fix someone’s computer then :)) Jul 21 03:42
mpak it is not them, it is a newspaper that get the report Jul 21 03:42
mpak the report was in paper form Jul 21 03:42
DaemonFC http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PtHiut6hzTg Jul 21 03:42
TechrightsBot Title: YouTube- KEEP YOUR STUPID KIDS OFF THE INTERNET .::. Size~: 105.16 KB Jul 21 03:42
DaemonFC Windows 7 Ultimate with Canadian language pack Jul 21 03:42
*DaemonFC hands one to cubezzz3 Jul 21 03:42
DaemonFC eh? Jul 21 03:42
*cubezzz3 sits on it Jul 21 03:43
*mpak puts a cup of coffee on it Jul 21 03:43
cubezzz3 dude, I’m the last person on the planet to use windows 7 Jul 21 03:43
DaemonFC cubezzz3: You love Windows 7 Jul 21 03:43
DaemonFC and you know it Jul 21 03:43
cubezzz3 I’ll tell you what Jul 21 03:43
mpak yeah, hypnotize him Jul 21 03:43
cubezzz3 you make it work on my 486 and I’ll use it Jul 21 03:44
cubezzz3 no cdrom drive :) Jul 21 03:44
DaemonFC but it DOES work on a 486 Jul 21 03:44
*DaemonFC waves his hand in front of cubezzz3 Jul 21 03:44
ender2070 overclock it to 800mhz Jul 21 03:44
ender2070 give it 512 mb ram Jul 21 03:44
DaemonFC This is the operating system you’re looking for Jul 21 03:44
ender2070 it’ll work then Jul 21 03:44
cubezzz3 even windows 2 sucked Jul 21 03:44
DaemonFC you WILL buy new hardware Jul 21 03:44
cubezzz3 and every version after that Jul 21 03:44
cubezzz3 jedi tricks don’t work on me, only money! Jul 21 03:44
DaemonFC you HAVE money Jul 21 03:45
ender2070 what if you received a free legit copy? Jul 21 03:45
cubezzz3 yeah but I don’t spend it on Microsoft products Jul 21 03:45
mpak http://tiny.cc/j8uwb Jul 21 03:45
*DaemonFC dumps out his monopoly box set and hands the money to cubezzz3 Jul 21 03:45
DaemonFC you guys use that stuff up there, right? Jul 21 03:45
mpak sorry about the previous link Jul 21 03:46
cubezzz3 lol Jul 21 03:46
mpak it was http://tinyurl.com/2arjpgf Jul 21 03:46
TechrightsBot Title: korobkin: Forefront Security for what it is worth .::. Size~: 31.52 KB Jul 21 03:47
*DaemonFC wonders if the Canadian serial killers are polite Jul 21 03:47
DaemonFC shame this isn’t 1990, I could get a Canadian hitman for half price Jul 21 03:47
DaemonFC have him whack the neighbors Jul 21 03:47
DaemonFC with a hockey stick Jul 21 03:47
DaemonFC or maybe let his hockey hair devour them whole Jul 21 03:47
DaemonFC bones and all Jul 21 03:47
DaemonFC :D Jul 21 03:47
mpak ok, have a good day guys Jul 21 03:48

IRC Proceedings: July 20th, 2010

Posted in IRC Logs at 6:50 am by Dr. Roy Schestowitz

GNOME Gedit

Read the log

Enter the IRC channel now

South African Government Surrenders to Microsoft Again

Posted in Africa, GNU/Linux, Microsoft, Windows at 5:26 am by Dr. Roy Schestowitz

SA flag

Summary: Microsoft captures a laptops flag in South Africa after lobbying and dumping

LAST MONTH we shared a Tectonic interview (ish) where the editor of the site explained how proprietary software vendors can take over, sometimes by getting rid of the Free software proponents. We saw that happening in several countries before. According to this latest report, the acquisition or removal of Free software advocates in South Africa is paying off for Microsoft:

Government Gazette 32077 (PDF), which details the approved specifications says that the laptops must run “Windows XP or higher”, include Microsoft Office as well as use Windows Live. Other approved software includes a range of Microsoft applications such as Microsoft Digital Literacy and Microsoft Partners In Learning.

The department does not specify any open source alternatives to the Microsoft software for the initiative.

How typical. Let’s go back exactly 2 years ago and remember how Microsoft derailed GNU/Linux/ODF in South African schools. Shame on Microsoft and on Bill Gates for pretending to be doing “charity” when this so-called ‘charity’ is actually an anti-competitive software dump.

“By May of 1994, Gates’s patience was growing so thin that not even a public relations pro like Pam Edstrom could muzzle him.”

Barbarians Led by Bill Gates, a book composed
by Pam’s daughter

Patents Roundup: RPX Grows, Netflix Issues a Patent Challenge, More on In Re Bilski

Posted in America, Patents at 5:11 am by Dr. Roy Schestowitz

Netflix logo

Summary: Potpourri of software patent news from the past week and a half (focused on the United States)

HAVING taken a break for a while, a lot of patent news piled up. Here are the important bits of information from the United States:

Association of Press Release Distributors, LLC (“Association of Press Release Distributors, LLC fight against #swpat on publishing press releases on websites,” emphasises Rui Seabra)

There are hundreds of press release distribution companies. Most exist with little to no interaction with each other in their industry. That ends today.

RPX Client Network Grows 150% in Six Months (see our Wiki page about RPX)

The new clients include global electronics companies NEC Corporation and Hitachi, Ltd.; infrastructure software provider Novell, Inc.; semiconductor manufacturer Nanya Technology Corporation; software developer Lawson Software, Inc.; wireless voice and data solutions provider Leap Wireless International Inc.; speech-recognition leader Nuance Communications, Inc.; and the world’s largest bookseller, Barnes & Noble, Inc.

Netflix Tries to Fix One Part of the Patent System

There’s a very interesting case, Media Queue v. Netflix, where Netflix is asking the Federal Circuit to revisit the standard for awarding attorneys’ fees. Here’s their appeal brief [PDF]. It would like the court to create parity between plaintiffs and defendants. Right now, the system tilts to help plaintiffs recover their fees if willful infringement is demonstrated, which is fairly easy to demonstrate. But defendants wrongfully sued have little hope of success when asking that their legal fees be covered, unless they can prove the claims were objectively baseless or brought in bad faith, a mighty high bar to get over. Netflix would like to change that to allow district courts to have discretion to award attorneys fees when folks bring litigation unlikely to succeed.

[...]

Netflix, in short, is asking the court to think about defendants who are attacked with very weak patents, and who then are more or less pragmatically forced to settle rather than fight, just because it’s cheaper. If they can’t get their attorneys’ fees paid, what in the world makes them whole? Netflix says Media Queue is “a non-practicing entity,” which is the polite way to call such entities. Setting an “objectively reckless” standard is a lower bar than proving frivolity or bad faith, and Netflix seems to be of the opinion that patent holders with weak patents are over-incentivized to bring questionable and very costly litigation, knowing they are unlikely to have to pay their victim’s attorneys’ fees, which can typically be in the millions.

NTP Keeps On Making The Case For Patent Reform As It Sues More Companies

Company suing eBay for $3.8B: eBay “unfairly stole the idea” of e-Payment systems

Another day, another major lawsuit. This time, a company called XPRT Ventures LLC has sued eBay for allegedly stealing “the idea and method of payment used in eBay’s PayPal and similar electronic payment systems” according to the press release put out by the XPRT’s lawyers Kelley Drye & Warren LLP.

Write Brothers, Inc. Celebrates a Decade at Comic-Con International 2010

Write Brothers currently holds three software patents. It holds two for the Dramatica® story assistant, and one for the timeline-based presentation of text used in the StoryView™ outlining software. Streamline is the fourth technology patent Write Brothers has filed.

Microsoft will offer test versions of Dynamics CRM in September

Microsoft biggest competitor in this arena is Salesforce.com, which sells a Web-based software service for customer relationship management. The two companies are currently suing each other over software patents.

There is still a lot of new coverage about the Bilski case:

The silver lining in the Bilski decision isn’t where most people believe (“Florian Müller” warning — he is sometimes misguided in his targeting of issues)

About two weeks ago the Supreme Court of the United States (SCOTUS) handed down its opinion in re Bilski, a business method patent case. The patent application was rejected, but in a way that didn’t draw any kind of line that would affect patents on software technology.

[...]

Let’s better face this fact: there isn’t a single killer argument against software patents that will convince a non-programmer if that same counterpart has also heard the pro-patent argument. If you can ever convince a majority of decision-makers, you’ll have to do it indirectly. The direct approach has been tried by many people for many years — to no avail (except, as I mentioned before, in a defensive situation).

Patent Litigation Weekly: Eben Moglen on Bilski, Software Patents, and Big Pharma

Moglen’s position on the subject of software patents—that they should be banned—is, to say the least, outside the mainstream in legal circles. It has, however, garnered support among software developers and other techies, especially those who work in the world of open-source and free software.

Moglen’s critique of the patent system extends well beyond the software issues he writes about, however. He suggests, for instance, that the 20-year monopoly granted by a patent is the product of a bygone era. And though he rejects the notion that he is “anti-patent,” he says that the patent monopoly grant should be subject to a rigorous cost-benefit analysis, not simply handed out at the “monopoly window” that he believes the current Patent and Trademark Office represents.

Sanity From the 1st Post-Bilski Decision from BPAI: In Re Proudler

Look at this, will you? The first decision from the Board of Patents Appeals and Interferences post-Bilski to reference that US Supreme Court decision, in In Re Proudler [PDF], a ruling rejecting HP’s application for a software patent, setting forth a rule stating, as I read it, as saying software is not patentable because it’s an abstraction:

Laws of nature, abstract ideas, and natural phenomena are excluded from patent protection. Diamond v. Diehr, 450 U.S. at 185. A claim that recites no more than software, logic or a data structure (i.e., an abstraction) does not fall within any statutory category. In re Warmerdam, 33 F.3d 1354, 1361 (Fed. Cir. 1994). Significantly, “Abstract software code is an idea without physical embodiment.” Microsoft Corp. v. AT&T Corp., 550 U.S. 437, 449 (2007). The unpatentability of abstract ideas was confirmed by the U.S. Supreme Court in Bilski v. Kappos, No. 08-964, 2010 WL 2555192 (June 28, 2010).

This is not the last word, I’m sure, as HP can certainly try to reword. But don’t you find this encouraging? I do. And that’s why I wanted it in our permanent record of the Bilski case and its aftermath.

First Post-Bilski Patent Appeals Ruling Rejects Software Patent (Bilski precedence is already killing patents)

Well, well, well. Following the rather ridiculously vague Bilski ruling, that doesn’t actually say what the right test should be for whether or not business methods or software should be patentable, many people have been wondering what it really means. While some of the justices have hinted at the idea that most software really isn’t patentable, that’s not at all clear from the ruling. Instead, the ruling suggests that the courts come up with a new test, and then the Supreme Court will tell them whether or not that new test is okay. Many software patent system supporters have interpreted this to mean that software patents are perfectly okay. But perhaps they shouldn’t go that far just yet.

Post-Bilski Decision

One of the first decisions post-Bilski has shot down an appeal of a rejected patent application by HP. The patent-examiner had rejected the patent on the grounds of prior art (It’s mostly AND applied to rules for passing data…) but the appeal-board rejected the claims on the grounds of non-patentability

From the Editors: The Supreme Court’s road not taken

Bilski patent ruling will increase costs of doing business, says expert

United States: The Supreme Court Rules That The Process in Bilski is Not Patentable, But Refuses to Foreclose The Patentability of Business Methods

Bilski, Business Method Patents and the Uncertainty Principle

Bilski: One Step Forward… Two Steps Back

Inventors Given Hope on Patents for Business Methods

Software, pharmaceutical, and business method patents survive

A Close Call for Silicon Valley

Death Knell For Software Patents

United States: The Long-Awaited Bilski (In) Decision

[Ben Klemens on] Bilski and software patents

Should software be patentable?

It seems to me that the concept of certain generic sorts of software patents could well be made redundant thanks to the growth of open source, while remaining for specialist applications that have a technical purpose.

Patent Office Says No to Supreme Court and Software Patents

Startups and University Research: Too Much Emphasis on Patents?

When the Supreme Court ruled last month on the Bilksi case, denying Bilski’s patent claim that Bilksi’s patent but not making any real statements on the overall patentability of business methods or software, several opponents of software patents, including VCs Jason Mendelson and Brad Feld expressed their disappointment.

[...]

The study surveyed over 11,000 professors, and of the 1948 who responded who had started businesses, only 682 – about a third – had established them to exploit the patents obtained via the university intellectual-property systems. The remaining 1266 respondents had started businesses based on non-patentable knowledge.

Supreme Court On Patenting

Software patent advocates are praising the said decision of the Supreme Court like Tom Syndor saying that the Supreme Court was sensible in rejecting the said idea. A new layer and era of patent decade will help in requiring patent applicants to present plaintiffs to prove that their ideas are not abstract.

Paul Kedrosky’s article “Software Patents Need to Be Abolished” has spread further (also published in other places with Brad Feld, who is a critic of software patents [1, 2, 3]).

Jonathan Jones Acknowledges He is in Monsanto’s Pocket (Updatedx2)

Posted in Intellectual Monopoly, Patents at 4:38 am by Dr. Roy Schestowitz

Monsanto booster

Summary: Proponent of food monopoly (using controversial patents on misunderstood seeds) remarks on the lack of disclosure, namely his paychecks from Monsanto

SEVERAL weeks ago we wrote about Monsanto proponent Jonathan Jones, who without any disclosure decided to promote Monsanto’s agenda in the MSBBC. Here is Jones admitting the conflict of interests:

The scientist in charge of a taxpayer-funded trial that may determine whether genetically modified crops will be grown in the UK has been attacked for his close links to the US biotech giant Monsanto.

Professor Jonathan Jones, head of the Sainsbury Laboratory at the John Innes Centre, the UK’s leading plant research centre, has shrugged off the controversy, insisting he has never tried to hide his business relationship with Monsanto or the GM industry.

“Never tried to hide” is not the same as disclosure. It is important that conflicts of interests are not left as “an exercise for the reader” to find. This is a failure both for the MSBBC and for Jones.

Related posts:

  1. Reader’s Article: The Gates Foundation and Genetically-Modified Foods
  2. Monsanto: The Microsoft of Food
  3. With Microsoft Monopoly in Check, Bill Gates Proceeds to Creating More Monopolies
  4. Gates-Backed Company Accused of Monopoly Abuse and Investigated
  5. How the Gates Foundation Privatises Africa
  6. Seeds of Doubt in Bill Gates Investments
  7. Gates Foundation Accused of Faking/Fabricating Data to Advance Political Goals
  8. More Dubious Practices from the Gates Foundation
  9. Video Transcript of Vandana Shiva on Insane Patents
  10. Explanation of What Bill Gates’ Patent Investments Do to Developing World
  11. Black Friday Film: What the Bill Gates-Backed Monsanto Does to Animals, Farmers, Food, and Patent Systems
  12. Gates Foundation Looking to Destroy Kenya with Intellectual Monopolies
  13. Young Napoleon Comes to Africa and Told Off
  14. Bill Gates Takes His GMO Patent Investments/Experiments to India
  15. Gates/Microsoft Tax Dodge and Agriculture Monopoly Revisited
  16. Beyond the ‘Public Relations’
  17. UK Intellectual Monopoly Office (UK-IPO) May be Breaking the Law
  18. “Boycott Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation in China”
  19. The Gates Foundation Extends Control Over Communication with Oxfam Relationship
  20. Week of Monsanto
  21. The Gates Foundation Nearly Doubles Its Investment in Walmart, Also Invests in McDonald’s and GMO

Update: GM Watch has also just responded to this. “Jones backs down over Monsanto connection” says the headline and the author points out that “an article appeared in The Observer newspaper detailing Prof Jonathan Jones’s failure to make clear his busines links to Monsanto in a recent article for the BBC.”

Jones said: “It is not true to suggest I have attempted to hide my role as co-founder and science advisory board member of Mendel Biotechnology, which has contracts with Monsanto, Bayer and BP.”

GM Watch also quotes a comment which says: “I found out about Prof Jones’ involvement in an American based biotech firm back in 2001 when someone told me there were jobs going there. I was quite surprised to find Prof Jones, and if my memory serves me correctly a couple of other leading British plant scientists on the directorial board. The thing that surprised me back then was that having worked in their field for over ten years and having heard them speak on numerous occasions at conferences etc that I had never heard them mentioned their clearly relevant commercial interests. If my memory serves me correctly they always stuck to their wholly impartial for ‘the public good’ scientist persona.

“Now following the thieving banks [and] the thieving politicians, I am not surprised at all. Our leading lights are all the same, out for number one.”

Update #2: GM Watch also brings attention to this site which documents Jonathan Jones’ attacks on GMO critics/sceptics.

Fraunhofer Promotes Software Patents, Even in Europe (and Van Quickenborne Facilitates It)

Posted in Europe, Microsoft, Patents, Videos at 4:33 am by Dr. Roy Schestowitz

Fraunhofer

Summary: Patent news from Europe, including some new warnings about proponents of the harmful practice of software patenting

Fraunhofer is close to Microsoft and even to the Gates Foundation, as we showed in posts such as:

According to Jan Wildeboer, Dr. Kurt Blind from Fraunhofer says that a software patent “reduces transaction costs”.

Wildeboer asks: “In what galaxy does he live?”

This pattern of patent maximisation over at Fraunhofer is at least a consistent one. Fraunhofer is a true proponent of monopolies.

Interestingly enough, the following new interview with Van Quickenborne reveals that they (Belgian government) plan to enable software patents through the back door. “Comment of Hartmut Pilch on the EU Patent video removed by Euractiv,” says the Belgian president of the FFII, which was founded by Pilch himself. Are dissenting views about this video being suppressed by deletion? Apparently so. Here is another new video of Van Quickenborne, who talks about the same subject.


At a later stage, the president of the FFII pointed out that according to Horns, “Mr Marco Schulze of BIKT had argued that patent law obstructs proper use of copyright.” These are some serious misconceptions that even Horns is opposing in his blog. Horns is not a hardliner.

Politicians ought to be educated about the technical matters involved. A lot of them remain gullible enough to rush through anything that lawyers and monopolies they work for are proposing. “Very soon, the progress bar will finally be legal to use in software in the EU,” wrote Rui Seabra. The patent is due to expire on October 24th. Why was it patented in the first place? It’s just a digital metaphor for something like an hourglass. And why was in patented in Europe, which claims to be against software patents?

Apple Patents That Retard GNU/Linux/X Font Rendering Finally Expire, Microsoft Still a Barrier (ClearType Patents)

Posted in Apple, GNU/Linux, Microsoft, Patents at 4:02 am by Dr. Roy Schestowitz

Keyboard

Summary: As Apple’s monopoly on a certain font rendering method expires, FreeType enables BCI by default, but Microsoft still has patents in this area of subpixel rendering

Jan Wildeboer, Rui Seabra, and Carlo Piana pass the message that “MSFT has ClearType patents for subpixel rendering on LCD screens” (details in this page).

This was said in reference to the news that “FreeType 2.4 [is] now free from patent restrictions”:

The FreeType development team has released version 2.4 of the rendering library for TrueType and PostScript fonts. FreeType is used in almost all Linux and open source Unix systems. The latest version is also much more stabile when dealing with broken or damaged font files.

“Now that is good news,” Oiaohm wrote in IRC. “Font rendering on Linux will come up to everything else.”

Jan Wildeboer wrote: “Truetype hinting #swpat (Apple owns them) have expired. So now the BCI is enabled by default in FreeType” (see this page)

Florian Müller wrote about it too, but the news was mostly covered in short messages. This fine example of the harms of software patents (making products poorer than they ought to be) did not receive the attention it truly deserved. We previously covered the ill effects of software patents on font rendering and mentioned Apple in this context. Below we add some older articles for background and future reference.

______
2006

Optimal Use of Fonts on Linux

The font subsystem on Linux evolved a lot in the last years, from an old naming, handling and option of fonts, to the support of True Type, Bistream Vera, etc. As of release time of Fedora Core 2, components like Xft, FreeType and FontConfig, and higher level software usage of them has stabilized and is now considered mature.

Perspective: Microsoft’s forgotten monopoly

The story of how Microsoft used its monopoly in operating systems to acquire a dominant position in office applications and browsers has often been told. But there’s another Microsoft monopoly that’s rarely mentioned, even though most of us see it every day.

Microsoft’s fonts are used to display most Web pages on the planet. Even Linux and Mac users, who often have fled Windows to avoid dependence on Microsoft, read most of their content using Microsoft fonts.

Linux Libertine Open Fonts offers free Times Roman alternative

Currently, Linux Libertine consists of more than 1,750 glyphs for Latin, Greek, and Cyrillic alphabets and their derivatives, including ligatures and kerning tables. Some work remains to be done on the italics, but the roman or ordinary weight is complete, as well as the bold and underlined weights. A set of small caps is in development, and a grotesque or sans serif font (one without serifs) is planned, but not yet available.

2007

Finding Software That Slows Down Your Computer

The PC Spy is trying to make people aware of the worst software that is out there, and to no surprise Norton Internet Security 2006 is at the top.
 
[...]
 
It is pretty obvious that having a large number of fonts degrades performance in Windows. I think that I’ll be going through and deleting some of the ones that came with Vista because I really don’t need 400+ fonts.

Visual comparison of major OS’s font rendering

Personally I don’t like ClearType at all. And looking at it gives me headaches. Also, Linux’s myth of bad font rendering is finally over.

Checking out the new Open Font Library

Up until the last few years, typefaces were a neglected aspect in FOSS. However, the increased popularity of the GNU/Linux desktop and the emergence of software for designers is changing that. “The whole vectorization of the desktop with Inkscape is really doing a beautification of the desktop,” Phillips says. In such an atmosphere, the OFL looks like an idea whose time has come.

Clearing up the Novell ClearType controversy

So, although this story illustrates just how software patent issues can wind their way into open-source software, it doesn’t appear to have any direct link to the Microsoft/Novell partnership or the issues, such as the GPLv3 revision, that surround it.

Liberation Fonts

The first release is a set of fully usable fonts, but they will lack the fully hinting capability (hinting adjusts font pixelization so that the fonts render with high quality at large and small sizes) provided by TrueType/FreeType technology. That release is now ready. The second release will provide full hinting of the fonts, and that release will be available by the end of the calendar year.

Interview with David Turner of Freetype

If the patent owner of hinting gives the Freetype project a free license, would you accept it?
 
David Turner: It really depends on the terms of this “free license”. Basically if it means the patent can not be freely re-licensed to other people, I really don’t see why I would find that useful. If you absolutely need the bytecode interpreter, you can be patient and wait for October 9, 2009, when the patents expire.
 
[...]
 
There is no clear answer as to what is best. Personally, I can’t stand native TrueType hinted fonts anymore, they look too distorted to me, even if their contrast is better. My favorite Linux distribution is Ubuntu at the moment, and the first thing I do after installing it is to wipe the version of FreeType provided with it to get rid of the bytecode interpreter :o)
 
Also, I still don’t understand why Debian and Ubuntu keep distributing patent-infringing code in FreeType, while they keep MP3 and DVD playback out of their normal installs. I’m not even sure it’s DFSG compliant… 

Improving Linux font rasterization?

While the discussion continues it looks like that in the long term the major toolkits have to get together to talk about implementing the mentioned techniques. Or, as suggested by David, a initiative dedicated to bringing patches upstream is launched. It could try to work with upstream on the one hand, but with the distributors on the other hand – if the users see the results because the distributions include the patches it might help influencing the decision of upstream.      
But there is no way of reaching perfect font rasterization with changes in FreeType only. 

3 Examples of Bad Microsoft Word Typography

From the makers of Arial, here are three examples of bad typography in Microsoft Word. Bad typesetting in Word finds its way into résumés, business plans, research papers, government documents, even published books. These small inconsistencies and imperfections may be un-noticible in small doses, but paragraph-after-paragraph they stack up—resulting in ugly, visually-incohesive documents. Word isn’t for professional typography work, but that’s no excuse for these typography sins.     

Microsoft, Apple extend font licensing agreement

Apple Inc. and Microsoft Corp.said Thursday they have renewed their font licensing agreement. Financial terms weren’t disclosed. Under the agreement, Apple users will have ongoing use of the latest versions of Microsoft Windows core fonts, the companies said.

Open source fonts

If you’ve ever gone looking for legitimately free fonts, you’ve probably found that there are a lot of really bad ones. But there’s also a lot of discussion out there about “open source fonts.”  
 
Some who post about open source fonts are really just talking about free-as-in-beer typefaces. Some, however, have embraced the open source philosophy as applied to typography.   

2008

Ubuntu and Fonts

In this short tutorial i discuss some handy fonts related tips that could improve user’s desktop experience . The tips include installing Microsoft True type fonts enabling one to render documents and web pages created in Microsoft Windows properly in Ubuntu Linux, Installing a set of cool looking fonts released by RedHat – Liberation fonts package , making fonts look good on your LCD Display by turning on subpixel smoothing , installing some cool and free fonts on your Ubuntu Desktop and finally how to install any font if  you have it’s ttf file .        

Ubuntu Hardy – Liberation Fonts now Fully Hinted?

A recent update came through for liberation fonts. It wasn’t clear, but it looks as if there is now full hinting available. Looks very nice! Might have  to add this to my Win XP work laptop as well.  

Liberation Fonts Increase Interoperability For Linux Users

Most problems when opening Word documents under GNU/Linux are due to missing fonts. Therefore, Red Hat published a set of fonts metric-compatible with the Windows core fonts last year.

100+ Beautiful Free Fonts for Ubuntu

If you are a graphic and web designer, the default fonts that came with Ubuntu will surely be not enough for your needs. However, if you know where to look, you can find plenty of additional fonts that can help get the job done.

Ubuntu Basics – Appearance

Like it or not, the Arial font looks good on Windows just as Helvetica looks good on a Mac (unless you’re some typography nerd that insists on arguing which looks better/worse/etc.)

Arial looks even better when used in Ubuntu.

« Previous Page« Previous entries « Previous Page · Next Page » Next entries »Next Page »

RSS 64x64RSS Feed: subscribe to the RSS feed for regular updates

Home iconSite Wiki: You can improve this site by helping the extension of the site's content

Home iconSite Home: Background about the site and some key features in the front page

Chat iconIRC Channels: Come and chat with us in real time

New to This Site? Here Are Some Introductory Resources

No

Mono

ODF

Samba logo






We support

End software patents

GPLv3

GNU project

BLAG

EFF bloggers

Comcast is Blocktastic? SavetheInternet.com



Recent Posts