Links 26/6/2010: HP and Linux, GNOME Shell 2.31.4 is Out
Contents
GNU/Linux
-
Ballnux/HP
-
HP linux netbook
This is the HP Mini 100e, a netbook which looks are fully customizable. There’s an option for SUSE Linux as the operating system. It’s nice to see something different in operating system options, too bad the other 2 options are windows versions (XP and 7)
-
HP and Linux’ OEM problem
The problem, however, will remain in any case. In freeing itself from the tyranny of Windows, HP takes software and customer responsibility into its own hands. It’s something no Linux distro owner has been able to do in a consumer market.
If HP succeeds Microsoft is in real trouble.
-
-
Kernel Space
-
Is PowerTop Still Useful For Extending Your Battery Life?
-
Graphics Stack
-
Intel Releases Its 2.12 X.Org Driver, 2010Q2 Package
While Intel had only released its xf86-video-intel 2.12 release candidate ten days ago and there was only one RC, yesterday afternoon they decided to go forward and make the final release. The xf86-video-intel 2.12.0 DDX driver is now available and they have also tagged their 2010Q2 driver package.
-
-
-
Applications
-
NetUP IPTV 1.6 has been released
NetUP have released a new version of IPTV Complex, an interactive TV software bundle. It introduces new graphic interface featuring a number of improvements both in design and on technical level.
-
GUI For GoogleCL Script 0.1
-
VLC 1.1.0 for Linux – Complete Review
As always, VideoLAN has come up with interesting tweaks, updates and enhancements to its all popular VLC media player with the release of version 1.1.0.
-
9 Top Alternative Linux Music Players
Reinventing the wheel is sometimes viewed as a significant barrier to the development of open source software. Critics point out that if developers simply collaborated more with each other, instead of creating yet another Linux distribution or programming another text editor, this would help to simplify matters for users, and actually significantly advance the development of established open source projects.
-
Proprietary/Wine
-
Wine Announcement
The Wine development release 1.2-rc5 is now available.
What’s new in this release (see below for details):
– Many translation updates.
– A lot of bug fixes. -
An introduction to CrossOver Office and Games for Solaris
-
Linux game-time refined with latest Wine
Wine, the project that lets Linux users run Windows apps within Linux, has released a major update that fixes a number of bugs and includes 64-bit support.
Wine 2.1 includes a new set of icons, a number of fixes for video rendering – improving Windows gaming – and better font anti-aliasing and handling of desktop link files.
-
-
Instructionals
-
Hackery Xen 4.0.1-rc1 source & kernels packaged for Ubuntu Lucid @Virtualusr Site up to 4.0.1-rc3
-
How To Install nVidia 256.35 Display Drivers In Ubuntu (From A PPA Repository)
-
How To Install BIKA LIMS Inkosi On Ubuntu Server In 15 Minutes
-
Install New GIMP 2.6.9 in Ubuntu 10.04 ‘Lucid Lynx’
-
JasperReports 3.6: Creating a Report from XML Data using XPath
-
Setting Up VAAPI Hardware Accelerated Video Decoding for Ubuntu 10.04 (example Intel Poulsbo GMA 500)
-
-
-
Desktop Environments
-
K Desktop Environment (KDE SC)
-
What Happened at LinuxTag
During the conference, Radio Tux interviewed Frederik Gladhorn about the KDE Plasma Netbook interface (interview in German) and Frank Karlitschek participated in the discussion around cloud computing (also in German). Frank also did an interview with Vincent Unz and Stormy Peters from GNOME.
-
KOffice 2010 Summer Sprint Report
Hot on the heels of the 2.2 release of KOffice — the first release we feel that users can give a try and use for real work — the KOffice developers met in Essen-Horst in Germany, in the wonderful Linux Hotel. Thanks to sponsorship by the KDE e.V. and the hard work by Alexandra Leisse and Inge Wallin, we could spend three days discussing and hacking.
-
-
GNOME Desktop
-
-
Distributions
-
New Releases
-
Debian Family
-
Verbal bits from the Debian Project Leader
LinuxTag 2010 is the host of a Debian miniconf; that, in turn, was where relatively new Debian leader Stefano Zacchiroli delivered a relatively high-energy “state of Debian” talk. According to Stefano, Debian is doing great, but can do better yet; he has some ideas for how to make the project better.
-
Canonical/Ubuntu
-
Project Harmony looks to improve contribution agreements
On 16 June Project Harmony had its first official meeting in Boston, and we’re planning another in London on 1st July at Canonical’s offices. Its initial goal is to avoid proliferation in contribution agreements across FOSS software projects where those organisations chose to work with contribution agreements.
-
The Unity Launcher Looks Gorgeous [Ubuntu Netbook Edition 10.10]
-
Flavours and Variants
-
Goodbye Ubuntu, it’s been fun — as part of my withdrawal, I’m running Xubuntu … for now anyway
If you’re happy with Ubuntu Lucid, I salute you and wish I was among you. My problems at this point are my own — I don’t detect any groundswell of geeks moving away from the GNOME build of Ubuntu. And I’m glad Xubuntu is here to provide a stripped-down Ubuntu experience that more closely matches my hardware and workflow.
Yeah, I love freedom. Three cheers.
-
-
-
-
-
Devices/Embedded
-
Embedded Linux development platform adds PowerPC support
Mentor Graphics announced a version of its Mentor Embedded Linux development platform that supports Freescale’s PowerPC-based QorIQ and PowerQUICC processors. The multicore-ready Mentor Embedded Linux for QorIQ and PowerQUICC includes an Embedded System Builder build engine, an Eclipse-based Mentor Embedded Edge IDE (integrated development environment), and debug tools, says the company.
-
Linux-based multicore design targets femtocells
The initial TCI6485 and TCI6489 models were said to power femotcells serving between eight and 32 HSPA 3G wireless users, respectively. At the time, TI said the DSPs were offered with a Linux support package and a software reference design from TI partners Continuous Computing and MimoOn. (See farther below for more on the TCI6489.)
-
RISC/DSP cores gain Linux development support
ARC International announced that its ARC 700 processor cores would be available with a Linux distribution from Codito Technologies back in 2004. ARC added SIMD (single-instruction, multiple-data) instruction support to the ARC 700 line in 2005, and added support subscriptions for the Codito Linux tools in 2007.
-
Android
-
Seriously, why do you still have an iPhone?
And that’s my point. Surely the iPhone is the best phone for some people. However, we are a society that prefers choice because nothing is one-size-fits-all. There has to be a better phone for most than the iPhone. Sales are beginning to show this is true, as Android is quickly overtaking Apple. Yes, that has a lot to do with the proliferation of Android across 30+ mainstream devices and Apple having only one. Yet this goes to further my point: given the choice, you should go with the device that makes the most sense to you. As fans of open source, I cannot fathom how the iPhone can be an easy decision for you, the opensource.com reader.
-
Android Also Gives Google Remote App Installation Power
-
-
Free Software/Open Source
-
Open Tech Exchange talks to Tectonic
The latest episode of OTE podcast features an interview with Tectonic in which we talk about open source software in Africa.
-
Open Source Geographic Tracking?
-
Events
-
Web Browsers
-
Android Becomes Flash Mobile’s First BFF
-
Uncertain future for Flash
And it’s not just YouTube that uses Flash, almost all video sites do, as well as online games sites and entertainment sites. An older survey of websites by browser maker Opera found that in most countries around 30% of websites were built in or contained Flash elements. And in some countries that was as high as 40% or 50%. So it’s safe to say that as much as 30% of the web relies in some or other way on Flash.
-
Mozilla: We’re not ‘on board’ with Google’s plugin spice
Mozilla says it has “no official position” on NPAPI Pepper, the revamped browser plug-in API developed by Google for use with Native Client, a plug-in that runs native code inside its Chrome browser.
-
-
SaaS
-
Red Hat says everybody gets a cloud
At its Boston developer summit Red Hat is pushing the theme that every company can have its own cloud with the first in a line of Cloud Foundation tools.
-
-
Programming
-
Take more note when Eclipse code drops on schedule
Five years into my tenure on this beat and I still read, in comments, snark about open source programmers being amateurs, coding in their parents’ basements, in their pajamas.
This was always a false image. Not that I have anything against a good parent’s basement, or a nice comfortable pair of jammies. And when open source was being born, at the bottom of the dot-bomb, there was high unemployment in the code-o-sphere.
But the coders and the coding were always professional. There have always been a lot of people in open source who knew how to make the coding train run on time.
-
-
Standards/Consortia
Leftovers
-
Security/Aggression
-
Peace campaigner, 85, classified by police as ‘domestic extremist’
For John Catt, protest has never been about chaining himself to a railing or blocking a road in an act of civil disobedience. The 85-year-old peace campaigner’s far milder form of dissent typically involves turning up at a demonstration with his daughter, Linda, taking out his sketch pad and drawing the scene.
-
Senator Moves To Form Federal “Cyber-Emergency” Agency
The President would gain the power to unilaterally declare a national cyber-emergency and order operators of “critical infrastructure” to immediately implement “response plans” as provided for by the act. Those who fail to do so would be subject to fines, while those who comply would be protected from civil liability for any damages they might cause in doing so — government speak for “you can break people’s stuff and they’re just out of luck.”
-
FBI Failed To Break Encryption of Hard Drives
-
-
Environment
-
Ushahidi tracks the Gulf Oil Spill: Open Source Crowdsourcing at Work
Together, crowdsourcing and open source are a potent combination especially during possible emergencies. In this case, the Ushahidi based Oil Crisis Map has helped share data across communities and has openly presented the magnitude of the oil spill. Also, it has enabled people on the ground to actively participate in solving this crisis using current and accurate information.
Ushahidi (Swahili for “testimony”) itself emerged from another emergency – monitoring a disputed Kenyan election in 2007 with a mash-up of eyewitness reports onto a Google map. Today Ushahidi has developers from Kenya (where it started), Ghana, South Africa, Malawi, Netherlands and the US. Ushahidi was also used in Project Vote Report India for India’s 2009 general elections to track election irregularities.
-
-
Censorship/Privacy/Civil Rights
-
Reporters Without Borders unveils first-ever “Anti-Censorship Shelter”
Reporters Without Borders today launched the world’s first “Anti-Censorship Shelter” in Paris for use by foreign journalists, bloggers and dissidents who are refugees or just passing through as a place where they can learn how to circumvent Internet censorship, protect their electronic communications and maintain their anonymity online.
-
-
Copyrights
-
Creative Commons Responds to ASCAP
Yesterday, we reported that ASCAP said that organizations like Creative Commons were undermining their copyrights. Today, we’ve received an official response from Creative Commons with regards to the letter writing campaign.
In the same article, we discussed how Creative Commons was, contrary to what ASCAP said, not about undermining anyone elses copyrighted material, but rather, giving artists an option that was not the Public Domain (no rights reserved) nor Copyright (all rights reserved).
Eric Steuer, a Creative Commons spokesperson, thanked ZeroPaid for the earlier posting as being well-thought out and was happy to respond to ASCAPs letter
-
Clip of the Day
CLUG Talk 25 August 2009 – Experiences as a Novice Linux User (2009)
Eye on Novell: SCO, People, Business, SLED/Ballnux, SUSE HackWeek, and Other Events
Summary: This week’s roundup of Novell news, including news about OpenSUSE
SCO
• Blank Rome Files a 4th Bill in the SCO Bankruptcy
Another Blank Rome bill has been filed in the SCO bankruptcy, their fourth, this one covering January and February of 2010, which brings us closer to up-to-date, but we are not there yet. That means there will be more bills to come. The total bill is $244,836.50 for fees plus $3,783.55 for expenses, but for now they ask for the usual 80% of the fees, or $195,869.20.
• Novell Files Bill of Costs (once again) in SCO v. Novell
People
• Fortinet appoints new regional director for Thailand, Southeast Asia & Hong Kong
Chang’s previous roles include: Vice President of Sales and Marketing for Asia Pacific & Middle East at inter-Touch, Managing Director of STSN, a global internet service provider, and Market Development Manager for Asia Pacific at Novell.
• Interview with Jan Newman, SageCreek Partners
Jan’s been in the Utah technology industry for awhile, having been a Executive Vice President at Novell, and founder of KeyLabs, another of the area’s successes.
[...]
Jan Newman: My background, is I started at Novell, and spent ten years there. I worked at the executive level for lots of years under the tutelage of Ray Noorda. When Ray retired, and went outside of Novell, I founded KeyLabs, which we sold to Exodus Communications for about $50M in 1999.
• Can your leadership handle the hotdog?
The biggest claim to fame I suppose is the good Dr. Eric Schmidt when he was the CEO @ Novell.com. It’s a long story, but involves a couple of newly hired guys (me and another guy from Toronto), sushi and a mansion in San Francisco. Eric (I have a hard time not calling him Mr.) eschewed everything that a leader should be, and that I will always carry with me – both as a goal, and as a role model.
Business
• Ogilvy & Mather wins Best in Show for IBM campaign at Ace Awards
For best ad campaign with a budget of $250,000 and less, PJA Advertising+Marketing, Cambridge, Mass., won for Novell Inc.’s “Making IT Work as One” campaign.
• New grading system gets school board OK
The school board also approved purchases of over $15,000 for Novell, Weidenhammer Systems Corp. and Norlight Inc.
• How Clouds Are Working for Public Sector Users
The City of Los Angeles has received lots of attention for moving to Google Apps. This $7.25 million deal, serving 34,000 employees is one of the biggest deployments of Google Apps anywhere. It replaces an aging Novell GroupWise email system and includes a privacy provision providing the city with unlimited damages if its nondisclosure agreement (NDA) is breached by Google (Nasdaq: GOOG).
SLED/Ballnux
• HP Announces Mini 100e Education Edition Netbook (mentioned at an earlier stage)
The little netbook has a 10.1-inch screen and weighs 3.19 pounds. The display is LED backlit and has a WSVGA display and the keyboard is 92% full size. The little rig will be offered with Windows 7 Starter, XP Home, and SuSE Linux OS’.
• HP launches Mini 100e netbook for students
Interestingly, a pre-release version of this netbook was on view at Computex earlier this month at the Novell booth. At the time, I assuemd it was a Classmate PC, but looking closer, it becomes clear that the design is similar but not identical to computers based on Intel’s reference design.
• Share your appliances with SUSE Gallery!
SUSE HackWeek
• Ixion – threaded formula calculation library
• Hackweek V: YaSTroid (interesting project, but shades of MonoDroid [1, 2, 3, 4])
Hackweek is an excellent opportunity to try something new. Hackweek V was not the exception. From June 7th to June 11th I joined a fantastic group of hackers to implement YaSTroid, our Android Front-end to WebYaST.
• YaSTroid
MonoTouch
• FTC Launching Investigation on Apple
Examples of developer tools that are fall out include Adobe’s Flash platform and Novell’s MonoTouch.
Events
• Let’s beat the drum for openSUSE conference 2010 (Michael Löffler also suggested drifting away from Novell)
• openSUSE 11.3 Launch Party in Nürnberg (15.7.)
LinuxTag 2010
Misc.
Microsoft ‘TEs’ (AstroTurf Employees) Comment on Predictions of Microsoft Doom – Using Talking Points, Without Disclosure
Summary: Paid Microsoft AstroTurfer (probably several, but not yet confirmed) copies and pastes talking points from his bosses, typically as comments in response to blog posts that are critical of Microsoft
OUR earlier explanations of Microsoft problems contain many citations of other posts and articles on the subject. Kara Swisher from the WSJ (Murdoch) has been defending Microsoft in posts we would rather not cite here; she is quoting Microsoft’s talking points and propaganda, printing, defending and publishing them verbatim (without challenging the obvious fallacies and made-up numbers).
Those who have read this site for the past week or so will know that Microsoft has many predictions of doom about it not only in blogs but also in the mainstream press (Forbes for example). Microsoft has taken a massive PR hit and it knows this.
Thanks to one of our readers we now have some evidence that Microsoft unleashes its employees to ‘fight back’ against truthful articles. How? Talking points and propaganda. The damage control is clearly extracted from the head of propaganda at Microsoft (Microsoft names it ‘Communication’, just like the Gates Foundation names this role which Larry Cohen abandoned last year). Microsoft’s current ‘Communication’ minister was put in place after a few shuffles which even involved Waggener Edstrom. This ‘Communication’ minister (officially a VP), whose Microsoft TEs join as they post copies (as in “copy and paste”) of his message (c/f Kara’s original) in blog comments without any disclosure about their employer, is a sign of great failure, maybe even a violation that the FTC should investigate. The blog comments are sourced from Microsoft, posted by paid Microsoft AstroTurfers (TEs), without disclosure. Microsoft ought to develop products, not people who hound Microsoft critics.
“Microsoft must be rather scared given how low it has stooped.”This particular example which we gave happens to have come from a Microsoft employee who smeared this site [1, 2] and smeared me personally with a comparison to a serial killer. It’s part of the same technique which is used against one’s opposition in the least ethical of ways, essentially a daemonisation which portrays one’s opponent as a dangerous terrorist or something of that sort [1, 2]. In some cases, the intention is to provoke and rile up one’s opposition for an insult to be blurted out in return and then used completely out of context as ‘dirt’.
But anyway, the main point is that a reader of ours found evidence that Microsoft still uses old tricks to rescue a reputation it lost long ago. It’s not just one example as there are many others like the Microsoft employee in question and they are all on Microsoft's payroll. That’s their job.
Microsoft must be rather scared given how low it has stooped. Kara Swisher should know better. █
Read this post for an explanation of the screenshot
Entryism Watch: Australia’s Largest ISP Dumps GNU/Linux Mirror Months After Putting Microsoft in Charge
Summary: Telstra provides some examples of what ‘former’ Microsoft executives can do to a company; we also look at The ‘Open’ University, SIIA, and Yahoo!
ESTABLISHMENTS that get associated with Microsoft often react differently than those which do not. When former executives from Microsoft become part of another company’s management (or when a deal is signed), decisions that are made eventually make less sense to the surroundings and more sense to Microsoft.
As we pointed out last year, a portion of Microsoft’s executive ranks was entering Telstra [1, 2], which is of course parenting BigPond. This pair (Microsoft and Telstra) was then signing more Microsoft deals and getting closer to the companies’ point of intersection, as expected.
A reader has just told us that “Australia’s Largest ISP Ditches Linux Mirror,” according to Slashdot:
An anonymous reader writes “Australia’s largest ISP, BigPond, has decided to ditch its local mirrors of Linux and other open source operating systems, as well as various other open source software and Creative Commons media. BigPond posted a terse update on the service’s website, citing reasons of low popularity and the existence of better services like download.com and Tucows. BigPond customers are not impressed by the move, given that the ISP is infamous in Australia for its high prices and relatively low monthly quotas of bandwidth (many users are on 10gb or 25gb per month plans) and all downloads from this service did not count towards their monthly limits.”
Here is a forum thread and files index. As we showed 2 years ago, Bigpond had also removed OpenOffice.org. It would be hard to prove malicious intent which is caused by Telstra’s relationship with Microsoft, recruitment of Microsoft executives, and subsequent deals, but it’s reasonable to suspect a correlation.
Yesterday, Glyn Moody wrote about The ‘Open’ University serving Microsoft even more after adding Microsoft’s Martin Bean [1, 2, 3, 4] as a vice-chancellor (highest rank in UK universities).
Naturally, offering such courses about closed-source software is an important part of providing a wide range information and training. And I’m sure there will be similarly courses and qualifications for open source programs.
After all, free software not only already totally dominates areas like supercomputers, the Internet and embedded systems, but is also rapidly gaining market share in key sectors like mobile, so it would obviously make sense to offer plenty of opportunities for students to study and work with the operating system of the future, as well as that of the past.
That’s true for all academic establishments offering courses in computing, but in the case of the Open University, even-handedness assumes a particular importance because of the context:
The Open University has appointed a Microsoft boss to be its fifth vice-chancellor.
Martin Bean is currently general manager of product management, marketing and business development for Microsoft’s worldwide education products group.
What a farce. The ‘Open’ University will teach young people to be proprietary. Oh, the irony.
Speaking of bad influence from Microsoft in Europe, the SIIA takes his international attacks on Free software to Europe this week.
Five months after expanded its policing of counterfeit software applications to Europe, the Software and Information Industry Association (SIIA) has filed a trio of lawsuits in Germany and the UK accusing online sellers of hawking stolen or knock-off versions of Adobe Systems’ applications on eBay.
SIIA, a trade association representing roughly 500 software and digital content companies, has been on a mission to eliminate or at least reduce the rampant sale of stolen or counterfeit software on popular e-commerce sites — most notably eBay (NASDAQ: EBAY).
SIIA is a front for companies like Microsoft and Novell.
Last but not least, after Microsoft was displacing the leadership of Yahoo! to grab control of their search engine users we hear this predictable news from Joseph Tartakoff and many others:
One of Yahoo’s key search executives, who sought to put the best light on its decision to outsource back-end search crawling to Microsoft over the last several months, is leaving the company.
Microsoft ruined Yahoo! from the inside. Why don’t others learn? It’s called entryism. █
When Windows Collapses, So Will Microsoft
Summary: Another look at the problems Windows is having and why the rest of Microsoft is very much hinged upon Windows
WINDOWS Vista 7 is not selling as well as Microsoft wants people to believe. In fact, it fails to attract even Windows XP users. As the following new blog post points out, Microsoft managed to do better than Vista, but it’s not enough. Almost anything is better than Vista.
I’ve been listening that Microsoft did a good job regarding Windows 7. For crying out loud! I would like to understand what a good job is for the ones who share this idea. After all, Windows Vista was a disaster and anything that replaces it is preferable, but unlikely to be labeled “a good job” because of merely being “different”.
Microsoft defended Vista with every weapon the company had, but the attempt was a doomed enterprise. Users refused abandoning Windows XP to adopt Vista. Not even the Mojave experiment could change their perception about the substitute of Windows Longhorn. The last hope for Vista was the change from 32 bit to 64 bit systems, but that also failed. Nothing worked. The only course left was to say “Hasta la Vista!” to the hated OS and, thus, everyone celebrated the coming of Windows 7 with fireworks…because it had to be better than Vista.
Yet, if Windows 7 is better than Vista because it is not Vista, then everything is BETTER than Vista. XP is better than Vista. XP SP2 is better than Vista. XP SP3 is ALSO better than Vista. Ultimately, that repulsive Garbage Pail Kids movie IS better than Vista.
On top of this, Windows has a serious “fragmentation” issue [1, 2, 3, 4, 5], especially since Vista. Here is a good new listing that highlights this fragmentation:
Linux is regularly accused of being too fragmented but Microsoft has its own minefield to navigate.
One of the regular criticisms levelled against Linux is that with so many versions available the platform is “fragmented”. The idea is that because there are so many “distributions” of Linux, users will be confused and unsure of which to pick.
[...]
Desktop
1. Windows 7 Starter – The edition with the fewest features;
2. Windows 7 Home Basic – A version available for emerging markets;
3. Windows 7 Home Premium – The standard home user-focused edition of Windows;
4. Windows 7 Professional – More features for enthusiasts and small business owners;
5. Windows 7 Enterprise – Aimed at the enterprise market and sold through volume licensing only; and
6. Windows 7 Ultimate – A version of Windows 7 Enterprise but available to users as individual licenses.Mobile
On the mobile front Microsoft also has a good handful of editions, six in fact.
1. Windows Mobile 6.x – The remaining Windows Mobile edition;
2. Windows Phone 7 – The newer smartphone-focused OS that has been so long in the coming;
3. Kin Phone OS – A version of Windows Phone 7 for the Kin phones;
4. Windows Embedded Handheld – The newest edition to the lineup for the Motorola enterprise digital assistant;
5. Windows Embedded Standard – An OS focused on TVs, set-top boxes and kiosks; and
6. Windows Embedded Compact 7 – A still-to-be-released version of Windows 7 for slates and tablets.
Windows is not just another product; This is the product which Microsoft relies on the most because it acts as a pipeline to others and it is among the few products that are actually profitable. Looking at Microsoft’s online endeavours, literally billions of dollars are being lost there and it’s not getting any better:
For as long as I can remember Microsoft Blog service has been hit with a plethora of spam which would fill the comments section with offers of trainers, jewelry and all manner of dodgy offers.
Now that Linux gets into the hands of millions of new users per month Microsoft can only sue and use fake numbers to maintain an illusion of control (Windows has already lost to Linux in several key areas). The truth is, Microsoft goes through the same thing SUN went through several years ago. Without Windows everywhere, Microsoft and Office cease to be a de facto standard. Microsoft also tried to use Office to make Microsoft a de facto standard, but it failed because well-documented corruption led to the correct perception that OOXML is a fraud:
ISO and other standards bodies did not learn from the OOXML debate. Reform of ISO is pending to allow more fast tracked standards from ECMA. Procurement of OOXML might be illegal in Europe.
Henry Blodget says that “odds are increasing that Microsoft’s business will just completely collapse.” It’s time to look beyond Microsoft and look at the phenomena which stand in the way of software freedom. Software patents are one issue we'll know a lot more about on Monday. █
Why is Florian Müller Sometimes Promoting Microsoft’s Agenda? (Updated)
Summary: Florian Müller supports NEON’s case against IBM
WE ROUTINELY quote Mr. Müller, but we very well know that his interests outside the software patents debate do not intersect with ours. It is somewhat sad that as we first showed yesterday, Müller pushes the Microsoft line against GNU/Linux domination in mainframes (be it by IBM or someone else). We wrote about NEON in [1, 2], but the connection to Microsoft’s front does not deter Müller who promotes the anti-IBM line in Slashdot. In his blog he even links to Maureen O’Gara (who needs no special introduction [1, 2, 3, 4, 5]).
Müller portrays this whole thing without mentioning that Microsoft owns parts of the case and even companies involved (e.g. T3 [1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7]); he uses Dana’s ZDNet blog for consent. From the latest:
The efforts by open source TurboHercules to break IBM’s mainframe monopoly through the European Commission got some proprietary support this week when NEON Enterprise Software LLC of Austin, Tex. filed an EU complaint alongside a U.S. antitrust lawsuit.
NEON was founded by BMC Software co-founder John Moores, so even if you have never heard of it, they have the money to pursue the case.
Müller is a decent guy and he will hopefully rethink what his work against IBM is doing to GNU/Linux in mainframes. Müller harmed the migration to GNU/Linux in Munich and now he harms Free software, essentially by promoting some partners of Microsoft. █
Update: In his defence, Müller has responded by E-mail.
From: Florian Mueller
Sent: Saturday, June 26, 2010 6:55 PM
To: Roy Schestowitz
Subject: NEON is not a Microsoft frontHi Roy,
We’ll always have a combination of items on which we agree and ones on which we disagree. Whether or not you elect to quote from this, I’d like to provide an explanation as to why I welcomed NEON’s announcement of an impending antitrust complaint against IBM.
My primary concern about the mainframe case is the Hercules open source project, which started in 1999 and can therefore not be considered a Microsoft front by any reasonable stretch of the imagination. I believe this is now a situation in which antitrust intervention can benefit free software and open source once again, as Samba benefitted from the EU antitrust case against Microsoft.
NEON also filed a complaint, not with a view to emulation but a different scenario in which IBM alleges infringement of “intellectual property”. In NEON’s case one of IBM’s legal theories is based on the DMCA, a piece of legislation that I’m sure you have a critical perspective on.
At any rate, I feel comfortable reporting on NEON because I can’t see any indication that they are a Microsoft front. NEON’s principal founder and owner (besides the company’s employees) is John Moores Sr., a billionaire philanthropist who co-founded BMC (hence his wealth). This isn’t the kind of company that would act as anyone else’s front. NEON has its own beef with IBM, but it underscores the need for antitrust intervention against an abuse of a dominant market position (or, simply put, monopoly) and that’s why I was glad to see them act not only in the US, where they’ve already lodged a complaint, but also in the EU.
Given NEON’s background and the 11-year history of the Hercules open source project, this leaves only T3 as a complainant with a Microsoft connection. I heard that Microsoft is a shareholder of T3 but haven’t been able to find out more detail on how much of the company they own. I haven’t had any contact with T3 nor with NEON myself. I have no reason to assume that TurboHercules is linked to them.
At the end of the day, my view is that there is a serious problem with IBM’s anticompetitive conduct, an antitrust intervention would be justified. A possible Microsoft involvement with one of the three complainants isn’t the issue that the European Commission will be interested in. What matters is whether the European economy is harmed by IBM’s behavior.
I can’t see any negative effects on the mainframe version of GNU/Linux. On the contrary, I have talked to mainframe developers and I have learned that most if not all of the developers of the mainframe port of GNU/Linux use(d) Hercules for their own development and testing purposes, including but not limited to Alan Cox (former Red Hat Fellow, now employed at Intel) and Bernharnd Kaindl (who did the mainframe port of SuSE Linux).
Hercules is available for GNU/Linux as well as Windows.
If there are customers who want to continue to use existing (“legacy”) z/OS program code, they are now forced to use IBM hardware and Hercules would give them a choice for some use cases. For possibly porting their applications to GNU/Linux, the switching costs, risks, delays and efforts involved are huge, but the existence and availability of Hercules certainly isn’t a factor that would adversely affect anyone’s attitude toward ports.
Best regards,
Florian
Bogus Software Patents Used Against Google Because Android(Linux)+Services Are Winning
Summary: As Google claims to be spreading over 1 million Linux-based phones per week, Apple which is a self-admitted ‘thief’ is suing again and Frontier Communications does too — using a patent whose description Frontier distorts
YESTERDAY we wrote about the latest patent lawsuit against software that makes the headlines. It’s the Frontier lawsuit against Google (coverage by Reuters), where the patent involved is described as follows:
Oh, and if you want to see how continuation patents are abused, you can check out the original patent application, which focuses on something quite different than the eventual patent. It’s much more about switching calls from one line to another. It’s only in the later patent (not filed until well after Google Voice was widely established in the market), that Frontier made the patent sound a lot more like what Google Voice actually does.
That’s not a concrete patent. It’s software-implemented and it’s inspired by real-world equivalents.
Apple is also suing Android/Linux (via HTC) because about 160,000 Android phones are sold daily while hypePhone 4 encounters a disaster, not just the Gizmodo PR disaster which we covered in:
- Microsoft’s Phone Business as Dead as Zune, But Apple Too Loses Its Mind
- Apple’s Hounding of Bloggers Becomes a PR Disaster
- Apple’s Connection to Abuse of Gizmodo Employee Shown, EFF Fights Back
- Microsoft is Contacting Publications, Asking Them to Add More Anti-Linux Slant
- Does Android’s Chief Compare Steve Jobs to North Korea’s Dead Leader (Kim Il-sung)?
- “Behind the Open Codec FUD Attack, W3C Captured by Microsoft, Apple, Nokia and So On?”
- Firm of Bill Gates’ Father Gets Involved in Gizmodo Raid Case, Gizmodo May Sue
- When Brands Become Cults
Against Monopoly writes about Monday’s Bilski decision, noting that it may impact software patents as we last argued yesterday.
Even the most ardent defenders of the current patent regime expect the Court to strike down “business method” patents. The big question will be if the Court goes even farther and delivers a broader decision affecting software patents and other controversial forms of patent monopolies.
Last night we explained why it looks favourable to those wishing to abolish software patents. These patents are not about ingenuity, they are about mixing or extending existing ideas. Apple is not original at all and it admits this publicly (video in the link, with another newer one below). █